Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that it’s not at all surprising that home education is on the rise?

134 replies

teaandaflorentineplease · 03/11/2026 13:48

Having read the recent thread on secondary schools locking the loos in lesson time, I couldn’t help but think that it’s not a surprise that home education is becoming a more and more popular choice for our children. I was genuinely shocked both at the treatment of school children as prisoners by schools, and by the horrendous behaviour that leads to that treatment in the first place. Shitting on the floor, vandalism, vaping, violence and bullying are simply the ones I can remember from the top of my head. My main takeaway was horror at the situation, and a thought that there’s no way in hell I want to send my toddler into an environment like that in ten years time.

It brought to mind this article I read about how home education is in the rise in Blackpool, and that’s a trend which seems to be nationwide.

School budgets are being stretched impossibly tightly and have been for so long that it’s impossible to shield children from the impact of this. There’s not the budget for enough TAs and that means that managing large classes falls to one teacher. We all know that SEN are at a high, as are behaviour issues and school readiness so that one teacher has to manage a classroom which has more challenges than before with less help than before. That means that most children in a classroom won’t be able to get as much independent care and attention, poor behaviour and bullying go unchecked, and children who have more minor SEN or are quietly struggling are missed. It also means that children who have more significant SEN but fall short of a 1:1 (if that’s even provided) also won’t get what they need in the classroom either. Teachers also have a lot of pressures to do things which don’t actually help their classes, maybe from an academy trust, overbearing head teacher, Ofsted, or something else. Just so much busy work that doesn’t add any value to the children, and takes up teachers’ time and makes them burn out. And all this means that there’s a lot of violence and disruption in schools, nobody is getting the attention they deserve and everyone is suffering because of it. Home education means that you know your children are safe, have access to the loo when they need and have individual attention and a curriculum which can be tailored to them. If they grasp a concept quickly, you can move on, if they’re struggling then you can spend more time on it. I want to be clear that this isn’t a thread bashing teachers or TAs, most are doing the best they can, but it’s bashing the system that teachers are working in.

School holiday fines simply seem to make a more adversarial and antagonistic relationship between parents and schools. Parents seem to just share advice how to get around the fines, like taking children out after morning registration, so they don’t trigger the limit. They don’t even work because attendance rates haven’t improved. All it seems to do is create a conflict between the parents and schools/LAs. I also think that parents are ultimately the one’s responsible for their children’s childhood and education unless there are safeguarding concerns and giving a parent a criminal record for taking their children out of school for one week three years in a row is bananas to me and while it seems a small thing, I totally get why parents don’t want to put their children in a system that criminalises them for going on holiday at the wrong time. Especially in a cost of living crisis where many families’ only option for a holiday is in term time due to cost. I know this seems a minor point, and I considered leaving it out, because I don’t think anybody is taking the decision to HE because of holiday fines alone, but it’s just an extra thing which puts barriers up and creates a conflict between parents and schools.

I also think that the rise in home education also makes a difference because it’s more visible and it increases the opportunities available which in turn makes it more desirable. My local area’s home education community is large and active so concerns about friends and socialisation don’t feel relevant in the context of the opportunities that home educated children have. It becoming more popular also normalises it. I feel there’s still a lot of people who see home education as the preserve of the extremely religious, or by flat earthers who failed their own GCSEs, but more people home educating means that people will see that actually most home educators are normal families and see it as a viable and possibly desirable path for their children too. And if children start to struggle in schools, home education seems to be becoming seen as a good alternative rather than trying to fit a square peg in a round hole with school.

On so many of the articles I’ve read about the rise in home education, there’s a comment on how local authorities wish to stop the rise and increase the number of children in schools, but without tackling core issues parents have, and without significant investments I can only see home education rising in popularity. So am I being unreasonable to think that home education’s rise is inevitable in the current climate and that if local authorities and government want to reduce this number significant changes need to happen.

OP posts:
NaiceGoose · 03/11/2026 16:23

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 03/11/2026 14:51

10 years ago I used to think people that home educated were a little bit eccentric now I can see why people choose to do this. I do think school gives a good start to life for social expectations, working life, socialisation. However I do feel like school now is more of a punishment- they give detentions for the most insignificant reasons and I am only in my 30’s but I just don’t remember it being like that when I was young. I feel it’s a shame for teachers too as they are overburdened

I used to think the same. My view of Home Educators were quirky/hippy/anti establishment/alternative lifestyle/earth mother types...and now we Home Educate I see that is very much not the case at all! 🤣

I would send ny child to school if UK secondary schools were a nice place to be though. If the violent/disruptive children were removed immediately and the kind, respectful children who want to learn were able to do so without having ridiculous rules in place like having toilets locked so children don't smoke or stab each other in there at breaktime! Smaller class sizes would be ideal but having 30 children in a class is manageable when all of those children are taught and expected to behave like decent humans and show respect for each other, their teachers and their school- it is not at all manageable with rude, agressive, violent children mixed in!

Many of the Home Ed parents we meet are current or ex teachers/TAs too- which speaks volumes really.

Campanulaceae · 03/11/2026 16:23

We might be moving to DH's home country, and if we do so I will be homeschooling our four.

My two eldest currently go to school, but I am so put out by the topics they cover and the books they read. Some books I would describe as subversive. Everything seems to be geared towards the lower-average level of the classes. We've also had some severe behavioural issues which were just unheard of when I was a kid.

We are classically conservative parents, and modern schooling just doesn't suit what we want for our children.

5128gap · 03/11/2026 16:26

I agree with you that the school environment can be appalling and understand the concerns parents have.
However I'm genuinely surprised that the number of parents who are confident enough in their abilities to take on the hugely responsible task of educating their child is on the rise.
I'm a well educated woman but there came a point in my DC education where I struggled to support with some homework, never mind having sufficient knowledge and understanding to teach every subject in its entirely to the required standard. Plus of course, the aptitude to teach.
Term time holidays is a different issue. I think the rules and fines are draconian, and how we can have a system of fines for a two week absence sitting alongside a system that allows some parents to remove their child from education altogether with little to no monitoring, is inexplicable to me.

NaiceGoose · 03/11/2026 16:29

Mytrousersitch · 03/11/2026 16:18

Children are lumped together with other children they have nothing in common with at home ed groups too. No 12 year old wants to willingly hang out with a 6 year old, no matter how much their parents pat themselves on the back for “having friends of all ages, not just ones born in the same year.”

Bullying happens wherever there are children together. Home educated children can be nasty too, and often, their parents are completely ineffective at dealing with them at all.

Edited

Spending time with children and adults of all ages has great benefits- my teenager enjoys socialising with older and younger children sometimes. However, many of the Home Ed groups/activities we do are split by approxmate age as of course teenagers and toddlers have different interests and abilities. There are lots of teen only Home Ed groups for them to socialise too.

Of course you have some Home Ed children (and parents) who are badly behaved- the beauty of Home Ed is that you can just choose not to meet them again 🤣 With Home Ed your child isn't forced to be in a classroom 6 hours a day 5 days a week with a violent and disruptive child like they could be at school.

Mytrousersitch · 03/11/2026 16:39

NaiceGoose · 03/11/2026 16:29

Spending time with children and adults of all ages has great benefits- my teenager enjoys socialising with older and younger children sometimes. However, many of the Home Ed groups/activities we do are split by approxmate age as of course teenagers and toddlers have different interests and abilities. There are lots of teen only Home Ed groups for them to socialise too.

Of course you have some Home Ed children (and parents) who are badly behaved- the beauty of Home Ed is that you can just choose not to meet them again 🤣 With Home Ed your child isn't forced to be in a classroom 6 hours a day 5 days a week with a violent and disruptive child like they could be at school.

I can only tell you my experiences of years of home ed.

All I can say is, after years of shitty home ed groups, when my ds stated school in year 6, he was so fucking happy at suddenly having 30 kids in his class, 30 in the other two classes, and the other 90 children in the year below him to chose from after being home educated (we had the opportunity travel a lot with work before then, so home ed was our best option).

Children who go to school know children of different ages too - but that’s a choice.

I can’t tell you how many home ed groups I’ve run over the years where kids have been so lonely and upset and it’s all so forced.

Oh and two younger ones are 6 and 13. They aren’t “forced” to be in a classroom with the same children all day. Even my 6 year olds lessons are mixed up for ability, into
smaller groups etc.

Timeforachange26 · 03/11/2026 16:40

Ablondiebutagoody · 03/11/2026 14:25

Inclusion above everything else is driving the kids it is supposed to benefit out of school altogether. Those with violent "emotional regulation" issues are untouchable.

Fully agree. Its beneficial to no one

ilovesooty · 03/11/2026 16:50

5128gap · 03/11/2026 16:26

I agree with you that the school environment can be appalling and understand the concerns parents have.
However I'm genuinely surprised that the number of parents who are confident enough in their abilities to take on the hugely responsible task of educating their child is on the rise.
I'm a well educated woman but there came a point in my DC education where I struggled to support with some homework, never mind having sufficient knowledge and understanding to teach every subject in its entirely to the required standard. Plus of course, the aptitude to teach.
Term time holidays is a different issue. I think the rules and fines are draconian, and how we can have a system of fines for a two week absence sitting alongside a system that allows some parents to remove their child from education altogether with little to no monitoring, is inexplicable to me.

I agree and as mentioned above I'm surprised that so many parents are able to home school in the current economic climate.

MintTwirl · 03/11/2026 16:51

Home education numbers have risen hugely since Covid and there is a multitude of reasons for that and yes issues with the school system is absolutely one of those reasons.

The home ed community as a whole is a really diverse bunch of people, now more than ever, it has changed a lot of over the last few years.

DaisyJohnson · 03/11/2026 17:38

I'm not surprised that many parents want something better for their children than schools, because schools are drastically underfunded. I am surprised that so many parents believe they can be that something better. I'm a secondary teacher and I don't believe for a single second that even with all my training I could do a good job of home educating. I don't have the training for it.

And if I'm honest, I get a lot of home education stuff on my Facebook feed. The spelling and grammar of too many of the parents posting there is so poor that it fills me with dread for what their children can be learning from them. Many of those parents are writing at a level that would put them in a low set in Year 7 English.

I think there should be higher standards or bare minimum qualifications for home education. I see home educators advising each other on how to avoid proper scrutiny and it makes me really worried for those children.

hotmumshit · 03/11/2026 17:42

I think that all state services are fundamentally destroyed and unless you can afford to pay for

Health
Education
Housing in a gated community, security instead of police, private road works and bins

Youre screwed.

Witchyhoures · 03/11/2026 17:53

I dont think HE should be completely restricted but do think its problematic when people havent themselves passed at least maths and english think they can even cover ks2 work.
That is the case for relatives. Their kid needs to be in school. Also the kid is now very withdrawn.

There is an issue with schools. Teachers compared to when i was at school seem to resent doing anything even marking so to expect them to deal with class behaviour etc...

Its not like inclusion is working though as one dc has a boy in class who cant read or write. And yes that will impact the other kids due to distraction of the kid being always outside class.

NaiceGoose · 03/11/2026 18:22

Mytrousersitch · 03/11/2026 16:39

I can only tell you my experiences of years of home ed.

All I can say is, after years of shitty home ed groups, when my ds stated school in year 6, he was so fucking happy at suddenly having 30 kids in his class, 30 in the other two classes, and the other 90 children in the year below him to chose from after being home educated (we had the opportunity travel a lot with work before then, so home ed was our best option).

Children who go to school know children of different ages too - but that’s a choice.

I can’t tell you how many home ed groups I’ve run over the years where kids have been so lonely and upset and it’s all so forced.

Oh and two younger ones are 6 and 13. They aren’t “forced” to be in a classroom with the same children all day. Even my 6 year olds lessons are mixed up for ability, into
smaller groups etc.

Edited

Oh I totally understand it will be a different experience for everyone, I too am just stating our own personal experience. My child is a teenager and we happen to have met lots of lovely teens in local groups and I also organise lots of educational days out for local teens too- so I also have some control over the age range for those.

As with everything, there is positive and negative to both options- school and home ed. For us, Home Ed has been great but I do appreciate it isn't the same experience for everyone.

SpanThatWorld · 03/11/2026 18:24

Acquaintance of ours decided to home ed and pulled their kids out of the schools my kids were at. "Do children need to do Maths?"
Marvellous time. Long holidays in France. Played several instruments. All lovely.

And then they realised that their eldest had no qualifications and couldn't go to university.
Younger kids were back in school the next September. And had a lovely time catching up with all the academic stuff they had missed and all the friends they hadn't seen much of. Because a PE lesson that consists of playing football with your dad is frankly rubbish

Netcurtainnelly · 03/11/2026 18:35

MyBestThing · 03/11/2026 16:01

I have read two separate disturbing threads on here recently where a parent removed their child from school and many years later they have a really difficult teenager who has no qualifications or education.
That's why Home Ed has a bad reputation.

Equally there will be happy kids who have never had to deal with bullying at school.

NaiceGoose · 03/11/2026 21:43

Witchyhoures · 03/11/2026 17:53

I dont think HE should be completely restricted but do think its problematic when people havent themselves passed at least maths and english think they can even cover ks2 work.
That is the case for relatives. Their kid needs to be in school. Also the kid is now very withdrawn.

There is an issue with schools. Teachers compared to when i was at school seem to resent doing anything even marking so to expect them to deal with class behaviour etc...

Its not like inclusion is working though as one dc has a boy in class who cant read or write. And yes that will impact the other kids due to distraction of the kid being always outside class.

I don't think the issue with schools is the teachers not wanting to do anything- every teacher I have ever worked with has done all they can for the children with the time they have. Most work long hours and then evenings, weekends and school holidays too. The problem is large class sizes, lack of funding, lack of resources, lack of time, lack of TAs/support staff, children with SEN not having the support the support they need, parental meetings during teaching time, parents not supporting the school and violent/disruptive children.

I do agree that to Home Ed effectively you should ideally have at least a reasonably decent level of education but even if not, these things can be outsourced- there are lots of Home Ed classes, group tuition and online lessons available. Many Home Ed children I know are self motivated and keen to learn, they can self teach some aspects with the correct resources provided or learn alongside their parent. We all have our strengths and weaknesses of course, for example, I can help my teenager to GCSE level Maths, Science and English but I am unlikely to be much use should they choose to study A Level Astronomy or Marine Biology.

Also remember, attending school in no way ensures a child will achieve the expected level, the very parents we are discussing who have a lower than average level of education probably spent many years in school themselves!

CousinBette · 03/11/2026 21:58

Using Blackpool as an example of a place where ‘home education’ is on the rise just shows that you know absolutely nothing about the social problems Blackpool faces and the reasons why so many children have been deregistered from school. If you think the vast majority of those home ed kids in Blackpool are receiving an adequate alternative education then you are sorely mistaken.

Watchoutfortheslowaraf · 03/11/2026 21:59

I know of a few people who HE. One has no grasp of basic grammar and seems to just print sheets off twinkl randomly and that’s them done for the day.

The other has enrolled her dc into lots of online classes, encouraged him to set up a mini business and he is doing some GCSEs in Year 9.

You get good HE parents and bad ones. You get good schools and bad ones. My DC are luckily at very good mainstream schools and are doing well academically and socially and loving all the extra curricular. Which is a relief because I couldn’t afford to give up work and home school and I don’t think (after giving it a brief go in Covid times) I could cope with it either!

Jimmyjumpy · 03/11/2026 22:35

You may be describing some behaviour in some schools but apart from that you are spouting nonsense.

Passaggressfedup · 04/11/2026 11:19

Schools can't cope with the appalling behaviours children are exhibiting nowadays because they've never been taught respect and discipline.

Why do you think schools have to resort to closing bathrooms? Because of them being used for bad behaviours.

Like most older generations, we managed to hold it during lessons. The only exception was an accident when girls first had their period. Nowadays, it seems 15 years old can't possibly hold their pee for 45 minutes! Yeah right!

If parents could discipline their kids instead of treating them like precious China, maybe the school would not have to resort to such measures!

LibertyBustop · 04/11/2026 11:45

My kids received a great education, their teachers were hardworking and enthusiastic in support of their pupils’ education, and their environments were uniformly welcoming, warm and safe.

Now obviously there will be schools with issues, but it’s hardly universal.

I have known quite a few homeschooling families. The parents were very enthusiastic and well meaning but without exception their children were undereducated, immature and socially lacking.

I would not for a moment suggest that therefore all homeschooling is a bad thing for children but it does seem that homeschooling parents think it that it’s ok to do the same for schools.

You can choose to homeschool without demonising schools to validate your choice.

Bollin · 04/11/2026 11:50

Ablondiebutagoody · 03/11/2026 14:25

Inclusion above everything else is driving the kids it is supposed to benefit out of school altogether. Those with violent "emotional regulation" issues are untouchable.

This.

We had to remove our child from the state school due to their mental health suffering from getting beaten up repeatedly by a classmate with ‘emotional regulation’ issues, aka was a violent bully. We could afford private so went there - wonderful safe, calm environment. Another classmate’s parent home schooled.

We need to provide a safe, calm state school experience. It shouldn’t be too much to ask surely - but it apparently is.

Bollin · 04/11/2026 11:51

I do think that in order to home schooled secondary you need a lot of spare cash for tutors. Very few parents could adequately teach further maths for example.

MintTwirl · 04/11/2026 11:58

LibertyBustop · 04/11/2026 11:45

My kids received a great education, their teachers were hardworking and enthusiastic in support of their pupils’ education, and their environments were uniformly welcoming, warm and safe.

Now obviously there will be schools with issues, but it’s hardly universal.

I have known quite a few homeschooling families. The parents were very enthusiastic and well meaning but without exception their children were undereducated, immature and socially lacking.

I would not for a moment suggest that therefore all homeschooling is a bad thing for children but it does seem that homeschooling parents think it that it’s ok to do the same for schools.

You can choose to homeschool without demonising schools to validate your choice.

Not all home educators demonise schools of course some do just as some people demonise home education.
I have no issues with schools as a whole but I am critical of certain parts of the schooling system. I am also critical of some home educators.

Timeforachange26 · 04/11/2026 12:02

Bollin · 04/11/2026 11:51

I do think that in order to home schooled secondary you need a lot of spare cash for tutors. Very few parents could adequately teach further maths for example.

very few kids learn further maths at school either. By the time they are at that stage they can attend college

Mytrousersitch · 04/11/2026 12:04

Passaggressfedup · 04/11/2026 11:19

Schools can't cope with the appalling behaviours children are exhibiting nowadays because they've never been taught respect and discipline.

Why do you think schools have to resort to closing bathrooms? Because of them being used for bad behaviours.

Like most older generations, we managed to hold it during lessons. The only exception was an accident when girls first had their period. Nowadays, it seems 15 years old can't possibly hold their pee for 45 minutes! Yeah right!

If parents could discipline their kids instead of treating them like precious China, maybe the school would not have to resort to such measures!

It’s not just the children where I live, it’s the parents. They regularly fight with each each other in the playground at pick up, their children don’t stand a chance.

When I worked in schools ten years ago it was the same. I remember having to have a meeting with parent because their child had spat at me and called me a cunt (I had asked them to move from my office door as they were blocking it on purpose). The mum looked me in the eye and said, “you probably are a cunt.”

It’s not a recent thing. There are awful people brining up useful children everywhere, forever.

I am 47. We weren’t allowed to go to the toilet during lessons when I was at secondary school. You went at break or lunch. I don’t se why parents are suddenly up in arms about it. I tell my children to wait until a break time.

(But then again, I went through the entirety of my childhood just having a few sips of squash with lunch, children now seem to have to have a water bottle permanently attached to them at all times).

Swipe left for the next trending thread