Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that it’s not at all surprising that home education is on the rise?

134 replies

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 13:48

Having read the recent thread on secondary schools locking the loos in lesson time, I couldn’t help but think that it’s not a surprise that home education is becoming a more and more popular choice for our children. I was genuinely shocked both at the treatment of school children as prisoners by schools, and by the horrendous behaviour that leads to that treatment in the first place. Shitting on the floor, vandalism, vaping, violence and bullying are simply the ones I can remember from the top of my head. My main takeaway was horror at the situation, and a thought that there’s no way in hell I want to send my toddler into an environment like that in ten years time.

It brought to mind this article I read about how home education is in the rise in Blackpool, and that’s a trend which seems to be nationwide.

School budgets are being stretched impossibly tightly and have been for so long that it’s impossible to shield children from the impact of this. There’s not the budget for enough TAs and that means that managing large classes falls to one teacher. We all know that SEN are at a high, as are behaviour issues and school readiness so that one teacher has to manage a classroom which has more challenges than before with less help than before. That means that most children in a classroom won’t be able to get as much independent care and attention, poor behaviour and bullying go unchecked, and children who have more minor SEN or are quietly struggling are missed. It also means that children who have more significant SEN but fall short of a 1:1 (if that’s even provided) also won’t get what they need in the classroom either. Teachers also have a lot of pressures to do things which don’t actually help their classes, maybe from an academy trust, overbearing head teacher, Ofsted, or something else. Just so much busy work that doesn’t add any value to the children, and takes up teachers’ time and makes them burn out. And all this means that there’s a lot of violence and disruption in schools, nobody is getting the attention they deserve and everyone is suffering because of it. Home education means that you know your children are safe, have access to the loo when they need and have individual attention and a curriculum which can be tailored to them. If they grasp a concept quickly, you can move on, if they’re struggling then you can spend more time on it. I want to be clear that this isn’t a thread bashing teachers or TAs, most are doing the best they can, but it’s bashing the system that teachers are working in.

School holiday fines simply seem to make a more adversarial and antagonistic relationship between parents and schools. Parents seem to just share advice how to get around the fines, like taking children out after morning registration, so they don’t trigger the limit. They don’t even work because attendance rates haven’t improved. All it seems to do is create a conflict between the parents and schools/LAs. I also think that parents are ultimately the one’s responsible for their children’s childhood and education unless there are safeguarding concerns and giving a parent a criminal record for taking their children out of school for one week three years in a row is bananas to me and while it seems a small thing, I totally get why parents don’t want to put their children in a system that criminalises them for going on holiday at the wrong time. Especially in a cost of living crisis where many families’ only option for a holiday is in term time due to cost. I know this seems a minor point, and I considered leaving it out, because I don’t think anybody is taking the decision to HE because of holiday fines alone, but it’s just an extra thing which puts barriers up and creates a conflict between parents and schools.

I also think that the rise in home education also makes a difference because it’s more visible and it increases the opportunities available which in turn makes it more desirable. My local area’s home education community is large and active so concerns about friends and socialisation don’t feel relevant in the context of the opportunities that home educated children have. It becoming more popular also normalises it. I feel there’s still a lot of people who see home education as the preserve of the extremely religious, or by flat earthers who failed their own GCSEs, but more people home educating means that people will see that actually most home educators are normal families and see it as a viable and possibly desirable path for their children too. And if children start to struggle in schools, home education seems to be becoming seen as a good alternative rather than trying to fit a square peg in a round hole with school.

On so many of the articles I’ve read about the rise in home education, there’s a comment on how local authorities wish to stop the rise and increase the number of children in schools, but without tackling core issues parents have, and without significant investments I can only see home education rising in popularity. So am I being unreasonable to think that home education’s rise is inevitable in the current climate and that if local authorities and government want to reduce this number significant changes need to happen.

OP posts:
Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 04/11/2026 12:09

TraitorOrFaithful · 03/11/2026 14:44

Your post is very negative OP. My DC attends a state school and is having a good experience- nothing like the environment you describe.

