Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest you watch and share the film unauthorised absence - particularly if you work in schools/your child has SEN or difficultly attending school

773 replies

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 20:31

This excellent short film Unauthorised Absence has been produced to highlight
the actual reality of what it is like for families whose children can't cope in school for whatever reason (SEN, mental health, anxiety etc) and how they are often punished rather than helped. It is a heatwrenching watch.

The story follows a single mother fighting a punitive education system when her autistic nine-year-old daughter experiences severe school distress and emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA). It stars Emily Bruni, Beatrice Flaherty, Cathy Tyson, and Anna Maxwell Martin.
It is on the longlist for the Best Short Film at the British Independent Film Awards.

It was crowd funded by parents and others whose childrens have suffered due to the system and aims to help change the dialogue around how these children and their parents are viewed. Both my children have had great difficulties in school one not being able to attend at all and the other forcing herself in until she had a severe breakdown while school told us they were both 'fine in school' - so I think it is really important to watch and share this.

(Please note - the film contains some pretty distressing scenes and there is some self harm. It is quite a difficult watch for anyone who has been through this with their family)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn8C7WuGv8g

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Bathmats4eva · 12/11/2026 06:45

I've not watched the whole thing yet but feel like I have as it's been so heavily trailed on my socials! It looks very accurate for some parents. But-

DC is autistic and in a mainstream secondary, although diagnosed pretty early and we had an EHCP in place well before secondary. Her attendance is good, the school meets need and I get really uncomfortable with the 'mainstream school is damaging for all autistic children' trope I often see bandied about. I'm also a secondary school governor with responsibility for attendance so I see the full picture.

I think as a school we do as well as we can- we've got a pastoral team, attendance officers who approach with care, great at reasonable adjustments, a sensory room. We refer to AP, we work closely with the LAs, we apply for a billion EHCPs where we think they are needed. As a general rule we work in partnership with parents. Do we get it right 100%? Probably not, but we really try hard.

We also have a cohort of good old fashioned truancy, which was really doing for our attendance figures.

It is really possible for 2 things to be true at once, and one of those is that some families have very low engagement with school and don't ensure attendance, without SEND being a particular issue, and remove for holidays- while some schools also don't meet need. There are safeguarding issues for some children who do not attend, or it might be the only meal they get that day, or the only break from being a carer.

There are ways to get curious rather than punitive about the low engagement, but ultimately the fine is a useful indicator that schooling of some sort needs to happen for some families. Schools should be working to the statutory guidance well before any fine needs to happen, which is 'support first'.

The 'schools are awful, they are harmful' trope is very harmful in itself. I know it had us absolutely terrified we were going to end up with EBSA, and in fact it's been fine.

Velumental · 12/11/2026 06:51

Bathmats4eva · 12/11/2026 06:45

I've not watched the whole thing yet but feel like I have as it's been so heavily trailed on my socials! It looks very accurate for some parents. But-

DC is autistic and in a mainstream secondary, although diagnosed pretty early and we had an EHCP in place well before secondary. Her attendance is good, the school meets need and I get really uncomfortable with the 'mainstream school is damaging for all autistic children' trope I often see bandied about. I'm also a secondary school governor with responsibility for attendance so I see the full picture.

I think as a school we do as well as we can- we've got a pastoral team, attendance officers who approach with care, great at reasonable adjustments, a sensory room. We refer to AP, we work closely with the LAs, we apply for a billion EHCPs where we think they are needed. As a general rule we work in partnership with parents. Do we get it right 100%? Probably not, but we really try hard.

We also have a cohort of good old fashioned truancy, which was really doing for our attendance figures.

It is really possible for 2 things to be true at once, and one of those is that some families have very low engagement with school and don't ensure attendance, without SEND being a particular issue, and remove for holidays- while some schools also don't meet need. There are safeguarding issues for some children who do not attend, or it might be the only meal they get that day, or the only break from being a carer.

There are ways to get curious rather than punitive about the low engagement, but ultimately the fine is a useful indicator that schooling of some sort needs to happen for some families. Schools should be working to the statutory guidance well before any fine needs to happen, which is 'support first'.

