Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting scans to identify source of pain in friend with cancer and dementia.

214 replies

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 14:10

Situation - group of 70 + age friends supporting X a lone mutual friend ( no family ).
X has a soft tissue cancer that has spread .
Hospital has carried out a one off targeted radiotherapy treatment on one site in spine .
X doesn't want more treatment .
Hospital have said no scans because X won't accept treatment .
X has dementia and thinks ,wrongly ,that treatment will be surgery or chemo.
X has some chronic health conditions - Chrons ,arthritis in knees ,painful back .
X often complains of back and knee pain and sometimes pain in lower abdomen.
The problem is that as friends we disagree about the need for investigative scans when X is complaining of pain .
X is not consistent in reporting pain ,when I am with her it can vary over the course of hours to v painful to no reported pain .
Some of us worry that a scan is needed to identify whether pain is caused by one of the chronic conditions or by a new spread .
Could abdomen pain be caused by Chrons or pressure from a new met.?
Is the ongoing back pain worse because X is lonely or walking badly because of arthritic knees .
X has been referred to a hospice by the hospital for future pain relief .
Hospice don't feel scans necessary .
But surely cause of pain needed to determine treatment ?
Unreasonable to want scans ?
Or reasonable to want scans ?

OP posts:
ApiratesaysYarrr · 02/11/2026 06:26

Trounlet · 31/10/2026 14:17

Also, unless you or the other friends have lasting power of attorney, you will not be able to influence X's care and treatment.

Even if you did have LPA, you wouldn't be able to demand scans that the drs don't think will work.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 02/11/2026 06:32

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 16:46

Absolutely " scan " is such a vague term .
Apologies.
I think at this stage a CT ot ultrasound might ,for instance,help identify a spread and provide an answer about whether the back pain is related to this or is X's chronic pain aggravated by her knees .
I agree MRIs are less well tolerated ,probably necessary when originally diagnosing the cancer but not needed now .
Again ,in case I'm being unclear ,I'm absolutely not trying to push for treatment but for the best ,most effective pain relief .
X loves independently,goes out ,shops .
I've no idea how much longer she has to enjoy this .
X advised the hospital that she didn't want treatment so they advised that she should seek support from a hospice .
They didn't refer her because there was nothing they could do ( although without her consent of course there was nothing they could do ) or because they judged her to be end of life .

Neither CT nor ultrasound would be the best scan to look for those sorts of issues. Even an MRI won't tell you whether the pain is coming from back or knees - as someone already said, there is a poor correlation between pain and what we see on scans - clinical assessment is better for that.

AbouttimeIhadanewusername · 02/11/2026 06:34

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 16:46

Absolutely " scan " is such a vague term .
Apologies.
I think at this stage a CT ot ultrasound might ,for instance,help identify a spread and provide an answer about whether the back pain is related to this or is X's chronic pain aggravated by her knees .
I agree MRIs are less well tolerated ,probably necessary when originally diagnosing the cancer but not needed now .
Again ,in case I'm being unclear ,I'm absolutely not trying to push for treatment but for the best ,most effective pain relief .
X loves independently,goes out ,shops .
I've no idea how much longer she has to enjoy this .
X advised the hospital that she didn't want treatment so they advised that she should seek support from a hospice .
They didn't refer her because there was nothing they could do ( although without her consent of course there was nothing they could do ) or because they judged her to be end of life .

If your friend has dementia then how on earth is she going to keep perfectly still during a CT, MRI or any other scan. It is difficult enough to keep still under normal circumstances.
OP, the kindest thing you can do is let your friend make her own decisions. Pain relief tends to be general. As in agreement with a previous poster, if I had dementia, I would welcome anything to limit my life.

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 06:44

"Even if you did have LPA, you wouldn't be able to demand scans that the drs don't think will work"
I don't know why you've made this remark .
Where have you got the idea that I'm wanting to " demand scans ' ?
And where have you got the idea that I need advising on being an attorney ?

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 06:45

ApiratesaysYarrr · 02/11/2026 06:32

Neither CT nor ultrasound would be the best scan to look for those sorts of issues. Even an MRI won't tell you whether the pain is coming from back or knees - as someone already said, there is a poor correlation between pain and what we see on scans - clinical assessment is better for that.

Yes ,I agree

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 06:47

@AbouttimeIhadanewusername your reason for assuming that I am.makingndecisions on behalf of my friend are what exactly ?

OP posts:
AbouttimeIhadanewusername · 02/11/2026 06:51

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 06:47

@AbouttimeIhadanewusername your reason for assuming that I am.makingndecisions on behalf of my friend are what exactly ?

Your friend has said she doesn’t want any treatment.

kiwiane · 02/11/2026 06:53

I feel for you - I’ve been in a similar situation with a relative refusing hospital assessment and I really wanted to know what was causing the underlying symptoms to see if they could improve.
You have more certainty that their condition is in the palliative care zone and you can support pain relief; I would keep a notebook of symptoms as it is likely they may need stronger medication.
Try to ignore suggestions that you’re being an over involved and controlling friend by people online, you are advocating for your friend and everyone needs someone in their corner at a time like this.

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 06:57

This entire thread is you not trusting medical professionals! Apart from chiropractors
Could you back that statement up please ?
Have you taken my attitude of questioning and seeking more information from HP as equal to not trusting ?.
In real life one has to be proactive about treatments ,not passive .
The rheumatologist prescribed ibrofruen to ,X despite her having Chrons .
Was I wrong to have doubts about this ?
Her GP ,despite brain scans and a dx from.thr memory clinic of Alzheimer's,didn't realise this .
Speaking to X the GP reassured X that her memory difficulties were normal,and that she wouldn't be referring to the memory clinic .
HP s and drs not Gods ,they can make mistakes ,they can miss things .
if I want more information it's not because I don't respect them it's because I'm not the sort of person who accepts ( with.no.explaination) everything I'm told .

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 07:04

@AbouttimeIhadanewusername where have I said that she should have treatment ?
I started this thread because I was worried that the hospice would assume any pain was caused by the cancer .
I am.worried about opiods being prescribed and how the hospice will correctly judge my friends pain .
I have found the discussion helpful in highlighting the difficulty of scans in pinpointing the cause of pain and the impact that having one on my friend would have .
I'm.not trying to force treatment on X ( what would that look like ? A straight jacket and a gun to the med professionals head ? ).
I'm trying to prepare myself for a discussion with the hospice about pain management .
And this thread has helped me with that .
Despite all the negative and frankly unsubstantiated accusations .

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 07:07

@kiwiane thank you so much ,your post means the world to.me .
It's so hard supporting my friend and many of the remarks here have had me in tears .
I'm honestly not a bossy ,manipulative ,unpleasant person that HP and co attorneys dread contact with .

OP posts:
AbouttimeIhadanewusername · 02/11/2026 07:08

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 07:04

@AbouttimeIhadanewusername where have I said that she should have treatment ?
I started this thread because I was worried that the hospice would assume any pain was caused by the cancer .
I am.worried about opiods being prescribed and how the hospice will correctly judge my friends pain .
I have found the discussion helpful in highlighting the difficulty of scans in pinpointing the cause of pain and the impact that having one on my friend would have .
I'm.not trying to force treatment on X ( what would that look like ? A straight jacket and a gun to the med professionals head ? ).
I'm trying to prepare myself for a discussion with the hospice about pain management .
And this thread has helped me with that .
Despite all the negative and frankly unsubstantiated accusations .

Sorry but I do think scans come under treatment. I have had a few and they are not pleasant.

Newname26 · 02/11/2026 07:24

Op how do they determine if its dementia or cancer in the brain?
I knew someone who's cancer had spread into the brain causing them to go off on completely crazy tangents very similarly to the way people with altzimers dementia do.

I think your biggest questions have to be is she safe living alone?
A lot of dementia patients become wanderers and get lost, go looking for places that no longer exist. And they can easily leave gas on.

And how do you get her to take the meds?
It does sound like she could benefit from the social work having carers pop in in morning to see she's up and taken meds and the same at bedtime make sure she's actually home.

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 07:29

@AbouttimeIhadanewusername ok ,I understand your view.
I would never try and force my friend to anything - apart from.anything it wouldn't be possible .
I.th8no my opening post has been obscured by many others .
I.wanted to know if it was unreasonable to expect the hospice to scan to.pin point and target the most effective pain relief .
A couple of posters have explained why this wouldn't help and why the hospice has the approach it has .
I've taken this on board and found it helpful .

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 07:31

@Newname26 she has had brain scans .
The pattern they show is indicative of Alzheimer's and not a spread of the cancer .

OP posts:
Newname26 · 02/11/2026 07:37

Right so they have determined she does have dementia. What a sorry state, so many complex things going on.

So how is she being kept safe?
Who's looking after her house?
Would she accept carers a couple of times a day?

Portmore · 02/11/2026 07:40

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 14:36

Three attorneys have H&W Pof A .
We don't agree 😕 - I am in the want diagnostic scans to inform.appropriate pain relief camp .
BUT responses here making me review my thoughts .
one of the stumbling blocks is that X cannot retain and process the info about what " treatment " consists of .
X has it fixed in her mind that it's either surgery or chemo .
These have both been ruled out by the hospital .
A targeted one off session of radiotherapy was done and did,as far as I can tell , relieve pain for about 18 months .

Diagnostic scans don't advise on pain relief.

A hospice specialist nurse would want to treat the pain itself & the person as a whole rather than needing to know the precise underlying causes - A scan is unlikely to give those answers.

Even if you got your way & she had a 'scan' that didn't show anything new - how often would she have to have these 'scans' & how many different types etc.

You need to push for pain management rather than repeated scans. Pain is a complex illness in it's on right - often there is no specific visible 'cause' and the outcome is managing the pain rather than trying to find exactly what causes each pain.

Whenisitsummer · 02/11/2026 08:08

What further treatment did the hospital offer, that your friend has refused?
It's not really clear.
Presumably, with metastatic cancer and a one off palliative radiotherapy session, there was no curative goal.
On balance, further investigations (such as scans) and treatments are unlikely to be in your friend's best interests and may simply cause distress , especially with a dementia diagnosis.
Pain can be managed, irrespective of the cause.
There are specific pain tools that can be used for those suffering with dementia (such as the abbey pain scale).

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 08:34

@Portmore thank you .This has already been covered .
@Whenisitsummer it was at an early appointment when options were being discussed .
It was pointed out that this particular cancer wasn't v responsive to chemo ,and that wasn't on the table .Although my friend didn't take that on board .
One option was cyber knife .

OP posts:
AreYouGoingToBeLong · 02/11/2026 08:49

I’m surprised a chiropractor would be willing to treat someone with spinal met(s?).

Does she have any other gastrointestinal symptoms that might point towards a crohns flare? If so a discussion with GP or consultant re a course of steroids seems reasonable. But if nothing else particularly pointing towards it being a flare of crohns then pain management as per palliative care advice.

If you feel X’s pain has increased since last seen by palliative care then you can ask for referral back to reassess.

MissMoneyFairy · 02/11/2026 09:09

You did say the chiropractor had a copy of her scan and x was having gentle massage which they enjoyed and you didn't think it fair to stop, now you say it's on hold until they have more information. Why are you worried about opiates being prescribed?

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 09:43

Yes ,it's now on hold .I think.nevsusr c.believed a new scan was in the offing .
And possibly because the pain was reported as worse .
As for opiods ,have a Google about them and Alzheimer's.

OP posts:
Yourcousinrachel · 02/11/2026 09:45

HappyViewer · 31/10/2026 23:52

I know, I was genuinely shocked when the OP said in her opinion X didn’t have capacity. She didn’t reply to this.

There seems to be misunderstanding that it is only the job of a trained professional to assess capacity. It isnt. And it isnt as complex as people are saying. Friends and family need to know themselves about capacity, yes, to be able to judge if there is a concern and to alert adult social care for safeguarding purposes. So the OP isnt doing anything wrong in forming her own decision on her friends capacity.

For example, a GP gave my MIL an opioid, when she called them complaining of pain. She had just been released from a rehab unit where they had deliberately weaned her off the opioid as it compromised her cognition further and increased her fall risk. I wrote a complaint pointing out MIL did not understand the risks due to her compromised cognition and did not know it was addictive and no thought had been given to the need for bowel support with opioid medication. Paracetamol was controlling her pain, but the issue was MIL wasnt taking it regularly.

This is what SCIE says

Who should assess capacity?

  • Anyone caring for or supporting a person who may lack capacity could be involved in assessing capacity – follow the two-stage test.
  • The MCA is designed to empower those in health and social care to do capacity assessments themselves, rather than rely on expert testing by psychiatrists or psychologists – good professional training is key.
  • However, in cases involving complex or major decisions you may need to get a professional opinion. This could be a general practitioner (GP) or a specialist (consultant psychiatrist or psychologist)
AreYouGoingToBeLong · 02/11/2026 09:47

I made my first reply before reading on. I’ve now read all of @limetrees32 ‘s responses and I think you’ve been put through the mill a bit on this thread.

To me you come across as a kind, caring friend who is engaged with the relevant medical and legal issues and a critical thinker.

I can fully understand your question about whether another scan could lead to better targeted pain relief and I don’t think it’s unreasonable given the type of cancer your friend has.

For what it’s worth my advice would be:

  1. Your friend has knee pain and a known diagnosis of arthritis. Steroid injections to the joint have worked in the past so it is
    entirely sensible to think they might work again. Very reasonable to ask GP for referral back to rheumatologist to discuss this in more detail.

  2. Your friend’s pain is not adequately controlled with paracetamol alone. This could be because it’s just not strong enough, or it could be because she isn’t taking it regularly enough due to her cognitive decline. This is exactly the sort of thing that should be discussed with the palliative care team. I think my specific questions to them would be - a radiotherapy dose really helped and gave long lasting relief. Could this be repeated? If not why not? (And this should naturally provide you with an answer to the question of whether further scans are useful, because if a targeted therapy such as this is off the table then scans no longer needed). Radiotherapy for pain relief is absolutely within the palliative care remit.

  • friend can’t remember to take her medication and therefore pain isn’t sufficiently controlled. What do they suggest? It may be a low dose of a pain killer patch is helpful, or it may be that there is a local medicines management team in the community who can help with eg alarmed “dosset boxes” or other innovative solutions. These sorts of teams do exist in some areas so worth exploring.

I really do hope you find a way to support your friend to remain as comfortable and as independent as possible for as long as possible.

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 09:53

Thank you @AreYouGoingToBeLong .
Kind of you to take time to post at length with helpful suggestions.

OP posts: