Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that it’s not at all surprising that home education is on the rise?

134 replies

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 13:48

Having read the recent thread on secondary schools locking the loos in lesson time, I couldn’t help but think that it’s not a surprise that home education is becoming a more and more popular choice for our children. I was genuinely shocked both at the treatment of school children as prisoners by schools, and by the horrendous behaviour that leads to that treatment in the first place. Shitting on the floor, vandalism, vaping, violence and bullying are simply the ones I can remember from the top of my head. My main takeaway was horror at the situation, and a thought that there’s no way in hell I want to send my toddler into an environment like that in ten years time.

It brought to mind this article I read about how home education is in the rise in Blackpool, and that’s a trend which seems to be nationwide.

School budgets are being stretched impossibly tightly and have been for so long that it’s impossible to shield children from the impact of this. There’s not the budget for enough TAs and that means that managing large classes falls to one teacher. We all know that SEN are at a high, as are behaviour issues and school readiness so that one teacher has to manage a classroom which has more challenges than before with less help than before. That means that most children in a classroom won’t be able to get as much independent care and attention, poor behaviour and bullying go unchecked, and children who have more minor SEN or are quietly struggling are missed. It also means that children who have more significant SEN but fall short of a 1:1 (if that’s even provided) also won’t get what they need in the classroom either. Teachers also have a lot of pressures to do things which don’t actually help their classes, maybe from an academy trust, overbearing head teacher, Ofsted, or something else. Just so much busy work that doesn’t add any value to the children, and takes up teachers’ time and makes them burn out. And all this means that there’s a lot of violence and disruption in schools, nobody is getting the attention they deserve and everyone is suffering because of it. Home education means that you know your children are safe, have access to the loo when they need and have individual attention and a curriculum which can be tailored to them. If they grasp a concept quickly, you can move on, if they’re struggling then you can spend more time on it. I want to be clear that this isn’t a thread bashing teachers or TAs, most are doing the best they can, but it’s bashing the system that teachers are working in.

School holiday fines simply seem to make a more adversarial and antagonistic relationship between parents and schools. Parents seem to just share advice how to get around the fines, like taking children out after morning registration, so they don’t trigger the limit. They don’t even work because attendance rates haven’t improved. All it seems to do is create a conflict between the parents and schools/LAs. I also think that parents are ultimately the one’s responsible for their children’s childhood and education unless there are safeguarding concerns and giving a parent a criminal record for taking their children out of school for one week three years in a row is bananas to me and while it seems a small thing, I totally get why parents don’t want to put their children in a system that criminalises them for going on holiday at the wrong time. Especially in a cost of living crisis where many families’ only option for a holiday is in term time due to cost. I know this seems a minor point, and I considered leaving it out, because I don’t think anybody is taking the decision to HE because of holiday fines alone, but it’s just an extra thing which puts barriers up and creates a conflict between parents and schools.

I also think that the rise in home education also makes a difference because it’s more visible and it increases the opportunities available which in turn makes it more desirable. My local area’s home education community is large and active so concerns about friends and socialisation don’t feel relevant in the context of the opportunities that home educated children have. It becoming more popular also normalises it. I feel there’s still a lot of people who see home education as the preserve of the extremely religious, or by flat earthers who failed their own GCSEs, but more people home educating means that people will see that actually most home educators are normal families and see it as a viable and possibly desirable path for their children too. And if children start to struggle in schools, home education seems to be becoming seen as a good alternative rather than trying to fit a square peg in a round hole with school.

On so many of the articles I’ve read about the rise in home education, there’s a comment on how local authorities wish to stop the rise and increase the number of children in schools, but without tackling core issues parents have, and without significant investments I can only see home education rising in popularity. So am I being unreasonable to think that home education’s rise is inevitable in the current climate and that if local authorities and government want to reduce this number significant changes need to happen.

OP posts:
Jijithecat · 03/11/2026 14:18

Who has been given a criminal record for taking their child out of school for one week three years in a row?

Ablondiebutagoody · 03/11/2026 14:25

Inclusion above everything else is driving the kids it is supposed to benefit out of school altogether. Those with violent "emotional regulation" issues are untouchable.

zoeslim · 03/11/2026 14:38

Ablondiebutagoody · 03/11/2026 14:25

Inclusion above everything else is driving the kids it is supposed to benefit out of school altogether. Those with violent "emotional regulation" issues are untouchable.

Yes I would never allow my kids to go to a woke state school

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 14:40

Jijithecat · 03/11/2026 14:18

Who has been given a criminal record for taking their child out of school for one week three years in a row?

This is from the government website (picture will take a while to load). A third absence within a three year period automatically goes to court. It then depends on the Magistrates to determine what will happen. A fine in magistrates court is given even in the lowest culpability and harm if the parents are found or plead guilty according to the sentencing guidelines.

To think that it’s not at all surprising that home education is on the rise?
OP posts:
DeftGoldHedgehog · 03/11/2026 14:41

YANBU

Though I think a lot of parents would like school to actually be just fit for purpose and for their children to just go to school. They haven't really wanted to take charge of their children's education but haven't been left with any other options.

TraitorOrFaithful · 03/11/2026 14:44

Your post is very negative OP. My DC attends a state school and is having a good experience- nothing like the environment you describe.

theresnolimits · 03/11/2026 14:45

It feels to me that you have taken all the worst click-bait examples you can find about schools and extrapolated them to all schools. Criminal records and ‘shitting in the floor’. Extreme or what?

Some of the things you mention are not to do with schools but home environment: poor behaviour, taking kids out of school for holidays, failing to support schools with discipline. Society’s attitudes to authority has changed dramatically over the past twenty years as have diagnosed SEN conditions and schools can only deal with the students they have in front of them.

The whole toilet debate grates on me. In thirty plus years of teaching I’ve hardly ever met a child who couldn’t wait to go to the toilet (secondary). If they have a physical condition, they will have a toilet pass. If it’s a girl with a period issue, a quick heads up and she’s allowed out. The main issue is kids don’t want to waste their break going to the toilet, so they leave it and need to go in class time. They need to take responsibility for that. If I allow even 2 or 3 out of my lesson that’s 4-6 exits and entrances in an hour lesson - so basically someone coming or going every ten minutes. Then they’ve missed a bit of the lesson so are asking what we’re doing or what did they miss? It’s so disruptive - they’re not ‘prisoners’, they have every opportunity to go to the toilet at break - as indeed do I and I had menopause flooding issues and didn't need to walk out of their lessons. And if every class is allowing one child out at a time, that could be 50 kids out wandering the site (we were a ten form intake). Rant over.

As for home education, only time will tell how well it served these young people. In 10/20 years time, how disadvantaged will they be and how will they feel about their parents’ decision? It’s only long term that we will know. But if you want a considered debate, please enough with the hyperbole.

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 03/11/2026 14:51

10 years ago I used to think people that home educated were a little bit eccentric now I can see why people choose to do this. I do think school gives a good start to life for social expectations, working life, socialisation. However I do feel like school now is more of a punishment- they give detentions for the most insignificant reasons and I am only in my 30’s but I just don’t remember it being like that when I was young. I feel it’s a shame for teachers too as they are overburdened

ElectricThrowAddict · 03/11/2026 14:51

I think most parents of toddlers can't imagine their child in secondary school.

I have teens and they have flourished in state comps. Yes they are surrounded by young people who face lots of challenges and are very disadvantaged, those whose behaviour is poor and disruptive etc, but they have been supported to attend and take part and have done really well. They have enjoyed all the opportunities, trips, sports and drama on offer. They have excelled academically. They have loads of friends and they are very aware of how different people can be and how to get along with people you have little on common with.

Mine would have been pretty bored at home. I couldn't hope to replicate the breadth of subjects and sports etc they have been able to access at school, nor could I or would I be able to facilitate them mixing with so many people so different to us. I can't take the whole family on a sports tour or skiing or on geography field trips etc etc.

I absolutely understand that schools don't work for everyone and that SEN changes a lot. But I wouldn't dismissed the state education system out of hand at all.

