Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest you watch and share the film unauthorised absence - particularly if you work in schools/your child has SEN or difficultly attending school

773 replies

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 20:31

This excellent short film Unauthorised Absence has been produced to highlight
the actual reality of what it is like for families whose children can't cope in school for whatever reason (SEN, mental health, anxiety etc) and how they are often punished rather than helped. It is a heatwrenching watch.

The story follows a single mother fighting a punitive education system when her autistic nine-year-old daughter experiences severe school distress and emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA). It stars Emily Bruni, Beatrice Flaherty, Cathy Tyson, and Anna Maxwell Martin.
It is on the longlist for the Best Short Film at the British Independent Film Awards.

It was crowd funded by parents and others whose childrens have suffered due to the system and aims to help change the dialogue around how these children and their parents are viewed. Both my children have had great difficulties in school one not being able to attend at all and the other forcing herself in until she had a severe breakdown while school told us they were both 'fine in school' - so I think it is really important to watch and share this.

(Please note - the film contains some pretty distressing scenes and there is some self harm. It is quite a difficult watch for anyone who has been through this with their family)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn8C7WuGv8g

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
lemonts · Today 14:02

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 13:43

Are you joking? Clear treatment plan 25 years ago?

Schools took parents' words then.

There were a couple of near permanent non-attenders in my year.

The PP describes a diagnosis of depression and anti depressive medication being prescribed. I would call that a clear treatment plan, in what way do you think it is not a clear treatment plan for a depressive episode?

lemonts · Today 14:06

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 13:47

Why do you believe it 'is complete rubbish'?

The issues are widely reported.

No i have not seen widely reported issues of CYP being off school for a period of a month with a single diagnosed MH condition with a clear treatment plan and their parents being pursued through the courts for non attendance.

I have seen plenty of other types of scenario around EBSA but none that would be comparable to the PP who described being off school for a month receiving treatment and then returning to school.

Happylife32 · Today 14:14

I watched the film and in many ways it was disturbing. I do feel that both diet and sleep contribute greatly to mental stability, and yet we never saw Thea eating a healthy meal, or told anything about how much sleep she was getting. There was a lot missing from the film as it was only 15 minutes long. We weren't told if the father was involved anywhere, for instance.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 14:21

Happylife32 · Today 14:14

I watched the film and in many ways it was disturbing. I do feel that both diet and sleep contribute greatly to mental stability, and yet we never saw Thea eating a healthy meal, or told anything about how much sleep she was getting. There was a lot missing from the film as it was only 15 minutes long. We weren't told if the father was involved anywhere, for instance.

The film was about the school response. Whatever she ate, wherever her dad was - the point remains a 'computer says no' response is damaging.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 14:26

lemonts · Today 14:06

No i have not seen widely reported issues of CYP being off school for a period of a month with a single diagnosed MH condition with a clear treatment plan and their parents being pursued through the courts for non attendance.

I have seen plenty of other types of scenario around EBSA but none that would be comparable to the PP who described being off school for a month receiving treatment and then returning to school.

Not sure if it's me, but I'm not following your point.

What is this 'clear treatment plan' you are referring to? Many young people can't get seen in the first place at present.
The poster you're referring to didn't have a 'clear treatment plan' either, they just saw a GP who gave a prescription. The difference was the parent made the decision. That simply can not happen now. So young people get stuck - too ill to attend, but on a waitlist for years.

OneandFiveOnly · Today 14:28

Happylife32 · Today 14:14

I watched the film and in many ways it was disturbing. I do feel that both diet and sleep contribute greatly to mental stability, and yet we never saw Thea eating a healthy meal, or told anything about how much sleep she was getting. There was a lot missing from the film as it was only 15 minutes long. We weren't told if the father was involved anywhere, for instance.

Ever heard of ARFID?

lemonts · Today 14:32

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 14:26

Not sure if it's me, but I'm not following your point.

What is this 'clear treatment plan' you are referring to? Many young people can't get seen in the first place at present.
The poster you're referring to didn't have a 'clear treatment plan' either, they just saw a GP who gave a prescription. The difference was the parent made the decision. That simply can not happen now. So young people get stuck - too ill to attend, but on a waitlist for years.

Edited

My point was that the PP described a short period off school when she received a diagnosis of depression for which she was also then medicated. She then sais that nowadays that would be EBSA. I was pointing out that that wouldn't be classifed as EBSA today.

If you go to a GP and they diagnose a condition and then give you medication to treat and either cure or improve that condition, that is a treatment plan, I am not sure how I can be any clearer! In some cases as per the PP the treatment is effective and sometimes it is not in which case you normally go back and they review the treatment plan. I am not sure what aspect if this your are struggling to understand.

OneandFiveOnly · Today 14:35

I’ve just had a fantastic talk with a very experienced SENDCo who has utterly lamented the state of the education system and schools (and confirms they were very different 25 years ago), the complete stripping of curiosity, joy and exploration from learning and a rapid deterioration in support schools can give and access to support in the past 15 years. She’s been around the block a few times, has managed units where children were so shut down and so traumatised that they weren’t functioning but with the right support are now successful well adjusted adults (noT NEET)

Schools are damaging children.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 14:36

lemonts · Today 14:32

My point was that the PP described a short period off school when she received a diagnosis of depression for which she was also then medicated. She then sais that nowadays that would be EBSA. I was pointing out that that wouldn't be classifed as EBSA today.

If you go to a GP and they diagnose a condition and then give you medication to treat and either cure or improve that condition, that is a treatment plan, I am not sure how I can be any clearer! In some cases as per the PP the treatment is effective and sometimes it is not in which case you normally go back and they review the treatment plan. I am not sure what aspect if this your are struggling to understand.

Obviously I wasn't there and neither were you so we are somewhat guessing! - I read that they didn't have a diagnosis, they just had some Prozac and went home. A 'depressive episode' is not a diagnosis.

lemonts · Today 14:42

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 14:36

Obviously I wasn't there and neither were you so we are somewhat guessing! - I read that they didn't have a diagnosis, they just had some Prozac and went home. A 'depressive episode' is not a diagnosis.

Well of course, i filled in the gap, between the GP reviewing the patient and prescribing some medication, with them identifying some sort of issue the medication was meant to address, but by all means if you would rather interpret it as young person saw GP who made no findings with regard to their health and then unrelatedly prescribed them some anti depressants then by all means do so. Still not sure how it relates to EBSA though as it is not a comparable situation.

BruachAbhann · Today 15:05

OneandFiveOnly · Today 14:35

I’ve just had a fantastic talk with a very experienced SENDCo who has utterly lamented the state of the education system and schools (and confirms they were very different 25 years ago), the complete stripping of curiosity, joy and exploration from learning and a rapid deterioration in support schools can give and access to support in the past 15 years. She’s been around the block a few times, has managed units where children were so shut down and so traumatised that they weren’t functioning but with the right support are now successful well adjusted adults (noT NEET)

Schools are damaging children.

Completely agree. I'd like to add that schools are also damaging parents. My son has still got symptoms of PTSD 11 months on and I still have moments of complete overwhelm and sadness and anger when I think of what he's been through. I as a parent was completely blamed for his not being able to cope in school. I was told to 'shame' into behaving a certain way, which of course I did not. He was bullied by staff members and the narrative of what he was going through was framed as his fault. If he got upset they said it was because he couldn't manage his emotions.

It's very hard as a parent to see what's going on in the school and you have to put a certain amount of trust in them. But it turned out everything my son told me was happening to him was indeed happening and as soon as I became aware of this I took him out.

A friend of mine saw the way the special needs assistant harassed and needled at another child who had additional needs. The child begged to be left alone to play and that the SNA stop being 'mean' to her and ended up self-harming to try to make her stop. My friend went in to report it to the principal and was told to mind her own business and that the SNA was experienced. There was zero concern from any staff member for the child who was clearly distressed. She was playing perfectly happily until the SNA started at her for no reason.

It absolutely sickens me when I see parents being blamed for their children's struggles and distress when parents are completely shattered from the whole experience of trying to protect their vulnerable kids from an environment which should be safe and nurturing but is actually harmful.

I will add that my son comes from a very stable, happy family and has no issues at home. He was always perfectly happy and relaxed during school holidays and at weekends. People often comment on what a sociable, friendly and curious guy he is. But walking over the threshold into school made him visible stressed and anxious and ultimately was extremely detrimental to his mental health.

Velumental · Today 15:54

lemonts · Today 14:32

My point was that the PP described a short period off school when she received a diagnosis of depression for which she was also then medicated. She then sais that nowadays that would be EBSA. I was pointing out that that wouldn't be classifed as EBSA today.

If you go to a GP and they diagnose a condition and then give you medication to treat and either cure or improve that condition, that is a treatment plan, I am not sure how I can be any clearer! In some cases as per the PP the treatment is effective and sometimes it is not in which case you normally go back and they review the treatment plan. I am not sure what aspect if this your are struggling to understand.

But nowadays the GP.wouldnt diagnose depression in a child, they would refer to cahms, the child would be undiagnosed with only the parents say so for the time did, I was off for weeks, it would have been classed as EBSA.

Velumental · Today 15:58

lemonts · Today 14:01

So not comparable to the PP who i was responding to.

I am the pp you were responding to

Those children have a diagnosis same as I was diagnosed 'depressive episode' but in 1996 I could be diagnosed at treated at GP level and my school sent home work and I got back to school to do exams.

There was a stigma then but there weren't fines. Absolutely there would have been pressure to get me in the door and the threat of fines for non attendance if I'd been off for weeks. You really don't think that happens? Who do you think the children with EBSA are? If not children struggling with neurodivergence and associated mental health?

lemonts · Today 16:06

Velumental · Today 15:54

But nowadays the GP.wouldnt diagnose depression in a child, they would refer to cahms, the child would be undiagnosed with only the parents say so for the time did, I was off for weeks, it would have been classed as EBSA.

Do you know what EBSA is an acronym for? It is not equivalent to being medically unfit for school. By your rationale a child who has surgery and is signed off to recover would be classed as EBSA which is plainly not the case. Access to services is a whole other discussion but it doesn't suddenly make things EBSA when they are not.

lemonts · Today 16:10

Velumental · Today 15:58

I am the pp you were responding to

Those children have a diagnosis same as I was diagnosed 'depressive episode' but in 1996 I could be diagnosed at treated at GP level and my school sent home work and I got back to school to do exams.

There was a stigma then but there weren't fines. Absolutely there would have been pressure to get me in the door and the threat of fines for non attendance if I'd been off for weeks. You really don't think that happens? Who do you think the children with EBSA are? If not children struggling with neurodivergence and associated mental health?

And there is a fundamental difference between an Autism diagnosis for which their is no treatment per se and is a lifelong condition and say a mental health diagnosis with a treatment plan which could be a range of different things. There is a big issue with co morbidity across these two areas but again that is a different situation to the one you described

NightHeron · Today 16:44

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 12:55

This is it though, what can they do? EBSA only appeared in its current form a few short years ago. People don’t have the foggiest how to approach it. Everyone’s trying. Sadly a lot of these kids are just beyond help. I really doubt anything bar sheer necessity will see them live a normal adult life. Aka the benefits rug being pulled, which is now set to happen, with an extremely painful adjustment period

No, it didn’t. I was working on a SEN helpline 28 years ago, and I was coming across children, as young as seven or eight, who were suicidal, because they couldn’t cope in school; as were my colleagues. We were advising parents to video their children school refusing in the mornings, as evidence for the SEND tribunal.

Scamworried · Today 19:11

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 12:49

I don’t really believe it’s a life or death scenario. I think this type of language is unhelpful.

Im going to assume you just don't understand rather than the alternative

Please educate yourself suicide is a thing and lots of young people have committed suicide due to school. Deny it doesn't help anyone and does alot of damage

Scamworried · Today 19:16

lemonts · Today 13:15

No you wouldn't you would have been off sick with a diagnosed mental health condition for which there was a clear treatment plan in place overseen by a clinician.

That doesn't happen now

Scamworried · Today 19:21

lemonts · Today 13:20

I haven't said any of those things. I simply pointed out that it is not true to say that children with EBSA are regularly completing suicide in response to a poster stating that that was the case. I think it's good news personally that suicide rates amongst pre teens and young teens are and always have been low. It seems concerniung to me that someone would want to exaggerate the risks associated with EBSA to suggest that CYP are regularly completing suicide. Of course if that's what you believe that's up to you but it's not actually true.

It's statistics until it's your own child the. It doesn't matter how low the statistic are - any child being suicidal because of school is one child too many

Scamworried · Today 19:30

lemonts · Today 14:32

My point was that the PP described a short period off school when she received a diagnosis of depression for which she was also then medicated. She then sais that nowadays that would be EBSA. I was pointing out that that wouldn't be classifed as EBSA today.

If you go to a GP and they diagnose a condition and then give you medication to treat and either cure or improve that condition, that is a treatment plan, I am not sure how I can be any clearer! In some cases as per the PP the treatment is effective and sometimes it is not in which case you normally go back and they review the treatment plan. I am not sure what aspect if this your are struggling to understand.

Today the GP would not diagnose depression and give a prescription. The GP would need to refer to a pediatrician/Cahms
The child would then be on a long wait list not getting treatment
The school would be pushing attendance at any cost and threatening fines. So the parent would be pressured to get child to school while unwell.

The continued attendance at the environment causing the depression along side the longer wait before treatment means that where as a month on meds and ready allowed that poster to return to school now the young person depression would be much much worse before treatment could even begin

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 19:41

Velumental · Today 15:58

I am the pp you were responding to

Those children have a diagnosis same as I was diagnosed 'depressive episode' but in 1996 I could be diagnosed at treated at GP level and my school sent home work and I got back to school to do exams.

There was a stigma then but there weren't fines. Absolutely there would have been pressure to get me in the door and the threat of fines for non attendance if I'd been off for weeks. You really don't think that happens? Who do you think the children with EBSA are? If not children struggling with neurodivergence and associated mental health?

That poster appears determined to draw false parallels between two completely different eras, school policy environments, NHS policy environments etc.

What happened to you then was of it's time - and yes because you were free to take some time out you had scope to recover quickly.

The attendance hyper-focus has had some very serious, negative side effects.

Velumental · Today 21:23

lemonts · Today 16:06

Do you know what EBSA is an acronym for? It is not equivalent to being medically unfit for school. By your rationale a child who has surgery and is signed off to recover would be classed as EBSA which is plainly not the case. Access to services is a whole other discussion but it doesn't suddenly make things EBSA when they are not.

Emotional based school avoidance.

And if I was a teenager now and lay in bed and refused to get out and said I couldn't do it and couldn't go to school and my brain was fuzzy and I couldn't concentrate and everything was entirely broken... My mum would phone the school, they'd tell her to call the GP, the GP would refer me to cahms, I'd wait 6-8 months for a diagnosis and the same again for treatment if it was a simple mh diagnosis. So if be a year battling the will to get out of bed and begging not to have to go to school and failing exams. Etc etc etc. My life plan would have been right out the window. People like you would have been stood around judging me.

Autism is lifelong but the comorbidiyies of mh don't have to be if a child is taught how go manage their environment to suit them.

You see to want to write autistic children off rather than support them. Because what's the point? But that's your extreme ableism

OneandFiveOnly · Today 21:32

lemonts · Today 16:06

Do you know what EBSA is an acronym for? It is not equivalent to being medically unfit for school. By your rationale a child who has surgery and is signed off to recover would be classed as EBSA which is plainly not the case. Access to services is a whole other discussion but it doesn't suddenly make things EBSA when they are not.

Why do you think EBSA is not the equivalent to being medically unfit for school?

FYI ‘medically unfit’ does not exist in the relevant laws and associated statutory guidance.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page