Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest you watch and share the film unauthorised absence - particularly if you work in schools/your child has SEN or difficultly attending school

772 replies

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 20:31

This excellent short film Unauthorised Absence has been produced to highlight
the actual reality of what it is like for families whose children can't cope in school for whatever reason (SEN, mental health, anxiety etc) and how they are often punished rather than helped. It is a heatwrenching watch.

The story follows a single mother fighting a punitive education system when her autistic nine-year-old daughter experiences severe school distress and emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA). It stars Emily Bruni, Beatrice Flaherty, Cathy Tyson, and Anna Maxwell Martin.
It is on the longlist for the Best Short Film at the British Independent Film Awards.

It was crowd funded by parents and others whose childrens have suffered due to the system and aims to help change the dialogue around how these children and their parents are viewed. Both my children have had great difficulties in school one not being able to attend at all and the other forcing herself in until she had a severe breakdown while school told us they were both 'fine in school' - so I think it is really important to watch and share this.

(Please note - the film contains some pretty distressing scenes and there is some self harm. It is quite a difficult watch for anyone who has been through this with their family)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn8C7WuGv8g

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Velumental · Today 12:54

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 12:49

I don’t really believe it’s a life or death scenario. I think this type of language is unhelpful.

Don't you?

Pre teens and teens attempt and manage suicide semi regularly, or they descend into horrible depressive states as adults and do it then. Kids who could otherwise be happy and productive. You do t think that's life or death?

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 12:55

Greentablecloth · 17/11/2026 14:11

We did try private therapy while on waiting lists. It didn’t help in our case. She eventually said he was beyond her scope as a therapist.
It’s also not affordable/not accessible for everyone.

CAMHS weren’t effective either when we did see them.

Although we did see escalating behaviours in primary school, sometimes children manage okay and parents are unaware until everything becomes too difficult and comes crashing down, sometimes in second level. So it’s not always an obvious progression.

This is it though, what can they do? EBSA only appeared in its current form a few short years ago. People don’t have the foggiest how to approach it. Everyone’s trying. Sadly a lot of these kids are just beyond help. I really doubt anything bar sheer necessity will see them live a normal adult life. Aka the benefits rug being pulled, which is now set to happen, with an extremely painful adjustment period

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 12:56

Velumental · Today 12:54

Don't you?

Pre teens and teens attempt and manage suicide semi regularly, or they descend into horrible depressive states as adults and do it then. Kids who could otherwise be happy and productive. You do t think that's life or death?

I don’t think they would otherwise be happy or productive. I’m yet to see any of them really turn it around, maybe the odd case with crazy expense and adjustments which can’t possibly be maintained into adult life

lemonts · Today 13:01

Velumental · Today 12:54

Don't you?

Pre teens and teens attempt and manage suicide semi regularly, or they descend into horrible depressive states as adults and do it then. Kids who could otherwise be happy and productive. You do t think that's life or death?

This just isn't true. Suicide rates for 10-14 year olds (under 10 isn't recorded as the numbers are so small and suicidal intent is so rare amongst that age group) are very very low and have remained pretty static for the last ten years at least. The idea that EBSA is routinely a matter of life or death is a grotesque mischaracterisation of reality.

Velumental · Today 13:03

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 12:56

I don’t think they would otherwise be happy or productive. I’m yet to see any of them really turn it around, maybe the odd case with crazy expense and adjustments which can’t possibly be maintained into adult life

My sister is about to turn 40, she has adhd, possibly autism, she school refused, truanted, snuck out and went to parties, was taken advantage of, her pre teen and teen years were a shambles. She eventually scraped anough gcses to do a levels, went to a different school, one with flexibility and support even for 6th form. She finished school, went to university and still struggled in her early 20s. By the time she was 30 she was in a highly paid management position, she works in mental health care which is how she got her own diagnosis and she's incredible. Married 10 years, 3 children, home owner, truly amazing person. And no one threw expense at her she just ended up at a more supportive school almost by accident and had a supportive but very broke family. We grew up in poverty.

I have so many stories like this, several within my own family because neurodivergence runs in families. The child you see screaming and writhing at the school gates could absolutely one day be a nurse or a doctor.or a teacher or a technician. I've seen it over and over again.

Just because you're unpleasant and bigoted and want to write kids off

Velumental · Today 13:05

lemonts · Today 13:01

This just isn't true. Suicide rates for 10-14 year olds (under 10 isn't recorded as the numbers are so small and suicidal intent is so rare amongst that age group) are very very low and have remained pretty static for the last ten years at least. The idea that EBSA is routinely a matter of life or death is a grotesque mischaracterisation of reality.

Children grow up.

The treatment they received as children makes the difference between a child living a long, happy and productive life with support and a child going on to suffer poor mental health in adulthood and lead lives that end in suicide or addiction or prison

That is literally life or death. .

Thekidsarefightingagain · Today 13:06

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 12:53

They’re overwhelmed because of the sheer number of referrals.

I know of at least 5 young people going through CAMHS for EBSA and similar, and that’s the ones I know about, aka in my relatively small friendship and family circle. If it’s any representation of the rest of the country there must be hundreds of thousands in the waiting lists, all for conditions that we barely know anything about as they were only named a few years ago.

It’s not a failure of ‘the system’, the system is being burdened with entirely unrealistic expectations.

Social care are overwhelmed too because of this. I've noticed the same with CAMHS - it must be really frustrating for them as they are left trying to n pick up the pieces but have all the risk thrown at them too. I wonder what staff retention is like there now.

Only so many clinical psychologists etc can be trained each year as few training places as only so many people can be trained at once. We can't magic SaLTs, OTs out of thin air either.

It's very scary what's going to happen, it's been going on for so long and however vocal everyone is across the board it just gets ignored yet again.

Velumental · Today 13:07

lemonts · Today 13:01

This just isn't true. Suicide rates for 10-14 year olds (under 10 isn't recorded as the numbers are so small and suicidal intent is so rare amongst that age group) are very very low and have remained pretty static for the last ten years at least. The idea that EBSA is routinely a matter of life or death is a grotesque mischaracterisation of reality.

School absenteeism as a risk factor for self-harm and suicidal ideation in children and adolescents: a systematic review and meta-analysis - PMC https://share.google/Iy8cnaWpRVSNIvdtn

There are clear studies linking self harm and suicide with school avoidance.

lemonts · Today 13:10

Velumental · Today 13:05

Children grow up.

The treatment they received as children makes the difference between a child living a long, happy and productive life with support and a child going on to suffer poor mental health in adulthood and lead lives that end in suicide or addiction or prison

That is literally life or death. .

Given that EBSA is a recent phenomenom and escalated massively post covid I think it is a massive stretch to extrapolate that it is the root of all of the societal issues that go into adult mental health, contact with the justice system and or addiction. But do continue to catastrophise.

lemonts · Today 13:12

Velumental · Today 13:07

School absenteeism as a risk factor for self-harm and suicidal ideation in children and adolescents: a systematic review and meta-analysis - PMC https://share.google/Iy8cnaWpRVSNIvdtn

There are clear studies linking self harm and suicide with school avoidance.

I am not sure you read that link fully before you posted it!

Velumental · Today 13:12

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 12:55

This is it though, what can they do? EBSA only appeared in its current form a few short years ago. People don’t have the foggiest how to approach it. Everyone’s trying. Sadly a lot of these kids are just beyond help. I really doubt anything bar sheer necessity will see them live a normal adult life. Aka the benefits rug being pulled, which is now set to happen, with an extremely painful adjustment period

It was renamed EBSA a few years ago

Prior to that it was persistent truancy that no one bothered looking into.

You think kids didn't hate school and refuse to attend in the 60s and 70s? I know first hand that they did in the 80s and onwards.

I'm 43, I loved school because I was academic and loved to learn but the social isolation I suffered meant when i had a depressive episode age 16 I couldn't attend, I lay in bed in silence for a month. My mum took me to the GP, they gave me prozac, I went back to bed, it was a dark dark time. My mum told school I was too sick to attend, she brought me cups for tea and buttery toast. She put on my favourite movies, she bought me books at the charity shop and I came back to life in time to do my exams.

Because I'm academic I sailed through a l the exams despite the time kissed, I. Very good at exams. Went to university, worked alongside studying, got my degree, my post graduate degree, have a successful career etc.

But for that month I would have been classed as EBSA.

lemonts · Today 13:15

Velumental · Today 13:12

It was renamed EBSA a few years ago

Prior to that it was persistent truancy that no one bothered looking into.

You think kids didn't hate school and refuse to attend in the 60s and 70s? I know first hand that they did in the 80s and onwards.

I'm 43, I loved school because I was academic and loved to learn but the social isolation I suffered meant when i had a depressive episode age 16 I couldn't attend, I lay in bed in silence for a month. My mum took me to the GP, they gave me prozac, I went back to bed, it was a dark dark time. My mum told school I was too sick to attend, she brought me cups for tea and buttery toast. She put on my favourite movies, she bought me books at the charity shop and I came back to life in time to do my exams.

Because I'm academic I sailed through a l the exams despite the time kissed, I. Very good at exams. Went to university, worked alongside studying, got my degree, my post graduate degree, have a successful career etc.

But for that month I would have been classed as EBSA.

No you wouldn't you would have been off sick with a diagnosed mental health condition for which there was a clear treatment plan in place overseen by a clinician.

Velumental · Today 13:16

lemonts · Today 13:10

Given that EBSA is a recent phenomenom and escalated massively post covid I think it is a massive stretch to extrapolate that it is the root of all of the societal issues that go into adult mental health, contact with the justice system and or addiction. But do continue to catastrophise.

Noone said it as the root of all mental health difficulties. I said it was part of a picture and supporting during it can be all the difference to a person's outcome.

It's not a recent phenomenon. Some kids found online learning much easier than managing school, some kids were out of the system that they found hard. School is a small window in a person's life, childhood is difficult because you have no control over how your life is. Why don't people see kids as human beings? With a full range of emotions who will quickly grow up and be adults? Why not.offer support while they grow.

Why the keenness to say parents of kids with ebsa are awful, kids with ebsa will amount to nothing. Whole history doesn't show us this. Kids in my generation we had issues and stayed off school and got kept home and noo w fined anyone. And we got through.

LyndaLaHughes · Today 13:17

As a teacher, the idea that conditions in schools are not driving this is utterly ludicrous. There I a reason that over 40,000 teachers are leaving every year and some of those same conditions that are driving teachers out are also causing some children to find it very hard to go to school. The curriculum is crammed. Children are expected to grasp harder things earlier, then move on before some of them have had time to get the hang of it. There’s less time for fun or for the lesson that goes slightly off plan because the children are genuinely interested. Even when they’ve done something well, it’s straight on to the next target, the next step, the next thing to improve. When do they get to feel proud of what they’ve already done? Plus it’s far too hard. Children are constantly feeling like everything is a challenge- and not in a good way
We’ve squeezed out so much of the time children used to have to play, make things, be creative and learn how to get along with each other. Think about what children learn when they make up a game together. They have to agree on the rules, work out how to include someone who wants to join in and figure out what to do when they fall out. There used to be more room for that, and for children to discover they were good at something that would never show up in a test score. Now we’re so busy getting through the curriculum that some of the most important things children learn at school barely get a look-in.
Then there’s the testing, the data drops, the booster groups and the constant pressure to get results. The fear of Ofsted can shape everything from what goes in a child’s book to how a school deals with behaviour. Some policies seem designed to look good on an inspection day. The children and staff have to live with them every day. Children pick up on adult stress too. They can feel it when everyone is rushing and nobody has a minute to spare.
We have children in mainstream classrooms with significant needs who, years ago, might have had a place in a specialist school, a unit or a smaller specialist class. Those children deserve the support that makes it possible for them to learn and feel safe. Funding is stretched, specialist places are scarce and the services schools used to turn to have been cut back. A teacher can care deeply about a child and still struggle to give them the time they need when there are thirty children in the room. When staff keep leaving, some children have to start all over again with the adults they’ve only just learned to trust.
Then, when a child struggles, we’re so quick to reach for a sanction. A child who is overwhelmed gets a detention for walking out. A child who has spent all morning trying to get through the door gets told off for being late. Who has time to sit down with them and ask what happened? Having one adult who knows them and understands why they’re struggling might be the very thing that helps them come back tomorrow.
I remember there being more room to slow down, enjoy school and actually get to know the children in front of us. I’ve been a teacher for over 25 years and I can see exactly what the problem is so I totally disagree with anyone trying to blame parents or not understanding the realities of EBSA. The system needs to change dramatically for the sake of everyone in it. It’s ridiculous to think that a system having such a negative impact on teachers isn’t also impacting children negatively too.

Velumental · Today 13:19

lemonts · Today 13:15

No you wouldn't you would have been off sick with a diagnosed mental health condition for which there was a clear treatment plan in place overseen by a clinician.

Which is the case for a lot of these kids, many don't recover like I did or don't get access to mental health diagnosis, I only saw the GP no referrals needed. Called in the morning, at the doctors in the afternoon, script and follow up arranged. Supportive parent. No need for her to worry her meagre income would be eroded if she didn't force me in to school.

lemonts · Today 13:20

Velumental · Today 13:16

Noone said it as the root of all mental health difficulties. I said it was part of a picture and supporting during it can be all the difference to a person's outcome.

It's not a recent phenomenon. Some kids found online learning much easier than managing school, some kids were out of the system that they found hard. School is a small window in a person's life, childhood is difficult because you have no control over how your life is. Why don't people see kids as human beings? With a full range of emotions who will quickly grow up and be adults? Why not.offer support while they grow.

Why the keenness to say parents of kids with ebsa are awful, kids with ebsa will amount to nothing. Whole history doesn't show us this. Kids in my generation we had issues and stayed off school and got kept home and noo w fined anyone. And we got through.

I haven't said any of those things. I simply pointed out that it is not true to say that children with EBSA are regularly completing suicide in response to a poster stating that that was the case. I think it's good news personally that suicide rates amongst pre teens and young teens are and always have been low. It seems concerniung to me that someone would want to exaggerate the risks associated with EBSA to suggest that CYP are regularly completing suicide. Of course if that's what you believe that's up to you but it's not actually true.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 13:22

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 21:28

School has never been LESS punitive. 2000s we had uniform inspections, Saturday detentions, teachers would actually shout at you, no screens just endless boring writing. At primary we had to sit facing the wall if we were naughty.

It’s not schools that have changed, it’s children

Don't recognise ANY of that from the period, or even a decade earlier.

lemonts · Today 13:23

Velumental · Today 13:19

Which is the case for a lot of these kids, many don't recover like I did or don't get access to mental health diagnosis, I only saw the GP no referrals needed. Called in the morning, at the doctors in the afternoon, script and follow up arranged. Supportive parent. No need for her to worry her meagre income would be eroded if she didn't force me in to school.

So there are a lot of children with diagnosed mental health conditions, with identified treatment plans overseen by clinicians whose parents are being forced to take them in or they are going to be taken to court, is that really what you are suggesting, because that is complete rubbish (i.e families in a situation directly comparable to your)

SleeplessInWherever · Today 13:27

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 13:22

Don't recognise ANY of that from the period, or even a decade earlier.

Nope, me neither.

I was in primary school in the 90s and secondary school 01-06.

I used to wear pink converse for school because I thought I was clever, my tie had tramlines in, I was never sent home. Ever. I didn’t do PE for 2 years because I didn’t want to.

We had blackboards in Primary, and whiteboards in secondary. Don’t recall them being interactive. But learning wasn’t just writing stuff, it was engaging and “doing things.”

I was teaching myself by 2014 and I’ve never made a child face a wall, or encountered a Saturday detention.

AlwaysHangry · Today 13:29

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 12:49

I don’t really believe it’s a life or death scenario. I think this type of language is unhelpful.

It really its though for us, my DD self-harms has suicidal ideation many visits to CAMHS/STAR Team at hospital on medication for depression/anxiety writing suicide notes planning to end her life at xyx time because she knows i can only stay awake for so long all because school has taught her that she isn't good enough and not having her needs met by school because of her ADHD and ASD. So what about that makes it unhelpful we are the ones that are actually living in this nightmare.

Velumental · Today 13:31

lemonts · Today 13:23

So there are a lot of children with diagnosed mental health conditions, with identified treatment plans overseen by clinicians whose parents are being forced to take them in or they are going to be taken to court, is that really what you are suggesting, because that is complete rubbish (i.e families in a situation directly comparable to your)

Edited

There are ASD children with diagnoses which are pages long from their neurodevelopmental team outlining their difficulties.including anxiety, difficulties with sensory environments, burnout due to these things, diagnoses including mental health conditions worsened by attending schools that don't offer support, who wait years for an EHCP that forces schools to provide the support they need. Those children are being forced to attend or their parents fined for non attendance. Often children with anxiety or anxiety related to ASD are awaiting diagnoses, the waiting list in Glasgow is 4-6 years long so a child referred in P1 will be seen around P6. No GP can diagnose or treat a child for MH condition these days, the child sits on a cahms waiting list for years waiting to be seen for diagnosis and treatment.

So yes. These are children with mental health conditions escalating due to lack of treatment and support. Who do you think children with EBSA are? If not children who are struggling with neurodevelopment and mental health?

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 13:39

Frazzlesforever · 14/11/2026 22:43

Some good news that apparently the film is going to be shown in the house of Lords. Hopefully it will make people start to think about this issue a bit more.

Thanks for sharing.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 13:43

lemonts · Today 13:15

No you wouldn't you would have been off sick with a diagnosed mental health condition for which there was a clear treatment plan in place overseen by a clinician.

Are you joking? Clear treatment plan 25 years ago?

Schools took parents' words then.

There were a couple of near permanent non-attenders in my year.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 13:47

lemonts · Today 13:23

So there are a lot of children with diagnosed mental health conditions, with identified treatment plans overseen by clinicians whose parents are being forced to take them in or they are going to be taken to court, is that really what you are suggesting, because that is complete rubbish (i.e families in a situation directly comparable to your)

Edited

Why do you believe it 'is complete rubbish'?

The issues are widely reported.

lemonts · Today 14:01

Velumental · Today 13:31

There are ASD children with diagnoses which are pages long from their neurodevelopmental team outlining their difficulties.including anxiety, difficulties with sensory environments, burnout due to these things, diagnoses including mental health conditions worsened by attending schools that don't offer support, who wait years for an EHCP that forces schools to provide the support they need. Those children are being forced to attend or their parents fined for non attendance. Often children with anxiety or anxiety related to ASD are awaiting diagnoses, the waiting list in Glasgow is 4-6 years long so a child referred in P1 will be seen around P6. No GP can diagnose or treat a child for MH condition these days, the child sits on a cahms waiting list for years waiting to be seen for diagnosis and treatment.

So yes. These are children with mental health conditions escalating due to lack of treatment and support. Who do you think children with EBSA are? If not children who are struggling with neurodevelopment and mental health?

So not comparable to the PP who i was responding to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread