Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting scans to identify source of pain in friend with cancer and dementia.

214 replies

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 14:10

Situation - group of 70 + age friends supporting X a lone mutual friend ( no family ).
X has a soft tissue cancer that has spread .
Hospital has carried out a one off targeted radiotherapy treatment on one site in spine .
X doesn't want more treatment .
Hospital have said no scans because X won't accept treatment .
X has dementia and thinks ,wrongly ,that treatment will be surgery or chemo.
X has some chronic health conditions - Chrons ,arthritis in knees ,painful back .
X often complains of back and knee pain and sometimes pain in lower abdomen.
The problem is that as friends we disagree about the need for investigative scans when X is complaining of pain .
X is not consistent in reporting pain ,when I am with her it can vary over the course of hours to v painful to no reported pain .
Some of us worry that a scan is needed to identify whether pain is caused by one of the chronic conditions or by a new spread .
Could abdomen pain be caused by Chrons or pressure from a new met.?
Is the ongoing back pain worse because X is lonely or walking badly because of arthritic knees .
X has been referred to a hospice by the hospital for future pain relief .
Hospice don't feel scans necessary .
But surely cause of pain needed to determine treatment ?
Unreasonable to want scans ?
Or reasonable to want scans ?

OP posts:
MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 15:09

Nearly50omg · 31/10/2026 15:02

Waste of medical time if the persons refusing treatment!

And the patients, being taken to hospital, having a cannula maybe with fluids and a dye, any prep, waiting around, laying on a cold trolley, being unable to eat or drink, waiting to go home, not being able to consent, is it always in the patients best interests.

LIZS · 31/10/2026 15:21

Scans themselves carry risks and require the cooperation of the patient to stay still. If they do not want treatment there is little point in forcing the issue when pain management is available. This decision would be considered by a mdt not just on the say so of one doctor.

MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 15:22

turkeyboots · 31/10/2026 14:50

No ibuprofen or any NSAID for someone with Crohn's. Ever.
Crohn's is treated with steroids, immunosuppressants or biological medicines, and your friend should have a Gastro consultant or a knowledgeable GP at least to manage it.
If the chiropractor is helping her feel better, let it be. It won't cure anything but hands on treatment is a great placebo.

Edited

Hands on is OK as long as it doesn't involve any known areas of disease or weak inflamed areas

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 15:46

Thanks all .
It's not so much that I'm pushing for treatment although I can't get away from.the.fact that a scan showed a met on the spine and a one off radiotherapy treatment was carried out to slow spread and relieve pain .
So it's hard to rule out a repeat ,especially as X can't consider this as she can't remember the treatment and thinks it will involve chemo .
What I do want is the most effective pain management and I don't understand how this is possible without narrowing down what is causing the pain .
The main pains mentioned by X relate toher knees and back .
Past rheumatology appointments have successfully treated this with steroid injections .
It was also suggested that knee pain affected how X walked and that back pain was a result .
Which makes me think that a scan would identify a further spread which could be managed by appropriate pain relief or rule out a further spread in which case we could push for another steroid injection .
I'm.not wanting chemo / lengthy radiation / immunotherapy : I just want the best targeted approach to manage the pain .
The hospice must have experience of dementia and multiple conditions and I must have confidence that they will know how to deal .
It's my problem I think that I don't understand how they target pain when they are not clear about the cause .
And of course I respect X's stated wishes .
But it's difficult when they are not based on the facts ( ie a scan will lead to chemo.and surgery)
I want the best for her .
I don't automatically agree when X tells me there's no point having a COVID and flu injection because she's got cancer and is dying .or that there are no.doctors at her surgery so it's pointless making an appointment ,or that there's no point eating because she's dying .etc etc .
And I feel the same about this - accepting her right to chose but trying to help her find the best course of action .
For her ,not me .

OP posts:
MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 15:47

LIZS · 31/10/2026 15:21

Scans themselves carry risks and require the cooperation of the patient to stay still. If they do not want treatment there is little point in forcing the issue when pain management is available. This decision would be considered by a mdt not just on the say so of one doctor.

With so many physical problems where would you even start with scans, spine, knees, neck, abdo, a full body mri?

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 15:48

I think the back would be the most obvious one .

OP posts:
MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 15:53

The pain team and palliative care will treat pain without a diagnosis for someone who is nearing the end of their life, they try a combination of meds until the patient either says they are comfortable or they seem comfortable, your friend had a one off dxt a long time ago, it was palliative treatment which worked for a while but it sounds like her illness is progressing, if there was treatment available they would have offered a course of dxt, chemo or surgery then, not just a one off.

HowNowBrownCow33 · 31/10/2026 16:11

Well firstly Im assuming X doesnt have capacity? And cannot be helped to gain capacity?

If shes been referred to hospice for pain management it sounds like palliative treatment for the cancer, it sounds like the hospital dont think theres much else they would offer to treat it at this stage. At which point are the scans going to change anything? If paracetemol controls the pain then take paracetamol, it doesnt matter why the pain is happening.

If the hospital and hospice thought a scan was in x's best interests they would do it. Is a scan even an option? What scans are we talking, would X tolerate it? An MRI or a PET scan?

A "scan" is just very vague and you cant just have a scan if the hospital dont think its necessary.

Lastknownaddress · 31/10/2026 16:23

Sorry for the difficult situation you are in. Dementia can also cause pain, mask pain and change the presentation of pain. It doesn't always primarily effect memory. My relative has atypical Alzheimers which is effecting their movement and pain sensing far more than their memory.

The kindest thing to do would be to be advocate on her behalf to get the right pain relief and care at the right time. She has made her decision (and honestly I can understand why, dementia is cruel).

TwitchyNibbles · 31/10/2026 16:29

There really isn't any point to a scan if it isn't going to influence treatment. Which your friend doesn't want. And which frankly may not exist beyond a certain point unfortunately.
If your friend has Crohns they shouldn't be taking NSAIDs at all.
Is the chiropractor performing spinal manipulations/corrections? This is a big no no if there is active cancer due to the possibility of spinal mets, (especially if they have been seen previously) which could develop at any time. Scanning now doesn't mean one wouldn't develop in a few months/weeks. How often would you have to repeat scans to check this? Soft tissue massage etc should be fine if done gently.

Also scans don't magically show you the cause of all pain - the body and nervous system is far more complicated than that. Loads of people with really severe back pain have scans that are unremarkable. They don't tell the whole story.
Many scans have complications/limitations - MRI's can be quite horrendous if someone is even slightly claustrophobic. CT/x-rays/PET scans give further doses of radiation. Ultrasounds only really show soft tissue abnormalities. Non of them are likely to give you a definitive answer, especially if the pain is very variable - edited to add or if the patient is not the most reliable historian due to their mental capacity.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 16:34

but it sounds like her illness is progressing, if there was treatment available they would have offered a course of dxt, chemo or surgery then, not just a one off.
Yes ,I imagine the disease is progressing .
One off treatments is something they offer to slow growth of some mets in this cancer .
I don't know on what basis you are declaring that if treatment were available they would have offered a course of radiotherapy not a one off .
Or is it just semantics - the difference between treatment and palliative care .

OP posts:
99doubledeckerbuses · 31/10/2026 16:35

OP,

Have you ever had a MRI of your spine? I have. You're usually in the scanner for around an hour. There is also the chance that depending on the type of scan they will use contrast medium as well which involves having a canula placed.
When you're in the MRI scanner itself, it isn't much fun. It's vvvv claustrophobic and vvvv noisy. And you must stay absolutely and totally still and not move anything.

Is someone who has dementia really going to a) understand all of the above, b) understand why they need a MRI scan and c) lie still for as long as it takes? By the sounds of what you have described she wouldnt be able to consent to the scan in the first place?

And to what purpose? If her treating team had already decided she isn't for any further treatment then is a scan really going to be of any benefit or is it more likely to be distressing? If it is to guide pain relief then there are already recognised tools for identification of pain in patients with dementia. Especially if they are not able to consistently verbalise pain. The hospice will know about them.
Don't discount the role of regular paracetamol either as opposed to it taken 'as and when'. It's always easier to prevent pain than cure pain. Paracetamol can often (in my experience) be really good at this. Again, the hospice will know this.

MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 16:38

When did she have the one off, it's given for pain and it worked for 18 months but that must have been a while ago. It wasn't a cancer treatment to get rid of the cancer, it sounds like it was used for palliative reasons, if they thought the cancer could be treated they would offer a course of dxt, chemo or surgery.

EatenTooMuchChocolateAgain · 31/10/2026 16:43

I understand it’s a difficult situation for you all. As her dementia progresses I’d imagine any treatment for all the other conditions will get harder for her to tolerate and also you supporting her to comply. How advanced is her dementia now? End stages of dementia are awful and if you read the posts on the elderly parents board on here you’ll see that often an earlier release managed by hospice care and medication to manage symptoms might be the kinder thing that struggling through years of treatments for cancer and having to endure the end stages of dementia. It’s a very difficult decision but ultimately I think there’s very little you can do except support her decisions.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 16:46

Absolutely " scan " is such a vague term .
Apologies.
I think at this stage a CT ot ultrasound might ,for instance,help identify a spread and provide an answer about whether the back pain is related to this or is X's chronic pain aggravated by her knees .
I agree MRIs are less well tolerated ,probably necessary when originally diagnosing the cancer but not needed now .
Again ,in case I'm being unclear ,I'm absolutely not trying to push for treatment but for the best ,most effective pain relief .
X loves independently,goes out ,shops .
I've no idea how much longer she has to enjoy this .
X advised the hospital that she didn't want treatment so they advised that she should seek support from a hospice .
They didn't refer her because there was nothing they could do ( although without her consent of course there was nothing they could do ) or because they judged her to be end of life .

