Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest you watch and share the film unauthorised absence - particularly if you work in schools/your child has SEN or difficultly attending school

773 replies

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 20:31

This excellent short film Unauthorised Absence has been produced to highlight
the actual reality of what it is like for families whose children can't cope in school for whatever reason (SEN, mental health, anxiety etc) and how they are often punished rather than helped. It is a heatwrenching watch.

The story follows a single mother fighting a punitive education system when her autistic nine-year-old daughter experiences severe school distress and emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA). It stars Emily Bruni, Beatrice Flaherty, Cathy Tyson, and Anna Maxwell Martin.
It is on the longlist for the Best Short Film at the British Independent Film Awards.

It was crowd funded by parents and others whose childrens have suffered due to the system and aims to help change the dialogue around how these children and their parents are viewed. Both my children have had great difficulties in school one not being able to attend at all and the other forcing herself in until she had a severe breakdown while school told us they were both 'fine in school' - so I think it is really important to watch and share this.

(Please note - the film contains some pretty distressing scenes and there is some self harm. It is quite a difficult watch for anyone who has been through this with their family)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn8C7WuGv8g

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ThisWildPoet · 12/11/2026 09:02

Schools aren't the issue. The education framework is.
The expectations on teachers are completely unachievable and therefore they don't have the 'time' to deliver what is expected.
Not saying there aren't rubbish teachers, but there are also rubbish parents. ( not talking about this specific example) some parents forget that, to them, their child is the most important thing on the planet but they aren't the only person the staff have to deal with.
Making accommodations for your child at home is far far easier than making them for 34 individuals when you're the only adult.
We need more specialist schools brought back so we can give students the education they need.

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:03

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 21:28

School has never been LESS punitive. 2000s we had uniform inspections, Saturday detentions, teachers would actually shout at you, no screens just endless boring writing. At primary we had to sit facing the wall if we were naughty.

It’s not schools that have changed, it’s children

and do you think the needs of children with SEN, especially girls with undiagnosed Sen were being met then either??

and tbh, I went to school in the 80s and 90s and I don't recogniseost of what you say. I'm sorry you went to a shit school, that doesn't mean that's what we want for our kids.

TeethAreImportant · 12/11/2026 09:09

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 21:31

That may be the case ( although personally I feel they are a lot worse since I was at school in the 1980s - so a long time ago!)
However the film is more about the punitative approach to children not being able to attend. As in parents can be fined if their child is unable to attend school due to poor mental health or unmet SEN needs.

You obviously didn't have corporal punishment in your school. In my school (primary), in the 1980s, children were still regularly hit by teachers, I was hit myself by a female teacher, over her knee, in front if the whole class, I can't even remember what for, I think it was talking. Also got hit over the head with the wooden chalk board wiper by a male teacher in secondary. I wasn't a naught child, was never on report, suspended etc... did well at lessons. There was just casual violence meted out, sometimes for very small things.

Whatafustercluck · 12/11/2026 09:11

DustyOwl · 12/11/2026 07:42

I have worked in schools for 25 years, class teacher, TA, behaviour lead, forest school teacher, mainstream, SEND schools, PRUs (pupil referral units) APs (alternative provision). I have worked in areas of social deprivation and schools in incredibly wealthy areas. I have got around.
My Dad was an education psychologist and my Mum a primary school teacher for 30 years. I currently work as a speech’s and language therapist with children on the cusp of permanent exclusion. I have also had children who have been all the way through the state school system.

I can give you my 2 pennies worth, which will be true of some children and not of others, because after all this time, I am still learning and definitely don’t know all of the answers.

This is an incredibly complex situation, born from the fact that society has changed immeasurably in the last 25 years, the way people parent has changed (not better or worse) and the education system has massively changed too. Not schools, the whole system.

When my Dad was working, and Ed psych would regularly go to a school. They’d see children who were a concern and then support the school/parents. Each school had a designated one from the LEA. Academies came along, we no longer have the massive team of universal support, offered to every school. This support was multi level, teachers were given training too.

The system was much better (not perfect) at offering support to children with low level need. Parents weren’t always aware of the support a child was getting because it came to the whole school. We have gone back to a medical model. Children have to have a diagnosis to access support, schools don’t have the budget to get the support they need.

More importantly there was time. Schools were not a hot house of constant testing, to meet arbitrary standards. That level of constant assessment just didn’t exist. Teachers had time to teach and support children who needed it. Teachers still want to do that now but there isn’t time. The foundation subjects have been squeezed to death. Is your child a talented musician? Can’t afford private lessons? Tough. There will be no recognition in school because there isn’t time to teach it/support it. Drama? PE? Art? In primary schools, where we had time to spend a whole afternoon doing it, now there is a topic, which lasts a term. Teachers try to cover it other ways by creative teaching in the core subjects but, if your child isn’t good at Maths and English, there isn’t time to celebrate and nurture their interest and talent. Parents pay chunks of money for private lessons in drama, art, sports etc but if you can’t afford that, forget it. Your child’s talents won’t be recognised and they won’t feel like they are succeeding. Not the schools fault, a system based on assessing children on Maths and English (notice not much science) in primary. By the time they get to secondary they already feel like failures.

Then we move onto support staff. There were TAs to offer support to children and teachers. They weren’t in every class, then they were, to match the changing curriculum the the pressures teachers faced. Then the TAs were taken away, because of budgets but also because supports staffs wages are so disgustingly low that many, very skilled professionals have to leave, to earn enough, to support themselves. The TAs role has changed, the responsibilities have changed but the pay hasn’t. They aren’t Teacher Assistants anymore, they are Assistant Teachers and they get paid bugger all.

I haven’t said everything I want. Not even slightly, but I bet you’re glad I’m going to stop now. I’m going to get to my job, seeing the parents and teachers, struggling to do their best.

These are massive generalisations. There is way more than this to consider, society, parenting, the way children socialise etc but I have run out of time.

Oh, and by the way, I blame Gove. Just saying.

Thank you for such a measured and insightful post. I read the first page of responses and began to despair. It was worth sticking with the thread to get to this, which is just so, so true - right down to Gove!

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 09:12

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:03

and do you think the needs of children with SEN, especially girls with undiagnosed Sen were being met then either??

and tbh, I went to school in the 80s and 90s and I don't recogniseost of what you say. I'm sorry you went to a shit school, that doesn't mean that's what we want for our kids.

They weren’t.

Goldenbear · 12/11/2026 09:12

Pobblewob · 12/11/2026 06:34

For those saying schools haven’t changed, why have so many teachers left and why is it so hard to recruit more? Clue: it’s not because of the kids

In many cases it IS because of the kids. Poor behaviour is regularly cited as a reason for leaving teaching. Along with entitled parents, trying to meet too many needs, and rubbish pay.

The pay 'isn't' rubbish though. Average overall pay is £52000. Equally, many schools have a top heavy structure so you get many deputies or Head of curricular posts, or some other such additional role that gives them Teacher and Learning Responsibilities (TLR) supplements. Considering most teachers work pretty locally, they don't have to pay expensive season tickets for train fair to the nearest city which maybe £400 a month then it fairs pretty well.

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:15

ThisWildPoet · 12/11/2026 09:02

Schools aren't the issue. The education framework is.
The expectations on teachers are completely unachievable and therefore they don't have the 'time' to deliver what is expected.
Not saying there aren't rubbish teachers, but there are also rubbish parents. ( not talking about this specific example) some parents forget that, to them, their child is the most important thing on the planet but they aren't the only person the staff have to deal with.
Making accommodations for your child at home is far far easier than making them for 34 individuals when you're the only adult.
We need more specialist schools brought back so we can give students the education they need.

but a bright child with autism is unlikely to have their educational needs met at a special school because they primarily support kids with educational needs.

I friend had her 5 year old excluded from school for turning up not wearing the correct uniform. school know she has complex medical needs, that there were issues with uniform in nursery, that Mom had tried communicating with school, that they were accessing all the help available, pursuing extra help, waiting for a diagnosis. The teacher stood in the door and refused access. Not because making an accomodation was too hard - it was more effort to exclude her. Even when they were told a few days later the autism was confirmed, they didn't respond. she literally told them in a meeting and they just say there saying nothing. Because like the girl in the film, once she's in she masks so hard she's quiet and compliant. Then melts down at home.

Some schools are absolutely without doubt led by ignorance and stubborness, especially around girls

MotherofPufflings · 12/11/2026 09:19

Reading these replies I'm a bit confused about whether we're saying that EBSA has always happened, we just never noticed before/all the kids who would have school refused in the past were in specialist provision before (seems unlikely)/EBSA has gone up but it's because of changes to the education system.

What is interesting is that school avoidance seems to have significantly increased in many other Western countries (US, Australia, New Zealand and others) since covid. That it went up at a particular point in time and across numerous countries suggests to me that it isn't the school environment or changes to the education system that are driving this alone and there's other factors at play.

ChocolateApples · 12/11/2026 09:24

What we did have at my secondary school was a lot of what was classed as truancy. These were kids who weren't engaged with school who simply didn't come in for a significant chunk of time. I wonder how they would be classed today. It was definitely seen as misbehaviour, although there were attempts to help them. I only know of one person who had the label of school refusal.

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:25

HettyTagliatelli · 11/11/2026 22:12

I work in a school and am
Interested enough to save this to watch. I’m wondering if the right balance is struck though or if it’s just critical of schools for the sake of it. Does it mention that the majority of unauthorised absences are because parents value the free education their children receive so little that they’d rather take cheap
holidays or they keep their children off school for a sniffle when they’d be perfectly fine and build some resilience by going in? Or talk about the parents who keep their children at home because of their own anxieties and need for company?

The reason that schools face so much pressure to prevent absence is that there is clear evidence that absence has a detrimental effect on long term educational outcomes. They have a responsibility to do what is best for children’s education even when parents don’t. So while there are no doubt children that genuinely struggle with being in a school environment and have genuine reasons for high levels of absence, there are also a significant number of children that are at home when they should be at school and whose parents are failing them by choosing not to send them in.

no because it is very specifically about children with (undiagnosed) SEN. Why should that need to be coopted to cover every other issue in society. maybe make your own film called Marbella or Maths, a Mother's Choice.

ThisWildPoet · 12/11/2026 09:25

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:15

but a bright child with autism is unlikely to have their educational needs met at a special school because they primarily support kids with educational needs.

I friend had her 5 year old excluded from school for turning up not wearing the correct uniform. school know she has complex medical needs, that there were issues with uniform in nursery, that Mom had tried communicating with school, that they were accessing all the help available, pursuing extra help, waiting for a diagnosis. The teacher stood in the door and refused access. Not because making an accomodation was too hard - it was more effort to exclude her. Even when they were told a few days later the autism was confirmed, they didn't respond. she literally told them in a meeting and they just say there saying nothing. Because like the girl in the film, once she's in she masks so hard she's quiet and compliant. Then melts down at home.

Some schools are absolutely without doubt led by ignorance and stubborness, especially around girls

I never said special school. I said specialist. I meant having adapted provision for students of all abilities. I wasn't taking about sticking all kids with needs in a room and forgetting about them. Schools can not meet the needs of every student, its impossible. So maybe we need to look at tailored provision being more available. Smaller settings with targeted learning and staff with higher levels of specific training. Yes teachers learn about (for example) autisim, but no 2 autistic students are the same, put 5 with different needs in a class of 34 and then add on all the other needs, disabilities, mental health concerns, and the staff can not do it.

HeartsAndLove · 12/11/2026 09:26

Thank you for sharing, I can’t watch it right now as things are still too raw but thanks for sharing it as I had not heard of it and will try to watch it soon

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:27

TheSnappyBluePoster · 12/11/2026 01:28

I remember as a child, i didn't like the school dinner's version of christmas dinners.They served up and didn't want to eat it. So I didn't

Me, along with another child, experienced prolonged screaming and shouting from the female teacher in front of the entire rest of the class involving language such as this - AND AS FOR YOU, YOU OUGHT TO BE SHOT. YOUR BEHAVIOUR WAS DISGRACEFUL.

I still remember the rage on her face. I didn't like my school dinners when I was seven years old.

Children have change rather than school and the poor little darlings, can't make it to school because of stress and anxiety for whatever reason, but quite frankly, they're not being spoken to like this.

I'm unsure of your point

Children being screamed at and hit my well have forced compliance, but I can guarantee it was in no way good for the child or the adult they became.

I'm unsure if you think anything less than abuse must be ok, or we should return to abusing children?

Frazzlesforever · 12/11/2026 09:27

Stiwy · 12/11/2026 00:45

I used to be a school refuser. I didn’t want people to look at me (I hate being perceived even now) My mum was a no nonsense type and would drag me there, she made me go. I remember the head teacher sitting me in her office and asking why I didn’t want to go. Once i was there I masked/managed and I found learning and exams very easy. It was the other people and being looked at, having to socialise, having to answer questions in class that was the issue. I was cripplingly anxious.

As much as I hated my mum at the time, she did me a huge favour. If I’d lied about being ill or really wouldn’t go, she wouldn’t let me stay home and watch TV or do my artwork, she wouldn’t have let me ride a scooter to school, she made sure there were consequences for not going to school. My attendance was never 100% or anywhere close but she made sure I passed my exams.

Had she let me stay home, I’d have failed to launch. I wouldn’t have learned how to mask at all (I feel this is a useful life skill for autistic people because the world will never change for us), I wouldn’t have learned to cope with the outside world. I would have stayed in the house forever.

I am autistic but I’m glad I wasn’t pandered to because I’ve built a life. I choose to stay home a lot these days but if I have to go out there, I know how to operate in the neurotypical world because I was forced out of my comfort zone. I have many struggles but because I got qualifications I was able to get a job that pays for aids and adaptations to help me. I can choose to work from home.

I fear we are setting girls like I was up for a failure to launch. They won’t be able to function in society if they’ve never had to learn to try because I know for a fact, given the choice, I wouldn’t have flown if I wasn’t pushed out of the nest, no matter how uncomfortable it got.

This is really interesting to me. I'm pleased worked out for you. I used to agree with what you said.

I took your mums approach (a little softer maybe- but expected school attendance etc). Unfortunately not everyone can just push through things - my daughter has had a huge breakdown and still unwell 9 months on. It doesn't always end positively.

OP posts:
Cunninghunt · 12/11/2026 09:29

Velumental · 12/11/2026 00:53

  1. my son learns well at school, he has a ridiculously high IQ which was measured due to all his other issues. It does him no good if he comes home, screams, self harms and can't sleep until 2am from stress (thankfully no longer our reality due o interventions put in place by us, schools Nd psychology)

  2. if you have a child with ASD having a sensory meltdown it's not rewarding school avoidance to allow them to spin or swing to calm their nervous system, it's support for a disability.ovement and fresh air and time to recover can be the difference in getting a child in say 10 minutes late or being sat on the ground next to a rocking screaming child several hours later and not getting them in at all.

  3. do you have children and a job? Are you available to take a parenting course which is very unlikely to help in the case of a Neurodivergent child?

  4. you want her to take the child to school right? The school is on a busy road. How do you propose she takes the emotionally volatile child to the school that is causing the emotional volatility which is on a busy road without minding a volatile child by a busy road?

Could you please talk me through how you would get that child to school? Keep up your work commitments? Attend a parenting course when you're out of annual leave? Please talk me through how you're getting that child who is so distressed she's violent towards herself and her mum dressed, out the door and safely tos cool in a timely fashion?

  1. the child would not be able to focus well and "mask" all day (which incidentally is something everybody has to do) if their nervous system was screaming at them all day long.More importantly the child is gaining an education and not throwing away their future.
  2. If they need to spin etc for ten minutes before school, then you build it into the morning routine.
  3. Parental leave, annual leave??
  4. The mum wasn't even looking at the child let alone holding onto her!
Soontobe60 · 12/11/2026 09:30

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 11/11/2026 22:25

Autism and MH issues do not start at home ffs.

Many MH issues do start at home though.

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:33

metellaestinatrio · 12/11/2026 07:50

There were also a lot more children in the classroom if we go back to the 60s/70s (40+ kids in my mum’s primary school class) and yet teachers still managed to maintain order - which was largely because schools were stricter, everyone sat in lines facing the front, you were hit with a ruler if you talked, teaching was very much “chalk and talk”. Yet now, when primary schools at least are much more nurturing, child-focussed environments with extra adults in the room and multiple adjustments for children who struggle we are saying schools are “too draconian” and this is why children refuse to go in?

perhaps the issue is, if you verbally and physically abide children, or they see children around them openly physically and verbally abused and of the threat of them being verbally and physically abused is ever present, you can break most children into a level of compliance that's more about disconnecting and emotionally disabling them, rather than them being able to grow and flourish.

we no longer accept abusing children as ok.

so children are more able to feel and express what's actually going on.

now as a society we're still lagging behind because cwere giving kid's their voice but we haven't learnt to fully listen.

So the child is struggling to go to school because of things inside them, they aren't scared of a beating because we no longer think it's ok to abuse children, but they lack the articulation and society lacks the flexibility to support that.

Hopefully the generation we're raising who have voiced but aren't fully heard will be the adults who are able to listen and build a society adaptable to everyone.

just as once children with a physical disability wouldn't have been able to fully access mainstream education, and now can, we can only hope society continues to develop.

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 09:35

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:03

and do you think the needs of children with SEN, especially girls with undiagnosed Sen were being met then either??

and tbh, I went to school in the 80s and 90s and I don't recogniseost of what you say. I'm sorry you went to a shit school, that doesn't mean that's what we want for our kids.

My school was brilliant. It had excellent outcomes. I’m very grateful I got to attend. I’m not NT myself and without proper structure and expectations I’m sure I would’ve spent my days watching TV and getting inside my own head at home. Once you do that it’s very hard to come back.

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 09:36

Problem is everyone wants a softly softly education system that prioritises feelings and has no expectations. This just isn’t realistic unfortunately. We do need a workforce at the end of it, not adults who spend their lives introspecting and needing constant ‘support’ to do the most basic things

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 09:38

Cunninghunt · 12/11/2026 09:29

  1. the child would not be able to focus well and "mask" all day (which incidentally is something everybody has to do) if their nervous system was screaming at them all day long.More importantly the child is gaining an education and not throwing away their future.
  2. If they need to spin etc for ten minutes before school, then you build it into the morning routine.
  3. Parental leave, annual leave??
  4. The mum wasn't even looking at the child let alone holding onto her!
  1. What qualifications do you have that inform you that children are not able to mask all day? Educational Psychologist? SALT? Pediatrician? Specialist teacher?
Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 09:40

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 09:38

  1. What qualifications do you have that inform you that children are not able to mask all day? Educational Psychologist? SALT? Pediatrician? Specialist teacher?

It’s an internet chat forum. You’ve probably provided opinions on something you’re not an expert on 🤷‍♀️ doesn’t mean it’s not valid discussion

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:41

Cunninghunt · 12/11/2026 09:29

  1. the child would not be able to focus well and "mask" all day (which incidentally is something everybody has to do) if their nervous system was screaming at them all day long.More importantly the child is gaining an education and not throwing away their future.
  2. If they need to spin etc for ten minutes before school, then you build it into the morning routine.
  3. Parental leave, annual leave??
  4. The mum wasn't even looking at the child let alone holding onto her!
  1. well yes of course the child can't focus well and mask sll day, which is why the teacher commented on her being in their own world. and they're not gaining an education if their only way to cope is going onwards.
  2. you realise the child isn't doing any behaviour for a set time? she probably tried getting up earlier, but then the child is then extrs tired on top, and sleeping poorly at night due to the stress.
3.She clearly said she'd used all her leave. Parental leave doesn't cover the bills. the real question is where is the Dad and why had he abdicated responsibility?
  1. The mother was overwhelmed and on the verge of a breakdown. she's about to face court, fines, the threat of jail which would likely mean her kid in care. No one is suggesting she'd perfect. We can sll have moments when we're pushed and pulled so hard we just momentarily cannot function, hence the walking away. It's not the same as intentionally neglecting her or trying to punish her. it's literally a few seconds ofjust not being able to do this for one second more. it's you've never reached that point. an a different day the car would have stopped faster, or not been there or she'd have run in the other direction. the whole point is it's the absolute apex of the emotional snd physical breakdown of this family.
Whatafustercluck · 12/11/2026 09:41

MotherofPufflings · 12/11/2026 09:19

Reading these replies I'm a bit confused about whether we're saying that EBSA has always happened, we just never noticed before/all the kids who would have school refused in the past were in specialist provision before (seems unlikely)/EBSA has gone up but it's because of changes to the education system.

What is interesting is that school avoidance seems to have significantly increased in many other Western countries (US, Australia, New Zealand and others) since covid. That it went up at a particular point in time and across numerous countries suggests to me that it isn't the school environment or changes to the education system that are driving this alone and there's other factors at play.

Edited

Covid definitely had an impact. For some, the lack of socialisation at a key developmental stage, fear of germs, other people, not going to school etc has left its mark. However, the impact was even greater for undiagnosed ND children. One of the opportunities to have their additional needs recognised is through school, so many were denied timely support. Waiting lists increased. Appointments took place via screens instead of face to face. All of this increased the impact on children who may well have had better outcomes if they'd received more timely, effective support. And now we're playing catch up. Except we're not catching up - indeed we are becoming further and further behind, which simply exacerbates an already huge problem.

As for EBSA, I believe it has always been there. A boy in my class, came from a 'good' family, was academically bright but had crippling anxiety that saw him spending increasing time away from the classroom until he was no longer there at all. He now stacks shelves in my local Tesco. But statistics prove that it has worsened in recent years - coinciding with both Covid and Gove's educational reforms. I genuinely believe that SEN children who would have coped without EHCPs in mainstream schools in the old system, and pre-Covid, are no longer able to access the learning. Austerity has deprived schools of the resources they once had, fewer TAs, bigger class sizes, more unpredictability in the classroom environment, noise etc.

None of this is schools' fault, but neither are most parents to blame. When people are quick to question my parenting, I reply that our eldest has near-perfect attendance, is predicted to do well in his GCSEs (though not nearly as well as he could do if he didn't have adhd), and is a sensible, kind, thoughtful almost 16 year old. Two kids, raised by the same parents, in the same way, an absence of childhood trauma, but completely different outcomes.

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:42

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 09:36

Problem is everyone wants a softly softly education system that prioritises feelings and has no expectations. This just isn’t realistic unfortunately. We do need a workforce at the end of it, not adults who spend their lives introspecting and needing constant ‘support’ to do the most basic things

literally no one is asking for they. we want an education system that is fit to meet the needs of it's students and a SLT willing to empower that.

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 09:44

thisismeithinkorisit · 12/11/2026 09:42

literally no one is asking for they. we want an education system that is fit to meet the needs of it's students and a SLT willing to empower that.

Ok so what does this actually look like? If you were given 5 things to change the school what would you actually do? I feel like whatever you did wouldn’t be enough.

Swipe left for the next trending thread