Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest you watch and share the film unauthorised absence - particularly if you work in schools/your child has SEN or difficultly attending school

773 replies

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 20:31

This excellent short film Unauthorised Absence has been produced to highlight
the actual reality of what it is like for families whose children can't cope in school for whatever reason (SEN, mental health, anxiety etc) and how they are often punished rather than helped. It is a heatwrenching watch.

The story follows a single mother fighting a punitive education system when her autistic nine-year-old daughter experiences severe school distress and emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA). It stars Emily Bruni, Beatrice Flaherty, Cathy Tyson, and Anna Maxwell Martin.
It is on the longlist for the Best Short Film at the British Independent Film Awards.

It was crowd funded by parents and others whose childrens have suffered due to the system and aims to help change the dialogue around how these children and their parents are viewed. Both my children have had great difficulties in school one not being able to attend at all and the other forcing herself in until she had a severe breakdown while school told us they were both 'fine in school' - so I think it is really important to watch and share this.

(Please note - the film contains some pretty distressing scenes and there is some self harm. It is quite a difficult watch for anyone who has been through this with their family)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn8C7WuGv8g

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
BluebellBeth · 13/11/2026 09:58

This is what punitive measures do to children with send https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3j4748xxgv0o

I had a teacher tell me on X that the coroner didn't have any right to say what they did in this case and that they as a teacher knew better than the coroner. It's only ever teachers I meet that have this level of arrogance (it is not all teachers obviously)

Taylor Lee looking and smiling at the camera. He is wearing glasses and has short black hair which is curly at the front.

Devon school's strict rules led to boy's death - coroner

Taylor Lee, from Plymouth, Devon, took his own life after struggling with school.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3j4748xxgv0o

Fortuity · 13/11/2026 10:00

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 21:28

School has never been LESS punitive. 2000s we had uniform inspections, Saturday detentions, teachers would actually shout at you, no screens just endless boring writing. At primary we had to sit facing the wall if we were naughty.

It’s not schools that have changed, it’s children

If you think that schools are not like that now, you are really quite deluded.

Secondary academies in particular still have uniform inspections, in fact they put inordinate weight on stupid uniform rules like pupils being unable to remove blazers in hot weather without permission. They not only have detentions, they have isolation units where pupils may be made to sit for hours and even days on end in a small cubicle facing the walls with no interaction with anyone else bar the supervisor. Teachers certainly shout - I heard of one which made it normal practice on the first day of the September term to line up the whole of Year 7 and shout at them about how they mustn't put a toe out of line for fear of horrendous consequences.

Needless to say, schools like that are not disposed to make reasonable adjustments for disability and if anything would like to manage children with SEND out.

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 10:00

BluebellBeth · 13/11/2026 09:58

This is what punitive measures do to children with send https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3j4748xxgv0o

I had a teacher tell me on X that the coroner didn't have any right to say what they did in this case and that they as a teacher knew better than the coroner. It's only ever teachers I meet that have this level of arrogance (it is not all teachers obviously)

Yup.

Fortuity · 13/11/2026 10:05

BluebellBeth · 13/11/2026 09:58

This is what punitive measures do to children with send https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3j4748xxgv0o

I had a teacher tell me on X that the coroner didn't have any right to say what they did in this case and that they as a teacher knew better than the coroner. It's only ever teachers I meet that have this level of arrogance (it is not all teachers obviously)

It's really odd - I've come across some absolutely lovely teachers, but there are some who believe that they know better than anyone. At a meeting about SEND that I was at, a school SENCO stood up and complained bitterly that, when she advised councils that pupils didn't need EHCPs, parents would go to tribunals and would get them. It was gently pointed out to her that, just maybe, experienced and qualified educational psychologists and speech and language and occupational therapists might know more than she did, and the expert tribunal was working on the basis of the evidence in front of it, but she clearly struggled massively with the concept that she might not be infallible.

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 10:24

I don't live in an affluent area. Our local school was similar. Behaviour out of school similar as it was in school. New HT came in (no off rolling). I know that they introduced a great and meaningful reward system - prioritised over anything punitive, all rewards focused - and put in place a lot of other things. Interestingly the kids' behaviour out of school is great, no more fights, no more smoking weed in public. The students take a lot of pride in their school. Lessons are rarely disrupted.

Don't get me wrong, there are still problems but it's not the same school and it's made such a difference to out of school behaviours. Parents say the rewards system made all the difference although I'm sure it's more than that.

Maybe it's a one off but a really strong and compassionate SLT has made all the difference.

BaffledAndBemusedToo · 13/11/2026 10:25

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 09:48

You’ve pretty much described me too.

It was only after I had children and - surprise surprise - they turned out to be autistic that I suddenly realised I was too (though according to some in this thread I’ve simply ‘made’ my children autistic 🙄🙄🙄 shame on the teachers who believe that shite)

‘Bright but no common sense’ was exactly how I was described.

Me too!

BluebellBeth · 13/11/2026 10:29

Fortuity · 13/11/2026 10:05

It's really odd - I've come across some absolutely lovely teachers, but there are some who believe that they know better than anyone. At a meeting about SEND that I was at, a school SENCO stood up and complained bitterly that, when she advised councils that pupils didn't need EHCPs, parents would go to tribunals and would get them. It was gently pointed out to her that, just maybe, experienced and qualified educational psychologists and speech and language and occupational therapists might know more than she did, and the expert tribunal was working on the basis of the evidence in front of it, but she clearly struggled massively with the concept that she might not be infallible.

Yes I've found this too. I just can't get my head around why (some) teachers think they know better than SaLT, OT, CAMHs etc, when they have no qualifications in those areas, it's baffling

NightHeron · 13/11/2026 10:34

BeautifulLittlePumpkin · 13/11/2026 09:26

A lot of young people in isolation rooms are there because they have poor home lives. Many of them are bright and able, they do not necessarily have SEN. They think it’s acceptable to physically assault other students, staff, because that is what they are modelled at home. The purpose of the iso rooms is to help these young people reflect on their behaviour and choices. This is good in theory if you only have one or two in the room, but when there’s seven or eight it’s just a holding container. They feed off each other. The behaviour in there can be abysmal. In my experience analysing the stats from my recent school, it’s mainly young white, WC boys who are occupying these spaces. I did have a young boy with genuine SEN who was placed in there not too long ago and I sent him back to his lesson, as he was vulnerable to bullying that day, in that room. It can be a very intimidating space.

IMO, it is a nonsense to think that children and young people are going to sit and reflect on their behaviour in isolation! Either they are acting out behaviour, they have learnt at home in which case, it’s normal to them and no reflection for an hour is going to undo that model. Some may be communicating through their behaviour - like they may well have undiagnosed SEN. Teachers are not qualified to diagnose any SEN.

Research showed the worse a child’s developmental language disorder, the worse their behaviour is. At the time, the children in language units were essentially the same group of children as in EBD units. The difference was - children in language units had access to speech and language therapists, while children in EBD units had access to clinical psychologists.

Those children with undiagnosed SEN should really be assessed by educational psychologists and speech and language therapists. (It’s likely to be cheaper for the country in the long run)

Anyway, people learn best by social modelling and positive reinforcement!

It’s just a more socially acceptable name for warehousing of those children and young people, to get them out of the hair of the mainstream teachers, because it’s cheaper at the time, than trying to address their problems.

BaffledAndBemusedToo · 13/11/2026 10:36

Watchoutfortheslowaraf · 12/11/2026 21:30

The child the poster mentioned was sent into a school where she was bullied and had no friends for 7 years so it would have some impact I think. I Am wondering why she wasn’t moved to another school as that one caused so much damage over such a long period of time but perhaps there wasn’t another school in the area and parents couldn’t home school.

I was the poster. My daughter went to 3 schools, and was also homeschooled during that period. We tried everything to keep her in school, give her another chance, etc.

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 10:37

BluebellBeth · 13/11/2026 10:29

Yes I've found this too. I just can't get my head around why (some) teachers think they know better than SaLT, OT, CAMHs etc, when they have no qualifications in those areas, it's baffling

Edited

We were told by a HT that they are the experts in children not paediatricians!

BaffledAndBemusedToo · 13/11/2026 10:39

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 21:21

It's not about being fragile
SEN / ND kids are probably far more resilient than the other children. They have literally been square pegs pushed into round holes. But there is only so much anyone can take.

A normal leg isn't fragile but is still going to break if it's constantly battered and smashed. A broken leg doesn't mean you are fragile

Exactly this. What my daughter has gone through shows huge resilience.

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 10:46

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 21:48

I’m not saying it isn’t happening but why did your daughter (and so many like her) have nervous breakdowns in comparison to 20 years ago? Nobody ever seems to want to look outside just finger pointing at the school. Schools have not changed that much and whatever changes there have been, are generally more accommodating of children’s differences, not less.

20 years ago was before the Children and Fsmilies Act 2014 which abolished the two tier support system available to schools giving them greater access to professionals tho could help identify WHY a child might be struggling and support to solve of work around thd issues, often with some simple changes.

The abolishing of this system left these children and children going forward without support UNLESS the applied for an EHCP and at the same time removed much of the SEN budgets from schools. Leaving children for longer without support equals greater and more entrenched problems.

so I’m afraid you are wrong - it was a seismic shift in how schools supported children.