Completely agree. I don’t recognise any of the negative things the OP has written about for my kids school at all.

My kids regular state school has kids that go to Oxbridge and is within 3% achievement of grammars across the border and local private schools.

The issue is very much that not all state schools are created equal.

There are some that are actually really good (outstanding in old money), have great facilities, over a huge amount of extra curricular and trips.

There are some schools which clearly aren’t. Unfortunately that’s the rub but let’s not tar every school with the same brush.

Homeschooling is on the rise but let’s also add to the negative reasons parental entitlement, not wanting kids to follow rules (including attendance) and thinking they know better.

ManchesterMiracle · 04/11/2026 13:41

Fivebyfive2 · 03/11/2026 16:16

I'm getting my tin foil hat on here, but here goes -

There is a massive uptick on home ed//home school/un schooling advertising/content on SM and in the news. Horror stories about schools. It is everywhere.

Alongside this, I've noticed a massive uptick of parents of young children having massive anxiety about their little ones going to school - they're looking into not sending them before they're even starting. It's become a very common thing to ask on here, Reddit, online in general, in parent groups etc.

And guess who it almost always is planning/hoping to stay home with the child to facilitate this? The mum, of course!

I know there are issues with schools. Honestly I do. But many are absolutely fine, better even and most kids aren't finishing school traumatised or with life long bladder issues or with parents banged up for going in holiday.

I don't know, I'm just a bit suspicious of this fairly recent but significant push to get more women to stay home and less children to attend school. It feels very isolating to me. Especially when it's done out of fear, that has been planted before the children are even school age...

For the record, my lad is only in year 2 so I know it's very early days. He's autistic and is thriving at his mainstream school - happy, confident, bright, lovely friends, secure in the routine provided. And yet I was (and still am) BOMBARDED with algorithms telling me he would be destroyed by school.

Every time I hear about a child being home educated, I see a woman being taken out of the workforce and the gender pay gap continues. Yes, sometimes it’s the dads but not v often.

I also find it interesting how many home educators start threads about how bad schools are. If they are truly happy with their decision to home ed, why start thread after thread about schools?

Anyway, I have no skin in this game. My kids are working now or at university. They have such nostalgia for their school days, they really had a ball and they were the clichéd best years of their lives to date!

ManchesterMiracle · 04/11/2026 13:48

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 15:26

If my child struggles with home education then we’ll find the root of what they are struggling with and try to solve that. Maybe that will be to change up what we’re doing at home or to try school. I’m not sure because I can’t troubleshoot problems which haven’t happened yet.

There’s online curricula, tutors, so many parents with different backgrounds in home ed groups (an ex science teacher friend of my parents now tutors small group home educated children science GCSEs). Most home educated children come across and interact with lots of children from all different backgrounds and of different ages too. A local home ed group is likely to be as diverse as the local school.

How will you afford to home-school? Will you be working?

JuliaAgrippina · 04/11/2026 14:14

I am 47. We weren’t allowed to go to the toilet during lessons when I was at secondary school. You went at break or lunch. I don’t se why parents are suddenly up in arms about it. I tell my children to wait until a break time.

As long as there some emergency provision set up I also do see the issues during lessons with toilets beng locked.

But at DC school they were frequently late unlocking and didn't unlock all of them - so 15 minutes of a first break when kids were often trying to eat as luchtime eating was hard -- same at lunch revsion classes and sport/clubs happen in the 30 minutes you do not have time to lose the 10 minute queung before someone with a key comes to unlock small number so large queues. Any complaints and it was that doesn't happen - so I found DD2 didn't even try and use toilets in school hours and DN different school was same but with a longer journey home- and other teens with period issues skipped school those days.

Less an issue with policy more how implemented and yes it was due to poor behavior prior. I do not see any easy answers.

However I'm not sure it's a driving force for HE or strict uniform olcies they also had - as I did back in 90s - though my DC and DN did school college for post 16 education where that wasn't an issue at all.

TheUndomesticGoddess87 · 04/11/2026 14:34

I'm sure there are many parents with a child who attended school who became a difficult teenager with no qualification and a lack of education. Plenty of young people fall through the net at school. I doubt being a difficult teenager is unique to home education.

Edit: meant to quote @MyBestThing

sunshine244 · 04/11/2026 14:49

I was forced to home educate for a while due to my child not coping with school. It was entirly an unsuitable environment for my specific child and forced inclusion and closing SEN schools has been disastrous. However, I had no complaints about the school itself.

I tried very hard to keep education going. Most other parents I met home educating were either in a similar situation due to SEN or it was a choice and they were on principle against schools. The latter tended to do almost no education, often dragged their children around while working, and just did a few normal kids clubs.

I do also think there are some rose tinted glasses about how schools were in the past. We had a violent child in our primary class who threw chairs across the class abd punched teachers and pupils. In high school our toilets were locked during class time. During breaks they were impossible to use due to older kids smoking and blocking entrance etc. On the school bus someone lit my hair on fire, there was drinking and smoking. I'm 44 so quite some time ago.

teaandaflorentineplease · 04/11/2026 21:01

CousinBette · 03/11/2026 21:58

Using Blackpool as an example of a place where ‘home education’ is on the rise just shows that you know absolutely nothing about the social problems Blackpool faces and the reasons why so many children have been deregistered from school. If you think the vast majority of those home ed kids in Blackpool are receiving an adequate alternative education then you are sorely mistaken.

I didn’t say that I think the children in Blackpool are receiving an adequate education or that I think home ed is a desirable outcome for every family. I simply don’t know. I believe that home education can excellent, but that doesn’t mean it always or even often is. Home ed is very hard to study because it’s such a diverse group of people from those who’s children have several GSCEs very young to those who radically unschool and aren’t concerned if that means their children aren’t picking up basic literacy.

Just that given the state of many schools, it’s not surprising that many parents are choosing alternatives and that if the government and local authorities want children to return to schools and reverse the trend then changes need to be made to make schools safe, and provide adequate education. Schools aren’t perfect educators either and Blackpool has a significant problem with school educated children not passing their GCSEs. It’s sadly not the case that children aren’t picking going from being adequately educated and on course to pass school exams in school, but are withdrawn and suffer educationally at home. Children in Blackpool are being failed in their education anyway.

OP posts:
AlertCat · 04/11/2026 21:35

I think a lot of the rise in HE is the ongoing trend towards individualism. People don’t like being told what to do, or their kids being told what to do, and they want to be exceptions to the rules.

I’m a qualified teacher, I’ve worked across the age range and in specialist provisions, and as a tutor with some HE families. My area has a lot of people who HE. They all have a few things in common:

  • the mum stays home and has given up her professional career
  • they live in good sized homes, with gardens
  • dad has a job that can support a family of multiple children, in a high-cost area of the country, on just his earnings
  • they need to employ tutors
  • they need at least two cars
  • They often struggle when it gets to GCSE time because they discover that to sit public exams you have to pay to enter and pay an exam centre, if you can find one willing to host your child
  • their kids often ask to go to school when they get to 12, 13
  • at HE groups because it’s often all very nice and runs on goodwill, you often have flaky people who are late or whose kids disrupt the activity for the rest. These parents don’t appreciate being asked to conform to the rules of the group.
  • the kids don’t always end up with qualifications. I know one who’s relying on parents’ contacts to move forward, and another who’s having to study with the OU because of a lack of any formal qualifications.

I do wonder how more people will think about doing this. Very few can afford to give up an income.

New changes in safeguarding also mean that you cannot now unilaterally withdraw your child. The LA has to approve it, and they won’t if there are any concerns (such as child in need, social services involvement, vulnerable child, etc). At least there is a tiny bit more protection now for children whose families may not choose HE for their benefit.

OneGiant · 04/11/2026 21:46

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 15:26

If my child struggles with home education then we’ll find the root of what they are struggling with and try to solve that. Maybe that will be to change up what we’re doing at home or to try school. I’m not sure because I can’t troubleshoot problems which haven’t happened yet.

There’s online curricula, tutors, so many parents with different backgrounds in home ed groups (an ex science teacher friend of my parents now tutors small group home educated children science GCSEs). Most home educated children come across and interact with lots of children from all different backgrounds and of different ages too. A local home ed group is likely to be as diverse as the local school.

The thing I don’t get is you can’t work for the whole of your child’s school years- that’s 14 years, more if you have multiple children. There are very few part time flexible roles anyway, and you couldn’t both work and home educate primary age children without doing both really badly.

Being as home ed groups and tutors are paid for, it’s not affordable to do this to a level of quality unless you are quite well off.

If you work and expect kids to get on with it, it’s more like benign neglect (in some cases not so benign).

Also if your child is a toddler you don’t know how absolutely hellish it can be to teach your own child. I think many of us learned in lockdown that it’s extremely difficult for most, even qualified teachers.

NaiceGoose · 05/11/2026 11:35

OneGiant · 04/11/2026 21:46

The thing I don’t get is you can’t work for the whole of your child’s school years- that’s 14 years, more if you have multiple children. There are very few part time flexible roles anyway, and you couldn’t both work and home educate primary age children without doing both really badly.

Being as home ed groups and tutors are paid for, it’s not affordable to do this to a level of quality unless you are quite well off.

If you work and expect kids to get on with it, it’s more like benign neglect (in some cases not so benign).

Also if your child is a toddler you don’t know how absolutely hellish it can be to teach your own child. I think many of us learned in lockdown that it’s extremely difficult for most, even qualified teachers.

It is possible to work and Home Ed effectively. I do, although I only work part time and term time only. My child attended school for Primary though and only started Home Ed at the end of Year 6. There are affordable options, just not that many- if a parent is on a low wage they can claim help with childcare whilst they work via Universal Credit and use that to pay for things like a childminder or Forest school type drop off places

Cosyblankets · 05/11/2026 11:42

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 15:26

If my child struggles with home education then we’ll find the root of what they are struggling with and try to solve that. Maybe that will be to change up what we’re doing at home or to try school. I’m not sure because I can’t troubleshoot problems which haven’t happened yet.

There’s online curricula, tutors, so many parents with different backgrounds in home ed groups (an ex science teacher friend of my parents now tutors small group home educated children science GCSEs). Most home educated children come across and interact with lots of children from all different backgrounds and of different ages too. A local home ed group is likely to be as diverse as the local school.

And there are some who are "home educated" who do very little and no one checks on them. I have no problem with home education but there needs to be some kind of regulation and checks done.

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 11:49

Cosyblankets · 05/11/2026 11:42

And there are some who are "home educated" who do very little and no one checks on them. I have no problem with home education but there needs to be some kind of regulation and checks done.

There’s also many children in schools who learn very little and end up with no qualifications from school. Often as a direct result of violence, bullying and disruption in classrooms, which I feel is significant reason behind the current uplift in home educators. Without fixing the issues behind why parents don’t want to send their children to school, or why some children’s school experiences are so poor they develop anxiety and trauma from their school experiences then elective home education will keep rising regardless of how much local authorities say they want these children to return to school.

OP posts:
Mytrousersitch · 05/11/2026 11:51

Cosyblankets · 05/11/2026 11:42

And there are some who are "home educated" who do very little and no one checks on them. I have no problem with home education but there needs to be some kind of regulation and checks done.

Absolutely, but most home educators I met were dead against it.

I used to have someone from the local authority come round once a year. He’d have a cup of tea, ds would very excitedly show him what ever projects he’d been working on. He would tick his boxes and leave until the next year.

I made the mistake of telling some of the other home educators that we did that and I soon learned to keep my mouth shut. We were told we weren’t welcome at that particular group anymore because of it. We were new to home educators circles and Christ, I soon realised that not wanting a ten minute chat once a year was a way of life and such a battle that took over their lives.

I also realised that a lot of the home educators I knew were failing thier childrens education massively and that was why they didn’t want “intrusion” from the LA. I’m talking 8 year olds who couldn’t read a word, not due to any difficulties, but who’s parents wore it like a badge of honor that they unschooled and wouldn’t force their kids to do anything they didn’t want to, including read.

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 11:55

ManchesterMiracle · 04/11/2026 13:48

How will you afford to home-school? Will you be working?

We’ll be able to afford it with both DH and I working part time, and using a Forest School for childcare on days we’re both working. We’re fortunate that in order to secure funded nursery hours for our child that our pensions are in a good place, and we accept that there will almost certainly be a lifestyle hit in order to home educate as our child is currently in childcare three days per week and we’ll obviously need to reduce working days further. I’m also lucky in that my job is flexible and I can cover extra hours in the evenings.

Interestingly on the topic of affordability, one of the more common type of family I see home educating from the start are those for whom childcare costs made working feel prohibitive for the mother, and they adjusted to living on one salary in the preschool years and so home education doesn’t come with any extra costs for those families.

OP posts:
Apotofrealcoffee · 05/11/2026 11:57

I think you’ve painted it through too narrow a spectrum - chaotic violent austere schools, versus the angelic kids who feel forced to leave as they can’t cope.

I know a lot of families who have deregistered and the above isn’t really a snapshot of any of them.

Take my niece for example, out of school and ‘home educated’ for a year now. She’s autistic and has always been autistic, but mildly. She was a very shy and quiet young girl who clearly needed some help but her parents were totally disengaged from her needs and more interested in drinking, partying and using screen babysitters to keep their kids quiet and manageable.

So shit hits the fan when she turns about 9 and starts school refusing. Not because the school isn’t a nice place (it is and they offered a LOT of flexibility to help her), but because her parents have failed to parent and now her anxiety and ‘PDA’ is massive.

Her home education is woeful - a few worksheets here and there. A lot of TV and tablet time. The odd ‘nature walk’.

Sadly this is far from uncommon. I see a LOT of parents who simply want to put 2 fingers up at the system because the school won’t actually do all their parenting for him, deregister their kid and pretend the odd nature walk and worksheet is an actual education.

I predict a tidal wave of anxious, uneducated young people in 10/20 years who have spent their lives in onesies on tablets at home and can’t engage with the world. It’s going to be very expensive. The parents will say, thank God we home educated, as they are anxious people.

Cosyblankets · 05/11/2026 12:01

Mytrousersitch · 05/11/2026 11:51

Absolutely, but most home educators I met were dead against it.

I used to have someone from the local authority come round once a year. He’d have a cup of tea, ds would very excitedly show him what ever projects he’d been working on. He would tick his boxes and leave until the next year.

I made the mistake of telling some of the other home educators that we did that and I soon learned to keep my mouth shut. We were told we weren’t welcome at that particular group anymore because of it. We were new to home educators circles and Christ, I soon realised that not wanting a ten minute chat once a year was a way of life and such a battle that took over their lives.

I also realised that a lot of the home educators I knew were failing thier childrens education massively and that was why they didn’t want “intrusion” from the LA. I’m talking 8 year olds who couldn’t read a word, not due to any difficulties, but who’s parents wore it like a badge of honor that they unschooled and wouldn’t force their kids to do anything they didn’t want to, including read.

Edited

Once a year.

That's precisely my point.

What's the point of checking once a year?

Apotofrealcoffee · 05/11/2026 12:04

or they just never worked to start with (common)

Mischance · 05/11/2026 12:05

Home schooling done well is brilliant. In-school schooling done well is also brilliant.
Home schooling done badly is a bad thing. In-school schooling done badly is also a bad thing.
It all depends what is on offer where you happen to live, what you are able to offer at home and what your child's needs are.

I'm all for home schooling done well and would like to see the school curriculum rethought to better meet the needs of children.
Schools are in general too big which presents challenges of discipline and teacher burn out.

Burningbud1981 · 05/11/2026 12:16

@teaandaflorentineplease

think you’re being a little too general in your view of schools, particularly around violence, bullying and disruption in classrooms. I do appreciate that mainstream school is not a one-size-fits-all solution, and there will always be some children for whom it simply doesn’t work.
That said, I also think there are some parents who don’t like their children being told what to do or being given firm boundaries.
My son’s school is a good example. It’s a relatively new academy and initially had a reputation for being very disciplined. Unfortunately, a number of parents disagreed with that approach and complained, which led the school to relax some of its disciplinary standards. Behaviour deteriorated, learning was disrupted, and things became quite difficult.
A new leadership team eventually came in and took a much firmer approach. They made it clear to parents that the school was going back to basics and that those who strongly disagreed with the approach could choose another school. Since then, the school has improved massively and is now in the top 10 in the borough and above the national average for GCSE results.
It does show that clear boundaries and consistent discipline can make a real difference, doesn’t it?

ElectricThrowAddict · 05/11/2026 12:16

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 11:55

We’ll be able to afford it with both DH and I working part time, and using a Forest School for childcare on days we’re both working. We’re fortunate that in order to secure funded nursery hours for our child that our pensions are in a good place, and we accept that there will almost certainly be a lifestyle hit in order to home educate as our child is currently in childcare three days per week and we’ll obviously need to reduce working days further. I’m also lucky in that my job is flexible and I can cover extra hours in the evenings.

Interestingly on the topic of affordability, one of the more common type of family I see home educating from the start are those for whom childcare costs made working feel prohibitive for the mother, and they adjusted to living on one salary in the preschool years and so home education doesn’t come with any extra costs for those families.

Kindly, you are coming across as naive.

Your dc is a toddler currently and you have childcare 3 days a week.

Children become considerably more expensive as they grow. The activities and interests you want to support as HE do come with a cost - workshops, tutors, galleries, music lessons, museums, entrance fees, transport costs.

Forest school is nice for a few hours on a nice day but no child wants to go to forest school as their sole childcare for years on end and many kids don't like being cold/wet/muddy all the time. The forest schools near me offer v short hours and would not offer me the chance to out in decent hours at work.

The HE families I know either have one child and a parent on a very healthy income while the other is a SAHM (hasn't worked ever since having a child - not sure what this role models to the child/teen about education, qualifications and work ethic) or they have parents doing loads of part time/wfh/freelance jobs to keep afloat and they seem to have a lot of screen time and v stressed parents plus some genteel poverty issues.

You're making some pretty fixed statements about awful schools on the basis of no hormonal experience!

My teens have loved school, had a great time with loads of broader experiences, made good friends and got amazing grades enabling them to move on in life. I have worked throughout and we have a comfortable.life with nice outings, memberships, extra curriculars and holidays. What's to avoid?!

Mytrousersitch · 05/11/2026 12:23

Cosyblankets · 05/11/2026 12:01

Once a year.

That's precisely my point.

What's the point of checking once a year?

That’s pretty standard everywhere there are checks.

Could you imagine if it was compulsory for all home educators families and conducted once a term? It would never work. The volume of staff needed for that would make it unworkable.

Mytrousersitch · 05/11/2026 12:40

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 11:55

We’ll be able to afford it with both DH and I working part time, and using a Forest School for childcare on days we’re both working. We’re fortunate that in order to secure funded nursery hours for our child that our pensions are in a good place, and we accept that there will almost certainly be a lifestyle hit in order to home educate as our child is currently in childcare three days per week and we’ll obviously need to reduce working days further. I’m also lucky in that my job is flexible and I can cover extra hours in the evenings.

Interestingly on the topic of affordability, one of the more common type of family I see home educating from the start are those for whom childcare costs made working feel prohibitive for the mother, and they adjusted to living on one salary in the preschool years and so home education doesn’t come with any extra costs for those families.

Home educating my son until he was 11 took up ALL my time. I wouldn’t have been able to work and do it effectively.

I was very structured. We did 2 hours of work a day, maybe a bit longer as he got older. Yes, I know that people with children in school would be horrified at “only” 2 hours, but one on one learning is a hell of a lot different to a class full of children.

I can’t remember now but I think his maths tutor came twice a week for an hour.

Then it was all the social stuff that I was very hot on. Probably 3 mornings or afternoons a week there was some sort of soul destroying home ed group to attend.

We did try the forest school which everyone else who home educated their children used one day a week, but it wasn’t ds thing. He hated walking aimlessly around in the cold playing with twigs (“freezing my arse off, bored shitless, while the other bored kids chucked twigs at each other” is how he recounts it now as an adult 🤣), there is no saying your child will enjoy it. I have very strong views on it anyway (it attracts a certain sort of parent who just wants the wholesome aspect, but after volunteering lots at some over the years, it’s does tend to be just a load of bored, cold kids).

Thankfully, he loved music and drama and there was a drama school/dance type place that did after school clubs in lots of things, so the majority of his friends were school children who went there, he did a class there 5 days a week. He found a lot of the other home educated children hard work to be honest, so I was glad he had those other children.

Then there was all MY time, all the planning projects, activities and work. Do not underestimate how much time that will take you. We did use education city, when it was available to home educators, but even then, that didn’t cover everything.

All my life was taken up working with ds, driving him to activities and sitting there waiting while he did them, and planning his work.

It was all really fucking expensive too. All the clubs, travel, learning resources.

I could not have worked myself and home educated effectively.

I think you are being quite naive.

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 13:09

ElectricThrowAddict · 05/11/2026 12:16

Kindly, you are coming across as naive.

Your dc is a toddler currently and you have childcare 3 days a week.

Children become considerably more expensive as they grow. The activities and interests you want to support as HE do come with a cost - workshops, tutors, galleries, music lessons, museums, entrance fees, transport costs.

Forest school is nice for a few hours on a nice day but no child wants to go to forest school as their sole childcare for years on end and many kids don't like being cold/wet/muddy all the time. The forest schools near me offer v short hours and would not offer me the chance to out in decent hours at work.

The HE families I know either have one child and a parent on a very healthy income while the other is a SAHM (hasn't worked ever since having a child - not sure what this role models to the child/teen about education, qualifications and work ethic) or they have parents doing loads of part time/wfh/freelance jobs to keep afloat and they seem to have a lot of screen time and v stressed parents plus some genteel poverty issues.

You're making some pretty fixed statements about awful schools on the basis of no hormonal experience!

My teens have loved school, had a great time with loads of broader experiences, made good friends and got amazing grades enabling them to move on in life. I have worked throughout and we have a comfortable.life with nice outings, memberships, extra curriculars and holidays. What's to avoid?!

You seem to be assuming here that my plan for how HE will work for us at the moment is one I am planning to stick to doggedly for ‘years on end’ even if it’s clearly not working out for my child. At the moment my child loves the forest school. The forest school runs home ed sessions that suit my work and which many children are happy to attend so at the moment that makes sense to be plan A. I’m very aware that children grow up and change in needs and preferences as they grow up. We also wouldn’t need tutoring until they’re older, and museums and home ed groups and hobbies we’d attend plus childcare would not be more expensive than the current groups we attend plus nursery costs. I’m aware that children get more expensive and we can accommodate that.

Even though I’ve never been a SAHM and don’t plan to be, the comments about modelling a poor work ethic seem unfair. Surely what it teaches children is that it’s down to every family how they divide their household responsibilities and that contributing to the family doesn’t solely mean financially and that domestic work can still be appreciated by the family.

I’m glad your teens have had great school experiences. I don’t think that a school experience is necessarily negative like I don’t assume that a home ed experience is guaranteed to be positive. Both at their best can offer a good experience. I just think that there are a significant number of schools who are not able to offer that experience to some or all of their students because of the pressures I’ve already mentioned, and I feel that we can provide a good home education as an alternative to school.

OP posts:
Mytrousersitch · 05/11/2026 13:17

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 13:09

You seem to be assuming here that my plan for how HE will work for us at the moment is one I am planning to stick to doggedly for ‘years on end’ even if it’s clearly not working out for my child. At the moment my child loves the forest school. The forest school runs home ed sessions that suit my work and which many children are happy to attend so at the moment that makes sense to be plan A. I’m very aware that children grow up and change in needs and preferences as they grow up. We also wouldn’t need tutoring until they’re older, and museums and home ed groups and hobbies we’d attend plus childcare would not be more expensive than the current groups we attend plus nursery costs. I’m aware that children get more expensive and we can accommodate that.

Even though I’ve never been a SAHM and don’t plan to be, the comments about modelling a poor work ethic seem unfair. Surely what it teaches children is that it’s down to every family how they divide their household responsibilities and that contributing to the family doesn’t solely mean financially and that domestic work can still be appreciated by the family.

I’m glad your teens have had great school experiences. I don’t think that a school experience is necessarily negative like I don’t assume that a home ed experience is guaranteed to be positive. Both at their best can offer a good experience. I just think that there are a significant number of schools who are not able to offer that experience to some or all of their students because of the pressures I’ve already mentioned, and I feel that we can provide a good home education as an alternative to school.

Just be prepared for the fact that YOU might not like home educating.

It might sound great to you now, and who knows, you might love it, but the reality of it, day in day out can be vastly different.

I met some home educators who clearly hated it, but they had become so entrenched in the whole “school is terrible” mentality that it was like they had no way out.

I didn’t love home educating. I only did it as we had the opportunity for loads of amazing travel with my husbands work that wouldn’t have been possible with ds in school, so I had that respite from the home ed community (like any community, wherever you are, it’s never all sunshine and roses). I would never, ever chose to home educate again, my younger two children are in school.

It’s just something I’ve noticed over the years you get into this schools are all awful way of thinking and then get trapped. Just keep an open mind while you are doing it. Home education isn’t easy.

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 13:23

Mytrousersitch · 05/11/2026 12:40

Home educating my son until he was 11 took up ALL my time. I wouldn’t have been able to work and do it effectively.

I was very structured. We did 2 hours of work a day, maybe a bit longer as he got older. Yes, I know that people with children in school would be horrified at “only” 2 hours, but one on one learning is a hell of a lot different to a class full of children.

I can’t remember now but I think his maths tutor came twice a week for an hour.

Then it was all the social stuff that I was very hot on. Probably 3 mornings or afternoons a week there was some sort of soul destroying home ed group to attend.

We did try the forest school which everyone else who home educated their children used one day a week, but it wasn’t ds thing. He hated walking aimlessly around in the cold playing with twigs (“freezing my arse off, bored shitless, while the other bored kids chucked twigs at each other” is how he recounts it now as an adult 🤣), there is no saying your child will enjoy it. I have very strong views on it anyway (it attracts a certain sort of parent who just wants the wholesome aspect, but after volunteering lots at some over the years, it’s does tend to be just a load of bored, cold kids).

Thankfully, he loved music and drama and there was a drama school/dance type place that did after school clubs in lots of things, so the majority of his friends were school children who went there, he did a class there 5 days a week. He found a lot of the other home educated children hard work to be honest, so I was glad he had those other children.

Then there was all MY time, all the planning projects, activities and work. Do not underestimate how much time that will take you. We did use education city, when it was available to home educators, but even then, that didn’t cover everything.

All my life was taken up working with ds, driving him to activities and sitting there waiting while he did them, and planning his work.

It was all really fucking expensive too. All the clubs, travel, learning resources.

I could not have worked myself and home educated effectively.

I think you are being quite naive.

Edited

Maybe I’m being naive though I do see a couple of HE families like mine being successful. I know a family with an 11yo, a 9yo and a 6yo where both parents work part time. Their older kids don’t need childcare while their parents WFH, and the youngest goes to forest school in that time. I said to another commenter that the reason forest school is what I mentioned is my child loves it now and has friends there. If they change their mind, then we’ll change our approach to childcare too. I don’t have a fixed mindset with anything I’ve said. I’ve just looked at our current situation and planned based on what works now. And as things change, plans will change too.

We aren’t currently planning to have structured learning very young. Part of wanting to home educate is to stay play based for longer and wait to start formal lessons.

I don’t doubt it will be hard, but I see people in my community who are doing what I plan to do successfully. I’m not just making plans as I go.

OP posts: