Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that it’s not at all surprising that home education is on the rise?

134 replies

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 13:48

Having read the recent thread on secondary schools locking the loos in lesson time, I couldn’t help but think that it’s not a surprise that home education is becoming a more and more popular choice for our children. I was genuinely shocked both at the treatment of school children as prisoners by schools, and by the horrendous behaviour that leads to that treatment in the first place. Shitting on the floor, vandalism, vaping, violence and bullying are simply the ones I can remember from the top of my head. My main takeaway was horror at the situation, and a thought that there’s no way in hell I want to send my toddler into an environment like that in ten years time.

It brought to mind this article I read about how home education is in the rise in Blackpool, and that’s a trend which seems to be nationwide.

School budgets are being stretched impossibly tightly and have been for so long that it’s impossible to shield children from the impact of this. There’s not the budget for enough TAs and that means that managing large classes falls to one teacher. We all know that SEN are at a high, as are behaviour issues and school readiness so that one teacher has to manage a classroom which has more challenges than before with less help than before. That means that most children in a classroom won’t be able to get as much independent care and attention, poor behaviour and bullying go unchecked, and children who have more minor SEN or are quietly struggling are missed. It also means that children who have more significant SEN but fall short of a 1:1 (if that’s even provided) also won’t get what they need in the classroom either. Teachers also have a lot of pressures to do things which don’t actually help their classes, maybe from an academy trust, overbearing head teacher, Ofsted, or something else. Just so much busy work that doesn’t add any value to the children, and takes up teachers’ time and makes them burn out. And all this means that there’s a lot of violence and disruption in schools, nobody is getting the attention they deserve and everyone is suffering because of it. Home education means that you know your children are safe, have access to the loo when they need and have individual attention and a curriculum which can be tailored to them. If they grasp a concept quickly, you can move on, if they’re struggling then you can spend more time on it. I want to be clear that this isn’t a thread bashing teachers or TAs, most are doing the best they can, but it’s bashing the system that teachers are working in.

School holiday fines simply seem to make a more adversarial and antagonistic relationship between parents and schools. Parents seem to just share advice how to get around the fines, like taking children out after morning registration, so they don’t trigger the limit. They don’t even work because attendance rates haven’t improved. All it seems to do is create a conflict between the parents and schools/LAs. I also think that parents are ultimately the one’s responsible for their children’s childhood and education unless there are safeguarding concerns and giving a parent a criminal record for taking their children out of school for one week three years in a row is bananas to me and while it seems a small thing, I totally get why parents don’t want to put their children in a system that criminalises them for going on holiday at the wrong time. Especially in a cost of living crisis where many families’ only option for a holiday is in term time due to cost. I know this seems a minor point, and I considered leaving it out, because I don’t think anybody is taking the decision to HE because of holiday fines alone, but it’s just an extra thing which puts barriers up and creates a conflict between parents and schools.

I also think that the rise in home education also makes a difference because it’s more visible and it increases the opportunities available which in turn makes it more desirable. My local area’s home education community is large and active so concerns about friends and socialisation don’t feel relevant in the context of the opportunities that home educated children have. It becoming more popular also normalises it. I feel there’s still a lot of people who see home education as the preserve of the extremely religious, or by flat earthers who failed their own GCSEs, but more people home educating means that people will see that actually most home educators are normal families and see it as a viable and possibly desirable path for their children too. And if children start to struggle in schools, home education seems to be becoming seen as a good alternative rather than trying to fit a square peg in a round hole with school.

On so many of the articles I’ve read about the rise in home education, there’s a comment on how local authorities wish to stop the rise and increase the number of children in schools, but without tackling core issues parents have, and without significant investments I can only see home education rising in popularity. So am I being unreasonable to think that home education’s rise is inevitable in the current climate and that if local authorities and government want to reduce this number significant changes need to happen.

OP posts:
Runlikesomeoneleftgateopen · 06/11/2026 14:43

I have two sons.
Eldest sailed through school, but my youngest was diagnosed with a panic and anxiety disorder age 13, we went through an absolutely horiffic time of trying to force him in, which backfired badly, so resorted to home education.
Both sons have gone on to do well thankfully.
But l do know a few families where they have a mix of children either attending school or home educated because of similar situations.
Most parents do want their children in school, it makes life alot easier, especially if you are a lone parent like myself.
I tend to think along the lines if you planted a sun loving plant in deep shade, it wouldn't thrive, therefore you would move the plant, instead of expecting it to just adapt.
I fully understand it's not easy for many parents to home educate.
My son is very intelligent and taught himself, l carried on going to work same as normal.
l'm just so thankful it worked out as it was a very testing time.
He's 21 now, attending a local Uni and working part time remote.
He has recently asked for a referral re an ADHD diagnosis.

teaandaflorentineplease · 06/11/2026 14:49

FedUpCelery · 06/11/2026 09:01

Op, I'm not sure what the purpose was of your post. Maybe your child would thrive in school, maybe they would hate it, same for home education. Everyone's experience is different and it depends on the schools, your area and so on.

Home education can be great. If that's what you want to do, go for it. Keep paying attention to your child. It's not an irreversible decision. If they want to try school or if HE is not working for you or for your child it's always an option. (up to just before year 10, usually).

I do believe some home educators are naive if they don't get some sort of qualification for their child. Tweens and teens are fickle and they don't know what they don't know. One minute they can be thriving in home ed and have a plan that doesn't involve sixth form, the next, they've made a massive developmental change and they can want to be at sixth along with their friends. It's up to us to keep an eye on that future and make sure doors are kept open for them.
We weren't an entrepreneurial family so we've relied even more heavily on qualifications. I know school kids who tried college, hated it and found a place in the family business, or in gaining professional qualifications in outdoor activities, or other alternative routes. At least they got to try and cross it off the list as not for them right now - and there's always later.
Proactive home educators trend to be good at keeping their eye out for these opportunities too.

An ex home educator who is going on 3 or 4 year old knowledge of navigating college places may well be out of date. They are strict and there are always exceptions to this of course, but on the whole they have an entry system that works for them and they don't tend to individualise and they will have the full range of ideas about home education and experiences of home educated children that you have read on this thread. If you tick the boxes, it's a breeze so imo it's a good idea to tick those boxes of your child is able.

You're years away though. There are as many different ways of home educating as there are families. Keep reading and keep thinking and keep paying attention to your child. There are so many books out there on approaches and different approaches are good at different ages. Best of luck and enjoy!

My purpose was to question the fact that the government and local authorities state they want to reduce the number of home educated pupils but without the resource or willing to change the parts of the system that led to families HEing in the first place. And that given there doesn’t seem to be any plans to change how schools operate, I can’t see anything else other than more families choosing home education, which in turn normalises home education. It wasn’t meant to be a thread specifically for my family’s choice to home educate.

OP posts:
Timeforachange26 · 06/11/2026 14:50

What's wrong with him getting up at 11.30 though?

Teaching one on one takes far less time than crowd control in a large class which wastes over 50% of the lesson. So if a child had 5 hourly lessons in a school day then take away the messing about and could learn same stuff in just over 2 hours

Mytrousersitch · 06/11/2026 14:54

Cosyblankets · 06/11/2026 14:40

Because I teach a language and one of the topics is daily routine. When he said he had just got up at 1130 I had no reason to disbelieve him. When he asked me if I knew a maths tutor because he hadn't had any teaching since coming out of school I had no reason to disbelieve him.

When I said I didn't know what he did for English it was because it came up when we were doing the topic of school subjects and he said he didn't really do much English I had no reason to disbelieve him.
What more do you want me to say? This is a child who has been out of the system for at least a year. He told me I was his only teacher. He told me he had no teacher for maths and he followed a website sometimes. . He told me he didn't really do anything for English. I'm not imagining it.

Yes this is just one child. But how many others are there like this? As I say some will do it quite well. But there will be plenty who slip through the net.

One of the upsides to home Ed for me, even as someone who was very structured with plans and tutors was the fact that my child didn’t have to be up and sat at a desk at 9am. If we had a late night out somewhere or arrived home from travelling late, it didn’t matter what time we slept in to.

Cosyblankets · 06/11/2026 14:55

Timeforachange26 · 06/11/2026 14:50

What's wrong with him getting up at 11.30 though?

Teaching one on one takes far less time than crowd control in a large class which wastes over 50% of the lesson. So if a child had 5 hourly lessons in a school day then take away the messing about and could learn same stuff in just over 2 hours

Fully aware of that. I taught in a secondary school for almost 20 years.

Completely get that you don't need to do full lessons.
My point is that you need to do something this child was regularly doing nothing.
How is that preparation for life?

Cosyblankets · 06/11/2026 14:56

Mytrousersitch · 06/11/2026 14:54

One of the upsides to home Ed for me, even as someone who was very structured with plans and tutors was the fact that my child didn’t have to be up and sat at a desk at 9am. If we had a late night out somewhere or arrived home from travelling late, it didn’t matter what time we slept in to.

And again I get that for now and then.
This was all the time

Timeforachange26 · 06/11/2026 14:57

According to my DGS he does " nothing" at school every day

If the 11.30am get up isn't and issue why mention it

teaandaflorentineplease · 06/11/2026 14:57

TiredShadows · 06/11/2026 14:24

With the issues with cost of living, reducing exam centres that will take private applicants along with the rising costs, the massive issues that happened with home educated kids during the lockdowns that caused some kids to start going to schools at about the time it was starting to be reported about the increase, so I do find it a bit surprising.

With the way many describe it - with many groups and tutors, I can only imagine the increase is mainly by those who had far more money available than most of the home educators I know. Many home educated kids are not doing any of that. I know plenty of home educating families who stopped doing home ed groups because they found the bullying and violence in them just as bad if not worse than what's going on in schools.

I feel there’s still a lot of people who see home education as the preserve of the extremely religious, or by flat earthers

I home educated my children for many years, and I've never had any Brit assume I'm extremely religious or a flat earther. That is an American stereotype because a large proportion of American home schoolers do it for religious or political reasons.

IME, the British view of home education is generally more around being weird/eccentric, more hippie than anything else. I see why that is - as a previously poster said, those who choose it from the start tend to do it because of their reasons against schools, lean more individualistic and anti-authority and those who are all of those tend to be the most vocal if not really representative of most of us. Most British home educators are those who've withdrawn their children from school after a period of issues or not having a suitable place for their child due to SEN issues, and IME having been both a home educator and a school governor, there has been an increase since COVID lockdowns of parents withdrawing kids faster if the parents fit the above profile.

The UK has very, very lax home education laws. The new changes may change things, we'll have to wait and see what they do in action -- I think it's likely it'll be very little different to now where it varies widely by LA. Some LAs do a lot, some put very little into it, they tick a box and move on. Even having done regular reports and home visits for a few years (I think community visits would be better for many families and harder to fake), we were ignored for most of the time my kids were home educated.

Most parents care and try, but the older the child gets, the harder meeting all the education, social, and other needs is and there is very little support if you don't have the budget for it. There have always been parents who have withdrawn their kids and do very little at home with them. I know people where that happened back in the 80s and 90s. There have always been kids who struggle at home - just as there in school - and very little is done. There is very much a postcode lottery and a lot of gaps in support for children struggling no matte how a child is educated, but they can be different in what they can access based on how they are educated.

I home educated my children for many years, and I've never had any Brit assume I'm extremely religious or a flat earther. That is an American stereotype because a large proportion of American home schoolers do it for religious or political reasons.
IME, the British view of home education is generally more around being weird/eccentric, more hippie than anything else. I see why that is - as a previously poster said, those who choose it from the start tend to do it because of their reasons against schools, lean more individualistic and anti-authority and those who are all of those tend to be the most vocal if not really representative of most of us.
educated.

It’s an attitude I’ve seen, especially amongst people my age who have babies and young children. Personally I think their views are informed by American stereotypical views of home education, but people seem to be inheriting those stereotypes over here as well. I basically avoid any discussion on home education on any of the UK subreddits I’m on because you’re assumed to be an anti vax, flat earther (despite the fact that no vaccinations are required for UK schools so that’s not even a reason not to send your child to school. I think social media has blurred a lot of cultural lines and the US end up being the dominant culture, especially for more niche things like home education.

OP posts:
NaiceGoose · 06/11/2026 18:11

Cosyblankets · 06/11/2026 14:56

And again I get that for now and then.
This was all the time

A teenager's natural circadian rhythm is different to an adult's or a young child's. So falling asleep later and waking up later is perfectly normal and healthy. If you can't get to sleep until late why would you wake up at 7am if you don't have to be at work or school or somewhere else?

A lot of teen home ed groups and online lessons are late morning onwards- I suspect this is why. It makes no difference at all if you learn something at 9am or 4pm...or even at 9pm.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread