Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting scans to identify source of pain in friend with cancer and dementia.

214 replies

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 14:10

Situation - group of 70 + age friends supporting X a lone mutual friend ( no family ).
X has a soft tissue cancer that has spread .
Hospital has carried out a one off targeted radiotherapy treatment on one site in spine .
X doesn't want more treatment .
Hospital have said no scans because X won't accept treatment .
X has dementia and thinks ,wrongly ,that treatment will be surgery or chemo.
X has some chronic health conditions - Chrons ,arthritis in knees ,painful back .
X often complains of back and knee pain and sometimes pain in lower abdomen.
The problem is that as friends we disagree about the need for investigative scans when X is complaining of pain .
X is not consistent in reporting pain ,when I am with her it can vary over the course of hours to v painful to no reported pain .
Some of us worry that a scan is needed to identify whether pain is caused by one of the chronic conditions or by a new spread .
Could abdomen pain be caused by Chrons or pressure from a new met.?
Is the ongoing back pain worse because X is lonely or walking badly because of arthritic knees .
X has been referred to a hospice by the hospital for future pain relief .
Hospice don't feel scans necessary .
But surely cause of pain needed to determine treatment ?
Unreasonable to want scans ?
Or reasonable to want scans ?

OP posts:
fdsllp · 31/10/2026 22:25

You are clearly trying to advocate for a friend you care deeply for. More investigations don’t sound warranted, but finding a reliable means of pain relief for her is where to direct your efforts.

I also don’t think seeing a chiropractor is sensible in a situation where bone mets are likely.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 22:27

@Bababear987 for the hundredth time I don't want X to have further treatment for her cancer .
My aim is that she receives the best palliative care .
In the past she didn't make a sensible decision about treatment because she believed that this would involve chemo and long courses of radiotherapy This was not on offer .
It's too late now .
If you think not understanding what the hospital have said to her and basing her decision on the wrong information means that she had capacity then I can only disagree .

OP posts:
MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 22:29

You are not in a position to decide if she has capacity or not regarding treatment, you can tell her medical team your opinion but it's not your decision to make and h&w decisions cannot be made until capacity is lost. The health professionals can assess her capacity to make decisions about scans, medication or treatment in discussion with her, if she doesnt want to see a doctor what do you think you could do? Who do you think is going to take a terminally ill vulnerable person to hospital against their woll and the hospice medics advice. What treatment do you think she should have?

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 22:31

X doesn't have spinal.cancer ,as said she has a cancer that affects soft and connective tissue .

OP posts:
MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 22:33

But it spread to her spine so she also has cancer in her spine

magnoliagardenialilac · 31/10/2026 22:39

It's not so much that I'm pushing for treatment although I can't get away from.the.fact that a scan showed a met on the spine and a one off radiotherapy treatment was carried out to slow spread and relieve pain .

The spread to her spine was identified by. CT scan .

Past, present, or future spinal mets - stay away from the chiropractor.

magnoliagardenialilac · 31/10/2026 22:39

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 22:31

X doesn't have spinal.cancer ,as said she has a cancer that affects soft and connective tissue .

Seriously. I feel for the other POAs.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 22:39

Yes ,but it's not spinal.cancer .
This is relevant .It isn't in her bones it's in the surrounding tissue .
Ive said that in my view when she decided against treatment (active treatment ,not palliative ) she didn't have capacity .
We all try very hard to reassure X when it's something important about seeing a doctor .
We do our best to help her attend it's not a question of forcing her against her will m

OP posts:
jacks11 · 31/10/2026 22:42

@limetrees32

In response to your question of why not do a scan help decide on treatment, I’ll try to give you a clinically reasoned answer (I’m a Dr).

Patients and families often, wrongly (if understandably) think scans will give clear cut answers. Sometimes they do, often it just isn’t that simple. And this is especially true for pain. Pain is a complex thing- scans can give information but can also give lots of red herrings too. For example, the correlation between pain and degree of degenerative change on x-ray is simply not linear. You can look at an X-ray of a knee, hip or back and think “that’s advanced osteoarthritis, that should be very sore”, but actually the patient is doing quite well, and sometimes much earlier stage changes on x-ray to do not correlate to mild pain.

At your friends age she is likely to have osteoarthritis (“wear and tear” arthritis)- but you said she has also seen a rheumatologist so either has, or was suspected to have some form of inflammatory arthropathy- if this is the case and she has both then an X-ray will not tell you which is causing the pain. A blood test might tell you if her inflammatory markers are elevated….. but again, she has confounding factors which can also cause raises inflammatory markers (having cancer can itself cause raised inflammatory markers. as can crohn’s and increasing age). What I’m trying to say is it is entirely possible, even likely, that a scan will simply not give a key to find a magic bullet for her pain- even should it show something. We treat patients and symptoms, not scans (or we should, at least)- scan can inform treatment but they aren’t the be all and end all.

Truthfully, when patients are palliative (that does not necessarily mean death is imminent, more that treatment is not curative) symptom control is perfectly possible without knowing exactly what is happening or why. It can take a bit of trial and error to find the right analgesia/combination that controls pain adequately, but with tolerable side-effects (and obviously this usually changes as disease progresses).

This is a highly patient dependent, not scan dependent or disease dependent process, for the most part. Other than neuropathic pain- which is generally distinguishable from the description of the pain and does have agents that work better for this than opiates or anti-inflammatories (as a rule, though not everyone tolerated them)- there is not a painkiller for “arthritis” and a different painkiller for “bone pain”, another for “lung cancer” and so on. It’s the history. character, location and duration of pain that inform treatment most.

In cases like your friend’s, where no further active treatment for the cancer is going to be undertaken, it genuinely makes little odds if it is bone mets, OA in the knee or referred pain from the hip or compensatory movement patterns. The painkillers used are the same.

It is not unusual to trial some treatments- e.g. give the steroid injection into a sore knee to see if it helps (if safe to do so)a But it depends how sore she is. It might just be on bad days she has an extra painkiller to take, in addition to her paracetamol. A scan won’t help you decide any of this because it may not give you a definitive answer, and even if it did show cancer progression or a new bone met, the reality is that the treatment options don’t change given your friend has declined further cancer treatment.

HappyViewer · 31/10/2026 22:44

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 22:39

Yes ,but it's not spinal.cancer .
This is relevant .It isn't in her bones it's in the surrounding tissue .
Ive said that in my view when she decided against treatment (active treatment ,not palliative ) she didn't have capacity .
We all try very hard to reassure X when it's something important about seeing a doctor .
We do our best to help her attend it's not a question of forcing her against her will m

You cant just decide she didn’t or doesn’t have capacity with regard to this.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 22:58

@jacks11 thank you for your long post .
You make points that others have also made and I do.understand them and have found such helpful .

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 23:05

Off to bed now so you can all stop.worryimg about my fellow attorneys ,my cruelty to X ,my real motives ,my understanding of dementia and capacity ,and my pushy nature .
I'asked if I was being unreasonable and believe it or not.have found the responses informative .
Bit surprised by some of the assumptions but it's an internet thread and by it's nature relies on people assuming things .

OP posts:
TwitchyNibbles · 31/10/2026 23:18

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 22:39

Yes ,but it's not spinal.cancer .
This is relevant .It isn't in her bones it's in the surrounding tissue .
Ive said that in my view when she decided against treatment (active treatment ,not palliative ) she didn't have capacity .
We all try very hard to reassure X when it's something important about seeing a doctor .
We do our best to help her attend it's not a question of forcing her against her will m

Unfortunately if it was in the surrounding spinal tissue (or even organs sitting close to the spine) there is a very high chance that it will spread to the bones, if it hasn't already.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 23:29

I can only say that that's not what we've been told by the hospital treating her .

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 23:41

But it sounds likely to me 😞

OP posts:
magnoliagardenialilac · 31/10/2026 23:45

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 23:41

But it sounds likely to me 😞

Please acknowledge that you will cease taking her to the chiropractor, regardless.

BurnoutGP · 31/10/2026 23:48

Why dont you listen to the HCP clearly making sensible decisions and the POA who get to make those decisions. You sound utterly painful and using AI to make medical decisions. Does she actually have crohns? Or has AI ddcided she does? Just stop. You're making it worse trust me.

BurnoutGP · 31/10/2026 23:51

Lots of lay people think they can decide about "capacity" just because someone is not doing what they want/believe. Capacity is a very complex area that very experienced trained professional have difficulty with. So maybe leave it to the professionals.
Making unwise decisions doesn't mean you lack capacity just for info.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 23:52

@BurnoutGP .?
I've not asked or involved AI in any way .
Yes she has a Chrons dx.
What HCP and what decision ?

OP posts:
HappyViewer · 31/10/2026 23:52

BurnoutGP · 31/10/2026 23:51

Lots of lay people think they can decide about "capacity" just because someone is not doing what they want/believe. Capacity is a very complex area that very experienced trained professional have difficulty with. So maybe leave it to the professionals.
Making unwise decisions doesn't mean you lack capacity just for info.

I know, I was genuinely shocked when the OP said in her opinion X didn’t have capacity. She didn’t reply to this.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 23:54

I'm.allowed to have a view on capacity .
The professionals have passed no view on Xs capacity .

OP posts:
BurnoutGP · 31/10/2026 23:55

No i am afraid legally you do not. You can ask for a capacity assessment though from someone who is trained to do so.

magnoliagardenialilac · 31/10/2026 23:57

I think dealing with this level of ignorance, stubbornness and pushback - even as the OP claims she has "accepted" various points posters have made - must be a nightmare for the other POAs and any medical professionals encountered, even the slightly daffy sounding GP.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 23:59

I did respond ,I said
" If you think not understanding what the hospital have said to her and basing her decision on the wrong information means that she had capacity then I can only disagree ."
I'm don't know why there is shock that I have a view about capacity .
If you read some of the threads about elderly parents or relatives with dementia you'll find it's common to.make pass a view on someone's capacity .

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 00:02

It's illegal to have a view about someone's capacity ?
Have you a link to the legal ruling on this ?

OP posts: