Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting scans to identify source of pain in friend with cancer and dementia.

214 replies

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 14:10

Situation - group of 70 + age friends supporting X a lone mutual friend ( no family ).
X has a soft tissue cancer that has spread .
Hospital has carried out a one off targeted radiotherapy treatment on one site in spine .
X doesn't want more treatment .
Hospital have said no scans because X won't accept treatment .
X has dementia and thinks ,wrongly ,that treatment will be surgery or chemo.
X has some chronic health conditions - Chrons ,arthritis in knees ,painful back .
X often complains of back and knee pain and sometimes pain in lower abdomen.
The problem is that as friends we disagree about the need for investigative scans when X is complaining of pain .
X is not consistent in reporting pain ,when I am with her it can vary over the course of hours to v painful to no reported pain .
Some of us worry that a scan is needed to identify whether pain is caused by one of the chronic conditions or by a new spread .
Could abdomen pain be caused by Chrons or pressure from a new met.?
Is the ongoing back pain worse because X is lonely or walking badly because of arthritic knees .
X has been referred to a hospice by the hospital for future pain relief .
Hospice don't feel scans necessary .
But surely cause of pain needed to determine treatment ?
Unreasonable to want scans ?
Or reasonable to want scans ?

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:09

, "I don't think we should offer suggestions, that needs the pain team."
I only asked because a poster said the attorneys should ensure correct med.intake .
I thought if this was being proposed then some suggestions about how to achieve it should also be given .

OP posts:
Bitsostuff · 31/10/2026 21:10

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 14:29

Really useful replies ,thank you .
At the moment X spends money and I expend time and effort having private chiropractic treatment for back .
If the back pain is caused by a met and is not mechanical the best treatment might be pain medication and advice on how X should be helped to remember to take this .
If the abdominal pain is caused by Chrons rather than a met wouldn't the treatment be different ?
I'm always anxious about advising X to take ibrofruen as I worry about contraindication .

If your friend has crohns then she should definitely not be taking ibuprofen or any other NSAID. They will definitely cause abdominal pain.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:11

@Lastknownaddress read all my posts .

OP posts:
Bababear987 · 31/10/2026 21:12

Honestly theres nothing you or anyone can do.
If she wont accept carers but wont take her medication then its a case of waiting to things get worse and proper care is forced on her when she loses capacity.
If nobody can get her to take paracetamol what use do you think a scan will be? Start with regular paracetamol and work from there .

Lastknownaddress · 31/10/2026 21:14

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:06

We do respect her wishes ,honestly .
But we do try and support her to fully consider things when she's making a choice .
We don't just say " right oh ,no point ringing your surgery because there are no doctors working there ,only nurses that you don't trust "
I wonder how the specialists will consider and manage her bowels and dementia .
I'm.sute they'll do their best but with X living on her own and her hugely impaired ability to consistently and accurately describe her symptoms ,it won't be easy .

No it won't.

Is your underlying concern how much you might have to step in to support? How much pain they will be in? Or the fear of the unknown heading into this?

Dementia UK forum is excellent with specialist advice on there. People who have been through it, and are going through it.

Bitsostuff · 31/10/2026 21:14

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 20:19

I agree ,I tend to think her pain is caused by more than one thing .
She's not seen regularly by rheumatology.
She has to be referred back by her GP .GP ,understandably, thinks that if paracetamol helps then there's no need for a referral .
None of the posts here have explained why an approach of ' she has cancer and pain; lets try pain relief ' is more effective ,a better use of resources than investigating whether the pain is resulting from.something not related to the cancer .
But the hospice are the experts and will have dealt with this before .
The idea that I'm somehow preventing the hospice from doing their job is odd .
I wanted views and I wanted to.understand .
I've been partially successful.

Several posters have explained that scan results are of limited use in explaining the source of pain. And knowing the source will make no difference in how it's controlled in a patient that wants no treatment.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:15

@Bababear987 I can't add anything to my original post .
And if you think proper care can be forced on someone if they have lost capacity you are woefully ill informed .

OP posts:
Lastknownaddress · 31/10/2026 21:15

Oh and one more question - what support do you have in place? Being a carer or a support person, however arms length you are, is tough over the long haul.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:17

@Bitsostuff and I've explained several times why I think investigating the cause might lead to a better outcome .

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:18

@Lastknownaddress I don't think that your question is relevant to.this thread .

OP posts:
Bitsostuff · 31/10/2026 21:18

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:15

@Bababear987 I can't add anything to my original post .
And if you think proper care can be forced on someone if they have lost capacity you are woefully ill informed .

...especially as refusing further treatment is a perfectly valid choice for someone with your friend's health conditions.

HappyViewer · 31/10/2026 21:19

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:15

@Bababear987 I can't add anything to my original post .
And if you think proper care can be forced on someone if they have lost capacity you are woefully ill informed .

It can if that are sectioned.

Bitsostuff · 31/10/2026 21:21

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:17

@Bitsostuff and I've explained several times why I think investigating the cause might lead to a better outcome .

You do but you are not taking into account the discomfort and risks of any medical investigation or the distinct possibility that they won't actually give you any accurate answers or affect pain control options.

MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 21:22

Attorneys do not have to ensure medication is taken, that is not their responsibility, even doctors and nurses can't enforce medication in hospital unless it's in an emergency, life saving or under a section and even then its in the patients best interests only and must be justified. If she doesn't want to take her meds, doesn't want carers, all you can do is let her GP know. Let the doctors worry about managing meds if and when they are prescribed.

Bababear987 · 31/10/2026 21:22

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:15

@Bababear987 I can't add anything to my original post .
And if you think proper care can be forced on someone if they have lost capacity you are woefully ill informed .

Im confused by a lot of your responses tbh. I didnt ask you to add anything to your original post but what is it you actually want?
She has capacity to make these decisions and is living at home and not taking her meds which is her choice, beyond that, theres nothing you can do.
If you are concerned for her welfare then speak to a gp or local adult safe guarding team. But a scan is useless if she wont take her meds anyway and pain is often treated the same way regardless of cause, especially in a patient who wants no further or invasive treatment.
So what is it you want from medical teams? Yes if she gets unwell enough and ends up in hospital she may be assessed as having lost capacity and decisions may need to be made for her but until that point, what you think should happen is unfortunately irrelevant.

HowNowBrownCow33 · 31/10/2026 21:22

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:17

@Bitsostuff and I've explained several times why I think investigating the cause might lead to a better outcome .

But why? You keep saying her pain is wel controlled with paracetemol so how will putting her through a scan change that?

What other treatment do you think anyone is going to offer if paracetemol is doing the job? And who are you expecting to do this scan given the hospital have said its not needed?

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:24

@Bitsostuff you think I'm not taking things into account .
Of course I am ,I'm not an idiot .
A CT scan or an ultrasound might be tolerated .
I don't think an MRi would be .

OP posts:
Bababear987 · 31/10/2026 21:26

HowNowBrownCow33 · 31/10/2026 21:22

But why? You keep saying her pain is wel controlled with paracetemol so how will putting her through a scan change that?

What other treatment do you think anyone is going to offer if paracetemol is doing the job? And who are you expecting to do this scan given the hospital have said its not needed?

Yes if she wont take her paracetamol when shes in pain, why would it matter what a scan says?
Will she take anytbing stronger than paracetamol or will she go for painful invasive treatments..... no. So the scan is not required. Just get her to take paracetamol. If she wont then leave the woman alone and call gp for advice.

Lastknownaddress · 31/10/2026 21:30

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:18

@Lastknownaddress I don't think that your question is relevant to.this thread .

Hmm. So I have read your responses. And honestly I think you have had lots of advice on here, from people who are experienced - either through living through making the tough decisions on behalf of friends and relatives, or professionally. People are trying to be supportive and kind. You don't have to answer my questions, they were rhetorical to try and support you to think through all the reasons behind your concerns. This stuff is tough, you sound incredibly anxious and - honestly - like you are struggling. This is normal and human.

For what it's worth, pain relief is never that targeted. Pharmacologically it is a blunt instrument and biologically further testing and diagnosis won't remove the pain. The only way of doing that would be a course of radiotherapy or chemo, or surgery. None of which will have good outcomes for someone with dementia. Dementia is a systemic disease. It is often comorbid with other conditions but in itself it can cause postural issues, pain issues and all the things you have described your friend as suffering. The Healthcare Professionals will be considering your friends needs on the basis of her total set of diagnoses, and listening to her preferences and wishes, and supporting her to make the best decision in her circumstances. They will / should explore pain relief options, but fundamentally most of the options are paracetamol, NSAIDs or Opiods. There isn't much else out there. They may even recommend medication where there are contraindications on the basis that if she only has a short time left - better to control the immediate pain, than worry about the long term side effects. As someone gets closer to the end it is all about assessing risk, ensuring comfort and supporting decisions and autonomy. Where they feel she lacks capacity they will aim to act in her "Best Interests".

If you truly think that they are not acting in her best interests, or you have remaining questions, then as an PoA you can ask for a best interests meeting, but I suspect from everything you have described the outcome will be the same. But I will bow out now as I don't think you are getting the answers you hope for and it is probably better to speak to healthcare team who can talk you through this than strangers on the Internet.

Wishing you and your friend the very best for what is to come.

MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 21:30

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:24

@Bitsostuff you think I'm not taking things into account .
Of course I am ,I'm not an idiot .
A CT scan or an ultrasound might be tolerated .
I don't think an MRi would be .

But it still involves a hospital trip, laying on a bed or uncomfortable machine that's cold, unfamiliar, unwanted, unnecessary, pointless and won't diagnose the source of her pain. You really need to step back from this suggestion. The doctors won't put in a referral unless they think it will be of benefit. They won't put your friend through a unnecessary procedure because some of her attorneys want it.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:32

I'm weary of correcting all these misstatements .
The hospital haven't said scans aren't needed .
The hospice have and I asked whether I was being reasonable to want scans to identify the cause of the pain Everyone feels that I am because pain is pain and can be treated with no regard to the cause .
I find this puzzling but I'm.not rejecting the conclusion .
I can accept something even though I find it hard to think it's an ideal solution .
For the avoidance of doubt I'm not trying willy nilly for some unknown reason of my own to put my friend through anything .
I'm trying to support her in the best way I can .
Sometimes this involves me questioning what has been presented by professionals as a given .

OP posts:
HappyViewer · 31/10/2026 21:37

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:32

I'm weary of correcting all these misstatements .
The hospital haven't said scans aren't needed .
The hospice have and I asked whether I was being reasonable to want scans to identify the cause of the pain Everyone feels that I am because pain is pain and can be treated with no regard to the cause .
I find this puzzling but I'm.not rejecting the conclusion .
I can accept something even though I find it hard to think it's an ideal solution .
For the avoidance of doubt I'm not trying willy nilly for some unknown reason of my own to put my friend through anything .
I'm trying to support her in the best way I can .
Sometimes this involves me questioning what has been presented by professionals as a given .

97% of us disagree with you.

Bitsostuff · 31/10/2026 21:37

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 21:24

@Bitsostuff you think I'm not taking things into account .
Of course I am ,I'm not an idiot .
A CT scan or an ultrasound might be tolerated .
I don't think an MRi would be .

And are you sure that either of these would show anything conclusive? For crohns you'd be looking at a ct with contrast, an mri with contrast or a coloniscopy/endoscopy - all invasive and uncomfortable.

Hugasaurusrex · 31/10/2026 21:38

HappyViewer · 31/10/2026 21:37

97% of us disagree with you.

Agreed @limetrees32 has that made you revise your opinion or not?

SleepingisanArt · 31/10/2026 21:39

OP knees can definitely cause back and hip pain as your walk changes if your knees hurt. I have chronic knee pain and on some days have to really concentrate so that I don't limp. (Fortunately this problem will be solved 'when' my knee is replaced.) So, if you think her knees could be the problem and your friend agrees, find a physio who is qualified to do guided injections. The steroids (plus some anaesthetic) will give her knees and probably her back some relief.

Medication for someone with dementia is a nightmare unless someone actively gives it to them and makes sure they take it at the right times. My father ended up in A&E because he couldn't remember if he'd taken his tablets so took them. It turned out he took the whole day's worth in one go instead of at three different times so overdosed terribly. He's now in a Nursing home so that's no longer a worry and after his hospital visit he's only on 5 drugs now instead of the 15 or so different tablets his GP had prescribed over the years but never reviewed.... I don't know how you'll solve that one if they won't have carers unless you are prepared to take it on.....