Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that I think Catherine of Aragon slept with Arthur

171 replies

achristmaswish · 25/10/2026 00:27

AIBU to think Catherine of Aragon did sleep with her first husband, Arthur?

I’ve been reading about Catherine of Aragon and her first marriage to Arthur, Prince of Wales, and I’m curious what other people think.

Arthur apparently said something along the lines of “I was in Spain last night” after their wedding night, which has always made me wonder whether they did consummate the marriage.

I know Catherine maintained that her marriage to Arthur had never been consummated, which later became hugely important when Henry VIII wanted to marry her.

But here’s what I don’t understand. After Arthur died in 1502, Catherine was left waiting to see whether she was pregnant. Surely, if they had never slept together, wouldn’t she have said so at the time? Why would there have been any uncertainty about a possible pregnancy?

I know there are arguments on both sides, and obviously we can’t know for certain what happened between them behind closed doors.

So, AIBU to think that Catherine and Arthur probably did sleep together, and that Catherine’s later insistence that they hadn’t was influenced by the circumstances surrounding her marriage to Henry VIII?

I’d love to hear what other history buffs think!

OP posts:
PunchSide · 26/10/2026 00:54

you never know I guess

fletcheronastretcher · 26/10/2026 05:31

I mean, we'll never know for sure but I think it's much more likely that she did. And I find it hard to believe that the daughter of two of history's most ruthless, calculating and arguably murderous rulers would have grown up to be truly saintly regardless of the image she portrayed to the outside world - even if she had some real and genuine religious convictions like her parents (who despite being very pious in some ways, used systemic state violence, political executions and religious persecution to achieve their objectives and maintain their iron grip on power). Or that she ever believed that her soul was truly at any real risk for telling a lie under oath given the many feats of spectacular and very strategic dishonesty her parents were known to have committed, all while being the defenders of the catholic faith (and subsequently catholic monarchs). Their own marriage was seemingly the result of a forged papal bull and her father was so ruthless and calculating he was apparently one of the inspirations for Machiavelli's The Prince. As the defenders of the catholic faith, Isabella and Ferdinand would have been masters in finding religious justifications for whichever actions they deemed to be in their own and the Spanish empire's best interests (which they probably saw as one and the same thing). Katherine would have been witness to much of this growing up and would have seen how religion and public piety were used to secure one's own political objectives.

Like most noble and royal women from what I understand, Katherine would also have been seen as a chess piece by her parents, to be used strategically to further their own aims and those of their empire's and she would be expected to do whatever it took to further those aims (although her mother died before her marriage to Henry). There is justification in the bible for lying where it serves the common good and I would be very surprised if she wasn't aware of the relevant verses as well as the biblical commandment for children to honour and obey their parents. And I also wouldn't be surprised if there wasn't a good deal more emphasis put on this latter commandment by her parents than on the commandments for honesty in courts and hearings etc given what we know about their behaviour more generally.

Which isn't to say that the whole subject of religion and beliefs about heaven, hell and the soul during those times aren't fascinating. While I'm no professional historian, I read a vast amount about this period ten or so years ago and I remember being surprised that Henry VIII was himself consumed with the issue of what would happen to his soul if he took certain courses of action and strenuously avoided some of them as a result. While simultaneously and openly disobeying other biblical commandments regarding adultery etc, having mistresses, illegitimate children and disposing of every wife who didn't give him what he wanted. It was very complex what they believed would send them to hell and what they thought could be disregarded completely. To me anyway, maybe they didn't see it as complex at all!

I definitely also think the fact that there's no record that Catherine ever claimed that the marriage was unconsummated until Henry was trying to divorce her decades later is significant. It probably wasn't overly important until he wanted rid of her.

THisbackwithavengeance · 26/10/2026 06:01

She was a Princess in her own right from a family far more important and powerful than the Tudors whose claim to the English throne was tenuous.

She had been a good and faithful wife and she was popular with the people.

She had been trusted to be Regent when Henry was abroad and the English had defeated the Scots on her watch.

She was happy to turn a blind eye to the mistresses and illegitimate DCs, that was par for the course.

So you can imagine the shock and humiliation when Henry tried to divorce her for an upstart commoner of questionable morals like Anne Boleyn. No wonder she dug her heels in. She was the original scorned wife. We’d’ve been cheering her on had she been posting on Mumsnet.

I always imagine how horrendous it would have been to have given birth to and lost so many babies. Women in those days must have been made of much sterner stuff than today because how would you get over that physically and mentally but she did!

WhisperingAngelisnotbad · 26/10/2026 06:26

LobeliaCider · 26/10/2026 00:46

I completely agree. It was Catherine's choices that made Mary's life so unhappy.

The papal dispensation meant that the marriage was made in good faith and the children of Henry and Catherine legitimate even if the marriage was later annulled. But Catherine refused to cooperate. Had she cooperated, Pope Clement VII could have overturned his predecessor's decision without detriment to Princess Mary or Catherine herself.

Instead, she forced Henry's hand, so the only option left open to him was to declare the marriage null from the start making Mary illegitimate.

If Catherine hadn't been so stubborn, Henry would have given her a generous settlement, Mary would have remained a legitimate Princess with her place in the succession (after legitimate sons) assured.

She could have remained in good favour with both her parents, made a good marriage while she was young enough to produce heirs and been happy. It was her own mother who denied her a happy life.

It was predominately Henry’s behaviour that made Mary’s life so difficult. I think we should keep sight of that.

MeridaBrave · 26/10/2026 08:12

He was 15, she had had just turned 16. I think she realised it would be better for her to claim to be a virgin. Henry became obsessed with the idea that leveriate marriage applied and even consulted with Rabbis. For that it wouldn’t have mattered if she was a virgin.

LobeliaCider · 26/10/2026 12:11

WhisperingAngelisnotbad · 26/10/2026 06:26

It was predominately Henry’s behaviour that made Mary’s life so difficult. I think we should keep sight of that.

By the early 1520s it was clear that Catherine was not going to give birth to a son.

There were ambitious Yorkist claimants to the throne who were already causing trouble because they knew the succession was not safe.

There were enough people still living who remembered the War of the Roses. England had enjoyed relative peace for 40 years and no one wanted to relive the bad old days.

On a personal level Henry acted badly, but Catherine could have made things much easier for herself and her daughter by cooperating.

GoodGirlFaith · 26/10/2026 12:17

For sure. The guy set up his own religion because he fancied Anne Boleyn so of course fibs were told.

Royal wedding nights were witnessed so I think it highly unlikely the marriage was no consummated.

Karmakamelion · 26/10/2026 12:25

ProudPearl · 25/10/2026 12:29

This thread has been absolutely fascinating. I've studied history but never the Tudors and this thread has made me realise I know very little about them beyond the basics. Can anyone recommend a book or TV series worth watching?

I love the Philipia Gregory books brilliant. Really atmospheric and well researched without being overwhelming

SerendipityJane · 26/10/2026 12:26

For sure. The guy set up his own religion because he fancied Anne Boleyn so of course fibs were told.

With the added irony that Henry was never really sympathetic with protestants at all ... but we are where we are,

FinallyHere · 26/10/2026 12:38

piscofrisco · 25/10/2026 00:41

She definitely did. And it’s always struck me as absolute stupidity that she maintained she didn’t and clung on til death. She was surely the first ‘pick me ‘ woman. She could have just retired to obscurity , gone to a nunnery or done an Anne of cleves and ended up quite happy and wealthy to boot on her own . Instead she attempted to stay married to an utter psychopath and died in penuary without seeing her only child again. Just why?

@piscofriscoIf she had taken the easy way out and retired to a convent, it would have a catastrophic impact on her daughter Mary.

JuliaAgrippina · 26/10/2026 12:39

Protestant cause was bubbling up on it's own in English society. It was just used by people in court.

Henry liked the money from the monasteries but wasn't really very enamoured of the protestant cause at all. It was just useful as Catherine wouldn't step aside wasn't his first choice at all.

Once made it came with more power and control and money and a new wife who may give him son or better yet many sons.

FinallyHere · 26/10/2026 12:42

@LobeliaCider well yes, make things easier for herself but then deprive her daughter of any future. And would have been declaring Mark to be a bastard.

Anne of Cleves did ok but then she didn’t have any offspring who needed to be protected

LizzieSiddal · 26/10/2026 12:50

I believe her 100%. She was a devote catholic and I really don’t think she would have lied about this.

Henry treated her disgracefully, what an awful man he was.

JuliaAgrippina · 26/10/2026 12:51

FinallyHere · 26/10/2026 12:38

@piscofriscoIf she had taken the easy way out and retired to a convent, it would have a catastrophic impact on her daughter Mary.

Possibly not - there was precedent as PP mention of marraiges being disolved and children from them still being consider legitimate. Eleanor of Aquitaine first two children daughters with french King were consider legitimate as the marriage was annuled which was what Henry wanted with Katherine.

Mary would have kept her place in succession - but same as if Katherine had died she risk having new brothers ahead but she'd have been considered a priceness and able to marry a Duke or Prince abroad or less likely a nobel man in England. She would have also been likely able to see her mother more in her final year as well.

It wasn't clear a woman could rule England at that point - we'd had the The Anarchy when Henry I daughter Maud was heir but her male cousin Stephen seized crown - 19 years of war and she had to step aside for her son in the end anyway. They'd just come out of the war of the roses 30-32 years of civil war. Tudors claim was thin and under constant threat.

Katherine looked more at her Mother as undisputed queen - rather than more murky English history - plus her own position for seven years had been hard and she'd hung on and won out with studdonness marrying Henry - so perhaps that also influenced her behavior.

InterIgnis · 26/10/2026 13:17

FinallyHere · 26/10/2026 12:42

@LobeliaCider well yes, make things easier for herself but then deprive her daughter of any future. And would have been declaring Mark to be a bastard.

Anne of Cleves did ok but then she didn’t have any offspring who needed to be protected

I believe an earlier offer was that Mary’s status and legitimacy would be preserved if Catherine accepted the annulment and retired to a nunnery. She refused.

What Henry VIII was requesting wasn’t unprecedented, and were it not for the political situation in Europe it would likely have been straightforward for him. Consanguinity was the common justification for annulments being granted.

There were valid political reasons for the request - the Tudor dynasty was a new one that emerged from decades of civil war. Stabilizing the monarchy was of utmost importance, and that meant a male heir. Unlike in Spain where Catherine’s mother Isabella was a powerful Queen regnant, England did not have a history of female monarchs, and nor did it have a positive view of the prospect. The one time when the throne was left to a woman, Empress Matilda, resulted in The Anarchy.

LobeliaCider · 26/10/2026 15:51

FinallyHere · 26/10/2026 12:42

@LobeliaCider well yes, make things easier for herself but then deprive her daughter of any future. And would have been declaring Mark to be a bastard.

Anne of Cleves did ok but then she didn’t have any offspring who needed to be protected

Catherine was the one depriving her daughter of her rightful future. Mary could have remained a princess and kept her position in the succession if Catherine had cooperated.

The worst thing that could have happened to Mary happened and it happened because of Catherine's intransigence. Mary was declared a bastard and stripped of the title "princess" (as was Elizabeth after Anne Boleyn's downfall). This didn't have to happen and wouldn't have happened if Catherine had done the right thing.

Only later when Henry realised he was going to die with only one potential successsor did he restore his daughters to their rightful positions. Nothing had changed except that he no longer needed to use Mary as a bargaining tool in his dispute with her mother.

MsAmerica · 26/10/2026 18:34

achristmaswish · 25/10/2026 02:58

Why? AIBU is open to all questions.

Because AIBU is becoming a useless catchall for people having problems thinking in specifics?

Grammarnut · 26/10/2026 21:54

wellington77 · 25/10/2026 20:54

History teacher here. I read Arthur’s exclamation of being “ inside Spain” as male bravado. Personally. Also Catherine was extremely religious, I don’t think she would be able to allow herself to lie on oath personally.

She might if she thought that it was God's will that she be queen of England. It is not too difficult to persuade oneself that this may be the case. And if she wasn't to be queen then Catherine was in limbo, probably unmarriageable.

DancingonmyOwn88 · 27/10/2026 13:00

This is happening in January if anyone is interested!

AIBU to say that I think Catherine of Aragon slept with Arthur
Duckeggbluecushion · 30/10/2026 11:44

SiegfriedSassoon · 25/10/2026 10:45

Didnt Henry VII consider marrying her himself after his wife died?

Not sure but he considered marrying her widowed sister Juana la loca rightful queen of Castile after her mothet's death. Castile allowed females to inherit the crown (unlike Aragon).

Henry VII had met Juana and her husband Philip the handsome when they unexpectedly visited England a few years earlier after a rough sea journey when travelling elsewhere.

JuliaAgrippina · 30/10/2026 12:46

Didnt Henry VII consider marrying her himself after his wife died?

I thought it was suggested informally and very much rejected by her parents especially her mother who was furiously opposed. There was a dowery return dispute and they were all keen to keep the alliance but there were potential canon law and legitimacy hurdles but it was mainly Isabelle opposition that killed it before it got to formal stage.

He was very keen on Juana match but her by then widowed father said no blaming her mental instablity a largely a political move so Ferdinand could control her kingdom himself.

Henry VII obviously didn't remarry but doesn't sound like he actually wanted to.

He seems to have suffered immense personal grief with wife death- not really wanted a risk of a succession crisis for remaining son Henry and historians agree he was far more interested in the diplomatic leverage of being an eligible bachelor than in actually walking down the aisle. He weaponised his single status to keep European powers guessing just like Elizabeth I his grandaughter later did.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page