Divebar2021 · 03/11/2026 14:55

What happens then to the children who struggle in a home schooling environment? How does the parent teach in subjects that they haven’t studied themselves for what … 20 / 30 years if at all? How are parents affording time away from work given we all know cost of living blah blah. How do you ensure home school children are exposed to a wide range of people, ideas and diverse thoughts. ( separate from your own ? )

Jijithecat · 03/11/2026 14:58

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 14:40

This is from the government website (picture will take a while to load). A third absence within a three year period automatically goes to court. It then depends on the Magistrates to determine what will happen. A fine in magistrates court is given even in the lowest culpability and harm if the parents are found or plead guilty according to the sentencing guidelines.

I asked who, as in can you give me a real life example of someone this has happened to?

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 15:10

theresnolimits · 03/11/2026 14:45

It feels to me that you have taken all the worst click-bait examples you can find about schools and extrapolated them to all schools. Criminal records and ‘shitting in the floor’. Extreme or what?

Some of the things you mention are not to do with schools but home environment: poor behaviour, taking kids out of school for holidays, failing to support schools with discipline. Society’s attitudes to authority has changed dramatically over the past twenty years as have diagnosed SEN conditions and schools can only deal with the students they have in front of them.

The whole toilet debate grates on me. In thirty plus years of teaching I’ve hardly ever met a child who couldn’t wait to go to the toilet (secondary). If they have a physical condition, they will have a toilet pass. If it’s a girl with a period issue, a quick heads up and she’s allowed out. The main issue is kids don’t want to waste their break going to the toilet, so they leave it and need to go in class time. They need to take responsibility for that. If I allow even 2 or 3 out of my lesson that’s 4-6 exits and entrances in an hour lesson - so basically someone coming or going every ten minutes. Then they’ve missed a bit of the lesson so are asking what we’re doing or what did they miss? It’s so disruptive - they’re not ‘prisoners’, they have every opportunity to go to the toilet at break - as indeed do I and I had menopause flooding issues and didn't need to walk out of their lessons. And if every class is allowing one child out at a time, that could be 50 kids out wandering the site (we were a ten form intake). Rant over.

As for home education, only time will tell how well it served these young people. In 10/20 years time, how disadvantaged will they be and how will they feel about their parents’ decision? It’s only long term that we will know. But if you want a considered debate, please enough with the hyperbole.

Some of the things you mention are not to do with schools but home environment: poor behaviour, taking kids out of school for holidays, failing to support schools with discipline. Society’s attitudes to authority has changed dramatically over the past twenty years as have diagnosed SEN conditions and schools can only deal with the students they have in front of them.

Whether the issues originate from homes or schools (and I was clear that I’m not bashing teachers) the fact is that there is a significant amount of disruptive behaviour in schools which aren’t resourced to deal with it and that has a knock on impact on the rest of the students in the classroom.

Im also not deliberately using hyperbole. I posted above the government website where a third absence in a three year period will result in a magistrate’s court fine even with the lowest harm and culpability according to the sentencing guidelines. That leaves a record which will show on a DBS check. It’s fairly new but it’s the law. The disgusting behaviour (violence, bullying, smoking/vaping, shitting on the floor and vandalism) was cited fairly often as a reason why toilets are locked between breaks on another recent thread. The consensus on that threads was largely that there aren’t the support staff to supervise corridors and left unchecked it is inevitable that students will trash the loos or use them for antisocial behaviour. I was shocked but this included parents who said their children went to independent schools trashing the loos, and there was not suggestion on that thread that the descriptions of poor behaviour was hyperbolic.

OP posts:
JuliaAgrippina · 03/11/2026 15:11

There are good state school out there still - in fact bulk of them are good.

DC secondary was great when eldest started went downhill later just before GCSE and was bloody awful DS years - and then came up slightly.

Yes toilets were locked and often not unlocked as supposed to be in breaks-after years of threats to do so - yes there were issued for DD2 getting to eat and drink and yes there was one winter with temps to low windows open and HT an arse about kids having coats on.

Kids still got through did well and went on to college and uni. We did think about HE at various points for differing reasons decided not to.

It is not the easier or cheap option and many get forced into it with schools not wanting or able to accomodate SEN/ND kids. It can be really positive - some of DD2 college mates were HE - their secondary also went down hill and ND was in play and they're doing really well with college and A-levels.

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 15:14

Jijithecat · 03/11/2026 14:58

I asked who, as in can you give me a real life example of someone this has happened to?

Why would an anecdote from me (which you would have no way of verifying anyway) matter more than the government guidance?

OP posts:
teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 15:26

Divebar2021 · 03/11/2026 14:55

What happens then to the children who struggle in a home schooling environment? How does the parent teach in subjects that they haven’t studied themselves for what … 20 / 30 years if at all? How are parents affording time away from work given we all know cost of living blah blah. How do you ensure home school children are exposed to a wide range of people, ideas and diverse thoughts. ( separate from your own ? )

If my child struggles with home education then we’ll find the root of what they are struggling with and try to solve that. Maybe that will be to change up what we’re doing at home or to try school. I’m not sure because I can’t troubleshoot problems which haven’t happened yet.

There’s online curricula, tutors, so many parents with different backgrounds in home ed groups (an ex science teacher friend of my parents now tutors small group home educated children science GCSEs). Most home educated children come across and interact with lots of children from all different backgrounds and of different ages too. A local home ed group is likely to be as diverse as the local school.

OP posts:
Jijithecat · 03/11/2026 15:35

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 15:14

Why would an anecdote from me (which you would have no way of verifying anyway) matter more than the government guidance?

Well because a real life example makes it seem more...real. Rather than just, this is the worst case scenario of what could happen.
People up and down the country take their children out of school during term time and yet that's not the reason why there's so much pressure on the justice system.

Divebar2021 · 03/11/2026 15:37

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 15:26

If my child struggles with home education then we’ll find the root of what they are struggling with and try to solve that. Maybe that will be to change up what we’re doing at home or to try school. I’m not sure because I can’t troubleshoot problems which haven’t happened yet.

There’s online curricula, tutors, so many parents with different backgrounds in home ed groups (an ex science teacher friend of my parents now tutors small group home educated children science GCSEs). Most home educated children come across and interact with lots of children from all different backgrounds and of different ages too. A local home ed group is likely to be as diverse as the local school.

How do you know what most home educated children are doing ? I’m interested in your source for your claims.

Netcurtainnelly · 03/11/2026 15:42

I admire parents who hime educate.
As long as you mix with other people at times why not.
At least no bullying.
How many people are lumped together at school with people they've got nothing in common with apart from they were born in the same school year.

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 15:45

Divebar2021 · 03/11/2026 15:37

How do you know what most home educated children are doing ? I’m interested in your source for your claims.

That’s fair, I should have said most home educated children I know, rather than a sweeping statement. I have a close friend who home educates, I know two people from a baby group who home educates their older children, and there’s a home ed group who have a session after my child’s swimming lesson while I’m having a drink in the cafe and I’ve chatted to them and their kids so I happen to know a fair few home educating families and this is what they do, and what I plan to do as well.

OP posts:
ElectricThrowAddict · 03/11/2026 15:57

Most home educated children come across and interact with lots of children from all different backgrounds and of different ages too. A local home ed group is likely to be as diverse as the local school.

This really isn't true. Certainly not locally to me. I know quite a few home ed families - a couple of them are HE from the off and they all have a SAHP, they are all white, middle class, all the dc do extra curricular sports, drama and music clubs. They all have cars and travel long distances around the local area to be part of the local HE scene. One of the mums runs aome of the local HE groups/forest school/website and social media, so it is very easy to see who takes part.

There is no real diversity, most definitely not of parental advantage, education and engagement. All these families are financially secure and have a parent who works very pt from home or not at all.

It is absolutely world's away from the genuine mix of people my dc meet in school - refugees, those with English as an additional language, those living in temp accommodation, those with caring responsibilities, those in care....

MyBestThing · 03/11/2026 16:01

I have read two separate disturbing threads on here recently where a parent removed their child from school and many years later they have a really difficult teenager who has no qualifications or education.
That's why Home Ed has a bad reputation.

Mytrousersitch · 03/11/2026 16:09

Meanwhile, all my three and every child I’ve ever known just goes to school and life carries on. I’ve never seen anything horrendous, some even have a great time.

On the other hand, I home educated my eldest until he was 11 and christ, bullying in home ed circles was rife. My son had a terrible time at a couple of home ed groups (there are little shites everywhere, some are home educated). And the parents were mostly batshit. My two youngest went to school from day dot, I wasn’t doing that shit again.

You are never allowed to say anything negative about home ed when you do it either. There are a lot of miserable home educated children - I was very involved in lots of groups and activities for years and saw hundreds of families.

If your face doesn’t fit in home ed circles, your child has no chance. It was all very much knit your own yogurt, no technology, vegan and wooden toys only where I was. Anyone who wasn’t like that (like me) was very much looked down upon and their children were steered away. So it wasn’t all lovely organic friendships for the children at all.

I saw so many parents bleat on about how great it was that their children weren’t “forced” to socialise with 30 children their own age - while their 13 year old was forced to sit and push lego around with an 8 year old as that’s the only choice they had, and there are posts everyday on home ed groups about how lonely a child is and the parent asking for friends for them.

But like I said, you aren’t allowed to say anything negative, or you are shunned.

My son is 24 now and he kept in touch with some home ed friends. Despite all the cries off, “home ed kids can go to Oxford!” as they were growing up, those children struggled as they got older and one has had to go no contact with his parents in order to go to college and get some qualifications as an adult as they were so against it.

Mytrousersitch · 03/11/2026 16:15

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 15:45

That’s fair, I should have said most home educated children I know, rather than a sweeping statement. I have a close friend who home educates, I know two people from a baby group who home educates their older children, and there’s a home ed group who have a session after my child’s swimming lesson while I’m having a drink in the cafe and I’ve chatted to them and their kids so I happen to know a fair few home educating families and this is what they do, and what I plan to do as well.

Ah, you will have heard the “everything is awesome” way of describing home ed that most of them do.

I didn’t. I was always honest about the drawbacks. But on the whole, people will smile though it and tell you it’s all hearts and rainbows even when they are struggling. I get it, they have to, but they keep the lie up amongst themselves which I will never understand.

Fivebyfive2 · 03/11/2026 16:16

I'm getting my tin foil hat on here, but here goes -

There is a massive uptick on home ed//home school/un schooling advertising/content on SM and in the news. Horror stories about schools. It is everywhere.

Alongside this, I've noticed a massive uptick of parents of young children having massive anxiety about their little ones going to school - they're looking into not sending them before they're even starting. It's become a very common thing to ask on here, Reddit, online in general, in parent groups etc.

And guess who it almost always is planning/hoping to stay home with the child to facilitate this? The mum, of course!

I know there are issues with schools. Honestly I do. But many are absolutely fine, better even and most kids aren't finishing school traumatised or with life long bladder issues or with parents banged up for going in holiday.

I don't know, I'm just a bit suspicious of this fairly recent but significant push to get more women to stay home and less children to attend school. It feels very isolating to me. Especially when it's done out of fear, that has been planted before the children are even school age...

For the record, my lad is only in year 2 so I know it's very early days. He's autistic and is thriving at his mainstream school - happy, confident, bright, lovely friends, secure in the routine provided. And yet I was (and still am) BOMBARDED with algorithms telling me he would be destroyed by school.

Mytrousersitch · 03/11/2026 16:18

Netcurtainnelly · 03/11/2026 15:42

I admire parents who hime educate.
As long as you mix with other people at times why not.
At least no bullying.
How many people are lumped together at school with people they've got nothing in common with apart from they were born in the same school year.

Children are lumped together with other children they have nothing in common with at home ed groups too. No 12 year old wants to willingly hang out with a 6 year old, no matter how much their parents pat themselves on the back for “having friends of all ages, not just ones born in the same year.”

Bullying happens wherever there are children together. Home educated children can be nasty too, and often, their parents are completely ineffective at dealing with them at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread