Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest you watch and share the film unauthorised absence - particularly if you work in schools/your child has SEN or difficultly attending school

773 replies

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 20:31

This excellent short film Unauthorised Absence has been produced to highlight
the actual reality of what it is like for families whose children can't cope in school for whatever reason (SEN, mental health, anxiety etc) and how they are often punished rather than helped. It is a heatwrenching watch.

The story follows a single mother fighting a punitive education system when her autistic nine-year-old daughter experiences severe school distress and emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA). It stars Emily Bruni, Beatrice Flaherty, Cathy Tyson, and Anna Maxwell Martin.
It is on the longlist for the Best Short Film at the British Independent Film Awards.

It was crowd funded by parents and others whose childrens have suffered due to the system and aims to help change the dialogue around how these children and their parents are viewed. Both my children have had great difficulties in school one not being able to attend at all and the other forcing herself in until she had a severe breakdown while school told us they were both 'fine in school' - so I think it is really important to watch and share this.

(Please note - the film contains some pretty distressing scenes and there is some self harm. It is quite a difficult watch for anyone who has been through this with their family)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn8C7WuGv8g

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Goldenbear · 12/11/2026 00:59

PollyBell · 12/11/2026 00:47

Doea anyone actually think why schools need children to actually attend school? They don't do it for it fun

Maybe if more parents took school seriously children would follow?

I don't think parents take it any less seriously than they did decades ago- many teenagers who didn't like school just traunted from about 13, their parents didn't care at my London comp! As a result of these data driven ideologies school life can be very boring now.

Ponderingwindow · 12/11/2026 01:04

Just a clip triggered a panic attack. It was extremely realistic.

We are in a good place right now, but it is a delicate balance and takes so much work from parents and DD.

Velumental · 12/11/2026 01:05

Goldenbear · 12/11/2026 00:59

I don't think parents take it any less seriously than they did decades ago- many teenagers who didn't like school just traunted from about 13, their parents didn't care at my London comp! As a result of these data driven ideologies school life can be very boring now.

It's this idea kids didn't truant in the past that I find hilarious. I went to a grammar school in northern Ireland renowned for good behaviour and strong behaviour policies and we still had truancy. We had mental health problema, eating disorders, self harm, underage drinkers, largely middle class parents too and yet even there truancy. It's not new.

It's just now parents are trying to help their kids rather than just force compliance

Velumental · 12/11/2026 01:07

Ponderingwindow · 12/11/2026 01:04

Just a clip triggered a panic attack. It was extremely realistic.

We are in a good place right now, but it is a delicate balance and takes so much work from parents and DD.

It was the screaming for me and the physically fighting against simple things like putting a t shirt on. But the high pitched scream, not screaming abuse or screaming at anything but the screaming in fear like an animal caught in a trap. It's horrible. That's what was so rwalistic

Velumental · 12/11/2026 01:08

Ponderingwindow · 12/11/2026 01:04

Just a clip triggered a panic attack. It was extremely realistic.

We are in a good place right now, but it is a delicate balance and takes so much work from parents and DD.

Oh and the child sat at the table happily, with headphones, at home with just mum, with a plate of safe food.

And the teacher pulling her hood down and the girls look of horror and the mums look of fear and the oblivious teachers nod 😬😭

Kirbert2 · 12/11/2026 01:14

Velumental · 12/11/2026 01:05

It's this idea kids didn't truant in the past that I find hilarious. I went to a grammar school in northern Ireland renowned for good behaviour and strong behaviour policies and we still had truancy. We had mental health problema, eating disorders, self harm, underage drinkers, largely middle class parents too and yet even there truancy. It's not new.

It's just now parents are trying to help their kids rather than just force compliance

Me too. I barely went to high school and I'm 36, it has always happened.

The solution back then was for my head of year to physically take me in his car. Just me and him, alone, 5 minutes down the road. Obviously that would never happen now but other than that, they shrugged their shoulders and didn't do much else about it. Eventually, they just accepted the fact that I'd barely turn up which also wouldn't happen now as attendance policies etc are so much more strict.

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 01:15

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 22:37

There’s no profit driver by schools themselves. So I will ask again - can you give me 1 specific example of things schools do now, that they didn’t do before; which is contributing to this phenomenon?

Years ago children with significant additional needs were not in mainstream. This with learning difficulties often sent time in the additional support class.
The teacher could literally see a child wasn't where they should be and would send them down to the class.
Pencil grips were given out of the teacher thought it would help. Some children went for a short time for one area of learning. Some spent a lot of time there over years.

Now - no help is given unless someone/several people agree. So children who may have quickly caught up with few lessons with her SEN teacher fall further and further behind waiting for help that never comes. Now schools can't just give a child a pencil grip to correct pencil hold
They have to wait for the Ed psych and OT to assess. Too often a child waits years to be seen. The difficulty in writing impact literacy and numeracy. It impacts self esteem and confidence.
In many cases by the time the child is actually seen too much damage has been done or child has picked up alternatives to cope that have become ingrained and it's too late to correct.

So even the slightest problem that years ago could have been addressed and sorted in a very short time becomes a lifelong challenge

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 01:21

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 22:38

It’s odd. Their home is odd. The mother seems almost zoned out from reality. There’s no joy or light in the girls life. Her mother is anxious and that’s rubbing off on her.

It reminds me of About A Boy. ‘He’s not expressing himself, he’s expressing you’

You are clueless.the mother is exhausted from trying to get her childs needs supported.

The point of the film which has clearly gone over your head is that this has been building long term. The system causes families so much stress , it is exhausting, soul destroying and seeing your child self harming and becoming so unwell is draining.

Would you be smiling and laughing if your child was self harming due to high levels of stress from an environment that is making your child unwell. Would you think oh this is fun getting hot and bitten. would you be pleased your child is hardly eating or drinking ?

If you would be the above then you are the odd one and I would be concerned for your children

Blondiney · 12/11/2026 01:21

I was a school refuser in the late 80s, definitely not a new thing.

TheSnappyBluePoster · 12/11/2026 01:28

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 21:31

That may be the case ( although personally I feel they are a lot worse since I was at school in the 1980s - so a long time ago!)
However the film is more about the punitative approach to children not being able to attend. As in parents can be fined if their child is unable to attend school due to poor mental health or unmet SEN needs.

I remember as a child, i didn't like the school dinner's version of christmas dinners.They served up and didn't want to eat it. So I didn't

Me, along with another child, experienced prolonged screaming and shouting from the female teacher in front of the entire rest of the class involving language such as this - AND AS FOR YOU, YOU OUGHT TO BE SHOT. YOUR BEHAVIOUR WAS DISGRACEFUL.

I still remember the rage on her face. I didn't like my school dinners when I was seven years old.

Children have change rather than school and the poor little darlings, can't make it to school because of stress and anxiety for whatever reason, but quite frankly, they're not being spoken to like this.

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 01:29

ElonAteMyHamster · 11/11/2026 22:47

Not ALL the problems start at home and this isn’t the case for ALL families but some children who don’t go to school do so for reasons that start at home (chaos, violence, fear of leaving vulnerable parents, lack of value of school). It’s way more complicated than it never starts at home.

With all due respect this film is about children with SEN and unmet needs at school who are absent due to school.
It isn't to address children absent for holidays or children with chaotic parents

Feel free to make your own film to address other reasons for absence - this film is to focus on the huge number of children being failed by the school system and the impact this has on the child and family

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 01:36

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · 11/11/2026 22:56

How on earth does it get to that stage?

Watch the film

It gets to that stage because we force them into school that is making them ill. We force them in because we are told we have to, it's the only way to get support they need, threats of fines etc

It gets to that stage because the forcing them in results in them harming a family member and then feeling so much self loathing and guilt.
They harm themselves because they can not cope and want to die. They want to be able to do what their peers do, they don't want their partner to lose their job, they hate how much stress they cause their family.

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 01:49

Bearneccessities · 11/11/2026 23:18

I watched it, and i related to alot of it, however I didn't like that they were portraying that if the child had a diagnosis then there would be help/support in place. This isn't what the many are facing, and I found that damaging. In our experience dc has several diagnoses. We've had 5 tribunals, 2 judicial reviews, we've done ICO and LGO. For over 3 years and counting we have had no access to education, we have had an EHCP for years yet still no provision is in place. For a decade the local authority and mainstream school system has stolen my dc's childhood and my motherhood, and I no longer have any hope for our future.

It's the system they tell parents they can't support without a diagnosis,
Then when you finally get through waiting list, assessment and diagnosis they then say support is need based not based on diagnosis.
Oh and the lovely kicker if your child has struggled for years they will use the managed not having support for x number of years and so why do you think we should add support now.

Any tactic to save money now even though it's well known that early intervention makes so much difference to outcome

Ponderingwindow · 12/11/2026 01:53

My ASD child experienced something absolutely horrific. She missed 5 days of school. I can tell you what the difference was between my country and Britain. In my country I had her seeing a therapist again in that week. We already had a relationship which sped things up a bit, but she had graduated from therapy. There was no multi year waitlist. I took her to the doctor and she started on medication that week. Again, no delay. Action. There was a crisis and the medical system supported her. Her school was ready to support as well. Her teachers had enough information to be sensitive to her situation. She had a school counselor that met with her and her teachers regularly.

children don’t end up missing school if there is a support system ready to address problems before they become entrenched and nearly untreatable,

Even the idea of waiting on a school placement is foreign. The school doesn’t get time to figure that out.

itsnotkooking · 12/11/2026 03:42

Stiwy · 12/11/2026 00:45

I used to be a school refuser. I didn’t want people to look at me (I hate being perceived even now) My mum was a no nonsense type and would drag me there, she made me go. I remember the head teacher sitting me in her office and asking why I didn’t want to go. Once i was there I masked/managed and I found learning and exams very easy. It was the other people and being looked at, having to socialise, having to answer questions in class that was the issue. I was cripplingly anxious.

As much as I hated my mum at the time, she did me a huge favour. If I’d lied about being ill or really wouldn’t go, she wouldn’t let me stay home and watch TV or do my artwork, she wouldn’t have let me ride a scooter to school, she made sure there were consequences for not going to school. My attendance was never 100% or anywhere close but she made sure I passed my exams.

Had she let me stay home, I’d have failed to launch. I wouldn’t have learned how to mask at all (I feel this is a useful life skill for autistic people because the world will never change for us), I wouldn’t have learned to cope with the outside world. I would have stayed in the house forever.

I am autistic but I’m glad I wasn’t pandered to because I’ve built a life. I choose to stay home a lot these days but if I have to go out there, I know how to operate in the neurotypical world because I was forced out of my comfort zone. I have many struggles but because I got qualifications I was able to get a job that pays for aids and adaptations to help me. I can choose to work from home.

I fear we are setting girls like I was up for a failure to launch. They won’t be able to function in society if they’ve never had to learn to try because I know for a fact, given the choice, I wouldn’t have flown if I wasn’t pushed out of the nest, no matter how uncomfortable it got.

This is an interesting account of your own personal experience. You say your mum made you go and dragged you there but that your own attendance was still nowhere near 100%. What happened on the days that you didn't make it in? I don't have kids so I have no skin in the game - I'm just curious about a situation which seems to be so heartbreaking for so many people.

Tickingcrocodile · 12/11/2026 04:21

I will definitely watch it but it still feels a bit too close to home. My daughter suffered with EBSA for years and is still struggling aged 16. I am very grateful to those who put all the effort in to make this film and try to get more people to understand the reality of this situation.

Unfortunately this thread has already shown that so many people just blame the parents. My DH and I are both teachers so clearly we value education but that doesn't mean we could force a highly distressed child into school every day, although there were times were we definitely tried to.

For those who say school hasn't changed that much, my child's school has infinitely more punitive behaviour systems than my school in the 90s. My DH is a secondary school teacher and he says the same. Unfortunately these systems don't seem to eliminate the bad behaviour but they do make some children (often ND like my DD) absolutely terrified.

Skatefordinner · 12/11/2026 04:22

@Stiwy

Have you watched the film?
I was also that ‘no nonsense’ parent. I physically dragged my DD out of bed and bundled her into the car on 2 occasions (the school was an 8 minute walk but how do you force a 12 year old to walk?) The first time she screamed all of the way there. The SEN lead came outside to meet her, sat in the back of the car with her for ten minutes talking to her and got her in. Within an hour she had self harmed in the toilet.

The pressure continued re getting her in (pressure from me as much as from school)

The second time it was harder to get her in the car. I felt sick. She was in floods of tears. She jumped out at the traffic lights, turned her location off on the phone and went missing for 3 hours. She was in a very vulnerable place and I felt sick with worry.

There comes a point when your child being alive becomes more important than not missing school. I didn’t do it again.

I look back and whilst know that I was just being ‘no nonsense’ (because your child has to attend school right ?) it was 100% the wrong thing to do and contributed to the situation becoming so much worse.

So whilst in your experience it was a good thing for you, for many it’s not as simple as ‘you just need to be no nonsense/ make them go’ .. physically what does that look like when they are older/ the same height as you? And mentally at what cost?

Iizzyb · 12/11/2026 05:23

The whole system is set up to treat truanting but this group of kids are struggling to cope with huge demands on them and for some of them, they just cannot cope with the school environment they are placed in.

The term ‘he’s fine here, just bring him in’ sends me cold now. Neurodivergent people mask & that’s often how these kids cope in school but it’s too hard to do that all the time so some have meltdowns, others just shutdown every so often and over time things just get harder.

DS has adjustments at his mainstream school to help him cope but not all the teachers follow what’s been asked. Then it gets too much because he’s been asked to cope with something the school have said he shouldn’t have to do.

most absences aren’t people takIng kids out of school for cheap holidays they are autistic & adhd kids being asked to cope with school environments they’re just not built for and schools have limited means to provide the support they need, some are not interested & some are downright horrible.

I’ve never been spoken to at work by anyone the way I’ve been spoken to by some school staff. The head at DC’s primary school for example - didn’t have a clue but was very confident in her views. Parents of dc like this have a much tougher time, advocating for dc with school & parenting dc who struggle with the world.

Those of you blaming the mum in this film & the home life as the cause - it’s very easy to judge when you don’t know what it’s like - and lucky you, frankly

Bringemout · 12/11/2026 05:53

I think pushing for children to be in mainstream schools when they shouldn’t be is probably one of the biggest issues. Schools are not set up to deal with this range of needs. My DD is a normal school with no obvious SEN kids in her class yet the range of ability is very wide which runs her teacher ragged trying to support the ones that need support and stretch the ones that need stretch.

Teachers and schools don’t often have the capacity to also meet the needs of children with MH problems or ND that substantially impacts behaviour or learning. I imagine it’s very frustrating all round.

For children with MH problems i imagine things like anxiety, not being at school makes social relationships more difficult and then you get into a cycle where you don’t want to go to school and then you get there and your social relationships have been damaged because of your absence and the cycle repeats. We had a child in the family that had constant stomach aches etc very bright, eventually his parents had enough and made him go in consistently and he ended up very happy and doing well. But it started very young, he was very sensitive and had been unwell as a baby so his parents always treated him like he was extremely fragile.

There is some research on school refusal, separation anxiety, social anxiety etc seem to be co-morbidities. I’m not sure that this anxiety is induced by school tbh. I’ve had lifelong problems with anxiety and it definitely had a lot to do with hime. For ND kids, yeah it’s probably got a lot to do with the fact that due to medical intervention a lot of children who wouldn’t have otherwise survived do (which is obviously a good thing) but we aren’t set up for it as a society. There is some research which indicates children who are born before full term are more likely to experience school refusal, even those born at 32-36 weeks due to developmental differences.

Lilacmauve77 · 12/11/2026 06:01

A harrowing, but accurate portrayal of what far too many children and parents experience daily.

Unless you have been in that position I think people just do not understand (although it wouldn’t hurt to try in some cases)

My own ‘school refuser’ wanted absolutely nothing more than to be able to go to school. They wanted to learn, wanted to get qualifications, wanted the friendships, wanted to be able to do the fun things like trips and prom.
But their unmet needs at school, and the daily battle of trying to go in-and I mean the battle with themselves, not just with me or the school, caused a total and complete burnout which took, quite literally, years to come back from.
Not all schools are the same, not all children are the same, not all reasons for non attendance are the same, but the lack of understanding is shockingly familiar.

Bearneccessities · 12/11/2026 06:23

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 01:49

It's the system they tell parents they can't support without a diagnosis,
Then when you finally get through waiting list, assessment and diagnosis they then say support is need based not based on diagnosis.
Oh and the lovely kicker if your child has struggled for years they will use the managed not having support for x number of years and so why do you think we should add support now.

Any tactic to save money now even though it's well known that early intervention makes so much difference to outcome

I just feel it's damaging because anyone watching it that has no experience of the unlawful behaviour of the supposed professionals, will believe it's only the ones without a diagnosis being failed

DundeeNewcastle · 12/11/2026 06:26

I can't watch it as know it will be triggering after my own experiences. But then I don't need to as I have lived it. Should be compulsory viewing for school staff on INSET days, however.

Pobblewob · 12/11/2026 06:34

For those saying schools haven’t changed, why have so many teachers left and why is it so hard to recruit more? Clue: it’s not because of the kids

In many cases it IS because of the kids. Poor behaviour is regularly cited as a reason for leaving teaching. Along with entitled parents, trying to meet too many needs, and rubbish pay.

chocolateface · 12/11/2026 06:40

Thanks for starting this thread and linking the film @Frazzlesforever

As a parent whose eldest child school refused 20 years ago (pre- tablets access constant access to the internet) and someone who currently works in a school (with the highest school attendance in the area) I’m mostly place marking until I have time to write a coherent post.
There is so much to unpick about school refusal, and it’s absolutely a conversation that needs to be had. 20 years ago the answer seemed to be home education. (I didn’t HE). I’m curious as to what other posters think is the answer today.

To quote my then 7yo: “It’s like a roller coaster ride. You see other people having fun and want to get on too, but you’re just too scared.” And yes, he was later diagnosed with ASD.

whatsit84 · 12/11/2026 06:43

ElonAteMyHamster · 11/11/2026 22:45

Not my argument but uniforms are definitely more draconian than when I was at school in the 80s!

Not true where I live. Very few schools do ties and blazers. My kids primary school doesn’t even ask for proper school shoes (much to the delight of my kids who go in Minecraft green skater trainers and converse 😂)