OP posts:
turkeyboots · 31/10/2026 16:57

I now half think you are supporting my mother! The refusal of treatment, refusing to eat and "I'll be dead soon so why bother" all sound very familiar. Its very hard supporting someone towards the end of their life, especially when you don't agree with their decisions.

Make sure you are looking after yourself as dementia is hard on everyone involved. As long as shes getting enjoyment out of as much as possible, I think you should step back a bit and try and be a friend and not a carer. You are doing a really lovely thing, but it will eat you whole if you don't look after yourself.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 17:26

@99doubledeckerbuses as it happens ,yes * have had an MRI of my spine .
Horrible and much good it did me !
The spread to her spine was identified by. CT scan .

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 31/10/2026 17:36

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 14:36

Three attorneys have H&W Pof A .
We don't agree 😕 - I am in the want diagnostic scans to inform.appropriate pain relief camp .
BUT responses here making me review my thoughts .
one of the stumbling blocks is that X cannot retain and process the info about what " treatment " consists of .
X has it fixed in her mind that it's either surgery or chemo .
These have both been ruled out by the hospital .
A targeted one off session of radiotherapy was done and did,as far as I can tell , relieve pain for about 18 months .

Regardless as to what LPAs state, ultimately the medical team will determine the best course of action. They are the experts.

jacks11 · 31/10/2026 17:38

YABU

In this situation, “scans” are not going to change the treatment as patient has made their wishes about further treatment clear. I also suspect that even if something else were to be found that your friend may not be medically fit for more invasive treatment. If symptom control is the extent of treatment, then that is the focus. The hospice palliative care team are absolutely the right people to help with this.

The “why” is irrelevant, really, at this point. I understand the desire to know, but I think you are beyond that at this stage in your friends illness.

And, being very blunt- it would be a waste of resources, because no matter what the scan shows it will not inform treatment.

Besides which, spinal or bony mets vs arthritis quite probably does not require a CT/MRI or PET scan- x-ray might miss very small bony lesions but would pick up anything significant. Obviously not so good for most soft tissue lesions, though. But again- if your friend has ruled out further treatment for any disease spread, what does it change?

MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 17:43

A scan won't identify where the pain is though , it may show a spread in her spine which could be causing pain or it could be her knees , chrone, or chronic pain. Pain is what a person, not a machine, says it is. I only know what I would so which would be ask if there will be a mdt, go if you have questions, ask about her prognosis and sympton management and future palliative care. .it's difficult to see someone you care for struggling but the doctors and health professionals will have the final say and I wouldn't put her through any more tests.

stichguru · 31/10/2026 18:02

Oh OP what an awful situation to be in. Honestly, if your friend doesn't want further curative treatment, I'm not sure that scans will be useful. It is unlikely that pain relief for a certain type of pain will HAVE to be vastly different from pain relief for a different type of pain. In palliative care, they have good strong pain relief that will work on many types of pain. Get a palliative care team involved if one isn't already.

HowNowBrownCow33 · 31/10/2026 18:13

Presumably the Dr's deemed her to have capacity when she declined treatment?

Honestly I think this is a pointless conversation, shes not been offered scans. Your friend doesnt want treatment. Its just a lot of what ifs but it doesn't sound like scans are available to your friend.

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 19:31

Im not saying that I think X should have a scan ( of any kind ) so that she can have treatment for the disease .
I'm puzzled that treating pain does not involve finding out whether it's the cancer causing the pain .
Giving pain relief when ,for example ,arguing for steroid injections for painful knees might be a better use of resources and have less side effects than medication to.comyrol.pain .
She has not refused to have scans ,the hospital treating her have discharged her because she does not want treatment .
They do not see their remit as discussing palliative care .

OP posts:
MissMoneyFairy · 31/10/2026 19:42

Because a scan will not diagnose pain, she could have spread in her spine, she could have bad knees, the scan won't differentiate, how could it? She could have pain in her spine and her back, a steroid injection won't cure that, she doesn't need a scan for a steroid injection in her knee. The hospice and pain specialists are the experts, they can try different meds, steroids, alternative therapies to treat her pain. Are you concerned about side effects? You need to let the hospice team take over.

Auroraloves · 31/10/2026 19:50

limetrees32 · 31/10/2026 19:31

Im not saying that I think X should have a scan ( of any kind ) so that she can have treatment for the disease .
I'm puzzled that treating pain does not involve finding out whether it's the cancer causing the pain .
Giving pain relief when ,for example ,arguing for steroid injections for painful knees might be a better use of resources and have less side effects than medication to.comyrol.pain .
She has not refused to have scans ,the hospital treating her have discharged her because she does not want treatment .
They do not see their remit as discussing palliative care .

Where is her pain? Is ot the same place where she had her previous radiotherapy treatment? There are rules around how many radiotherapy courses a patient can have.

Does your friend still see the consultant regularly? Could you attend a consultation with her and ask these questions? There are also roles about how many scans are permitted

Swipe left for the next trending thread