Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting scans to identify source of pain in friend with cancer and dementia.

214 replies

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 14:10

Situation - group of 70 + age friends supporting X a lone mutual friend ( no family ).
X has a soft tissue cancer that has spread .
Hospital has carried out a one off targeted radiotherapy treatment on one site in spine .
X doesn't want more treatment .
Hospital have said no scans because X won't accept treatment .
X has dementia and thinks ,wrongly ,that treatment will be surgery or chemo.
X has some chronic health conditions - Chrons ,arthritis in knees ,painful back .
X often complains of back and knee pain and sometimes pain in lower abdomen.
The problem is that as friends we disagree about the need for investigative scans when X is complaining of pain .
X is not consistent in reporting pain ,when I am with her it can vary over the course of hours to v painful to no reported pain .
Some of us worry that a scan is needed to identify whether pain is caused by one of the chronic conditions or by a new spread .
Could abdomen pain be caused by Chrons or pressure from a new met.?
Is the ongoing back pain worse because X is lonely or walking badly because of arthritic knees .
X has been referred to a hospice by the hospital for future pain relief .
Hospice don't feel scans necessary .
But surely cause of pain needed to determine treatment ?
Unreasonable to want scans ?
Or reasonable to want scans ?

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 00:08

With regard to the chiropractor,he has had a copy of the scan showing the lesion on Xs back .
He does gentle massage .
X enjoys it and always comes out in a good mood declaring that her back feels better .
She would be very upset if I told her she couldn't attend and if I didn't take her she would try and make her own way there and get lost .
I don't feel this is something I should try and dissuade her from.doing and hard as you may find it to believe I try to respect her and her wishes .

OP posts:
BurnoutGP · 01/11/2026 00:10

Oh dear you really are one of those aren't you. You just know better than everyone else even the trained professionals.
I didn't say it was illegal. But for medical/legal/financial decisions then the assessment should be carried out by someone trained to do so.
For basic decisions like "do you want a bath", " do you want a cuppa" then yiu just crack on.
But as yiu have neither POA/medical training then I am afraid no you do not get to decide.
https://www.mind.org.uk/information-support/legal-rights/mental-capacity-act-2005/about-the-mental-capacity-act/

PollyBell · 01/11/2026 00:10

Op there is trying to genuinely help and there is trying to take over and control try and reach a better balance, maybe it is just your posting style

magnoliagardenialilac · 01/11/2026 00:11

limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 00:08

With regard to the chiropractor,he has had a copy of the scan showing the lesion on Xs back .
He does gentle massage .
X enjoys it and always comes out in a good mood declaring that her back feels better .
She would be very upset if I told her she couldn't attend and if I didn't take her she would try and make her own way there and get lost .
I don't feel this is something I should try and dissuade her from.doing and hard as you may find it to believe I try to respect her and her wishes .

He does no "adjustments"?

But as you say, no recent/further scans have been done. How would he know where or if her cancer has since metastasised to?

I am glad she enjoys the massage, but a qualified masseur would be better.

limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 00:14

In response to.my " I'm.allowed to have a view ,you said
No i am afraid legally you do not.
That's not saying it's illegal ?
Right oh.

OP posts:
magnoliagardenialilac · 01/11/2026 00:16

limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 00:14

In response to.my " I'm.allowed to have a view ,you said
No i am afraid legally you do not.
That's not saying it's illegal ?
Right oh.

No. It is not saying it is illegal.

You are using language and terms you do not understand.

limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 00:21

@magnoliagardenialilac X trusts and likes and respects the practitioner .
She has been visiting him.for years .
He is well known with decades of experience
@PollyBell what have I tried to control ?
Or take over ?

@BurnoutGP I do have power of attorney but ,as I'm sure you know ,that wouldn't give me the power to decide about capacity .
Have a view ,yes .Express that view ,yes .
Complete a capacity assessment,no .

OP posts:
magnoliagardenialilac · 01/11/2026 00:24

So, she is mentally equipped to discern what is best for her when it comes to a chiropractor, but not when it comes to any other part of her health?

limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 00:24

magnoliagardenialilac · Today 00:16

limetrees32 · Today 00:14

In response to.my " I'm.allowed to have a view ,you said
No i am afraid legally you do not.
That's not saying it's illegal ?
Right oh.

No. It is not saying it is illegal -!you've lost me there Burnt out .

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 00:29

@magnoliagardenialilac capacity is decision dependent .
So yes it's possible for someone to lack capacity about one thing but to have it with regard to another .
X is relaxed with the chiropractor,she knows him.well.and he is familiar with him .
She doesn't need to follow any complex talk about her cancer not being responsive to chemo .She can absorb and consider the information he gives her .

OP posts:
HappyViewer · 01/11/2026 08:11

limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 00:14

In response to.my " I'm.allowed to have a view ,you said
No i am afraid legally you do not.
That's not saying it's illegal ?
Right oh.

You said much earlier on that X did not have capacity when they said they didn’t want treatment and then in later posts when challenged you addded the ‘in my view’.

HappyViewer · 01/11/2026 08:14

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 20:41

@HappyViewer She didn't have capacity when she decided not to have treatment .
She did agree to the palliative one off radiotherapy session.
I don't think there was anything that could be offered so I don't think her lack of capacity matters .
I do see that pain can be treated regardless of cause .
I feel I should apologise for worrying that pain relief will be given when another approach might be more appropriate.
And that side effects will not be helpful for her bowels or dementia .
But that's just me .

You said she didn’t have capacity, in this post, you can’t just say things like this if no formal capacity test has been carried out.

limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 09:08

Well it looks as though I can ,doesn't it ?
Will you be reporting me to.the thought police ?

OP posts:
LIZS · 01/11/2026 10:53

You can’t use POA if she still has capacity, that is a legal issue. You also still have to respect her wishes and interests, so cannot force her to accept treatment,

limetrees32 · 01/11/2026 10:56

@LIZS thank you ,I'm aware .
Of course I and the other attorneys respect her wishes .
There is,and never has been, any question of trying to force her to accept treatment .
FFS

OP posts:
HowNowBrownCow33 · 01/11/2026 15:04

Presumably the medical professionals did deem her to have capacity to decline treatment for her cancer, and presumably they also considered this to be in her best interests.

Its very unlikely that when presented with a dementia patient declining treatment for cancer, the consultant just completely ignored capacity. Especially given you say it was active treatment that didnt involve either a long course or chemo, radio or surgery I.e it sounds very treatable?

If your issue is that your friends pain is poorly controlled and you think she needs better care, thats entirely reasonable. And you should chase that up with the hospice team. Whether she needs a scan or not is a medical decision and is by the by.

Bababear987 · 01/11/2026 17:43

OP my god you are so rude and so overly confident about things you do not understand.
You've contradicted yourself so much in this post as well. If this is the way you carry on with professionals, God help them but id be concerned.
You have no issue giving someone with crohns ibuprofen or taking a person with dementia and cancer in her spine to a chiropractor BUT the actual medical professionals you dont trust?

You are not acting in her best interests at all.

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 04:03

My friend was prescribed ibrofruen .My concern is about her taking it .
The chiropractor has stopped treating her until he has more information about the Mets.
My friend told him ( incorrectly ) that she had an upcoming scan appointment .
Where have I said that I don't trust medical professionals?

OP posts:
whyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhy · 02/11/2026 04:57

She’s deemed to have capacity so these aren’t your decisions to make. Perhaps you need to take a step back

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 05:53

@whyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhy My friend has had no formal capacity assessment.
The team treating her cancer obviously felt that this wasn't necessary and responded to her as if she had capacity .
She can present very well over a short period of time .
She came out of the appointment with not only no clear understanding of what had been discussed but quoting completely erroneous " facts ".
She referred to an image that was shown ( of the area of concern in her spine ) as showing two spots in her liver .
And went on to say that as she has liver cancer and " you can't live without your liver " further treatment was pointless.
She believed that she had had chemo at this hospital .
She hadn't .
In my judgement she was unable to retain what was said to her or to make an informed decision .Posters can jump up and down and scream at me that I have no business forming this opinion but what would their conclusion be ?

OP posts:
magnoliagardenialilac · 02/11/2026 06:00

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 04:03

My friend was prescribed ibrofruen .My concern is about her taking it .
The chiropractor has stopped treating her until he has more information about the Mets.
My friend told him ( incorrectly ) that she had an upcoming scan appointment .
Where have I said that I don't trust medical professionals?

The chiropractor has stopped treating her until he has more information about the Mets.

Well, that is not what you said some hours ago:

With regard to the chiropractor,he has had a copy of the scan showing the lesion on Xs back .
He does gentle massage .
X enjoys it and always comes out in a good mood declaring that her back feels better .
She would be very upset if I told her she couldn't attend and if I didn't take her she would try and make her own way there and get lost .

limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 06:05

@whyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhy your remark " these aren't your decisions to make " shows what little understanding you have of capacity and being an attorney .
Even if a capacity assessment had been completed and she was judged not to have capacity to make this particular decision ,in a circumstance like this noone would be making decisions for her .
if she lacked capacity and it was a question of life or limb ,some imminent danger might be a different case .
My brother ,on a section 3 in a psychiatric hospital ,still had the right to have his wishes about ECT considered .
Medical professionals have to consider a person's wishes even when they lack capacity .
They must take into account the person's wishes expressed before they lost capacity .
My role as an attorney is to represent and advocate for my friend .To respect her choices .
And I am well aware ( and do not need some snarky reminder ) that this includes respecting my friends right to make unwise decisions and ones that I do not agree with .

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 06:10

No it's not what I said the other day - not because I'm a lying ,devious person but because I was only told this last night by one of the other attorneys who had taken her for an appointment on Saturday.
Apparently X told the chiropractor that she had an appointment next week at local hospital for a scan of her back ( she doesn't ).and he said he would wait for the report before future appointments .
Where have I said that I don't trust medical professionals?

OP posts:
limetrees32 · 02/11/2026 06:18

Many of the remarks aimed at me on here " using AI and not understanding the words " and the assumption that I am.trying to force X to do things against her wishes ,that I am.making decisions on her behalf ,that i.am.irrrsponsible ( for worrying about whether she should take the ibrofruen prescribed by the rheumatologist )
are so far from.the reality .
I'm appreciate that this is an internet forum and that people can and will judge me on the limited information that I can put here .
But TBH the negativity and assumption of continual wrong doing by me is quite alarming .

OP posts:
magnoliagardenialilac · 02/11/2026 06:20

Where have I said that I don't trust medical professionals?

This entire thread is you not trusting medical professionals! Apart from chiropractors.