Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that I think Catherine of Aragon slept with Arthur

171 replies

achristmaswish · 25/10/2026 00:27

AIBU to think Catherine of Aragon did sleep with her first husband, Arthur?

I’ve been reading about Catherine of Aragon and her first marriage to Arthur, Prince of Wales, and I’m curious what other people think.

Arthur apparently said something along the lines of “I was in Spain last night” after their wedding night, which has always made me wonder whether they did consummate the marriage.

I know Catherine maintained that her marriage to Arthur had never been consummated, which later became hugely important when Henry VIII wanted to marry her.

But here’s what I don’t understand. After Arthur died in 1502, Catherine was left waiting to see whether she was pregnant. Surely, if they had never slept together, wouldn’t she have said so at the time? Why would there have been any uncertainty about a possible pregnancy?

I know there are arguments on both sides, and obviously we can’t know for certain what happened between them behind closed doors.

So, AIBU to think that Catherine and Arthur probably did sleep together, and that Catherine’s later insistence that they hadn’t was influenced by the circumstances surrounding her marriage to Henry VIII?

I’d love to hear what other history buffs think!

OP posts:
PinkWaffleMaker · 25/10/2026 02:27

MsAmerica · 25/10/2026 02:24

Did it occur to you at all to post this in the History forum?

I enjoyed having it in AIBU 😂

TuxedoPark · 25/10/2026 02:27

UkuleleRose · 25/10/2026 02:11

Forgive my ignorance, but wasn't this a time when consummations where witnessed (or at least heard beyond the bed curtains) for royal couples? I've always defaulted to them not consummating, but I can see both sides.

No, they would have been escorted to the marital bed and placed into it, but no attendants stuck around for the actual sex.

nocoolnamesleft · 25/10/2026 02:30

behindtheanimalhouse · 25/10/2026 02:27

I was going to say this, there's a pretty good theory about it

What about the pain from the leg ulcers? That can't have helped either.

achristmaswish · 25/10/2026 02:58

MsAmerica · 25/10/2026 02:24

Did it occur to you at all to post this in the History forum?

Why? AIBU is open to all questions.

OP posts:
CalliopeFosterBeauchamp · 25/10/2026 03:10

I believe they definitely didn’t consummate it.

As others have said, she was extremely devout and I don’t believe she would have lied, even when her daughter’s legitimacy was at stake.

Look at her behaviour at the end of her life. Henry prevented Catherine and Mary from seeing one another. He took away her household and servants when she was suffering from cancer. Both M and C were ill with stress and anxiety.

She could have secured an “easy” retirement to a nunnery, been able to visit and correspond with her daughter, and has access to the best doctors, if she’d said to Henry that her marriage with Arthur had been consummated.

That she didn’t bend even under those dreadful circumstances tells me a lot about her integrity and about what she believed to be the truth.

I think both she and Anne Boleyn were remarkable women.

CorvusPurpureus · 25/10/2026 04:31

There’s also the question of how well informed nicely brought up young ladies in the C16th were in terms of Sex Ed.

Apparently Anne of Cleves had to have her ladies in waiting gently explain to her that what she was describing (Henry giving her a polite goodnight kiss & going to sleep), was unlikely to result in a new arrival for the royal nursery.

I’d be very surprised if Arthur didn’t at least have a go - he was a teenage lad with presumably the usual hormones, who’d been tucked into bed with a beautiful girl & told to get on with it. His ‘Spain’ comment is probably neither here nor there - if things hadn’t gone to plan, he would probably have been too embarrassed to admit to it - & they both probably thought they had a lifetime to get the hang of things.

I suspect some inept teenage fumbling - people were hitting puberty later so Arthur was probably more like a modern 12yo or so - & whilst we know some very young boys do regrettably have sex, plenty aren’t mentally or physically ready.

& if Catherine’s next experience was with an adult Henry, she might well have thought ‘ah ok THAT’S what it’s supposed to be like!’

Certainly after Arthur’s death, it was assumed she might be pregnant, & a dispensation was routinely obtained for her to marry his brother.

It doesn’t seem to have been remotely controversial that a) Catherine & Arthur’s marriage was real & b) that didn’t preclude her marriage to Henry - until he decided he wanted out 20 years later.

So if that was the first time Catherine was really asked what had happened in bed with Arthur…she may well have genuinely replied ‘well…not a lot, tbh’. Whether her memory was reliable - given how vested her interest was in defending her marriage - is, to me, as questionable as whether she was consciously lying or not.

iloveeverykindofcat · 25/10/2026 05:10

I doubt it. I think its hard for us to get our heads around the religious conviction people would have had in the medieval to Tudor period, where the prospect of Heaven and Hell were immediate, concrete realities. That would have been a huge, unholy lie with enormous consequences. Any children she had with Henry would be bastards and the (very young, one generation old) dynasty illegitimate in the eyes of God. Even Henry feared for his soul over this prospect. Whatever convictions she felt over her position on earth would have been secondary to the fate of her immortal soul.

Also yes, the worst of Henry's excesses were probably due to the TBI. He was unconscious for 2 hours after his horse fell on him. That's a significant brain injury. He was known to be moody and capricious before this, but also pleasant, charming and fun to be around. He got a hundred times worse after. Not that its an excuse for his treatment of his wives and friends, but it does explain some of it.

Timenowforanamechange · 25/10/2026 05:11

Catherine was devout. She never wavered, even at the end of her life. At the time, I don’t think she’d have put her soul in jeopardy.

So no, I don’t think it was consummated.

Always amuses me that she had a better claim to the throne, than Henry anyway. I know
right of conquest and all that but it still tickles me.

Henry was a psychopath. Probably following the jousting incident.

Mulledjuice · 25/10/2026 05:25

If they had consummated but she lied.about it she qaa risking her eternal soul but perhaps protecting her daughter Mary.

Henry was seeking to argue that, despite the papal dispensation, his marriage to Catherine was invalid and therefore Mary illegitimate.

I can well agree that Catherine wouldnt have chosen her own earlthy comfort over her own eternal soul, but she might have prioritised her only child.

I also agree it's possible that her experience of consummatiion with Arthur later on was quite different from that with Henryn ie she mught have believed herself to be telling the truth.

MinnieMountain · 25/10/2026 05:27

I never knew that Catherine had a stronger claim to the throne. Is that because she was a legitimate descendant through both of her parents, rather than Arthur's claim only through his mother?

Timenowforanamechange · 25/10/2026 05:38

In theory I think
Catherine was descended from John of gaunt second wife so a legitimate claim
henry through
John of gaunt third wife but an illegitimate claim as the children were born before the marriage and legitimated years after. However Henry’s also the son of the yorkist claimant so a mixed bag!

im sure someone with better history than me will come along as this sounds too garbled 😁

Zapx · 25/10/2026 06:02

piscofrisco · 25/10/2026 00:44

I think he was brain damaged after he got injured in the joust and everyone thought him a gonner. It was post that that he really became a nasty psychopath.

Do you reckon? I’d agree he seems worse after that but he was already married to Anne and had treated Catherine terribly by the time that happened… Eurgh, horrible man!

For my part, I reckon they didn’t. Based on absolutely nothing 🤣

Sausagenbacon · 25/10/2026 06:19

I think Hilary Mantel covers this well in Wolf Hall.
I also think that we view this through a very Anglo centric lens. She was part of a family that was much more prestigious family than the tudors, and was the aunt of Charles V, the most important man in Europe.
As a side note, her brother died (they say) from too much sex with his wife Margaret.
So I don't think it's as simple as 'poor Katherine'.
In fact I feel for Henry. He was only the 2nd in the dynasty and desperately needed a male heir. Though ironically his daughters were good rulers.
Sorry, this is rambling, but I do think history is more than a case of goodies and babies.

MotherOfCatBoy · 25/10/2026 06:27

A few years ago I watched the mini series The Spanish Princess and whilst it is probably a load of old tosh tarted up for the telly, I thought the first few episodes did a good job of positioning Katherine as the daughter of Isabella of Spain, and what that meant for her religious convictions and her sense of duty. There was a bit of background on Isabella as the instigator of the Inquisition (she thought she was doing the right thing after the Reconquista) and how she and Ferdinand brought up Katherine to be a Queen and do her duty. So I agree we look at this from a Tudor pov when we could do with a more European politics background.

However, in real life, maybe she interpreted her duty to be pragmatically whatever protected her position of relative power at the time, because that was what maintained her family’s hold on England….

Superhansrantowindsor · 25/10/2026 06:48

She Was very religious even for the time. She would not risk eternity in hell by lying imo.

damemaggiescurledupperlip · 25/10/2026 06:54

Arthur’s grandmother, Margaret Beaufort, had Henry VII at only 13 , and it nearly killed her. She never had another child, despite two further marriages, and it is believed she had been too injured from Henry’s birth

She later wrote or contributed to a bookl on childbirth procedures , so it was clearly a subject she felt strongly about

she had a good deal of influence in Henry VII’s court, and Arthur’s own mother had died so there was a vacuum there for her to fill. I have often thought it possible that she put her foot down and said ‘no sex until you are older, children’..

ElizaSchuylerHamilton243 · 25/10/2026 06:58

Catherine immediately saod they hadn't consummated after Arthur's death. Henry VII wasn't convinced which caused some issues with the papal dispensation for her second marriage. The Pope got both reports, the English one (saying they had) and the Spanish one (saying they hadn't) and avoided the whole thing by delaying. In the end, he sent the dispensation to Spain when Isabella was dying with the word 'perhaps' in it to settle the issue.

I agree with the posters above - Catherine was very religious and obsessed with her 'duty to God'. On her deathbed, she refused to say they had consummated which would result in eternal damnation.

There are some theories that Arthur died of testicular cancer (a weird quote from the doctor about parts of his body turning inward) which might have made his incapable but with teenage boasting, lack of sex Ed and pressure for a son, they probably just did some fumbling.

Also, they were allowed to consummate as the marriage had been delayed due to storms when Catherine crossed but she and Arthur wouldn't have been unaware that 'youthful enthusiasm' was blamed for her brother's death when he got married at the same age and was apparently very interested in his new wife.

DancingonmyOwn88 · 25/10/2026 07:01

piscofrisco · 25/10/2026 00:41

She definitely did. And it’s always struck me as absolute stupidity that she maintained she didn’t and clung on til death. She was surely the first ‘pick me ‘ woman. She could have just retired to obscurity , gone to a nunnery or done an Anne of cleves and ended up quite happy and wealthy to boot on her own . Instead she attempted to stay married to an utter psychopath and died in penuary without seeing her only child again. Just why?

This is such a shallow viewpoint.

She was a Princess of Spain, daughter of a Queen in her own right and a deeply religious and pious woman to boot. She believed she was following her Godly given path to be Queen of England. She had given her husband, the king, an heir, and as a daughter of a female ruler herself I’m sure she believed she had fulfilled her duty and Mary could go on to be Queen if Henry could only accept the hand that had been dealt (they lost many sons, one was around 7 weeks old)

Simply ‘retiring to a nunnery’ would be to give up the path she believed had been set out for her by God himself. Added to that it would mean abandoning her own daughter’s birth right as a princess of the blood. It cost her everything to hold steady to those beliefs, but she did, there was no ‘stupidity’ at play there.

With the above in mind I don’t believe she’d risk eternal damnation by lying and saying her marriage to Arthur was unconsummated. I think she was telling the truth.

DancingonmyOwn88 · 25/10/2026 07:09

achristmaswish · 25/10/2026 02:58

Why? AIBU is open to all questions.

I much prefer it here, I might not have seen it otherwise and it’ll get lots of interest from people who might not usually join in such a discussion, so ignore the stuffy comments like that!

Pollyanna87 · 25/10/2026 07:22

I agree they probably did.

Richard III definitely killed his nephews, and anyone who says otherwise is kidding themselves.

Timenowforanamechange · 25/10/2026 07:27

Buckingham
Margaret Beaufort
Henry VII
Richard III
all had cause to kill the the boys. Or they could have died natural deaths, not that I think they did. I think Richard did it, but he wasn’t the only one that it helped.

MinnieMountain · 25/10/2026 07:28

damemaggiescurledupperlip · 25/10/2026 06:54

Arthur’s grandmother, Margaret Beaufort, had Henry VII at only 13 , and it nearly killed her. She never had another child, despite two further marriages, and it is believed she had been too injured from Henry’s birth

She later wrote or contributed to a bookl on childbirth procedures , so it was clearly a subject she felt strongly about

she had a good deal of influence in Henry VII’s court, and Arthur’s own mother had died so there was a vacuum there for her to fill. I have often thought it possible that she put her foot down and said ‘no sex until you are older, children’..

I don't think Margaret Beaufort did tell them to wait. Her marriage was consummated unusually early, whereas 15 was normal for the time. Obviously she would have been keen for the dynasty that she did so much to found to carry on.

TheNightScentedStock · 25/10/2026 07:51

Pollyanna87 · 25/10/2026 07:22

I agree they probably did.

Richard III definitely killed his nephews, and anyone who says otherwise is kidding themselves.

I'm not so sure.

It certainly benefitted The Usurper, Henry V11 to have them out of the way.

PS. I wouldn't have seen this thread and all the interesting comments if it hadn't been in AIBU.
I didn't even know there was a History section and because of this, now I do and I'll have a root around in it. So, thanks @achristmaswish

Sausagenbacon · 25/10/2026 07:51

Henry VII

BMW58 · 25/10/2026 08:13

TheNightScentedStock · 25/10/2026 00:46

Why would Catherine, a devout Catholic, risk her soul by swearing that she was a virgin when she married Henry. She wouldn't risk eternal damnation.

As for the Spain remark, I hardly think he would have come out of the bed chamber and said, "Well, I couldn't do it."

Absolutely agree with this.

There's no way she'd have lied on oath in peril of her immortal soul.

As for his boasting about being in Spain - he was 15 ! Of course he was going to lie rather than be mocked!