Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that it’s not at all surprising that home education is on the rise?

134 replies

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 13:48

Having read the recent thread on secondary schools locking the loos in lesson time, I couldn’t help but think that it’s not a surprise that home education is becoming a more and more popular choice for our children. I was genuinely shocked both at the treatment of school children as prisoners by schools, and by the horrendous behaviour that leads to that treatment in the first place. Shitting on the floor, vandalism, vaping, violence and bullying are simply the ones I can remember from the top of my head. My main takeaway was horror at the situation, and a thought that there’s no way in hell I want to send my toddler into an environment like that in ten years time.

It brought to mind this article I read about how home education is in the rise in Blackpool, and that’s a trend which seems to be nationwide.

School budgets are being stretched impossibly tightly and have been for so long that it’s impossible to shield children from the impact of this. There’s not the budget for enough TAs and that means that managing large classes falls to one teacher. We all know that SEN are at a high, as are behaviour issues and school readiness so that one teacher has to manage a classroom which has more challenges than before with less help than before. That means that most children in a classroom won’t be able to get as much independent care and attention, poor behaviour and bullying go unchecked, and children who have more minor SEN or are quietly struggling are missed. It also means that children who have more significant SEN but fall short of a 1:1 (if that’s even provided) also won’t get what they need in the classroom either. Teachers also have a lot of pressures to do things which don’t actually help their classes, maybe from an academy trust, overbearing head teacher, Ofsted, or something else. Just so much busy work that doesn’t add any value to the children, and takes up teachers’ time and makes them burn out. And all this means that there’s a lot of violence and disruption in schools, nobody is getting the attention they deserve and everyone is suffering because of it. Home education means that you know your children are safe, have access to the loo when they need and have individual attention and a curriculum which can be tailored to them. If they grasp a concept quickly, you can move on, if they’re struggling then you can spend more time on it. I want to be clear that this isn’t a thread bashing teachers or TAs, most are doing the best they can, but it’s bashing the system that teachers are working in.

School holiday fines simply seem to make a more adversarial and antagonistic relationship between parents and schools. Parents seem to just share advice how to get around the fines, like taking children out after morning registration, so they don’t trigger the limit. They don’t even work because attendance rates haven’t improved. All it seems to do is create a conflict between the parents and schools/LAs. I also think that parents are ultimately the one’s responsible for their children’s childhood and education unless there are safeguarding concerns and giving a parent a criminal record for taking their children out of school for one week three years in a row is bananas to me and while it seems a small thing, I totally get why parents don’t want to put their children in a system that criminalises them for going on holiday at the wrong time. Especially in a cost of living crisis where many families’ only option for a holiday is in term time due to cost. I know this seems a minor point, and I considered leaving it out, because I don’t think anybody is taking the decision to HE because of holiday fines alone, but it’s just an extra thing which puts barriers up and creates a conflict between parents and schools.

I also think that the rise in home education also makes a difference because it’s more visible and it increases the opportunities available which in turn makes it more desirable. My local area’s home education community is large and active so concerns about friends and socialisation don’t feel relevant in the context of the opportunities that home educated children have. It becoming more popular also normalises it. I feel there’s still a lot of people who see home education as the preserve of the extremely religious, or by flat earthers who failed their own GCSEs, but more people home educating means that people will see that actually most home educators are normal families and see it as a viable and possibly desirable path for their children too. And if children start to struggle in schools, home education seems to be becoming seen as a good alternative rather than trying to fit a square peg in a round hole with school.

On so many of the articles I’ve read about the rise in home education, there’s a comment on how local authorities wish to stop the rise and increase the number of children in schools, but without tackling core issues parents have, and without significant investments I can only see home education rising in popularity. So am I being unreasonable to think that home education’s rise is inevitable in the current climate and that if local authorities and government want to reduce this number significant changes need to happen.

OP posts:
Minasama · 05/11/2026 13:25

I am not a fan of home ed except as a short term solution to a particular problem.

First try a different school.

I think it’s very notable that the people I have known personally who did home ed (with the shining exception of one who was amazing but sadly passed away young - so now her bereaved children have to go to school for the first time as well which is just awful) have been quite odd.

Either creative and spiritual types who desperately wanted their children at home with them or very depressive and felt school wasn’t stretching their child academically. People who I actually think smothered their kids rather than giving them roots and letting them fly.

