I have worked in schools for 25 years, class teacher, TA, behaviour lead, forest school teacher, mainstream, SEND schools, PRUs (pupil referral units) APs (alternative provision). I have worked in areas of social deprivation and schools in incredibly wealthy areas. I have got around.
My Dad was an education psychologist and my Mum a primary school teacher for 30 years. I currently work as a speech’s and language therapist with children on the cusp of permanent exclusion. I have also had children who have been all the way through the state school system.
I can give you my 2 pennies worth, which will be true of some children and not of others, because after all this time, I am still learning and definitely don’t know all of the answers.
This is an incredibly complex situation, born from the fact that society has changed immeasurably in the last 25 years, the way people parent has changed (not better or worse) and the education system has massively changed too. Not schools, the whole system.
When my Dad was working, and Ed psych would regularly go to a school. They’d see children who were a concern and then support the school/parents. Each school had a designated one from the LEA. Academies came along, we no longer have the massive team of universal support, offered to every school. This support was multi level, teachers were given training too.
The system was much better (not perfect) at offering support to children with low level need. Parents weren’t always aware of the support a child was getting because it came to the whole school. We have gone back to a medical model. Children have to have a diagnosis to access support, schools don’t have the budget to get the support they need.
More importantly there was time. Schools were not a hot house of constant testing, to meet arbitrary standards. That level of constant assessment just didn’t exist. Teachers had time to teach and support children who needed it. Teachers still want to do that now but there isn’t time. The foundation subjects have been squeezed to death. Is your child a talented musician? Can’t afford private lessons? Tough. There will be no recognition in school because there isn’t time to teach it/support it. Drama? PE? Art? In primary schools, where we had time to spend a whole afternoon doing it, now there is a topic, which lasts a term. Teachers try to cover it other ways by creative teaching in the core subjects but, if your child isn’t good at Maths and English, there isn’t time to celebrate and nurture their interest and talent. Parents pay chunks of money for private lessons in drama, art, sports etc but if you can’t afford that, forget it. Your child’s talents won’t be recognised and they won’t feel like they are succeeding. Not the schools fault, a system based on assessing children on Maths and English (notice not much science) in primary. By the time they get to secondary they already feel like failures.
Then we move onto support staff. There were TAs to offer support to children and teachers. They weren’t in every class, then they were, to match the changing curriculum the the pressures teachers faced. Then the TAs were taken away, because of budgets but also because supports staffs wages are so disgustingly low that many, very skilled professionals have to leave, to earn enough, to support themselves. The TAs role has changed, the responsibilities have changed but the pay hasn’t. They aren’t Teacher Assistants anymore, they are Assistant Teachers and they get paid bugger all.
I haven’t said everything I want. Not even slightly, but I bet you’re glad I’m going to stop now. I’m going to get to my job, seeing the parents and teachers, struggling to do their best.
These are massive generalisations. There is way more than this to consider, society, parenting, the way children socialise etc but I have run out of time.
Oh, and by the way, I blame Gove. Just saying.