The 'schools are awful, they are harmful' trope is very harmful in itself. I know it had us absolutely terrified we were going to end up with EBSA, and in fact it's been fine.

As always however, if the punishment for a crime is a fine, it's only a crime for poor people. Those who can easily afford the fine face no punitive measures. For many wealthier families they check the cost of a holiday in term time and just consider the fine another cost.

SecureYourOwnMaskFirst · 12/11/2026 06:53

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 00:50

I haven't watched, but the most heartbreaking thing for me when my child couldn't attend was how desperately she WANTED to be there.

Exactly this for us, too. In a few minutes I’m going to wake up a boy who desperately wants to be like the other kids and wants to learn. And he’s going to blame himself for being so cripplingly anxious he can’t do those things. It breaks my heart every day.

Sartre · 12/11/2026 06:57

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 21:48

I’m not saying it isn’t happening but why did your daughter (and so many like her) have nervous breakdowns in comparison to 20 years ago? Nobody ever seems to want to look outside just finger pointing at the school. Schools have not changed that much and whatever changes there have been, are generally more accommodating of children’s differences, not less.

This is something I have thought a lot about since my youngest DS was diagnosed autistic. It made me think back to my own schooling days and how many children had SEN then. We had a profoundly autistic boy in our class throughout primary who we all adored but other than this, to my knowledge, no one was diagnosed.

I can think of two other boys I’m pretty certain had autism. One was indeed a school refuser, up until around year 5 he would still cry and cling to his mum. We also had the boy who was utterly obsessed with dinosaurs and knew everything about them and also TY toys, even in yr 6. I just think it wasn’t as readily diagnosed.

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 07:06

Bathmats4eva · 12/11/2026 06:45

I've not watched the whole thing yet but feel like I have as it's been so heavily trailed on my socials! It looks very accurate for some parents. But-

DC is autistic and in a mainstream secondary, although diagnosed pretty early and we had an EHCP in place well before secondary. Her attendance is good, the school meets need and I get really uncomfortable with the 'mainstream school is damaging for all autistic children' trope I often see bandied about. I'm also a secondary school governor with responsibility for attendance so I see the full picture.

I think as a school we do as well as we can- we've got a pastoral team, attendance officers who approach with care, great at reasonable adjustments, a sensory room. We refer to AP, we work closely with the LAs, we apply for a billion EHCPs where we think they are needed. As a general rule we work in partnership with parents. Do we get it right 100%? Probably not, but we really try hard.

We also have a cohort of good old fashioned truancy, which was really doing for our attendance figures.

It is really possible for 2 things to be true at once, and one of those is that some families have very low engagement with school and don't ensure attendance, without SEND being a particular issue, and remove for holidays- while some schools also don't meet need. There are safeguarding issues for some children who do not attend, or it might be the only meal they get that day, or the only break from being a carer.

There are ways to get curious rather than punitive about the low engagement, but ultimately the fine is a useful indicator that schooling of some sort needs to happen for some families. Schools should be working to the statutory guidance well before any fine needs to happen, which is 'support first'.

The 'schools are awful, they are harmful' trope is very harmful in itself. I know it had us absolutely terrified we were going to end up with EBSA, and in fact it's been fine.

For some the ‘school is awful’ is not a trope.

LittlePickleHead · 12/11/2026 07:08

Another with a DS who was undiagnosed ASD and ADHD through primary school, but always struggled with separation. With lots of adjustment he managed to make it through primary but with hindsight the flags were so crimson the school should have referred him for assessment.

transfer to secondary was a disaster. He desperately wanted to be with his friends, but just couldn’t cope with the environment, particularly with not knowing whether he would get a detention or not.

hes now in a specialist provision, doing really well. He’s maintained his friendships from primary which is amazing but means he’s still aiming to get back to mainstream with them. I just don’t think it’s possible though.

to get him to specialist was two years out of school trying various things, with our privileged position of being able to pay for support and intervention. But even with that I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy, having to deal with the pain he was going through.

his current school is interest led, not punitive, small calm classrooms. He is interested in learning and sociable. So many parents I’ve spoken to have said their child would benefit from this approach. Coping with mainstream is not the same as thriving.

so yes, our school system (designed in the Victorian era) does need a rethink. One size doesn’t fit all in the workplace, why should it at school?

tamade · 12/11/2026 07:15

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 21:28

School has never been LESS punitive. 2000s we had uniform inspections, Saturday detentions, teachers would actually shout at you, no screens just endless boring writing. At primary we had to sit facing the wall if we were naughty.

It’s not schools that have changed, it’s children

You are right that schooling is different, gentler maybe. But the OP's point is I guess that attendance targets (in particular) have made the education system more punitive on families.

IAmUsingTheApplauseReactionSarcastically · 12/11/2026 07:20

Bathmats4eva · 12/11/2026 06:45

I've not watched the whole thing yet but feel like I have as it's been so heavily trailed on my socials! It looks very accurate for some parents. But-

DC is autistic and in a mainstream secondary, although diagnosed pretty early and we had an EHCP in place well before secondary. Her attendance is good, the school meets need and I get really uncomfortable with the 'mainstream school is damaging for all autistic children' trope I often see bandied about. I'm also a secondary school governor with responsibility for attendance so I see the full picture.

I think as a school we do as well as we can- we've got a pastoral team, attendance officers who approach with care, great at reasonable adjustments, a sensory room. We refer to AP, we work closely with the LAs, we apply for a billion EHCPs where we think they are needed. As a general rule we work in partnership with parents. Do we get it right 100%? Probably not, but we really try hard.

We also have a cohort of good old fashioned truancy, which was really doing for our attendance figures.

It is really possible for 2 things to be true at once, and one of those is that some families have very low engagement with school and don't ensure attendance, without SEND being a particular issue, and remove for holidays- while some schools also don't meet need. There are safeguarding issues for some children who do not attend, or it might be the only meal they get that day, or the only break from being a carer.

There are ways to get curious rather than punitive about the low engagement, but ultimately the fine is a useful indicator that schooling of some sort needs to happen for some families. Schools should be working to the statutory guidance well before any fine needs to happen, which is 'support first'.

The 'schools are awful, they are harmful' trope is very harmful in itself. I know it had us absolutely terrified we were going to end up with EBSA, and in fact it's been fine.

Getting an EHCP in place for an autistic girl before she starts secondary school is much easier said than done though. I tried to preemptively in Y5, given DD had a history of school refusal, but it was refused as she was ‘fine’ at the time. Things fell apart as soon as she started and it was a painful process for all involved until she eventually got an EHCP (currently funding a place at a mainstream private school with more resources to put into pastoral care) in Y8.

Many staff at her initial secondary were absolutely brilliant. It’s an amazing school for many children and her big sister is thriving there. They did a great deal for her (albeit too little, too late as I’d tried and failed to get her relatively minimal but essential support needs taken seriously before she started). However, our main contact was an absolutely dreadful ‘welfare officer’ who was obsessed with attendance and had limited nuance when it came to distinguishing between the different types of absence. I cannot overstate how much harm she caused. (As it happens, she chose to send her own autistic child to a nurturing small private mainstream school…)

Dicedpumpkin · 12/11/2026 07:31

My child who struggled to attend then went go a special school where he didnt struggle to attend. So same parents, same child, different environment. He went from a very distressing 20% attendance to a happy 97%.

Lack of attendance can have many causes so treating it all the same way by threatening fines and court action doesnt work for a significant number of cases.

Bathmats4eva · 12/11/2026 07:35

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 07:06

For some the ‘school is awful’ is not a trope.

Surely it's 'this school for this child' though?

Bathmats4eva · 12/11/2026 07:41

IAmUsingTheApplauseReactionSarcastically · 12/11/2026 07:20

Getting an EHCP in place for an autistic girl before she starts secondary school is much easier said than done though. I tried to preemptively in Y5, given DD had a history of school refusal, but it was refused as she was ‘fine’ at the time. Things fell apart as soon as she started and it was a painful process for all involved until she eventually got an EHCP (currently funding a place at a mainstream private school with more resources to put into pastoral care) in Y8.

Many staff at her initial secondary were absolutely brilliant. It’s an amazing school for many children and her big sister is thriving there. They did a great deal for her (albeit too little, too late as I’d tried and failed to get her relatively minimal but essential support needs taken seriously before she started). However, our main contact was an absolutely dreadful ‘welfare officer’ who was obsessed with attendance and had limited nuance when it came to distinguishing between the different types of absence. I cannot overstate how much harm she caused. (As it happens, she chose to send her own autistic child to a nurturing small private mainstream school…)

Yes it's not easy. I have a girl. Her presentation is very external though.

I don't say that to say 'ooo just get an EHCP and it's easy'. I know from tribunal x3 it's not. I say that to indicate her support needs were relatively clearly articulated before she started secondary and I think that's one of the places to start.

In our secondary we see a lot of year 7s who should have had those needs identified by primary school or other professionals much much earlier. But the secondary gets a lot of the blame, somehow.

Mondaytuesdayhappydays · 12/11/2026 07:42

’often’ ‘sometimes purely’

Aka not always
However MH and ACEs/trauma are closely linked I dint think many people would dispute that would they?

DustyOwl · 12/11/2026 07:42

I have worked in schools for 25 years, class teacher, TA, behaviour lead, forest school teacher, mainstream, SEND schools, PRUs (pupil referral units) APs (alternative provision). I have worked in areas of social deprivation and schools in incredibly wealthy areas. I have got around.
My Dad was an education psychologist and my Mum a primary school teacher for 30 years. I currently work as a speech’s and language therapist with children on the cusp of permanent exclusion. I have also had children who have been all the way through the state school system.

I can give you my 2 pennies worth, which will be true of some children and not of others, because after all this time, I am still learning and definitely don’t know all of the answers.

This is an incredibly complex situation, born from the fact that society has changed immeasurably in the last 25 years, the way people parent has changed (not better or worse) and the education system has massively changed too. Not schools, the whole system.

When my Dad was working, and Ed psych would regularly go to a school. They’d see children who were a concern and then support the school/parents. Each school had a designated one from the LEA. Academies came along, we no longer have the massive team of universal support, offered to every school. This support was multi level, teachers were given training too.

The system was much better (not perfect) at offering support to children with low level need. Parents weren’t always aware of the support a child was getting because it came to the whole school. We have gone back to a medical model. Children have to have a diagnosis to access support, schools don’t have the budget to get the support they need.

More importantly there was time. Schools were not a hot house of constant testing, to meet arbitrary standards. That level of constant assessment just didn’t exist. Teachers had time to teach and support children who needed it. Teachers still want to do that now but there isn’t time. The foundation subjects have been squeezed to death. Is your child a talented musician? Can’t afford private lessons? Tough. There will be no recognition in school because there isn’t time to teach it/support it. Drama? PE? Art? In primary schools, where we had time to spend a whole afternoon doing it, now there is a topic, which lasts a term. Teachers try to cover it other ways by creative teaching in the core subjects but, if your child isn’t good at Maths and English, there isn’t time to celebrate and nurture their interest and talent. Parents pay chunks of money for private lessons in drama, art, sports etc but if you can’t afford that, forget it. Your child’s talents won’t be recognised and they won’t feel like they are succeeding. Not the schools fault, a system based on assessing children on Maths and English (notice not much science) in primary. By the time they get to secondary they already feel like failures.

Then we move onto support staff. There were TAs to offer support to children and teachers. They weren’t in every class, then they were, to match the changing curriculum the the pressures teachers faced. Then the TAs were taken away, because of budgets but also because supports staffs wages are so disgustingly low that many, very skilled professionals have to leave, to earn enough, to support themselves. The TAs role has changed, the responsibilities have changed but the pay hasn’t. They aren’t Teacher Assistants anymore, they are Assistant Teachers and they get paid bugger all.

I haven’t said everything I want. Not even slightly, but I bet you’re glad I’m going to stop now. I’m going to get to my job, seeing the parents and teachers, struggling to do their best.

These are massive generalisations. There is way more than this to consider, society, parenting, the way children socialise etc but I have run out of time.

Oh, and by the way, I blame Gove. Just saying.

TealFrameCircle · 12/11/2026 07:49

SecureYourOwnMaskFirst · 12/11/2026 06:53

Exactly this for us, too. In a few minutes I’m going to wake up a boy who desperately wants to be like the other kids and wants to learn. And he’s going to blame himself for being so cripplingly anxious he can’t do those things. It breaks my heart every day.

Sounds a lot like my daughter. Wants to learn, wants to see her friends, wants to be okay, but something's stopping her. My ex saying she's being manipulative and should "just go back to normal" hasn't exactly helped.

Forty years ago we would have threatened her with a good hiding, she would have dragged herself in every day, and been quietly miserable all her life. According to daily mail logic those were the good old days.

Heartbreaking is exactly right.

SecureYourOwnMaskFirst · 12/11/2026 07:50

chocolateface · 12/11/2026 06:40

Thanks for starting this thread and linking the film @Frazzlesforever

As a parent whose eldest child school refused 20 years ago (pre- tablets access constant access to the internet) and someone who currently works in a school (with the highest school attendance in the area) I’m mostly place marking until I have time to write a coherent post.
There is so much to unpick about school refusal, and it’s absolutely a conversation that needs to be had. 20 years ago the answer seemed to be home education. (I didn’t HE). I’m curious as to what other posters think is the answer today.

To quote my then 7yo: “It’s like a roller coaster ride. You see other people having fun and want to get on too, but you’re just too scared.” And yes, he was later diagnosed with ASD.

To quote my then 7yo: “It’s like a roller coaster ride. You see other people having fun and want to get on too, but you’re just too scared.” And yes, he was later diagnosed with ASD.

What an insightful comment. I hope your son is well now and has found his own way.

My son keeps getting on the rollercoaster because he wants to be there and he feels like a failure not doing what he ‘should’. And instead of enjoying himself and feeling less fearful over time as a neurotypical person might it keeps making him sick and the other kids and some teachers then make him feel more like a failure.

metellaestinatrio · 12/11/2026 07:50

oviraptor21 · 11/11/2026 23:58

Because "all that" rarely happened.
The teachers had full control and the children were 95% well behaved. They had been taught to sit at their desks, to listen to the teacher when they were speaking and to get on with their work.
Modern classrooms are much more chaotic and teachers have to be monumentally better at keeping control. And some of them just don't.

I do believe there are more ND kids. Probably a combination of screen time and diet.

There were also a lot more children in the classroom if we go back to the 60s/70s (40+ kids in my mum’s primary school class) and yet teachers still managed to maintain order - which was largely because schools were stricter, everyone sat in lines facing the front, you were hit with a ruler if you talked, teaching was very much “chalk and talk”. Yet now, when primary schools at least are much more nurturing, child-focussed environments with extra adults in the room and multiple adjustments for children who struggle we are saying schools are “too draconian” and this is why children refuse to go in?

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 07:55

DustyOwl · 12/11/2026 07:42

I have worked in schools for 25 years, class teacher, TA, behaviour lead, forest school teacher, mainstream, SEND schools, PRUs (pupil referral units) APs (alternative provision). I have worked in areas of social deprivation and schools in incredibly wealthy areas. I have got around.
My Dad was an education psychologist and my Mum a primary school teacher for 30 years. I currently work as a speech’s and language therapist with children on the cusp of permanent exclusion. I have also had children who have been all the way through the state school system.

I can give you my 2 pennies worth, which will be true of some children and not of others, because after all this time, I am still learning and definitely don’t know all of the answers.

This is an incredibly complex situation, born from the fact that society has changed immeasurably in the last 25 years, the way people parent has changed (not better or worse) and the education system has massively changed too. Not schools, the whole system.

When my Dad was working, and Ed psych would regularly go to a school. They’d see children who were a concern and then support the school/parents. Each school had a designated one from the LEA. Academies came along, we no longer have the massive team of universal support, offered to every school. This support was multi level, teachers were given training too.

The system was much better (not perfect) at offering support to children with low level need. Parents weren’t always aware of the support a child was getting because it came to the whole school. We have gone back to a medical model. Children have to have a diagnosis to access support, schools don’t have the budget to get the support they need.

More importantly there was time. Schools were not a hot house of constant testing, to meet arbitrary standards. That level of constant assessment just didn’t exist. Teachers had time to teach and support children who needed it. Teachers still want to do that now but there isn’t time. The foundation subjects have been squeezed to death. Is your child a talented musician? Can’t afford private lessons? Tough. There will be no recognition in school because there isn’t time to teach it/support it. Drama? PE? Art? In primary schools, where we had time to spend a whole afternoon doing it, now there is a topic, which lasts a term. Teachers try to cover it other ways by creative teaching in the core subjects but, if your child isn’t good at Maths and English, there isn’t time to celebrate and nurture their interest and talent. Parents pay chunks of money for private lessons in drama, art, sports etc but if you can’t afford that, forget it. Your child’s talents won’t be recognised and they won’t feel like they are succeeding. Not the schools fault, a system based on assessing children on Maths and English (notice not much science) in primary. By the time they get to secondary they already feel like failures.

Then we move onto support staff. There were TAs to offer support to children and teachers. They weren’t in every class, then they were, to match the changing curriculum the the pressures teachers faced. Then the TAs were taken away, because of budgets but also because supports staffs wages are so disgustingly low that many, very skilled professionals have to leave, to earn enough, to support themselves. The TAs role has changed, the responsibilities have changed but the pay hasn’t. They aren’t Teacher Assistants anymore, they are Assistant Teachers and they get paid bugger all.

I haven’t said everything I want. Not even slightly, but I bet you’re glad I’m going to stop now. I’m going to get to my job, seeing the parents and teachers, struggling to do their best.

These are massive generalisations. There is way more than this to consider, society, parenting, the way children socialise etc but I have run out of time.

Oh, and by the way, I blame Gove. Just saying.

Thank you for writing this.

it’s truly hell watching your child disappear before your eyes as they try to cope.

The finger pointing and ablisim yet again from some on this thread is cruel and unnecessary.

All many parents and children want is to be able to live a ‘normal’ life with school as part of it.

My job is going down the pan, my child is self harming.,

Its a living hell

OneInEight · 12/11/2026 07:55

ds1 was another who within 2 weeks of being in an excellent special school was a totally different child than the child who was melting down so often in his mainstream primary. dh and I did not get everything right I admit but the speed of the change makes it really difficult to argue that it was solely our fault rather than a large contributor being the school environment.

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 08:01

Bathmats4eva · 12/11/2026 07:35

Surely it's 'this school for this child' though?

Surely adults can think for themselves? But

BillHadersLeftEye · 12/11/2026 08:05

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 22:03

Not saying it’s tiresome that I’m hearing about it, or that you’re not going through it. I know you are. My frustration lies in this absolute unwillingness to consider it’s anything apart from school that is causing their problems.

@Apotofrealcoffee so what else should we be considering in your expert opinion?

BusyGreySnail · 12/11/2026 08:17

HettyTagliatelli · 11/11/2026 22:12

I work in a school and am
Interested enough to save this to watch. I’m wondering if the right balance is struck though or if it’s just critical of schools for the sake of it. Does it mention that the majority of unauthorised absences are because parents value the free education their children receive so little that they’d rather take cheap
holidays or they keep their children off school for a sniffle when they’d be perfectly fine and build some resilience by going in? Or talk about the parents who keep their children at home because of their own anxieties and need for company?

The reason that schools face so much pressure to prevent absence is that there is clear evidence that absence has a detrimental effect on long term educational outcomes. They have a responsibility to do what is best for children’s education even when parents don’t. So while there are no doubt children that genuinely struggle with being in a school environment and have genuine reasons for high levels of absence, there are also a significant number of children that are at home when they should be at school and whose parents are failing them by choosing not to send them in.

I am sure some schools are doing what they can. However our expereience with school refusal (luckily only short term) has been linked to bullying. And it's amazing just how little the school was prepared to do about the cause of the anxiety that was causing DD not to want to go to school. I also wouldn't want to go into a place I was being bullied and had physical threats made against me. Plus I am not sure they cared at all about her educational outcomes because even if she made it into school she was far too frightened about the boys who had been threatening her (which was brushed off as just being banter) hiding around the corner to learn.

Do you know what happened when we FORCED her into school (against our better judgement), and told her to go to the adults if she was scared? They basically told her it was her own doing (this was actually to said to me, in front of her, on a phone call), and punished her for defiance when she in tears refused to go to the lesson. Do you know what it's like, as a parent, to have to force your child to go somewhere they feel physically unsafe and then be receiving mesages from your child saying how scared they are and knowing the adults she is meant to trust to keep her safe are punishing her when she goes to them?

The situation was entirely within the school's control, and even when we pushed and pushed to get them to safeguard her they still did the absolute bare minimum, and that was only on escalation. That was nothing to do with DD's homelife, nor parents "failing" her. The one people failing her were the school.

IAmUsingTheApplauseReactionSarcastically · 12/11/2026 08:24

Bathmats4eva · 12/11/2026 07:41

Yes it's not easy. I have a girl. Her presentation is very external though.

I don't say that to say 'ooo just get an EHCP and it's easy'. I know from tribunal x3 it's not. I say that to indicate her support needs were relatively clearly articulated before she started secondary and I think that's one of the places to start.

In our secondary we see a lot of year 7s who should have had those needs identified by primary school or other professionals much much earlier. But the secondary gets a lot of the blame, somehow.

Well both her primary and secondary dropped a bollock tbf. The main thing her primary took from her first EHCP assessment was the opportunity for her to get 25% extra time and boost their SATS results; they were otherwise useless. I met the secondary SENCo in the summer term of Y6 to explain her history/difficulties but it was clear when she started that the info hadn’t been passed on. And I wasn’t asking for much. I’m extremely - possibly overly - mindful of how much pressure schools are under and the criticism they face; in retrospect I should have been pushier. My point is, you can have loads of people doing the right thing, albeit reactively because they deprioritised a child due to lack of resources despite her mum’s best efforts, but if someone like our welfare officer is obsessed with attendance and clueless about masking autistic children’s needs, it’s to little avail.

I don’t think I’ll watch the film. These awareness-raising initiatives rarely make it to the right people and just have the unwanted side-effect of giving onlookers like some of the posters here another opportunity to dump on struggling parents.

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 08:32

HettyTagliatelli · 11/11/2026 22:12

I work in a school and am
Interested enough to save this to watch. I’m wondering if the right balance is struck though or if it’s just critical of schools for the sake of it. Does it mention that the majority of unauthorised absences are because parents value the free education their children receive so little that they’d rather take cheap
holidays or they keep their children off school for a sniffle when they’d be perfectly fine and build some resilience by going in? Or talk about the parents who keep their children at home because of their own anxieties and need for company?

The reason that schools face so much pressure to prevent absence is that there is clear evidence that absence has a detrimental effect on long term educational outcomes. They have a responsibility to do what is best for children’s education even when parents don’t. So while there are no doubt children that genuinely struggle with being in a school environment and have genuine reasons for high levels of absence, there are also a significant number of children that are at home when they should be at school and whose parents are failing them by choosing not to send them in.

The majority of unauthorised absences are parents basically bunking their kids off school? Where are the stats that back up your claim?

1099 · 12/11/2026 08:44

Pobblewob · 11/11/2026 21:55

Watched it too.

Schools work tirelessly to get children into school. They HAVE to follow legal processes for non attendees.

I agree with PPs that school refusal is being blamed on school, when society has changed.

Part of the problem though is that schools often don't follow the Legal Process, they get tied up following Policies.
The Education Act, covers exactly what schools should do in most of these circumstances but they simply don't do it, they insist on trying to get the child to go to school, I suspect because part of their (the schools) OFSTED (or whatever it is now) report being based on attendance.
There is actually no Law that says schools have to get children into school. That onus is on the parents.

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 08:49

1099 · 12/11/2026 08:44

Part of the problem though is that schools often don't follow the Legal Process, they get tied up following Policies.
The Education Act, covers exactly what schools should do in most of these circumstances but they simply don't do it, they insist on trying to get the child to go to school, I suspect because part of their (the schools) OFSTED (or whatever it is now) report being based on attendance.
There is actually no Law that says schools have to get children into school. That onus is on the parents.

In addition marking as ‘unauthorised’ stops the school from coming under scrutiny from OFSTED.