There have been some awful posts on here recently by people who couldn’t write well so clearly weren’t very educated who’d withdrawn their kids at 11 or 12 - the kids were now older teens with no GCSE passes and mental health problems. This is not a good outcome for home schooling.

Ultimateky life often involves being somewhere you don’t want to be and spending time with people you don’t want to be with, so school is quite good prep for that.

I think the clearest indication that homeschooling is often problematic comes from the vitriol you get when you suggest that there are some potential problems with it. These people will jump in and accuse you of knowing nothing about it, rather than conceding that there can be some problems as well as good sides.

ElectricThrowAddict · 05/11/2026 13:29

There are a million ways of doing things and we all choose our own path. I have no real investment in what you do but was pointing out how you come across, as many of us have and would do, when only the parent of a toddler and without truly knowing their personality, likes and dislikes and the future plans and needs of the family both logistically and financially.

Being sure schools are bad and kids have a horrible time, prior to visiting them or your child giving it a go, is a negative place to be and is likely to cause you potentially unnecessary stress. But you can of course hold these views and say these things! Just as I can share an alternate view.

This however:

Even though I’ve never been a SAHM and don’t plan to be, the comments about modelling a poor work ethic seem unfair. Surely what it teaches children is that it’s down to every family how they divide their household responsibilities and that contributing to the family doesn’t solely mean financially and that domestic work can still be appreciated by the family.

I disagree with. The HE families I know where they have a SAHM Mum (always the mum) who does everything 24/7 and a high earning dad (always the dad) who has v little responsibility or input into the dc day to day is the absolute opposite of what I think it is helpful for dc to grow up seeing.

I have teen dds and I encourage them to achieve academically and to work hard and strive for good grades. I help them to find their passion and interest and I support them to seek employment in well paid roles that suit them and their aptitude. I am very clear that they see me use my education in my career and they see me contribute economically and they see the partnership and stability their father and I role model by both working and both being active parents and housekeepers.

The HE families I am thinking of where the children/teens have no or occasional external qualifications and the mum has never used hers outside of the home...I am unclear what message that sends really, but it is far from where I want to be.

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 13:34

Mytrousersitch · 05/11/2026 13:17

Just be prepared for the fact that YOU might not like home educating.

It might sound great to you now, and who knows, you might love it, but the reality of it, day in day out can be vastly different.

I met some home educators who clearly hated it, but they had become so entrenched in the whole “school is terrible” mentality that it was like they had no way out.

I didn’t love home educating. I only did it as we had the opportunity for loads of amazing travel with my husbands work that wouldn’t have been possible with ds in school, so I had that respite from the home ed community (like any community, wherever you are, it’s never all sunshine and roses). I would never, ever chose to home educate again, my younger two children are in school.

It’s just something I’ve noticed over the years you get into this schools are all awful way of thinking and then get trapped. Just keep an open mind while you are doing it. Home education isn’t easy.

Maybe I won’t. You’ll notice that I haven’t provided a full curriculum and plan for my child’s KS4 education and that’s because I can’t make plans for something so far in the future. I don’t know what schools will look like in ten years time. I’m not optimistic based on how public services have been going, but maybe I’ll be surprised. Maybe our child will be a good fit for the grammar school, I’m sure our local schools will look totally different, maybe we’ll go down the independent route, maybe we’ll love home education? I don’t know because I’m not there. I believe that an outdoors play based education in the early years is better than formal learning which is why we don’t want to start with reception.

I’m also incredibly concerned by the reports of violence, vandalism, bullying and disruption coming from schools at the moment. I’m concerned by the lack of SEN support which impacts children with and without SEN. I just posted because I was reading the locking the toilets thread and seeing so many posters with so many stories of horrendous behaviour seen as an inevitability hence locking the toilets, I just thought that I cannot imagine sending my child into that environment. Then I thought of all the articles I’ve seen in the news about how local authorities and government want to reduce the rise in home ed, and want these children to return to school and I thought that that seems an impossible ask without changing the factors that are making parents deregister their children in the first place. I wasn’t really intending this to be a thread about my personal decision to HE, but more more about the school system.

OP posts:
NaiceGoose · 05/11/2026 13:43

AlertCat · 04/11/2026 21:35

I think a lot of the rise in HE is the ongoing trend towards individualism. People don’t like being told what to do, or their kids being told what to do, and they want to be exceptions to the rules.

I’m a qualified teacher, I’ve worked across the age range and in specialist provisions, and as a tutor with some HE families. My area has a lot of people who HE. They all have a few things in common:

  • the mum stays home and has given up her professional career
  • they live in good sized homes, with gardens
  • dad has a job that can support a family of multiple children, in a high-cost area of the country, on just his earnings
  • they need to employ tutors
  • they need at least two cars
  • They often struggle when it gets to GCSE time because they discover that to sit public exams you have to pay to enter and pay an exam centre, if you can find one willing to host your child
  • their kids often ask to go to school when they get to 12, 13
  • at HE groups because it’s often all very nice and runs on goodwill, you often have flaky people who are late or whose kids disrupt the activity for the rest. These parents don’t appreciate being asked to conform to the rules of the group.
  • the kids don’t always end up with qualifications. I know one who’s relying on parents’ contacts to move forward, and another who’s having to study with the OU because of a lack of any formal qualifications.

I do wonder how more people will think about doing this. Very few can afford to give up an income.

New changes in safeguarding also mean that you cannot now unilaterally withdraw your child. The LA has to approve it, and they won’t if there are any concerns (such as child in need, social services involvement, vulnerable child, etc). At least there is a tiny bit more protection now for children whose families may not choose HE for their benefit.

The new legislation in the Children's Wellbeing and schools act requiring permission to Home Educate in certain circumstances doesn't actually come into force until next year and I've read most Councils won't be enforcing it until likely around 2028. It will still only be required for very few families though including those on Child Protection Plans or who have been subject to CPP in the last 5 years due to safeguarding concerns (not those who just have a SW or on CIN plans).

I actually completely agree with the safeguarding checks being mandatory and the requirement to seek permission to Home Ed if there are significant safeguarding concerns already, despite it being a rather unpopular opinion in Home Ed circles. Almost all Home Ed families who do not want home visits do so to protect their privacy and legal right to Home Educate in a style they choose for their children, but of course there will always be the few who choose Home Ed as the easy way to hide abuse or neglect.

Perhaps it varies greatly in different locations and also by age group but most of the Home Ed families we know don't meet many of the criteria you have listed. Many have 2 working parents (albeit one usually part time) or are lone parent families with one working parent. Most are very aware of their rights and responsibilities and research and plan for their children to either persue vocational qualifications or work towards taking GCSE or FS qualifications either by way of 14-16 college or studying the course from home. Personally, I work, we don't live in a big house and we don't have 2 cars either. My child plans to study for and take GCSEs and A Levels and despite that not being for another couple of years we already know the local exam centres we can use, the cost and what exam boards they offer.

Mytrousersitch · 05/11/2026 13:44

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 13:34

Maybe I won’t. You’ll notice that I haven’t provided a full curriculum and plan for my child’s KS4 education and that’s because I can’t make plans for something so far in the future. I don’t know what schools will look like in ten years time. I’m not optimistic based on how public services have been going, but maybe I’ll be surprised. Maybe our child will be a good fit for the grammar school, I’m sure our local schools will look totally different, maybe we’ll go down the independent route, maybe we’ll love home education? I don’t know because I’m not there. I believe that an outdoors play based education in the early years is better than formal learning which is why we don’t want to start with reception.

I’m also incredibly concerned by the reports of violence, vandalism, bullying and disruption coming from schools at the moment. I’m concerned by the lack of SEN support which impacts children with and without SEN. I just posted because I was reading the locking the toilets thread and seeing so many posters with so many stories of horrendous behaviour seen as an inevitability hence locking the toilets, I just thought that I cannot imagine sending my child into that environment. Then I thought of all the articles I’ve seen in the news about how local authorities and government want to reduce the rise in home ed, and want these children to return to school and I thought that that seems an impossible ask without changing the factors that are making parents deregister their children in the first place. I wasn’t really intending this to be a thread about my personal decision to HE, but more more about the school system.

Yes, who knows. You’ll just have to see as you go along.

Just to say though, that my children’s learning has very much been play based and a lot of outdoors in reception and year 1. And that’s in a (pretty bad on paper) school on a council estate in the West Midlands, not some indie.

Early years are very much play based, especially reception. It’s not the case are sitting at a desk all day at all.

Apotofrealcoffee · 05/11/2026 14:01

I know a family with an 11yo, a 9yo and a 6yo where both parents work part time. Their older kids don’t need childcare while their parents WFH

So an awful lot of TV time it sounds like.

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 14:22

Minasama · 05/11/2026 13:25

I am not a fan of home ed except as a short term solution to a particular problem.

First try a different school.

I think it’s very notable that the people I have known personally who did home ed (with the shining exception of one who was amazing but sadly passed away young - so now her bereaved children have to go to school for the first time as well which is just awful) have been quite odd.

Either creative and spiritual types who desperately wanted their children at home with them or very depressive and felt school wasn’t stretching their child academically. People who I actually think smothered their kids rather than giving them roots and letting them fly.

There have been some awful posts on here recently by people who couldn’t write well so clearly weren’t very educated who’d withdrawn their kids at 11 or 12 - the kids were now older teens with no GCSE passes and mental health problems. This is not a good outcome for home schooling.

Ultimateky life often involves being somewhere you don’t want to be and spending time with people you don’t want to be with, so school is quite good prep for that.

I think the clearest indication that homeschooling is often problematic comes from the vitriol you get when you suggest that there are some potential problems with it. These people will jump in and accuse you of knowing nothing about it, rather than conceding that there can be some problems as well as good sides.

Edited

I’ve seen one post recently where a 16 or 17 year old was deregistered at 11 and after a year at home didn’t receive any kind of education. There were difficult and traumatic circumstances but the outcome was that that child had been educationally neglected and there didn’t seem to a be a path he was willing to engage in at that point to rectify it. That’s horrendous for that child. A few posters on here as well as you have said there have been multiple threads like that, and it doesn’t surprise me there’s more that I’ve missed. I have three main thoughts about that:

  1. regarding assessment of home education. It’s a real sticking point and I see both sides of it. I work in an industry where we are frequently audited by our customers. Most provide a standard for us to comply with and we are audited against that standard. A few don’t have any kind of standard and the result is that an auditor shows up and rates us on what they happen to think on the day that we have no way to prepare for. It’s different auditors every time who have different priorities and concerns. This is pretty much how it works at the moment for home education. Home educators are not required to stick to the national curriculum, and there are no agreed standards that are set that children should have reached by certain ages. All that is required is that children receive an education suitable for their age ability and aptitude. This is so broad that I can see why families are concerned. Some families live in areas with EHE officers who see it as their job to get children into school and so with no guidelines could fail inspections of many HE children that another EHE officer who had a more balanced view would consider appropriate. The flip side is that many home educated children are not receiving an appropriate education which is devastating for that child and these children do nee to be identified and it should be ensured that they are in receipt of a full education. I don’t think the current system is working to identify those children, and I don’t think the new bill will either. I’ve mentioned before that I feel that a lot of relationships between schools and parents feel adversarial and this is definitely true for home educators and education officers. A collaborative approach would be ideal but I have no idea how to do that in reality. And the more home educating families there are, the more resources are stretched and more children would slip through the cracks
  2. I’m not saying this as a look over there, but while many home educated children are left without a sufficient education, many school educated children are also left without a sufficient education. People were very critical about the mother who withdrew her child from home and allowed him to remain uneducated through his teenage years, and rightly so, but maybe if he’d stayed in school he’d have been in the number who didn’t engage with education in school either and left school without qualifications there too. There’s no way of knowing for that one child, but sadly schools are not places where every child can attend, have a positive experience, good socialisation and leave qualified and prepared for a bright future
  3. There’s wide differences in the families whose children aren’t receiving what most would consider a full education. Radical unschoolers who reject the system as a whole are very different from families who withdraw their child from a school due to issues with the school. The second group aren’t anti-school, they were sending their child there in the first place, but for whatever reason (and in the thread I saw it was bullying and violence) don’t find their child is safe at school, be that physically with regards to violence or the child’s mental health. Parents see their children suffering daily because of school and pull the plug. And sometimes end up in a horrible situation where their child won’t engage with education at home, and refuse to go back to school because of what happened to them previously at school. This is one of the biggest reasons for the rise in home education and while I’m really glad to hear that so many posters have had great school experiences for their children, that’s not universal and until schools can fix the terrible behaviours in schools which are driving children out, then this will keep increasing. But these children will need a very different approach to their education and probably some mental health support as well to help them re-engage with education. I’ve definitely waffled on this point, but I don’t think that most people don’t value education. I think that for parents who have taken their children out because of problems they’re just trying to firefight problems with their child’s physical and mental safety, and by the time that’s over, they have a child unwilling to engage in education and nowhere to get help for it.

The TL;DR is all children deserve an education. There needs to be system which works to identify which children are falling through the cracks of HE. There needs to be similar for children who are falling through cracks at school. There needs to be more support for children who have had to leave schools because of negative experiences there to make sure they get the education they deserve. And schools need a lot more resources to try to eradicate the reasons children were withdrawn in the first place and to support the education, and physical and mental health of every child there.

OP posts:
Campanulaceae · 05/11/2026 14:23

Apotofrealcoffee · 05/11/2026 14:01

I know a family with an 11yo, a 9yo and a 6yo where both parents work part time. Their older kids don’t need childcare while their parents WFH

So an awful lot of TV time it sounds like.

Our school aged kids are 5 and 6. During the summer holidays they were at home all day every day, bar the week we went on holiday.

DH and I both WFH full-time. They just played all day every day. Sometimes we'd let them watch a DVD, but on the whole they just made themselves busy.

BusyGreySnail · 05/11/2026 14:27

I am not surprised. My DD is at home today because some boys have threatened to "give her some" and the school isn't doing much about it (maybe they can't?) so she's scared to go in. This is just the last in a long line of bullying incidents. We can't find another decent school for her, despite best efforts and if I didn't have a full time job and didn't think she would struggled massively without social interaction, I would be very tempted to just remove her and home school her.

Jijithecat · 05/11/2026 15:33

OP how well do you know your local schools? Have you actually visited them, talked to local parents, volunteered in them, worked in them?

I realise I speak from a place of privilege but when looking for where to live DH and I prioritised areas with good schools. Our children go to the local academy and are happy to go to school each day. The pastoral care is good (my children do lean on this), exam results well above average. The school is well embedded in the community and has forged many relationships with external organisations which the pupils benefit from. They have friends at school and I believe they feel safe there. It's not all perfect but society isn't. Any issues in school largely reflect those in the local community and I can't protect my children from everything.

There are good schools out there it's just that they don't make for such an exciting headline.

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 15:39

Jijithecat · 05/11/2026 15:33

OP how well do you know your local schools? Have you actually visited them, talked to local parents, volunteered in them, worked in them?

I realise I speak from a place of privilege but when looking for where to live DH and I prioritised areas with good schools. Our children go to the local academy and are happy to go to school each day. The pastoral care is good (my children do lean on this), exam results well above average. The school is well embedded in the community and has forged many relationships with external organisations which the pupils benefit from. They have friends at school and I believe they feel safe there. It's not all perfect but society isn't. Any issues in school largely reflect those in the local community and I can't protect my children from everything.

There are good schools out there it's just that they don't make for such an exciting headline.

I know the local primary fairly well. It’s in the same academy trust as our third nearest school which a teacher friend quit after 1.5 terms because the academy trust were so toxic. I think the schools themselves are probably fine, but more academic than play based which isn’t what I want. We live in a nice area. I don’t know much about the local high schools, but it’s way too early anyway. DH’s high school was ridiculously sought after when he went and ten years later was the worst school in the area

OP posts:
AlertCat · 05/11/2026 17:00

required for very few families though including those on Child Protection Plans or who have been subject to CPP in the last 5 years due to safeguarding concerns (not those who just have a SW or on CIN plans)

@NaiceGoose not my understanding from my training this week. Perhaps it will vary by county.

i’m curious how home ed works when the parent(s) are in work? I actually wanted to HE mine but because I’m a teacher I wasn’t able to. Later I felt it was the right decision for us, she’s been really well served by her schools.

I have also appreciated other things that schools can easily offer, such as wellbeing team with neutral adults to talk to and get appropriate support from, trips abroad, and of course a very wide socialisation and experience of huge numbers of people (both good and bad).

Agree wrt MATs, and luckily both her schools have been single academy schools or not an academy (primary). ‘I’m not a fan of the marketisation of education but tbh the whole system could do with an overhaul anyway.

I read an interesting piece on child-led education and resilience recently, I’ll see if I can find it.

LlynTegid · 05/11/2026 17:01

I doubt it is the only factor at all.

Mytrousersitch · 05/11/2026 17:09

AlertCat · 05/11/2026 17:00

required for very few families though including those on Child Protection Plans or who have been subject to CPP in the last 5 years due to safeguarding concerns (not those who just have a SW or on CIN plans)

@NaiceGoose not my understanding from my training this week. Perhaps it will vary by county.

i’m curious how home ed works when the parent(s) are in work? I actually wanted to HE mine but because I’m a teacher I wasn’t able to. Later I felt it was the right decision for us, she’s been really well served by her schools.

I have also appreciated other things that schools can easily offer, such as wellbeing team with neutral adults to talk to and get appropriate support from, trips abroad, and of course a very wide socialisation and experience of huge numbers of people (both good and bad).

Agree wrt MATs, and luckily both her schools have been single academy schools or not an academy (primary). ‘I’m not a fan of the marketisation of education but tbh the whole system could do with an overhaul anyway.

I read an interesting piece on child-led education and resilience recently, I’ll see if I can find it.

When both parents work, you are usually told, “home education doesn’t happen Monday to Friday between 9 and 3!”

What happens is, they are farmed out to grandparents with a few crap worksheets and the tv, or older kids are just dossing about at home, “creating a business.”

I know I sound so negative, but that was my experience during years of home education and years after of knowing/keeping in touch with home ed families.

So many are so shit at it.

Sartre · 05/11/2026 17:11

State secondaries have always been like this, it’s nothing new. If you’re even remotely different in any way, you will be bullied mercilessly. It’s like Lord of the Flies. The toilets were locked at my school because kids would skive and hide in there plus fights had happened and some kids had smoked in there. My school was particularly bad but it wasn’t an isolated case. Fights were a daily occurrence, teen pregnancies were pretty common and the teachers had zero control.

I fear for my youngest child who has autism. He’s in a mainstream primary and they maintained he would remain there as he’s extremely academic. Just this week they have shifted towards potentially not being able to meet his needs and said he may need specialist provision after all. They have also removed his access to wraparound care with zero warning meaning DH and I have had to work around the emergency childcare between us. We both work FT and can’t quit our careers, we need the money… it’s totally blindsided me and I don’t know what we’ll do. It’s a toss up between home ed or finding an independent school and hoping his EHCP can fund the fees.

Apotofrealcoffee · 05/11/2026 17:12

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 15:39

I know the local primary fairly well. It’s in the same academy trust as our third nearest school which a teacher friend quit after 1.5 terms because the academy trust were so toxic. I think the schools themselves are probably fine, but more academic than play based which isn’t what I want. We live in a nice area. I don’t know much about the local high schools, but it’s way too early anyway. DH’s high school was ridiculously sought after when he went and ten years later was the worst school in the area

I agree with the other posters that you’ve jumped the gun when your child is still very little, likely because you’ve been fired up by Instagram ‘homeschool mama’ content.

Give it a few years.

My child would be very bored just doing nature walks and ‘messy play’ all day at age 7. She’s smart and likes academic learning. I wouldn’t have guessed that age 3 though.

Valeriekat · 05/11/2026 18:43

TraitorOrFaithful · 03/11/2026 14:44

Your post is very negative OP. My DC attends a state school and is having a good experience- nothing like the environment you describe.

Good for you but not all schools are the same.

Minasama · 05/11/2026 19:56

teaandaflorentineplease · 05/11/2026 14:22

I’ve seen one post recently where a 16 or 17 year old was deregistered at 11 and after a year at home didn’t receive any kind of education. There were difficult and traumatic circumstances but the outcome was that that child had been educationally neglected and there didn’t seem to a be a path he was willing to engage in at that point to rectify it. That’s horrendous for that child. A few posters on here as well as you have said there have been multiple threads like that, and it doesn’t surprise me there’s more that I’ve missed. I have three main thoughts about that:

  1. regarding assessment of home education. It’s a real sticking point and I see both sides of it. I work in an industry where we are frequently audited by our customers. Most provide a standard for us to comply with and we are audited against that standard. A few don’t have any kind of standard and the result is that an auditor shows up and rates us on what they happen to think on the day that we have no way to prepare for. It’s different auditors every time who have different priorities and concerns. This is pretty much how it works at the moment for home education. Home educators are not required to stick to the national curriculum, and there are no agreed standards that are set that children should have reached by certain ages. All that is required is that children receive an education suitable for their age ability and aptitude. This is so broad that I can see why families are concerned. Some families live in areas with EHE officers who see it as their job to get children into school and so with no guidelines could fail inspections of many HE children that another EHE officer who had a more balanced view would consider appropriate. The flip side is that many home educated children are not receiving an appropriate education which is devastating for that child and these children do nee to be identified and it should be ensured that they are in receipt of a full education. I don’t think the current system is working to identify those children, and I don’t think the new bill will either. I’ve mentioned before that I feel that a lot of relationships between schools and parents feel adversarial and this is definitely true for home educators and education officers. A collaborative approach would be ideal but I have no idea how to do that in reality. And the more home educating families there are, the more resources are stretched and more children would slip through the cracks
  2. I’m not saying this as a look over there, but while many home educated children are left without a sufficient education, many school educated children are also left without a sufficient education. People were very critical about the mother who withdrew her child from home and allowed him to remain uneducated through his teenage years, and rightly so, but maybe if he’d stayed in school he’d have been in the number who didn’t engage with education in school either and left school without qualifications there too. There’s no way of knowing for that one child, but sadly schools are not places where every child can attend, have a positive experience, good socialisation and leave qualified and prepared for a bright future
  3. There’s wide differences in the families whose children aren’t receiving what most would consider a full education. Radical unschoolers who reject the system as a whole are very different from families who withdraw their child from a school due to issues with the school. The second group aren’t anti-school, they were sending their child there in the first place, but for whatever reason (and in the thread I saw it was bullying and violence) don’t find their child is safe at school, be that physically with regards to violence or the child’s mental health. Parents see their children suffering daily because of school and pull the plug. And sometimes end up in a horrible situation where their child won’t engage with education at home, and refuse to go back to school because of what happened to them previously at school. This is one of the biggest reasons for the rise in home education and while I’m really glad to hear that so many posters have had great school experiences for their children, that’s not universal and until schools can fix the terrible behaviours in schools which are driving children out, then this will keep increasing. But these children will need a very different approach to their education and probably some mental health support as well to help them re-engage with education. I’ve definitely waffled on this point, but I don’t think that most people don’t value education. I think that for parents who have taken their children out because of problems they’re just trying to firefight problems with their child’s physical and mental safety, and by the time that’s over, they have a child unwilling to engage in education and nowhere to get help for it.

The TL;DR is all children deserve an education. There needs to be system which works to identify which children are falling through the cracks of HE. There needs to be similar for children who are falling through cracks at school. There needs to be more support for children who have had to leave schools because of negative experiences there to make sure they get the education they deserve. And schools need a lot more resources to try to eradicate the reasons children were withdrawn in the first place and to support the education, and physical and mental health of every child there.

Yes, I agree with everything you’ve said here. Nothing to add really.

TheUndomesticGoddess87 · 05/11/2026 20:15

ManchesterMiracle · 04/11/2026 13:41

Every time I hear about a child being home educated, I see a woman being taken out of the workforce and the gender pay gap continues. Yes, sometimes it’s the dads but not v often.

I also find it interesting how many home educators start threads about how bad schools are. If they are truly happy with their decision to home ed, why start thread after thread about schools?

Anyway, I have no skin in this game. My kids are working now or at university. They have such nostalgia for their school days, they really had a ball and they were the clichéd best years of their lives to date!

I'm sorry but I think posts like this come across as being completely tone deaf. My sister in law had a horrendous time at school. Relentlessly bullied to the point where she attempted suicide at the age of 15. All the way through her twenties she still struggled with her experiences and this manifested through self harm and an eating disorder. Being pulled out of school and home educated probably saved her life. Sorry, but when faced with putting your child in an early grave most people don't give a crap about the gender pay gap. But hey, your kids had the time of their life so who cares? My DC are both under 5 and I fully intend to send them to school. My eldest is currently in the nursery class at our local primary and will hopefully move onto reception but I fully understand why some home educate.

FedUpCelery · 06/11/2026 09:01

Op, I'm not sure what the purpose was of your post. Maybe your child would thrive in school, maybe they would hate it, same for home education. Everyone's experience is different and it depends on the schools, your area and so on.

Home education can be great. If that's what you want to do, go for it. Keep paying attention to your child. It's not an irreversible decision. If they want to try school or if HE is not working for you or for your child it's always an option. (up to just before year 10, usually).

I do believe some home educators are naive if they don't get some sort of qualification for their child. Tweens and teens are fickle and they don't know what they don't know. One minute they can be thriving in home ed and have a plan that doesn't involve sixth form, the next, they've made a massive developmental change and they can want to be at sixth along with their friends. It's up to us to keep an eye on that future and make sure doors are kept open for them.
We weren't an entrepreneurial family so we've relied even more heavily on qualifications. I know school kids who tried college, hated it and found a place in the family business, or in gaining professional qualifications in outdoor activities, or other alternative routes. At least they got to try and cross it off the list as not for them right now - and there's always later.
Proactive home educators trend to be good at keeping their eye out for these opportunities too.

An ex home educator who is going on 3 or 4 year old knowledge of navigating college places may well be out of date. They are strict and there are always exceptions to this of course, but on the whole they have an entry system that works for them and they don't tend to individualise and they will have the full range of ideas about home education and experiences of home educated children that you have read on this thread. If you tick the boxes, it's a breeze so imo it's a good idea to tick those boxes of your child is able.

You're years away though. There are as many different ways of home educating as there are families. Keep reading and keep thinking and keep paying attention to your child. There are so many books out there on approaches and different approaches are good at different ages. Best of luck and enjoy!

Cosyblankets · 06/11/2026 09:09

Mytrousersitch · 05/11/2026 12:23

That’s pretty standard everywhere there are checks.

Could you imagine if it was compulsory for all home educators families and conducted once a term? It would never work. The volume of staff needed for that would make it unworkable.

But it cannot be right that a child simply does not go to school under the guise of home education and there are no checks.

Itsthewoluff · 06/11/2026 09:18

I understand HS when school has been tried and it’s not worked out, but school is so much more than just education. I don’t think it would benefit the majority of children.

ElectricThrowAddict · 06/11/2026 09:21

TheUndomesticGoddess87 · 05/11/2026 20:15

I'm sorry but I think posts like this come across as being completely tone deaf. My sister in law had a horrendous time at school. Relentlessly bullied to the point where she attempted suicide at the age of 15. All the way through her twenties she still struggled with her experiences and this manifested through self harm and an eating disorder. Being pulled out of school and home educated probably saved her life. Sorry, but when faced with putting your child in an early grave most people don't give a crap about the gender pay gap. But hey, your kids had the time of their life so who cares? My DC are both under 5 and I fully intend to send them to school. My eldest is currently in the nursery class at our local primary and will hopefully move onto reception but I fully understand why some home educate.

You're conflating loads of different issues.

It is very sad your SiL had a terrible time.

That has almost zero bearing on the comments that were made about HE necessarily taking a parent out of the FT workforce.

It is also v different to those like OP who have no experience of their local school or their child attending.

Cosyblankets · 06/11/2026 09:24

I've just looked up what happens during the visit.
You do not need to allow them access to your home.

They do not need to see the child
You can send a description of what you're doing.... or let's be honest you can make it up. And as long as it's convincing you get left alone.
So no one sees the child and you could get chat gpt to write your evidence for you.
How is that doing anything to provide a decent foundation for young people? They could go for long periods seeing no one but a parent.

Yes there will be plenty doing a decent job. There's no denying that. But there's a huge net for kids to slip through and it's wrong.
Abuse in the home is often picked up by teachers / TAs / attendance officers. None of these people are involved in home education
The system is very very wrong

ManchesterMiracle · 06/11/2026 09:37

TheUndomesticGoddess87 · 05/11/2026 20:15

I'm sorry but I think posts like this come across as being completely tone deaf. My sister in law had a horrendous time at school. Relentlessly bullied to the point where she attempted suicide at the age of 15. All the way through her twenties she still struggled with her experiences and this manifested through self harm and an eating disorder. Being pulled out of school and home educated probably saved her life. Sorry, but when faced with putting your child in an early grave most people don't give a crap about the gender pay gap. But hey, your kids had the time of their life so who cares? My DC are both under 5 and I fully intend to send them to school. My eldest is currently in the nursery class at our local primary and will hopefully move onto reception but I fully understand why some home educate.

There will be individual circumstances like your sil where it’s essential to home educate. I hope she is doing ok now.

But as a society, home ed often means women leaving the workforce and the gender pay gap increasing. And I stand by the fact that that is not a good thing for women.

Swipe left for the next trending thread