Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest you watch and share the film unauthorised absence - particularly if you work in schools/your child has SEN or difficultly attending school

773 replies

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 20:31

This excellent short film Unauthorised Absence has been produced to highlight
the actual reality of what it is like for families whose children can't cope in school for whatever reason (SEN, mental health, anxiety etc) and how they are often punished rather than helped. It is a heatwrenching watch.

The story follows a single mother fighting a punitive education system when her autistic nine-year-old daughter experiences severe school distress and emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA). It stars Emily Bruni, Beatrice Flaherty, Cathy Tyson, and Anna Maxwell Martin.
It is on the longlist for the Best Short Film at the British Independent Film Awards.

It was crowd funded by parents and others whose childrens have suffered due to the system and aims to help change the dialogue around how these children and their parents are viewed. Both my children have had great difficulties in school one not being able to attend at all and the other forcing herself in until she had a severe breakdown while school told us they were both 'fine in school' - so I think it is really important to watch and share this.

(Please note - the film contains some pretty distressing scenes and there is some self harm. It is quite a difficult watch for anyone who has been through this with their family)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn8C7WuGv8g

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
mumsthewurd · 13/11/2026 02:10

I think the film is about an autistic girl? So she is “fragile” as you put it. She has sensory processing issues (sound and light) and internal struggles that no one sees or understands (the scene when her hood gets pulled off. Their home life is “odd” because the mum has had to adjust. You really don’t seem to be getting it at all. And i thought the teacher and SENCO were kind, they just didn't understand and the system was out of their hands. And draconian schools are everywhere, giving detentions for stupid things like the wrong socks or no pen. Putting children in isolation booths for hours. Making girls bleed through their uniforms because toilets are locked during lessons? I went to a strict school in the 80s it was never as bad as that. Strict but fair and kind. Common sense was used. And if you were late you got told off, not threatened with your mum being imprisoned!! Jesus wept.

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 05:51

whatsnewpussycatt · 13/11/2026 01:55

All these posters saying things like: It’s a parenting issue, parents today are too soft, they are raising children with no boundaries, parents want to blame school instead of themselves, parents just can’t be bothered to get their children to school, there was no such thing as EBSA in my day, parents put their foot down when I was younger, there was no Sen in my day, schools used to be stricter and such like. Well who raised today’s parents? IF it is such a huge parenting problem, who were our role models, who taught us how to parent? Seems like this magic generation, no nonsense schools, perfect system, did a rubbish job if the outcome is a generation of feckless parents. So who is to blame? Shouldn’t we blame the people who raised today’s parents? Shouldn’t we blame a system that churned out all these useless people? Clearly today’s children are a result of parenting that was taught by the previous generation…….Or we could be realistic and understand it’s a complex issue in a failing system.

I tend to think that people parent differently from their own parents, especially if we have insight. We take the ‘good bits’ and change the bits we felt were damaging.

Some people remember the punitive side of their childhood, which probably upset them at the time but served them quite well, and didn’t want to replicate it. Unfortunately, this doesn’t always have good outcomes for children.

MrsMurphyIWish · 13/11/2026 06:09

My son is autistic and thankfully not ESBA. I was really worried for the transition to high school (he’s now in Yr 8). He went from a one form primary to a 12 form entry secondary - it’s larger than average according to Ofsted reports. However, the SEND team are amazing - and the staff in general - and I believe that is a huge factor why DS is settled. He has uniform accommodations, time out pass, his EHCP states he should have 12 hours of 1:1 TA (he does although now he’s getting to the age that he doesn’t want them!). He knows he can go to the SEND hub whenever he wants (always manned). We are lucky. I’m a secondary teacher and we have nothing like the school DS goes to. My heart breaks for parents of ESBA students. If their children had access to a school like DS life would be easier. Not in all cases, but it helps when you feel you have support. Sadly posters who say “all SLT” should watch it are missing that schools have no money. It’s the bloody DfE who need to make the changes but they’re too interested in tinkering around the edges and I have no faith in the curriculum reforms.

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 06:12

MrsMurphyIWish · 13/11/2026 06:09

My son is autistic and thankfully not ESBA. I was really worried for the transition to high school (he’s now in Yr 8). He went from a one form primary to a 12 form entry secondary - it’s larger than average according to Ofsted reports. However, the SEND team are amazing - and the staff in general - and I believe that is a huge factor why DS is settled. He has uniform accommodations, time out pass, his EHCP states he should have 12 hours of 1:1 TA (he does although now he’s getting to the age that he doesn’t want them!). He knows he can go to the SEND hub whenever he wants (always manned). We are lucky. I’m a secondary teacher and we have nothing like the school DS goes to. My heart breaks for parents of ESBA students. If their children had access to a school like DS life would be easier. Not in all cases, but it helps when you feel you have support. Sadly posters who say “all SLT” should watch it are missing that schools have no money. It’s the bloody DfE who need to make the changes but they’re too interested in tinkering around the edges and I have no faith in the curriculum reforms.

We have all this provision, but we still have severe absentees.

swingingbackwardsandforwards · 13/11/2026 07:08

I don’t know that there is an ideal solution.

Secondary schools in particular do have to have systems in place for behaviour. I haven’t worked anywhere where you end up in isolation for having the wrong pen, it’s either something serious like fighting or really inappropriate behaviour or a culmination of behaviour and having the wrong pen might be a tiny part of that but more likely to be persistent disruption. I kind of agree it’s not ideal because you end up with the same people in there but what actually is the alternative? I’ve wondered this myself and I don’t have the answers. And it isn’t always or even often children with additional needs in there: they suffer too when lessons are disrupted.

And one point that often gets missed is that we’re getting the results. England has the highest reading level in Europe, which is no mean feat, especially when the much loved Scandinavian countries are included in that.

I honestly don’t think it’s to do with how schools are ‘now.’ Schools in the 80s, 90s and 2000s weren’t some sort of utopia, many were decaying 70s buildings with kids smoking in plain sight, fights, conflicts between friends, conflicts with teachers, petty rules (we used to get screamed at to take off our coats the second we crossed the threshold of the school which meant you’d get in the school and over six hundred kids would be grappling with taking bags off shoulders and removing coats in the narrow corridors rather than having an ounce of common sense and letting us remove them once we got to our form room.)

I think what had changed in the emphasis on attendance which means schools can neither be indifferent to a school refuser or sometimes compassionate. I don’t know why some schools think the punitive technique works but clearly it doesn’t.

Occasionally you get a parent who tries it on too and that can make schools a bit suspicious of children who seem to present normally in school. I know masking happens but it has become a bit of a catch-all. I’ve seen people stating their two and three year old children are masking at nursery!

I don’t have any easy answers here. I wish I did. Maybe there just aren’t any.

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 07:25

swingingbackwardsandforwards · 13/11/2026 07:08

I don’t know that there is an ideal solution.

Secondary schools in particular do have to have systems in place for behaviour. I haven’t worked anywhere where you end up in isolation for having the wrong pen, it’s either something serious like fighting or really inappropriate behaviour or a culmination of behaviour and having the wrong pen might be a tiny part of that but more likely to be persistent disruption. I kind of agree it’s not ideal because you end up with the same people in there but what actually is the alternative? I’ve wondered this myself and I don’t have the answers. And it isn’t always or even often children with additional needs in there: they suffer too when lessons are disrupted.

And one point that often gets missed is that we’re getting the results. England has the highest reading level in Europe, which is no mean feat, especially when the much loved Scandinavian countries are included in that.

I honestly don’t think it’s to do with how schools are ‘now.’ Schools in the 80s, 90s and 2000s weren’t some sort of utopia, many were decaying 70s buildings with kids smoking in plain sight, fights, conflicts between friends, conflicts with teachers, petty rules (we used to get screamed at to take off our coats the second we crossed the threshold of the school which meant you’d get in the school and over six hundred kids would be grappling with taking bags off shoulders and removing coats in the narrow corridors rather than having an ounce of common sense and letting us remove them once we got to our form room.)

