Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest you watch and share the film unauthorised absence - particularly if you work in schools/your child has SEN or difficultly attending school

773 replies

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 20:31

This excellent short film Unauthorised Absence has been produced to highlight
the actual reality of what it is like for families whose children can't cope in school for whatever reason (SEN, mental health, anxiety etc) and how they are often punished rather than helped. It is a heatwrenching watch.

The story follows a single mother fighting a punitive education system when her autistic nine-year-old daughter experiences severe school distress and emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA). It stars Emily Bruni, Beatrice Flaherty, Cathy Tyson, and Anna Maxwell Martin.
It is on the longlist for the Best Short Film at the British Independent Film Awards.

It was crowd funded by parents and others whose childrens have suffered due to the system and aims to help change the dialogue around how these children and their parents are viewed. Both my children have had great difficulties in school one not being able to attend at all and the other forcing herself in until she had a severe breakdown while school told us they were both 'fine in school' - so I think it is really important to watch and share this.

(Please note - the film contains some pretty distressing scenes and there is some self harm. It is quite a difficult watch for anyone who has been through this with their family)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn8C7WuGv8g

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
desperatemum1234 · 13/11/2026 11:28

Thank you, will watch.
And people need to remember, the child in the film is 9yo - think how it is when the child is 13, 14, 15 and bigger and stronger than you, and then also imagine a boy that age.

And as PP says, one main fear is breaking down IN school in front of peers, teachers etc and getting v little support. My daughter’s school has virtually no support for distressed students, whereas my friend’s daughter’s school has amazing support and resources.

MerryStork · 13/11/2026 11:29

I’ve watched it and living it to some extent! It was a hard watch for me but I hope it brings about change and better support and understanding.

Ormally · 13/11/2026 11:34

Scamworried · 13/11/2026 11:28

It can be used to unfairly punish
And difficulty with uniform are more pronounced in SEN and disabled people.

For example a child with a foot difference is going to struggle with school shoes this is going to cause pain in the short term and damage in the longer term.
Sometimes a child may get a diagnosis and adjustment to footwear in early years but often it takes years to be seen by a specialist and by then a lot of damage has been done. Foot structure differences are also more likely as a co-occuring condition to autism.

Children with dexterity difficulty will struggle more with buttons, ties and show laces. Not having a button done up, tie not correct length or laces not tied have resulted in punishment

Children anxious at school are more likely to struggle with a tight tie, they will feel suffocated but loosing so they can breath better can result in punishment

Skirt length. Pupils have been punished for skirt not being exactly the correct length when if a pupil is shorter or taller it can be difficult to get a skirt falling exactly in the right place. Im not talking skirts hiked up to very short I'm talking length variation due to height.

Pupils have been punished for removing their blazer while walking home in a heat wave

And it's not just blazers, ties, socks.
In DD's school, it extends regularly to swimming costumes and gym shorts, which has trod a line of shaming on the basis of sex and body type in otherwise quite resilient and compliant girls.

OneYearLater · 13/11/2026 11:45

I’ve watched it, it bought back a lot of memories. Oldest DD struggled with school from nursery. Her refusal was so extreme that she sprained her ankle once kicking DH when he was trying to get her dressed!
We took her out to home educate in year 5. It’s not ideal but there are no suitable schools in our area and I don’t think she’d still be here if we hadn’t.
The film is very accurate if you’ve lived it but I do wonder if it’s enough for people who have never been through it. It’s a shame they didn’t get the funds for a longer film but hopefully it’s a start into further awareness where it’s needed.

BruachAbhann · 13/11/2026 11:47

Yellowisthenewgreen · 13/11/2026 11:24

i think there’s far more to it than everyone saying that schools are to blame and schools are much worse than they were in the past as in my experience thats not the case at all.

We are in Scotland and my kids go to a village school where the classes are all 16-22 kids. Due to a huge increase in deferrals, many kids are now closer to 6 when they start school. Uniform is very lapse (we don’t even have an official school tie or blazer) and lots of kids just wear a tshirt and black leggings/ trousers/ shorts. We have no SATS in Scotland. The P1 to 3 classes have doors opening up to outdoor areas and kids have free play in and out throughout the day and the whole school does play based learning.
Each class does an assembly for the school once a year but other than that there’s no assemblies.
They have access to a sensory room and a “playroom” which has spinny chairs etc. and teachers happily give out pencil grips, slanted writing boards etc.
Theres a council wide flexischooling policy so some kids attend forest school/ sailing or stay at home one day a week.

It’s absolutely nothing like my primary school 30 years ago and yet there are still quite a few kids who are ‘school refusers’.

That sounds like an ideal school to me! Are there many issues with dysregulation or school refusal there? It seems like a very nice and accommodating environment for kids to learn in but is unfortunately outside the norm.

TeawithMeerksy · 13/11/2026 11:56

TheBers · 12/11/2026 20:35

Actually you could just de roll and home school.

I’m a nurse - I can’t be at home to educate my child? I would love to homeschool and I’m sure my child would love to be at home but I don’t think that would be of benefit to DC.

There are lots of benefits to being at school, when you can access it. I want my child to access school and be happy there and get a good education. And I acknowledge that avoiding school in the long term is going to make the problem worse. It’s just unfortunate that accessing that help (although it’s available) is long, tiresome, difficult, and like shouting into the ether.

Honestly, more than anything in the world I would LOVE to drop my child off happy and safe at school every morning, and we could get on with our lives.

Bushmillsbabe · 13/11/2026 13:05

NightHeron · 13/11/2026 10:34

IMO, it is a nonsense to think that children and young people are going to sit and reflect on their behaviour in isolation! Either they are acting out behaviour, they have learnt at home in which case, it’s normal to them and no reflection for an hour is going to undo that model. Some may be communicating through their behaviour - like they may well have undiagnosed SEN. Teachers are not qualified to diagnose any SEN.

Research showed the worse a child’s developmental language disorder, the worse their behaviour is. At the time, the children in language units were essentially the same group of children as in EBD units. The difference was - children in language units had access to speech and language therapists, while children in EBD units had access to clinical psychologists.

Those children with undiagnosed SEN should really be assessed by educational psychologists and speech and language therapists. (It’s likely to be cheaper for the country in the long run)

Anyway, people learn best by social modelling and positive reinforcement!

It’s just a more socially acceptable name for warehousing of those children and young people, to get them out of the hair of the mainstream teachers, because it’s cheaper at the time, than trying to address their problems.

Is that the purpose of isolation? I thought it was to remove the child who was being disruptive so the rest of the class could learn.
I agree that any reflection needs to be supported and worked through with help from trained school staff, exploring root cause for behaviour

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 13:51

Bushmillsbabe · 13/11/2026 09:42

Why would you think that a grammar school wouldn't have a significant number of SEN? Portions of the 11+ , such as the NVR, are much easier for some bright ND children, those with hyperfocus, specific spatial reasoning skills etc. SEN can also relate to physical disabilities and medical needs, which don't always impact on intellectual ability.

But yes, these children consistently have very engaged parents, who can provide support with assessments, tutoring and a stable home life.

Some of the disruptive children aren't due to SEN, but due to past/current trauma. One of my daughters close friends is very bright, very lovely mostly, but ends up in trouble a lot because she struggles with boundaries, especially when they come from men (due to lots of issues with an alternating absent/oppressive father), so male teachers and staff who tell her what to do often get an earful. She has huge potential, bright, sporty, sociable - but has made a name for herself as the 'rude girl', ends up with various sanctions at primary, which I predict will only get worse in secondary, especially if falls in with a 'bad crowd'. These children rarely end up in grammar- her mum struggles on NMW, no money for any extras, she tries her best but has her own challenges. Part of me wanted to offer to pay for her tutoring, but DH said it would go down badly and create a different dynamic in their friendship, so we didn't. But I do think that with different opportunities and environments, many of these disruptive children may be much better behaved.

Ok, less complex SEN. I'm not talking about higher NVR or VR scores and lots of kids with high IQs don't pass the 11+ due to low WM/processing speed/other needs. And it does feel like there's a hierarchy of needs appearing with the proposed SEND reforms.

People do make assumptions about behaviours in school being caused by trauma at home instead of school trauma. I'm not saying that the girl you have referred to has school trauma or unmet SEND but there is a huge amount of parent blame in general even if it's well meaning. Some comments on this thread are depressing and show a lack of understanding as it's much more complex.

Non maintained schools have a lot of children who historically would have been in specialist schools, more children with more moderate/complex needs etc than grammar schools.

A very high % of the prison population have speech and language disorders in addition to other needs which were not picked up. Low self esteem is rife among many children.

There aren't any winners in this system, parents are stereotyped eg neglectful parent/anxious parent. Teachers are more overworked than ever. Everyone loses out, especially children. Government are turning a blind eye, have done for many years now. It feels like it's divide and conquer. Can't see things getting any better, only worse.

NightHeron · 13/11/2026 13:53

Bushmillsbabe · 13/11/2026 13:05

Is that the purpose of isolation? I thought it was to remove the child who was being disruptive so the rest of the class could learn.
I agree that any reflection needs to be supported and worked through with help from trained school staff, exploring root cause for behaviour

I was responding to a pp, @BeautifulLittlePumpkin , who said:

”The purpose of the iso rooms is to help these young people reflect on their behaviour and choices.”

Considering some young children and people can apparently be in isolation rooms for days or weeks, there should come a point when it’s obvious, that approach is not working for some; and the school should give up with it.

When DD1 was going through the education system, research showed children needed to be at Level 4 in the Y6 SATs for reading to be able to cope in secondary school and 1 in 4 children weren’t. I don’t know how that level translates to modern scores; but I have heard some children by Y6 have been allowed to fall by the wayside and nobody has done anything about it, including not telling their parents! Children who can’t read at secondary, are not going to be able to reflect on anything, other than they are a failure, as it’s not their fault!

Bathmats4eva · 13/11/2026 14:01

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 10:24

I don't live in an affluent area. Our local school was similar. Behaviour out of school similar as it was in school. New HT came in (no off rolling). I know that they introduced a great and meaningful reward system - prioritised over anything punitive, all rewards focused - and put in place a lot of other things. Interestingly the kids' behaviour out of school is great, no more fights, no more smoking weed in public. The students take a lot of pride in their school. Lessons are rarely disrupted.

Don't get me wrong, there are still problems but it's not the same school and it's made such a difference to out of school behaviours. Parents say the rewards system made all the difference although I'm sure it's more than that.

Maybe it's a one off but a really strong and compassionate SLT has made all the difference.

Not a one off- DD's school do this as well and they aim for a ratio of 16 positive reward points to every negative as a baseline. There's a lot of looking at the data to check teachers are also rewarding SEND, minoritised students etc the same. You can get positive points even while you are in reflection or detention.

It's had a remarkable impact on both behaviour and attendance - that nebulous belonging. It's still a big, urban secondary with some of those challenges but really the teachers and leadership are working to include everyone the best they can. It's quite a popular school with SEND parents as a result.

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 14:02

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 11:15

No it really really isn’t.

You keep saying this, but you’re not countering with your own examples.

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 14:11

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 14:02

You keep saying this, but you’re not countering with your own examples.

You are the one who originally claimed that not scratching yourself at work and various other conforming to social norms is ‘masking’ - and yet you’ve given nothing to back that claim up.

Please do go and find me the literature that states it’s masking.

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 14:21

Bathmats4eva · 13/11/2026 14:01

Not a one off- DD's school do this as well and they aim for a ratio of 16 positive reward points to every negative as a baseline. There's a lot of looking at the data to check teachers are also rewarding SEND, minoritised students etc the same. You can get positive points even while you are in reflection or detention.

It's had a remarkable impact on both behaviour and attendance - that nebulous belonging. It's still a big, urban secondary with some of those challenges but really the teachers and leadership are working to include everyone the best they can. It's quite a popular school with SEND parents as a result.

That's interesting! Does it have the same impact on behaviours out of school? Not had anyone outside my house smoking weed for years and shoplifting seems to have pretty much stopped too.

What I also like about this school when I looked around is that the head girl/head boy aren't high flying academic kids but have had to overcome adversity.

No calling the police on parents whose kids are EBSA!

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 14:42

Velumental · 13/11/2026 09:44

There are 2 possible interpretations of this, you think masking is just following social norms like not picking your nose in public.

Or, you genuinely are Neurodivergent without knowing and have to actually mask. I spent my childhood practicing conversations in my head, planning every interaction meticulously, practising facial expressions Infront of a mirror, talking myself through how to do eye contact. When stressed I ran through well known prayers or conjugated french verbs in my head to calm myself. I taught myself to read at 3. I was well known for day dreaming, lost belongings constantly, struggled with friendships and feelings like everyone else had this rule book I'd not been given. I missed instructions not given directly to me but to the wider class. I have a ridiculously high IQ so I did really well academically and everything was placed under the heading of 'incredibly intelligent, no common sense' so I suspect I am a highly masking autistic woman.

I have an autistic son, a diagnosed autistic husband and a daughter who is just like me and just been referred for assessment.

My point is simply you may be masking but not realise masking is even a thing. Because I assumed everyone was working as hard as I was and setting up strategies like I do to cope. I do cope, I plan and organise and make lists and set alarms for everything. Since I've realised I'm probably autistic it gives me access to tools that work better for getting the most out of my brain.

That's what I'm hoping school will help my children with, finding strategies that help them and helping them learn to implement strategies themselves. So far our school have been amazing.

Yes, I was also like you. Early reader and highly anxious child, very OCD. DS1 is AuDHD.

Bushmillsbabe · 13/11/2026 15:11

NightHeron · 13/11/2026 13:53

I was responding to a pp, @BeautifulLittlePumpkin , who said:

”The purpose of the iso rooms is to help these young people reflect on their behaviour and choices.”

Considering some young children and people can apparently be in isolation rooms for days or weeks, there should come a point when it’s obvious, that approach is not working for some; and the school should give up with it.

When DD1 was going through the education system, research showed children needed to be at Level 4 in the Y6 SATs for reading to be able to cope in secondary school and 1 in 4 children weren’t. I don’t know how that level translates to modern scores; but I have heard some children by Y6 have been allowed to fall by the wayside and nobody has done anything about it, including not telling their parents! Children who can’t read at secondary, are not going to be able to reflect on anything, other than they are a failure, as it’s not their fault!

Edited

But if they 'give up with it', is the alternative the child returning to their class and continuing to disrupt? Obviously, the ideal is that whatever is causing their behaviour(be it SEN, trauma or something else) is addressed, but given the huge cuts to nhs and other services meaning situation is likely to get worse rather than better, this could take a very long time.

The best option is probably something like 'isolation light' - removed from class so their class can focus, but not to a room where cannot talk or learn, but to a small group focused space? But even that takes resources many schools don't have.

If a child is that far behind, a teacher doesn't need to tell a parent, it should be pretty obvious when doing supported reading, helping them with homework etc. However, I do know that sometimes parents are raising concerns but the school is unwilling or unable to offer further support. As you say, reading is so crucial.

Scamworried · 13/11/2026 15:28

PassTheCranberrySauce · 13/11/2026 14:02

You keep saying this, but you’re not countering with your own examples.

I have given many examples in response

Scattery · 13/11/2026 15:38

My DD has issues that are well-documented both by GP and specialists. Sometimes these issues preclude her from going into school, for very good reason, involving bodily fluid if you must know. Yesterday I got a letter from school threatening to put me forward for fines since her attendance was below 90%.

Half of AIBU will come in and say "wELL thaTs tHe SYSTEM--"

Well, yes. The system is hanging by a thread. It's broken for some.

You can blame "pushy" or "feckless" or (insert adjective of your choice here) parents all you like, but that isn't going to fix things.

I'm so thankful this is our last year of compulsory school because I am the one who's going to break next.

Some teachers are fantastic and others are horrendous, but neither side has enough clout to overturn a system that isn't fit for purpose. I'm very glad this film has been released and hope it instils a modicum of compassion in some of you AIBU judgypants.

Bathmats4eva · 13/11/2026 15:39

Thekidsarefightingagain · 13/11/2026 14:21

That's interesting! Does it have the same impact on behaviours out of school? Not had anyone outside my house smoking weed for years and shoplifting seems to have pretty much stopped too.

What I also like about this school when I looked around is that the head girl/head boy aren't high flying academic kids but have had to overcome adversity.

No calling the police on parents whose kids are EBSA!

I'm not sure they've looked at that - be interesting though to look at the data.

Parents should also check how a child's absence is being coded on the register. EBSA should be an I code (illness/medical). It shouldn't be coded as unauthorised. As a governor I look really closely at the coding (it's also not true that Ofsted don't pay attention to unauthorised absence as someone claimed up thread. They pay a lot of attention to this because it shows that the school isn't engaging with the child or family).

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 16:29

Scattery · 13/11/2026 15:38

My DD has issues that are well-documented both by GP and specialists. Sometimes these issues preclude her from going into school, for very good reason, involving bodily fluid if you must know. Yesterday I got a letter from school threatening to put me forward for fines since her attendance was below 90%.

Half of AIBU will come in and say "wELL thaTs tHe SYSTEM--"

Well, yes. The system is hanging by a thread. It's broken for some.

You can blame "pushy" or "feckless" or (insert adjective of your choice here) parents all you like, but that isn't going to fix things.

I'm so thankful this is our last year of compulsory school because I am the one who's going to break next.

Some teachers are fantastic and others are horrendous, but neither side has enough clout to overturn a system that isn't fit for purpose. I'm very glad this film has been released and hope it instils a modicum of compassion in some of you AIBU judgypants.

But it’s not the system. You’ve clearly identified medical grounds. They should be coding as I

Scamworried · 13/11/2026 16:36

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 16:29

But it’s not the system. You’ve clearly identified medical grounds. They should be coding as I

The issue is even with medical evidence they often are marking as unauthorized

Even with medical evidence they are often harassing parents. Sometimes this harrassing happens while the child is in hospital having procedures done.

The head once wanted me to tell a consultant who had advised a minimum recovery period before returning to school that he was wrong because they would look after the child in school

Pobblewob · 13/11/2026 16:38

Bathmats4eva · 13/11/2026 15:39

I'm not sure they've looked at that - be interesting though to look at the data.

Parents should also check how a child's absence is being coded on the register. EBSA should be an I code (illness/medical). It shouldn't be coded as unauthorised. As a governor I look really closely at the coding (it's also not true that Ofsted don't pay attention to unauthorised absence as someone claimed up thread. They pay a lot of attention to this because it shows that the school isn't engaging with the child or family).

Or that the family isn't engaging with school....

TaptheCap · 13/11/2026 16:51

Schools have changed, parents have changed and most all, the whole of society has changed which has altered so much.

I cannot stress how much this is not about the individual parents but society as whole:

Children are given less freedom - more of their time is spent in structured or semi structured environments.

They spend much more time in some sort of educational settings - wrap around care, holiday clubs etc. - whilst not actual school, school buildings and environments can illicit particular ways of behaving and similar levels of stress in the brain (not all stress is bad, not all stress is equal and some stress is necessary for positive healthy development).

Whilst this is lots of socialising, the time spent actually socialising - managing relationships independently, building social skills, being allowed to manage disagreements/ social hierarchies etc is much smaller and adults are much faster to step in. Conflict management is a skill children are no longer encouraged to practice or develop independently.

Children are less independent on almost all levels and life skills are reducing because of it.

"School readiness" has moved away towards educational milestones rather than task independence.

A reduction in 'arts' education in favour of increased literacy and numeracy contributes.

A society and economy built on two income families and full time work to retirement significant contributes to all of the above.

In short - kids need space and time to play in independent, multi-age, adult free environments to build skills necessary to enable full school engagement AND to recover from the structured environments of school. Children are over-scheduled and not provided with sufficient free time or time to participate in normal, healthy positive risk taking.

We are failing our children (I say this as a mum of 2 primary age kids) and school refusal is where it is showing up. But kids who happily go in to school are not immune to the failings of society.

BeautifulLittlePumpkin · 13/11/2026 17:04

Fortuity · 13/11/2026 11:07

You have an odd idea of how schools operate isolation rooms. In many schools that have them, they have a very rigid discipline system under which children can get detentions for something like forgetting to bring the right pen or nor having the right socks on. Then the discipline system provides for a certain number of detentions leading automatically to isolations. For children with fantastic, nurturing home lives but something like executive function problems, it is all too easy to clock up enough demerits or detentions to get put into isolation. Then it becomes a vicious circle, because every time they are put in isolation they lose several hours or days in class, get behind on their work, can't do their homework, and get another isolation. Many will unsurprisingly react by messing around in class to hide their embarrassment, and back they go into isolation.

It really is one of the most stupid systems possible.

I don’t have an odd idea, I’ve worked in them. I KNOW how they operate. Never has a child been in one of my isolation rooms due to missing a detention. I can only presume those schools don’t really have THAT much to complain about behaviour wise if that’s what they’re doing. If a student was in iso in the school I’ve just left, it was because of violence, verbal abuse, bringing drugs into school or any other variation of unsafe behaviour. Different schools, different areas. I’m not doubting what you’re saying, but I absolutely don’t have an odd idea about how many schools run them. Expand your mind.

Neverendingstory111 · 13/11/2026 17:09

TaptheCap · 13/11/2026 16:51

Schools have changed, parents have changed and most all, the whole of society has changed which has altered so much.

I cannot stress how much this is not about the individual parents but society as whole:

Children are given less freedom - more of their time is spent in structured or semi structured environments.

They spend much more time in some sort of educational settings - wrap around care, holiday clubs etc. - whilst not actual school, school buildings and environments can illicit particular ways of behaving and similar levels of stress in the brain (not all stress is bad, not all stress is equal and some stress is necessary for positive healthy development).

Whilst this is lots of socialising, the time spent actually socialising - managing relationships independently, building social skills, being allowed to manage disagreements/ social hierarchies etc is much smaller and adults are much faster to step in. Conflict management is a skill children are no longer encouraged to practice or develop independently.

Children are less independent on almost all levels and life skills are reducing because of it.

"School readiness" has moved away towards educational milestones rather than task independence.

A reduction in 'arts' education in favour of increased literacy and numeracy contributes.

A society and economy built on two income families and full time work to retirement significant contributes to all of the above.

In short - kids need space and time to play in independent, multi-age, adult free environments to build skills necessary to enable full school engagement AND to recover from the structured environments of school. Children are over-scheduled and not provided with sufficient free time or time to participate in normal, healthy positive risk taking.

We are failing our children (I say this as a mum of 2 primary age kids) and school refusal is where it is showing up. But kids who happily go in to school are not immune to the failings of society.

Now I can see this, I just think when you add in ND it magnifies it x100.

There is no sure start, there is no village, teachers and school staff are as well exhausted and trying to deal with a broken system.

Parents are at breaking point and importantly so are children.

The government keep changing the goal posts but not actully helping anything.
Its just all a mess.
Its all to much red tape or tick boxes which help no one.

My childs school have one TA to 4 classes but the CEO gets paid £240,00 a year.
I dont think academys have helped either.

Understanding, support and recognising when a child is in distress should be delt with compassion,not blaming the parent and not threatening with fines and court.

BeautifulLittlePumpkin · 13/11/2026 17:12

@NightHeron

I agree. The “purpose” of them is reflection. In reality we all know the underlying reasons for lots of young people’s behaviours, and it’s not something they're going to be able to reflect on in a day or two without extensive therapy. It goes way above the poor persons remit who has to cover the room. They do serve a purpose, and it’s to benefit the other kids and teachers so they don’t need to deal with the most disruptive and violent kids, so there is a benefit to it, just not to the actual kid who is in iso. Terrible, soul destroying job. Wouldn’t do it again.