Bacha1910 · 13/11/2026 10:50

So hard to watch this. We have been there in the last three years. My daughter went into autistic burnout in year 7, but it was "caused" by the cumulative stress of me doing literally what that mother did, day after day, dragging her in, despite her distress every day from about year 4 onwards. She also lay down in the road in traffic one day, which was horrific, so that was pretty awful to see on screen.

We're a "nice middle class family" by the way, for those posters who seem to think it's caused by parents who drink, smoke and bash their kids at home. I don't know. I suppose I wouldn't have believed it if I hadn't had to live it myself.

She got a diagnosis of Autism now, but it took getting to that point for it to happen. We actually had a very supportive school in some ways, we never got fined even when her attendance was 70% or lower. But even in that environment none of the teachers could see that she was autistic because she wasn't disruptive and she was academically very able. She's now in a very small school where she can access education and there's very little turnover of staff. She needs that familiarity to be comfortable going in. And it's still very stressful for her even with that.

BaffledAndBemusedToo · 13/11/2026 10:54

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 20:35

No mentally healthy child is going to be caused a brain injury by going to school, even if the school is ‘busy’ or uses PowerPoints. This simply isn’t a normal reaction to such a scenario, you have to be fragile to begin with.

Psychiatrists would beg to differ. You know, the people who are professionally trained. The ones who observe symptoms (whatever the cause) and make a professional judgement.
You really don’t get it do you?

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 10:59

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 07:27

That’s not masking 🙄

Yes it is. Masking is any situation in which you are required to self monitor, every human does it. The mask might be higher in autistic people, and there might be a bigger cost, but masking is a human behavioural trait.

I won’t go into detail, but I have an AuDHD child who copes in school due to a mixture of meds and masking.

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 11:05

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 10:46

20 years ago was before the Children and Fsmilies Act 2014 which abolished the two tier support system available to schools giving them greater access to professionals tho could help identify WHY a child might be struggling and support to solve of work around thd issues, often with some simple changes.

The abolishing of this system left these children and children going forward without support UNLESS the applied for an EHCP and at the same time removed much of the SEN budgets from schools. Leaving children for longer without support equals greater and more entrenched problems.

so I’m afraid you are wrong - it was a seismic shift in how schools supported children.

Edited

David Blunkett also decimated SEN schools due to inclusion. When EHCPs replaced statements the system went bankrupt as often the only way to get support and a lot of provision in them costs a fortune. Increase in children getting diagnosed too. Big private market for SEND support - eg a lot of speech therapists work privately now which depletes the NHS. It's been a perfect storm.

Fortuity · 13/11/2026 11:07

BeautifulLittlePumpkin · 13/11/2026 09:26

A lot of young people in isolation rooms are there because they have poor home lives. Many of them are bright and able, they do not necessarily have SEN. They think it’s acceptable to physically assault other students, staff, because that is what they are modelled at home. The purpose of the iso rooms is to help these young people reflect on their behaviour and choices. This is good in theory if you only have one or two in the room, but when there’s seven or eight it’s just a holding container. They feed off each other. The behaviour in there can be abysmal. In my experience analysing the stats from my recent school, it’s mainly young white, WC boys who are occupying these spaces. I did have a young boy with genuine SEN who was placed in there not too long ago and I sent him back to his lesson, as he was vulnerable to bullying that day, in that room. It can be a very intimidating space.

You have an odd idea of how schools operate isolation rooms. In many schools that have them, they have a very rigid discipline system under which children can get detentions for something like forgetting to bring the right pen or nor having the right socks on. Then the discipline system provides for a certain number of detentions leading automatically to isolations. For children with fantastic, nurturing home lives but something like executive function problems, it is all too easy to clock up enough demerits or detentions to get put into isolation. Then it becomes a vicious circle, because every time they are put in isolation they lose several hours or days in class, get behind on their work, can't do their homework, and get another isolation. Many will unsurprisingly react by messing around in class to hide their embarrassment, and back they go into isolation.

It really is one of the most stupid systems possible.

Scamworried · 13/11/2026 11:10

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 10:59

Yes it is. Masking is any situation in which you are required to self monitor, every human does it. The mask might be higher in autistic people, and there might be a bigger cost, but masking is a human behavioural trait.

I won’t go into detail, but I have an AuDHD child who copes in school due to a mixture of meds and masking.

To use your scratching example before

If I have a itch I scratch it, or go to the bathroom to scratch or wait till a different time to scratch (the need to scratch will likely wear off on its own). That's not masking that normal behaviour.
The cost of scratching v waiting is minimal. It doesn't take all my energy away in just managing not to scratch

When masking all the energy goes on appearing not to need to scratch. Even if your skin is literally on fire you mask because letting that mask down and scratching is not something your can do even through not scratching is taking up all your brain power, all your energy and leaving you with nothing. When you get to a safe space to scratch you will scratch so much you bleed

Fortuity · 13/11/2026 11:11

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 22:15

What is ‘Neo liberal’ about primary schools?

Whenever I ask people to give examples of this punitiveness, or why schools are Neo liberal hellholes, they can never actually give me any.

My daughter goes to a normal state primary in an average area and it’s wonderful. Forest school, a number of interesting clubs, sports twice weekly, art, crafts, interesting school trips, everything is thoughtful and about as far from ‘Neo liberal’ as you can get. The teachers don’t shout, everything is looked at in a compassionate manner.

Compare that to my days of sitting behind the teacher’s chair and being yelled at in 1997 and tbh I have no idea what everyone is going on about.

Whenever I ask people to give examples of this punitiveness, or why schools are Neo liberal hellholes, they can never actually give me any.

That's not actually true, though, is it? I've seen someone responding to a similar pointy from you on another thread with similar information to what I have said above about rigid uniform rules and discipline systems in may schools, particularly academies. You clearly have been given those answers. I suspect you choose to block them out of your mind.

Scamworried · 13/11/2026 11:12

Fortuity · 13/11/2026 11:07

You have an odd idea of how schools operate isolation rooms. In many schools that have them, they have a very rigid discipline system under which children can get detentions for something like forgetting to bring the right pen or nor having the right socks on. Then the discipline system provides for a certain number of detentions leading automatically to isolations. For children with fantastic, nurturing home lives but something like executive function problems, it is all too easy to clock up enough demerits or detentions to get put into isolation. Then it becomes a vicious circle, because every time they are put in isolation they lose several hours or days in class, get behind on their work, can't do their homework, and get another isolation. Many will unsurprisingly react by messing around in class to hide their embarrassment, and back they go into isolation.

It really is one of the most stupid systems possible.

Absolutely
Most kids would prefer to be seen as rebel by peers than stupid

But if you look behind the obvious behaviour there is almost always an underlying reason.

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 11:15

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 10:59

Yes it is. Masking is any situation in which you are required to self monitor, every human does it. The mask might be higher in autistic people, and there might be a bigger cost, but masking is a human behavioural trait.

I won’t go into detail, but I have an AuDHD child who copes in school due to a mixture of meds and masking.

No it really really isn’t.

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 11:19

A school uniform isn’t ‘punitive’ ffs

Yellowisthenewgreen · 13/11/2026 11:24

i think there’s far more to it than everyone saying that schools are to blame and schools are much worse than they were in the past as in my experience thats not the case at all.

We are in Scotland and my kids go to a village school where the classes are all 16-22 kids. Due to a huge increase in deferrals, many kids are now closer to 6 when they start school. Uniform is very lapse (we don’t even have an official school tie or blazer) and lots of kids just wear a tshirt and black leggings/ trousers/ shorts. We have no SATS in Scotland. The P1 to 3 classes have doors opening up to outdoor areas and kids have free play in and out throughout the day and the whole school does play based learning.
Each class does an assembly for the school once a year but other than that there’s no assemblies.
They have access to a sensory room and a “playroom” which has spinny chairs etc. and teachers happily give out pencil grips, slanted writing boards etc.
Theres a council wide flexischooling policy so some kids attend forest school/ sailing or stay at home one day a week.

It’s absolutely nothing like my primary school 30 years ago and yet there are still quite a few kids who are ‘school refusers’.

Scamworried · 13/11/2026 11:28

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 11:19

A school uniform isn’t ‘punitive’ ffs

It can be used to unfairly punish
And difficulty with uniform are more pronounced in SEN and disabled people.

For example a child with a foot difference is going to struggle with school shoes this is going to cause pain in the short term and damage in the longer term.
Sometimes a child may get a diagnosis and adjustment to footwear in early years but often it takes years to be seen by a specialist and by then a lot of damage has been done. Foot structure differences are also more likely as a co-occuring condition to autism.

Children with dexterity difficulty will struggle more with buttons, ties and show laces. Not having a button done up, tie not correct length or laces not tied have resulted in punishment

Children anxious at school are more likely to struggle with a tight tie, they will feel suffocated but loosing so they can breath better can result in punishment

Skirt length. Pupils have been punished for skirt not being exactly the correct length when if a pupil is shorter or taller it can be difficult to get a skirt falling exactly in the right place. Im not talking skirts hiked up to very short I'm talking length variation due to height.

Pupils have been punished for removing their blazer while walking home in a heat wave

Swipe left for the next trending thread