Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest you watch and share the film unauthorised absence - particularly if you work in schools/your child has SEN or difficultly attending school

773 replies

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 20:31

This excellent short film Unauthorised Absence has been produced to highlight
the actual reality of what it is like for families whose children can't cope in school for whatever reason (SEN, mental health, anxiety etc) and how they are often punished rather than helped. It is a heatwrenching watch.

The story follows a single mother fighting a punitive education system when her autistic nine-year-old daughter experiences severe school distress and emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA). It stars Emily Bruni, Beatrice Flaherty, Cathy Tyson, and Anna Maxwell Martin.
It is on the longlist for the Best Short Film at the British Independent Film Awards.

It was crowd funded by parents and others whose childrens have suffered due to the system and aims to help change the dialogue around how these children and their parents are viewed. Both my children have had great difficulties in school one not being able to attend at all and the other forcing herself in until she had a severe breakdown while school told us they were both 'fine in school' - so I think it is really important to watch and share this.

(Please note - the film contains some pretty distressing scenes and there is some self harm. It is quite a difficult watch for anyone who has been through this with their family)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn8C7WuGv8g

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
swingingbackwardsandforwards · 12/11/2026 20:49

Tbf, I’m not convinced that it is school, or at least not anything tangible about school.

I am absolutely not saying it is the fault of parents, but I do think in some cases you can accommodate and adapt all you can and the child still can’t manage because it’s so deeply rooted in anxiety.

ErmWhatNow · 12/11/2026 20:50

TheBers · 12/11/2026 20:29

And your suggestion is? Let them stay home until they’re 18 followed by a life on disability benefits?
Plenty of kids in alternative provision settings don’t turn up either.

Come up with a better solution.

Home education, employable skills, work on confidence and allow the child to blossom away from a restrictive, unnatural environment that doesn’t match anything else we have to do beyond school age.

Been there done that. Adult child now early 20s, happily working full time, earning a very good wage. Had he stayed at school he would not have this life.

Have a look at numbers of NEETs, far more than the numbers of children unable to attend school. So it’s quite a reach to assume that EBSA means a lifetime of disability payments when there are larger numbers getting through school and are then unable to do anything. Every young person I know who fits the NEET criteria has undiagnosed SN and/or mental health problems.

Honestly people have a very narrow and ignorant view of the reality many of us face, and the hard work that goes on, just to be told we’re the problem. 🙄

Society has some major problems going on, division and disinformation helps no one.

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 20:53

BruachAbhann · 12/11/2026 20:42

I do find it interesting from a human behaviour perspective on why some posters are so keen to look for reasons for school refusal other than the school itself. Trying to blame parents, home environment, financial reasons, relationship status and whatever else they can fling at the problem other than looking straight at the root cause of school as the obvious cause.

I wonder is this some kind of way to convince themselves it could never happen to their family? In the same way I scour harrowing articles about rape or child abduction for example, and try to find reasons that the terrifying event happened. Maybe the people weren't careful enough, they took unnecessary risks, it was a dangerous area. But the worst thing is when you realise it was completely out of their control and it could just as easily happen to you. That's truly terrifying.

I'm going to try look on these posters who are advocating for just giving our kids a slap, and blaming the parents and everything other than the school for the trauma they are going through in the most favourable light I can and think they are just scared their kids might have to go through something like that. But really, it's pretty shocking to read these posters take on the issue. Especially when the parents who are going through this have described what they are going through. There seems to be a complete lack of empathy and understanding from some people and no true desire to try to understand either.

I’m happy to answer.

Because it makes no sense to me.

Schools aren’t the same as in the 1990s, because it’s not the 1990s. But all the school blaming EBSA proponents flip flop between saying they’re like Victorian workhouses, and then lawless hotbeds of anarchy where kids run riot and cause utter chaos. Whenever I ask for examples of this ‘punitive’ system - boring detentions, corporal punishment, the cane perhaps? - the best they can come up with (and it’s always this one) is ‘they’re not allowed to use the toilet when they want’ (probably because they mess around vaping in it when they’re supposed to be learning).

There simply is no evidence to me, as somebody who went to primary school and has kids in primary school, that schools are radically different and more overwhelmingly stressful than they were 20 years ago.

I think the whole family environment has changed and the approach to risk and enjoyment is completely different. Screens have rewired kids brains to be so dopamine addicted that of course sitting still for any amount of time will feel very stressful. It isn’t lost on me EBSA kids spend most of their time on screens. Kids don’t take risks any more, parents are terrified of dropping the ball or harm coming to them in some way; so they’re just not developing resilience in the way we used to. Parents won’t allow sleepovers, playing out with other kids, walking to and from school alone in year 6, because they’re terrified of harm coming to them. So they keep them at home on screens, ‘managed’ but out of harms way. Parents themselves are highly anxious and centre their DC in absolutely everything, creating a sort of unhealthy symbiotic relationship. The end result is child who is on permanently high alert and finding everything terrifying/overwhelming bar being at home on screens where mum can look after them and wait on them.

TheBers · 12/11/2026 20:56

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 20:38

Living on what? Fresh air?

Well exactly.
Equally where’s the money coming from to provide bespoke 1:1 education?
Don’t assume theres some miracle setting. The chances of getting a small group setting that every child gets what they need is crazy. For most it’s learning social skills before any academic can take place. That implies some level of compliance in any setting.

PassTheCranberrySauce · 12/11/2026 21:06

Parents themselves are highly anxious and centre their DC in absolutely everything, creating a sort of unhealthy symbiotic relationship.

This is undoubtedly true, whether it’s a factor in school-related anxiety is debatable. Both schools and parents contribute to the emergence EBSA in ways they (and we) probably won’t ever be able to pinpoint (I’m a teacher whose eldest is an AuDHD secondary pupil).

My advice to all parents would be to get your child help as early as possible - even if they’re still very small. A malfunctioning HPA axis can cause all sorts of problems, not just school refusal. Involve the school, go straight to the GP, investigate both ASD and ADHD (I don’t think one exists without the other), get medication, do whatever it takes to get things moving forward as quickly as you can.

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 21:06

TheBers · 12/11/2026 20:56

Well exactly.
Equally where’s the money coming from to provide bespoke 1:1 education?
Don’t assume theres some miracle setting. The chances of getting a small group setting that every child gets what they need is crazy. For most it’s learning social skills before any academic can take place. That implies some level of compliance in any setting.

my child doesn’t need ‘bespoke’ - she just needs a smaller school or a smaller unit within a school. Hardly ‘bespoke’

and she has excellent social skills

You’re generalising.

There was a time when help and support in school wasn’t rationed in thd ways it is now - and the kids you’d complain in g about were supported. It was afforded then.

yelpmeout · 12/11/2026 21:07

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 20:53

I’m happy to answer.

Because it makes no sense to me.

Schools aren’t the same as in the 1990s, because it’s not the 1990s. But all the school blaming EBSA proponents flip flop between saying they’re like Victorian workhouses, and then lawless hotbeds of anarchy where kids run riot and cause utter chaos. Whenever I ask for examples of this ‘punitive’ system - boring detentions, corporal punishment, the cane perhaps? - the best they can come up with (and it’s always this one) is ‘they’re not allowed to use the toilet when they want’ (probably because they mess around vaping in it when they’re supposed to be learning).

There simply is no evidence to me, as somebody who went to primary school and has kids in primary school, that schools are radically different and more overwhelmingly stressful than they were 20 years ago.

I think the whole family environment has changed and the approach to risk and enjoyment is completely different. Screens have rewired kids brains to be so dopamine addicted that of course sitting still for any amount of time will feel very stressful. It isn’t lost on me EBSA kids spend most of their time on screens. Kids don’t take risks any more, parents are terrified of dropping the ball or harm coming to them in some way; so they’re just not developing resilience in the way we used to. Parents won’t allow sleepovers, playing out with other kids, walking to and from school alone in year 6, because they’re terrified of harm coming to them. So they keep them at home on screens, ‘managed’ but out of harms way. Parents themselves are highly anxious and centre their DC in absolutely everything, creating a sort of unhealthy symbiotic relationship. The end result is child who is on permanently high alert and finding everything terrifying/overwhelming bar being at home on screens where mum can look after them and wait on them.

What nonsense. My daughter is happy about absolutely everything except school. She hates it. I struggle to get her in most mornings. I used to be a teacher. I am a sensible person and good parent. She simply does not like it there. And it’s not specific to this school, I don’t think. Her main complaint is that there are too many worksheets and she doesn’t learn anything interesting. In my case the school have gone down the “your daughter is very anxious” route and it’s really hard to explain to them that it’s only about school!

ErmWhatNow · 12/11/2026 21:07

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 20:53

I’m happy to answer.

Because it makes no sense to me.

Schools aren’t the same as in the 1990s, because it’s not the 1990s. But all the school blaming EBSA proponents flip flop between saying they’re like Victorian workhouses, and then lawless hotbeds of anarchy where kids run riot and cause utter chaos. Whenever I ask for examples of this ‘punitive’ system - boring detentions, corporal punishment, the cane perhaps? - the best they can come up with (and it’s always this one) is ‘they’re not allowed to use the toilet when they want’ (probably because they mess around vaping in it when they’re supposed to be learning).

There simply is no evidence to me, as somebody who went to primary school and has kids in primary school, that schools are radically different and more overwhelmingly stressful than they were 20 years ago.

I think the whole family environment has changed and the approach to risk and enjoyment is completely different. Screens have rewired kids brains to be so dopamine addicted that of course sitting still for any amount of time will feel very stressful. It isn’t lost on me EBSA kids spend most of their time on screens. Kids don’t take risks any more, parents are terrified of dropping the ball or harm coming to them in some way; so they’re just not developing resilience in the way we used to. Parents won’t allow sleepovers, playing out with other kids, walking to and from school alone in year 6, because they’re terrified of harm coming to them. So they keep them at home on screens, ‘managed’ but out of harms way. Parents themselves are highly anxious and centre their DC in absolutely everything, creating a sort of unhealthy symbiotic relationship. The end result is child who is on permanently high alert and finding everything terrifying/overwhelming bar being at home on screens where mum can look after them and wait on them.

Your description does not match my experience or that of others I personally know. At all.

People have so many opinions and rarely are they based on fact, and it’s difficult because you do make a compelling argument. Screens have undoubtedly created a problem and have changed how children learn and communicate, but you’re using this argument to tar those whose family lives are turned upside down by EBSA and blame them.

I’m part of a home ed community whose numbers are mainly made up of children who were deregistered because of EBSA and unsupportive school/LA, and the next highest group is teachers who left to get out of the system and didn’t want their children going through school as it’s become such a toxic environment for so many.

Barely a week goes by without a thread or more from a teacher wishing to leave because things are so bad. Barely a week without threads from parents trying to keep their child safe. Bottom line is schools are now largely unsupportive (obviously there are exceptions, and primary schools appear to fare better) for everyone involved. People saying how much better schools are currently than they used to be are cherry picking information and ignoring the elephant in the room that teachers are also not coping.

Thekidsarefightingagain · 12/11/2026 21:07

DustyOwl · 12/11/2026 07:42

I have worked in schools for 25 years, class teacher, TA, behaviour lead, forest school teacher, mainstream, SEND schools, PRUs (pupil referral units) APs (alternative provision). I have worked in areas of social deprivation and schools in incredibly wealthy areas. I have got around.
My Dad was an education psychologist and my Mum a primary school teacher for 30 years. I currently work as a speech’s and language therapist with children on the cusp of permanent exclusion. I have also had children who have been all the way through the state school system.

I can give you my 2 pennies worth, which will be true of some children and not of others, because after all this time, I am still learning and definitely don’t know all of the answers.