I think what had changed in the emphasis on attendance which means schools can neither be indifferent to a school refuser or sometimes compassionate. I don’t know why some schools think the punitive technique works but clearly it doesn’t.

Occasionally you get a parent who tries it on too and that can make schools a bit suspicious of children who seem to present normally in school. I know masking happens but it has become a bit of a catch-all. I’ve seen people stating their two and three year old children are masking at nursery!

I don’t have any easy answers here. I wish I did. Maybe there just aren’t any.

Everyone masks, nobody goes to work and starts scratching themselves or having a nap at the desk Grin I think it’s just harder for autistic people to observe and internalise social rules.

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 07:27

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 07:25

Everyone masks, nobody goes to work and starts scratching themselves or having a nap at the desk Grin I think it’s just harder for autistic people to observe and internalise social rules.

That’s not masking 🙄

Whatafustercluck · 13/11/2026 07:29

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 07:27

That’s not masking 🙄

It's woeful how many inaccurate descriptions of masking have been thrown around on this thread, isn't it?

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 07:30

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 06:12

We have all this provision, but we still have severe absentees.

I would definitely be a persistent absentee nowadays - we had a more chilled out curriculum back then, if you didn't give your homework in you weren't penalised as it was on you if you didn't do it. No social media, no pressure as you knew you could walk into a job aged 16. etc. If I wanted at day off I could pretend I was sick and it was ok to have 90% absence. No one even raised it. It got me through anyway. I remember a teacher writing to my parents about how I didn't do homework, they wrote back saying good luck with that, the teacher laughed and it was never mentioned again. Parents were allowed to parent, teachers allowed to teach.

Ofsted came in and children started school refusing and numbers grew (but manageable) - I remember this happening.

I think that society is also a lot more anxious now as a whole which doesn't really help.

Scamworried · 13/11/2026 07:30

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 06:12

We have all this provision, but we still have severe absentees.

Lots of schools 'think' they have this provision but the effectiveness of what they provide can be altered but subtle differences

Our local school has a wellbeing room. Maned by a wonderful supportive TA. IF you get access to this room they support is amazing.
But this support is gate kept in the most weird ways.

Somechildren have open access and can go anytime other children with SEN have to jump through hoops first.
For my child this meant asking permission from the teacher they were scared of. The teacher would then demand to know why and she just couldn't answer for fear of being told off.
Some children have a toilet pass due to bladder issues. Sounds ideal right only any one asking to use the toilet gets told off and mocked in front of the class. So having a medical need means you have a pass but if you ask you still get told off, then if you show pass everyone in class is aware of your medical need now and so you still.been told off and mocked and now the bullies will name call too. So the child withholds and won't drink all day which negatively impacts their medical issues. But the school has passes for those with genuine medical needs. And periods as long as the child is happy for the teacher and peers to know they are on their period.

Many schools have a requirement to get a certain mark on homework. So if homework isn't done at all or if it doesn't hit the specific mark the pupil has to stay in several lunch breaks each week (to do and redo the work until they hit the magic pass mark).
This homework is the same level regardless of ability. So the top sets can complete to pass level without thinking. But pupils with SEN and learning difficulties spend hours on it and dont pass. The detention is sold as support to help but really is a punishment for not being smart enough.
And in a few schools I know of they go a step further and put names of pupils not making the grade up on a board for everyone to see

But in paper these things are made to look like supportive provisions. Really it often depends on the ethos of a school to if a provision is supportive or unsupportive but giving the illusion of support.

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 07:30

The level of ignorance (and its owners confidently claiming they know what they’re talking about) on this thread is astounding.

It’s an excellent example of yhd rampant bias, prejudice and ableism society still holds and it’s extremely disappointing that there are teachers on here showing shocking levels of bias and prejudice

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 07:31

Whatafustercluck · 13/11/2026 07:29

It's woeful how many inaccurate descriptions of masking have been thrown around on this thread, isn't it?

And woeful that so many ignorant people feel so terribly terribly confident to throw them around - which just screams ableism

As for thd professional on here showing such shocking levels of bias (the SENCo claiming she would always know when a child had been with their autistic parent - ‘make if that what you will’) comes to mind, she and other professionals like her who are biased, and gleefully and smugly practise confirmation bias, is the reason that autistic parents of autistic children are THREE TIMES more likely to be falsely accused, not just accused but found to have been falsely accused, of FII, other forms of child abuse, and neglectful parenting than an NT parent of an autistic child.

They should not be allowed to practise - it’s dangerous and destructive and causes long term harm.

Scamworried · 13/11/2026 07:36

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 07:25

Everyone masks, nobody goes to work and starts scratching themselves or having a nap at the desk Grin I think it’s just harder for autistic people to observe and internalise social rules.

Is scratching yourself something you have an inmate need to do? Do you need to scratch so badly you have to pinch yourself so hard you draw blood? That you have to sit there counting in your head all the prime numbers just to distract yourself so you can not scratch? Do you then have to scratch once home for several hours and your scratching leaves scars ?

Unless you have the above then you are not masking to stop scratching at work.

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 07:40

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 07:25

Everyone masks, nobody goes to work and starts scratching themselves or having a nap at the desk Grin I think it’s just harder for autistic people to observe and internalise social rules.

Are you another teacher? And you belueve ‘masking’ is not scratching your arse? Shocking

also, ‘provision’ isn’t provision if it doesn’t work for the child and ignores the SEND code of practise 2015?

Do you take a graduated approach with this ‘provision’

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 07:42

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 05:51

I tend to think that people parent differently from their own parents, especially if we have insight. We take the ‘good bits’ and change the bits we felt were damaging.

Some people remember the punitive side of their childhood, which probably upset them at the time but served them quite well, and didn’t want to replicate it. Unfortunately, this doesn’t always have good outcomes for children.

I can promise you it did not serve me well.

Bushmillsbabe · 13/11/2026 07:54

Thekidsarefightingagain · 12/11/2026 23:43

I think - downgrading vocational qualifications, even more pressure piled onto on schools to achieve better results, massively increasing the number of academies - schools as businesses don't work. Getting rid of coursework putting more pressure on students. TAs going, school budgets slashed, behaviour tsars promoting this stuff and encouraging schools to implement.

Ofsted (bleurgh) became more punitive and praised schools that had implemented things like isolation rooms & other shit to drive results. It's all led to stressed out children who have very little autonomy. Stressed out teachers and a system that barely functions. I'm sure there's loads more. This was all pre COVID too.

We looked round secondaries recently, we were put off by a school that had 3! The staff member showing us round said they couldn't manage behaviour without them, and there had been a huge improvement in behaviour since had them, was only sanction which actually worked. I asked a child what they thought about them when away from the teacher, and they echoed what teacher said, that had been much better since the new head introduced as she could actually hear the teacher. I asked what would get a child put there - the answers were repeated shouting in lessons, swearing at teachers, physical violence. It wasn't a response to not doing homework or wrong uniform.

Interestingly,none of the grammar schools had them, despite reporting a similar level of SEN to the school with 3.

But the concept that behaviour was so bad that they had to use isolation rooms put us off - that children thought that things were so bad that isolation was a good thing was really worrying.

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 07:55

Scamworried · 13/11/2026 07:30

Lots of schools 'think' they have this provision but the effectiveness of what they provide can be altered but subtle differences

Our local school has a wellbeing room. Maned by a wonderful supportive TA. IF you get access to this room they support is amazing.
But this support is gate kept in the most weird ways.

Somechildren have open access and can go anytime other children with SEN have to jump through hoops first.
For my child this meant asking permission from the teacher they were scared of. The teacher would then demand to know why and she just couldn't answer for fear of being told off.
Some children have a toilet pass due to bladder issues. Sounds ideal right only any one asking to use the toilet gets told off and mocked in front of the class. So having a medical need means you have a pass but if you ask you still get told off, then if you show pass everyone in class is aware of your medical need now and so you still.been told off and mocked and now the bullies will name call too. So the child withholds and won't drink all day which negatively impacts their medical issues. But the school has passes for those with genuine medical needs. And periods as long as the child is happy for the teacher and peers to know they are on their period.