This is an incredibly complex situation, born from the fact that society has changed immeasurably in the last 25 years, the way people parent has changed (not better or worse) and the education system has massively changed too. Not schools, the whole system.

When my Dad was working, and Ed psych would regularly go to a school. They’d see children who were a concern and then support the school/parents. Each school had a designated one from the LEA. Academies came along, we no longer have the massive team of universal support, offered to every school. This support was multi level, teachers were given training too.

The system was much better (not perfect) at offering support to children with low level need. Parents weren’t always aware of the support a child was getting because it came to the whole school. We have gone back to a medical model. Children have to have a diagnosis to access support, schools don’t have the budget to get the support they need.

More importantly there was time. Schools were not a hot house of constant testing, to meet arbitrary standards. That level of constant assessment just didn’t exist. Teachers had time to teach and support children who needed it. Teachers still want to do that now but there isn’t time. The foundation subjects have been squeezed to death. Is your child a talented musician? Can’t afford private lessons? Tough. There will be no recognition in school because there isn’t time to teach it/support it. Drama? PE? Art? In primary schools, where we had time to spend a whole afternoon doing it, now there is a topic, which lasts a term. Teachers try to cover it other ways by creative teaching in the core subjects but, if your child isn’t good at Maths and English, there isn’t time to celebrate and nurture their interest and talent. Parents pay chunks of money for private lessons in drama, art, sports etc but if you can’t afford that, forget it. Your child’s talents won’t be recognised and they won’t feel like they are succeeding. Not the schools fault, a system based on assessing children on Maths and English (notice not much science) in primary. By the time they get to secondary they already feel like failures.

Then we move onto support staff. There were TAs to offer support to children and teachers. They weren’t in every class, then they were, to match the changing curriculum the the pressures teachers faced. Then the TAs were taken away, because of budgets but also because supports staffs wages are so disgustingly low that many, very skilled professionals have to leave, to earn enough, to support themselves. The TAs role has changed, the responsibilities have changed but the pay hasn’t. They aren’t Teacher Assistants anymore, they are Assistant Teachers and they get paid bugger all.

I haven’t said everything I want. Not even slightly, but I bet you’re glad I’m going to stop now. I’m going to get to my job, seeing the parents and teachers, struggling to do their best.

These are massive generalisations. There is way more than this to consider, society, parenting, the way children socialise etc but I have run out of time.

Oh, and by the way, I blame Gove. Just saying.

With you on this and I blame Gove too. There have always been issues of course but with the education system but Gove along with austerity have had a disastrous impact.

I remember people being horrified by the idea of isolation rooms - schools were viewed as being cruel if they had one, very few did. Now it's the norm in schools, no one bats an eye lid.

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 21:16

TheBers · 12/11/2026 20:29

And your suggestion is? Let them stay home until they’re 18 followed by a life on disability benefits?
Plenty of kids in alternative provision settings don’t turn up either.

Come up with a better solution.

Is your answer to physically force them into school causing untold damage in the hope they kill themselves?

We home Ed because school was literally destroying our child. We tried for years for support the irony being if we had been listened to in the early years the support they needed would have been low cost short term but by dismissing the childs needs and not giving early support the needs grew and grew as did the trauma and school anxiety.
It is going to take years to fully recover but luckily we got out in time and now she is starting to thrive.

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 21:21

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 20:35

No mentally healthy child is going to be caused a brain injury by going to school, even if the school is ‘busy’ or uses PowerPoints. This simply isn’t a normal reaction to such a scenario, you have to be fragile to begin with.

It's not about being fragile
SEN / ND kids are probably far more resilient than the other children. They have literally been square pegs pushed into round holes. But there is only so much anyone can take.

A normal leg isn't fragile but is still going to break if it's constantly battered and smashed. A broken leg doesn't mean you are fragile

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 21:28

Velumental · 12/11/2026 20:32

And then you have all these parents whose kids have EBSA, telling you the stresses you imagine in our homes don't exist. And still you try to explain to us that it can't be school stressors surely.

Please quote where I said it can't be school stressors. My whole point is that there can be more than one stressor.

Watchoutfortheslowaraf · 12/11/2026 21:30

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 20:35

No mentally healthy child is going to be caused a brain injury by going to school, even if the school is ‘busy’ or uses PowerPoints. This simply isn’t a normal reaction to such a scenario, you have to be fragile to begin with.

The child the poster mentioned was sent into a school where she was bullied and had no friends for 7 years so it would have some impact I think. I Am wondering why she wasn’t moved to another school as that one caused so much damage over such a long period of time but perhaps there wasn’t another school in the area and parents couldn’t home school.

Neverendingstory111 · 12/11/2026 21:39

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 20:53

I’m happy to answer.

Because it makes no sense to me.

Schools aren’t the same as in the 1990s, because it’s not the 1990s. But all the school blaming EBSA proponents flip flop between saying they’re like Victorian workhouses, and then lawless hotbeds of anarchy where kids run riot and cause utter chaos. Whenever I ask for examples of this ‘punitive’ system - boring detentions, corporal punishment, the cane perhaps? - the best they can come up with (and it’s always this one) is ‘they’re not allowed to use the toilet when they want’ (probably because they mess around vaping in it when they’re supposed to be learning).

There simply is no evidence to me, as somebody who went to primary school and has kids in primary school, that schools are radically different and more overwhelmingly stressful than they were 20 years ago.

I think the whole family environment has changed and the approach to risk and enjoyment is completely different. Screens have rewired kids brains to be so dopamine addicted that of course sitting still for any amount of time will feel very stressful. It isn’t lost on me EBSA kids spend most of their time on screens. Kids don’t take risks any more, parents are terrified of dropping the ball or harm coming to them in some way; so they’re just not developing resilience in the way we used to. Parents won’t allow sleepovers, playing out with other kids, walking to and from school alone in year 6, because they’re terrified of harm coming to them. So they keep them at home on screens, ‘managed’ but out of harms way. Parents themselves are highly anxious and centre their DC in absolutely everything, creating a sort of unhealthy symbiotic relationship. The end result is child who is on permanently high alert and finding everything terrifying/overwhelming bar being at home on screens where mum can look after them and wait on them.

Have you had personal experience with EBSA? Do you have proof that children with EBSA are staying at home on screens?

Its funny because out of my 3 children only one has EBSA, my youngest is never on a screen and plays out when its not dark as she is in yr 6.

My oldest now and again and mainly with friends and my middle does go on them but mainly to do online work at home due to the fact he can not access school!
And im laughing at my child at home and having me wait on him!
He would go to school in a heartbeat if he did not feel so frightened he would rather hurt himself then be there!

Quite frankly most of the things your are implying are made up fiction.

TheBers · 12/11/2026 21:44

Neverendingstory111 · 12/11/2026 21:39

Have you had personal experience with EBSA? Do you have proof that children with EBSA are staying at home on screens?

Its funny because out of my 3 children only one has EBSA, my youngest is never on a screen and plays out when its not dark as she is in yr 6.

My oldest now and again and mainly with friends and my middle does go on them but mainly to do online work at home due to the fact he can not access school!
And im laughing at my child at home and having me wait on him!
He would go to school in a heartbeat if he did not feel so frightened he would rather hurt himself then be there!

Quite frankly most of the things your are implying are made up fiction.

You only speak for yourself. Do you have experience in school, especially SEN or alternative provision.
Do a term then come back.

Neverendingstory111 · 12/11/2026 21:49

Actually I do thanks! Was there for over 2 years so saw both sides!
I have not blamed the school, I am blaming the LA and the government though and the lack of help and support.

And of course I am going to speak about what my family are going through!
What experience have you had with EBSA?

SleeplessInWherever · 12/11/2026 21:53

TheBers · 12/11/2026 21:44

You only speak for yourself. Do you have experience in school, especially SEN or alternative provision.
Do a term then come back.

I taught SEN Primary and Secondary, and worked in Autism provisions, PRUs and AP.

Anyone with an ounce of experience knows that behaviour is communication.

So when a child is in crisis every day at school, or is completely disengaged from learning, or is going home and harming themselves, that behaviour is telling you something.

Generally that something is that their needs aren’t being met, that there’s some sort of social breakdown at school, or that they have significant mental health vulnerability or trauma.

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 22:25

Thekidsarefightingagain · 12/11/2026 21:07

With you on this and I blame Gove too. There have always been issues of course but with the education system but Gove along with austerity have had a disastrous impact.

I remember people being horrified by the idea of isolation rooms - schools were viewed as being cruel if they had one, very few did. Now it's the norm in schools, no one bats an eye lid.

I don't think that's entirely true. There are many parents who hate all this isolation stuff (especially when it's for ridiculous shit like wearing the wrong socks). Those higher up, you're right, they don't care.

Thekidsarefightingagain · 12/11/2026 22:49

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 22:25

I don't think that's entirely true. There are many parents who hate all this isolation stuff (especially when it's for ridiculous shit like wearing the wrong socks). Those higher up, you're right, they don't care.

Believe it or not it was often the higher ups who were horrified if another school had one. They were viewed as being really bad for children's self esteem pre Gove and austerity.

BeautifulLittlePumpkin · 12/11/2026 22:54

Mum didn’t implement firm boundaries. She looked a pushover. Girl looked as though she was screaming out for proper boundaries and emotional containment.

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 22:55

Thekidsarefightingagain · 12/11/2026 22:49

Believe it or not it was often the higher ups who were horrified if another school had one. They were viewed as being really bad for children's self esteem pre Gove and austerity.

I wonder what changed that's made them so acceptable?

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 23:13

BeautifulLittlePumpkin · 12/11/2026 22:54

Mum didn’t implement firm boundaries. She looked a pushover. Girl looked as though she was screaming out for proper boundaries and emotional containment.

I can't believe you watched the film and came to that conclusion 🫩

Thekidsarefightingagain · 12/11/2026 23:43

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 22:55

I wonder what changed that's made them so acceptable?

I think - downgrading vocational qualifications, even more pressure piled onto on schools to achieve better results, massively increasing the number of academies - schools as businesses don't work. Getting rid of coursework putting more pressure on students. TAs going, school budgets slashed, behaviour tsars promoting this stuff and encouraging schools to implement.

Ofsted (bleurgh) became more punitive and praised schools that had implemented things like isolation rooms & other shit to drive results. It's all led to stressed out children who have very little autonomy. Stressed out teachers and a system that barely functions. I'm sure there's loads more. This was all pre COVID too.

whatsnewpussycatt · 13/11/2026 00:44

@Apotofrealcoffee I went to school in the 90s the number of EBSA or truanting as it was called then was huge. This was a good school in a nice area. Maybe it was more apparent to me because I was one of the children truanting. People didn’t really talk about it then or care that much. It’s become more visible due to social media (like lots of things) but it was always there.

whatsnewpussycatt · 13/11/2026 01:55

All these posters saying things like: It’s a parenting issue, parents today are too soft, they are raising children with no boundaries, parents want to blame school instead of themselves, parents just can’t be bothered to get their children to school, there was no such thing as EBSA in my day, parents put their foot down when I was younger, there was no Sen in my day, schools used to be stricter and such like. Well who raised today’s parents? IF it is such a huge parenting problem, who were our role models, who taught us how to parent? Seems like this magic generation, no nonsense schools, perfect system, did a rubbish job if the outcome is a generation of feckless parents. So who is to blame? Shouldn’t we blame the people who raised today’s parents? Shouldn’t we blame a system that churned out all these useless people? Clearly today’s children are a result of parenting that was taught by the previous generation…….Or we could be realistic and understand it’s a complex issue in a failing system.