Many schools have a requirement to get a certain mark on homework. So if homework isn't done at all or if it doesn't hit the specific mark the pupil has to stay in several lunch breaks each week (to do and redo the work until they hit the magic pass mark).
This homework is the same level regardless of ability. So the top sets can complete to pass level without thinking. But pupils with SEN and learning difficulties spend hours on it and dont pass. The detention is sold as support to help but really is a punishment for not being smart enough.
And in a few schools I know of they go a step further and put names of pupils not making the grade up on a board for everyone to see

But in paper these things are made to look like supportive provisions. Really it often depends on the ethos of a school to if a provision is supportive or unsupportive but giving the illusion of support.

Yup, my child refuses to drink in school because the toilets are full of screaming kids at break. She has a toilet pass but using it means she has to draw attention to herself. School has done this to her. She was happy and confident before she started school and the bullying started.

BeautifulLittlePumpkin · 13/11/2026 08:56

Bushmillsbabe · 13/11/2026 07:54

We looked round secondaries recently, we were put off by a school that had 3! The staff member showing us round said they couldn't manage behaviour without them, and there had been a huge improvement in behaviour since had them, was only sanction which actually worked. I asked a child what they thought about them when away from the teacher, and they echoed what teacher said, that had been much better since the new head introduced as she could actually hear the teacher. I asked what would get a child put there - the answers were repeated shouting in lessons, swearing at teachers, physical violence. It wasn't a response to not doing homework or wrong uniform.

Interestingly,none of the grammar schools had them, despite reporting a similar level of SEN to the school with 3.

But the concept that behaviour was so bad that they had to use isolation rooms put us off - that children thought that things were so bad that isolation was a good thing was really worrying.

I’ve ran a few isolation rooms. Wouldn’t do it again. The job is hell. In the affluent school it was very rarely used, and was much more of a therapeutic space. In other schools, they are necessary to safeguard other students from violence etc. No one wants to work in there though, obviously. They get work to do, they don’t do it. I was just told to fuck off nine times out of ten. It’s a badge of honour for many of them to end up in isolation. I do have to laugh when I read comments on mumsnet where they think these kids still do work in isolation…. lol, lol, lol. It’s a zoo.

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 09:14

Bushmillsbabe · 13/11/2026 07:54

We looked round secondaries recently, we were put off by a school that had 3! The staff member showing us round said they couldn't manage behaviour without them, and there had been a huge improvement in behaviour since had them, was only sanction which actually worked. I asked a child what they thought about them when away from the teacher, and they echoed what teacher said, that had been much better since the new head introduced as she could actually hear the teacher. I asked what would get a child put there - the answers were repeated shouting in lessons, swearing at teachers, physical violence. It wasn't a response to not doing homework or wrong uniform.

Interestingly,none of the grammar schools had them, despite reporting a similar level of SEN to the school with 3.

But the concept that behaviour was so bad that they had to use isolation rooms put us off - that children thought that things were so bad that isolation was a good thing was really worrying.

Interesting that the grammar school reported a similar level of SEN, you wouldn't have thought that that was the case. Maybe the parents are more likely to get/able to afford independent ed psych assessments.

BeautifulLittlePumpkin · 13/11/2026 09:26

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 09:14

Interesting that the grammar school reported a similar level of SEN, you wouldn't have thought that that was the case. Maybe the parents are more likely to get/able to afford independent ed psych assessments.

A lot of young people in isolation rooms are there because they have poor home lives. Many of them are bright and able, they do not necessarily have SEN. They think it’s acceptable to physically assault other students, staff, because that is what they are modelled at home. The purpose of the iso rooms is to help these young people reflect on their behaviour and choices. This is good in theory if you only have one or two in the room, but when there’s seven or eight it’s just a holding container. They feed off each other. The behaviour in there can be abysmal. In my experience analysing the stats from my recent school, it’s mainly young white, WC boys who are occupying these spaces. I did have a young boy with genuine SEN who was placed in there not too long ago and I sent him back to his lesson, as he was vulnerable to bullying that day, in that room. It can be a very intimidating space.

Velumental · 13/11/2026 09:33

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 05:51

I tend to think that people parent differently from their own parents, especially if we have insight. We take the ‘good bits’ and change the bits we felt were damaging.

Some people remember the punitive side of their childhood, which probably upset them at the time but served them quite well, and didn’t want to replicate it. Unfortunately, this doesn’t always have good outcomes for children.

Or people have enough insight to know they'd have done perfectly well without being given 'something to cry about'

NightHeron · 13/11/2026 09:40

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 06:12

We have all this provision, but we still have severe absentees.

None of those provisions would have worked for DD1. She had

  1. a severe receptive language disorder (comprehension) - she couldn’t understand what the teacher was saying. A consequence of a receptive disorder is impaired concept formation - she could only understand concrete literal language. She couldn’t understand abstract, conceptual language, which gets more common as you go up through the education system; nor sarcasm, common sayings (she’d expect to see pigs flying past the window), sarcasm and puns.
  2. a profound expressive language disorder - she couldn’t get the syllables in a word in the right order, or the words in a sentence, or the sentences in a paragraph. She didn’t know the function of s, or ed, or ing at the end of a word, because her brain could not process the sounds, so she never worked out their function in grammar. She had a severe syntactical disorder.
  3. poor working memory (bottom one in a thousand people), so she couldn’t remember multi stage instructions
  4. severe dyslexia - she couldn’t read the material
  5. severe problems with verbal reasoning - faced with a problem, she couldn’t reason her way to an answer. She couldn’t do the work
  6. severe dyspraxia, so she couldn’t work out how to do practical subjects like woodwork

These are all co morbid conditions. Children can have any or all of the above, and also with any combination of autism, ADHD, speech disorders and epilepsy. There can also be poor information processing, when children cannot process information at the speed at which it is being delivered in a mainstream classroom.

DD1 had difficulty with the bottom up processing of words - her brain couldn’t do the auditory processing. She struggled with reading and spelling, but once she had read a story, she understood the story. Children with autism can have the opposite problem with top down processing. They can cut and paste language they have heard, and put it together, so they sound fluent - for instance, they could repeat a whole program on killer whales. However, ask them to explain how to play ludo; and they can’t put the language together. Likewise, they can read a story fluently; but they don’t know what the story is about.

Speech therapists said, if asked a question in class, DD1’s answer would be so far off the mark, she’d be a laughing stock. As it was, she was suicidal by age ten, being put in a mainstream class in the afternoons, because she knew she was a failure, compared to mainstream children.

No amount of desks in rows, clear walls, good behaviour in mainstream (and DD1 did have sensory processing disorder) would have addressed the above problems in a mainstream classroom.

We had appealed to the tribunal three times by the time, DD1 was ten; and the LA had agreed to send her to a specialist speech and language school - where she was in a class of ten, with a specialist teacher, a language based approach to the curriculum (no foreign languages), signing, symbols, a full time speech therapist, two TAs, an onsite OT ….Many of the children there had a different combination of the above specific learning difficulties. Every child had been bullied in mainstream. The specialist school told us, there were children like DD1 in mainstream.

As far as I can see, OP has shown no conception that some children can have some or all of these problems and more in the mainstream classroom; and what they need is a different environment - a small class, specialist teaching, the language aimed at their level of comprehension, signing to support comprehension, symbols to support reading and specialist techniques to teach language, maths, reading and writing!

Many of DD1’s friends went on to university for visual subjects like art, photography, etc or did useful jobs, which only need concrete language and not much reading - like cleaning, gardening, cookery.

Bushmillsbabe · 13/11/2026 09:42

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 09:14

Interesting that the grammar school reported a similar level of SEN, you wouldn't have thought that that was the case. Maybe the parents are more likely to get/able to afford independent ed psych assessments.

Why would you think that a grammar school wouldn't have a significant number of SEN? Portions of the 11+ , such as the NVR, are much easier for some bright ND children, those with hyperfocus, specific spatial reasoning skills etc. SEN can also relate to physical disabilities and medical needs, which don't always impact on intellectual ability.

But yes, these children consistently have very engaged parents, who can provide support with assessments, tutoring and a stable home life.

Some of the disruptive children aren't due to SEN, but due to past/current trauma. One of my daughters close friends is very bright, very lovely mostly, but ends up in trouble a lot because she struggles with boundaries, especially when they come from men (due to lots of issues with an alternating absent/oppressive father), so male teachers and staff who tell her what to do often get an earful. She has huge potential, bright, sporty, sociable - but has made a name for herself as the 'rude girl', ends up with various sanctions at primary, which I predict will only get worse in secondary, especially if falls in with a 'bad crowd'. These children rarely end up in grammar- her mum struggles on NMW, no money for any extras, she tries her best but has her own challenges. Part of me wanted to offer to pay for her tutoring, but DH said it would go down badly and create a different dynamic in their friendship, so we didn't. But I do think that with different opportunities and environments, many of these disruptive children may be much better behaved.

Velumental · 13/11/2026 09:44

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 07:25

Everyone masks, nobody goes to work and starts scratching themselves or having a nap at the desk Grin I think it’s just harder for autistic people to observe and internalise social rules.

There are 2 possible interpretations of this, you think masking is just following social norms like not picking your nose in public.

Or, you genuinely are Neurodivergent without knowing and have to actually mask. I spent my childhood practicing conversations in my head, planning every interaction meticulously, practising facial expressions Infront of a mirror, talking myself through how to do eye contact. When stressed I ran through well known prayers or conjugated french verbs in my head to calm myself. I taught myself to read at 3. I was well known for day dreaming, lost belongings constantly, struggled with friendships and feelings like everyone else had this rule book I'd not been given. I missed instructions not given directly to me but to the wider class. I have a ridiculously high IQ so I did really well academically and everything was placed under the heading of 'incredibly intelligent, no common sense' so I suspect I am a highly masking autistic woman.

I have an autistic son, a diagnosed autistic husband and a daughter who is just like me and just been referred for assessment.

My point is simply you may be masking but not realise masking is even a thing. Because I assumed everyone was working as hard as I was and setting up strategies like I do to cope. I do cope, I plan and organise and make lists and set alarms for everything. Since I've realised I'm probably autistic it gives me access to tools that work better for getting the most out of my brain.

That's what I'm hoping school will help my children with, finding strategies that help them and helping them learn to implement strategies themselves. So far our school have been amazing.

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 09:48

Velumental · 13/11/2026 09:44

There are 2 possible interpretations of this, you think masking is just following social norms like not picking your nose in public.

Or, you genuinely are Neurodivergent without knowing and have to actually mask. I spent my childhood practicing conversations in my head, planning every interaction meticulously, practising facial expressions Infront of a mirror, talking myself through how to do eye contact. When stressed I ran through well known prayers or conjugated french verbs in my head to calm myself. I taught myself to read at 3. I was well known for day dreaming, lost belongings constantly, struggled with friendships and feelings like everyone else had this rule book I'd not been given. I missed instructions not given directly to me but to the wider class. I have a ridiculously high IQ so I did really well academically and everything was placed under the heading of 'incredibly intelligent, no common sense' so I suspect I am a highly masking autistic woman.

I have an autistic son, a diagnosed autistic husband and a daughter who is just like me and just been referred for assessment.

My point is simply you may be masking but not realise masking is even a thing. Because I assumed everyone was working as hard as I was and setting up strategies like I do to cope. I do cope, I plan and organise and make lists and set alarms for everything. Since I've realised I'm probably autistic it gives me access to tools that work better for getting the most out of my brain.

That's what I'm hoping school will help my children with, finding strategies that help them and helping them learn to implement strategies themselves. So far our school have been amazing.

You’ve pretty much described me too.

It was only after I had children and - surprise surprise - they turned out to be autistic that I suddenly realised I was too (though according to some in this thread I’ve simply ‘made’ my children autistic 🙄🙄🙄 shame on the teachers who believe that shite)

‘Bright but no common sense’ was exactly how I was described.