Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that I think Catherine of Aragon slept with Arthur

171 replies

achristmaswish · 25/10/2026 00:27

AIBU to think Catherine of Aragon did sleep with her first husband, Arthur?

I’ve been reading about Catherine of Aragon and her first marriage to Arthur, Prince of Wales, and I’m curious what other people think.

Arthur apparently said something along the lines of “I was in Spain last night” after their wedding night, which has always made me wonder whether they did consummate the marriage.

I know Catherine maintained that her marriage to Arthur had never been consummated, which later became hugely important when Henry VIII wanted to marry her.

But here’s what I don’t understand. After Arthur died in 1502, Catherine was left waiting to see whether she was pregnant. Surely, if they had never slept together, wouldn’t she have said so at the time? Why would there have been any uncertainty about a possible pregnancy?

I know there are arguments on both sides, and obviously we can’t know for certain what happened between them behind closed doors.

So, AIBU to think that Catherine and Arthur probably did sleep together, and that Catherine’s later insistence that they hadn’t was influenced by the circumstances surrounding her marriage to Henry VIII?

I’d love to hear what other history buffs think!

OP posts:
Futurehappiness · 25/10/2026 13:59

Deadringer · 25/10/2026 13:21

As long as Catherine confessed to a priest before she died her sin would have been absolved I think, she wouldn't need to declare it publicly. Or perhaps she decided to accept eternal damnation as a sacrifice for her child. She was some woman either way. Such a shame that women had so little value then, i often wonder what the UK would be like if Henry and his court had accepted Mary as the future monarch, she might have married earlier and continued the family line.

If Catherine had agreed to the annulment when Henry raised it (I think around the late 1520s) with the condition of Mary retaining her place in the succession, then Henry could have married Anne Boleyn straight away, giving her several valuable extra childbearing years. She may well then have had a son which would have displaced Mary.....if not Mary would have had precedent over Elizabeth. As in fact she did anyway after the 1544 Act of Succession.

I don't think that Catherine's refusal to capitulate did Mary any favours, any more than it did Catherine. Mary was later forced, after years of bullying, to agree to her own illegitimacy. After which her position drastically improved. Although Henry could be cruel it was not an arbitrary cruelty, he could be generous enough toward those who did not stand in the way of what he wanted.

ThisWiseRobin · 25/10/2026 15:55

Timenowforanamechange · 25/10/2026 08:44

Yes I know, that’s why I said Henry through the illegitimate line, I was replying to the poster about Arthur’s claim, through their mother Elizabeth’s line as the yorkist heir! 😁 got to love a bit of Plantagenet and Tudor history. Although to be fair at that time of the morning it did sound very garbled.

Oh I beg your pardon, yes I misunderstood your post. Its my favourite time in history and such a treat to read a thread like this.

Timenowforanamechange · 25/10/2026 16:03

I know it’s such a great time in history. I love all the different claimants descending from Edward iii.

Uricon2 · 25/10/2026 16:24

I think Katherine fought Henry all the way for a number of reasons, one obviously being to protect the position of her daughter in the line of succession remained intact.

Another occurs to me, that she actually loved Henry. She had the best of him really, the handsome, sporty, sociable young man and they were together a long time, during which there was obviously a good degree of respect and trust (eg making her Regent) Clearly, he wasn't faithful to her and I doubt a Queen of her time would have expected it, but mistresses and children produced with them would not mean as much as always being No 1 publically and officially, which was removed by the ascent of Anne Boleyn. I can imagine her feeling genuinely heartbroken and betrayed as a woman, as well as her pride as the Princess of a great house being offended.

I think we (rightly most of the time) don't see dynastic marriages as having any romantic component, but those of eg Edwards I and III were wildly successful even if they were very much arranged to start with.

CrawlingFromShitshowToAfterglow · 25/10/2026 16:46

I'm working my way through this thread (thank you, OP), but I went off to find the aforementioned History Club board. There, I found a fascinating, old thread on Henry VIII. I've spent most of this Sunday afternoon down a Tudor rabbit hole!

www.mumsnet.com/talk/history_club/1572449-Henry-VIII-eh-What-a-bastard?page=1

AdmiralJaneRoland · 25/10/2026 17:25

Snowyowl99 · 25/10/2026 10:32

Of course we will never know. But I do believe they would have consummated the marriage. For one thing it was necessary to make it legally binding
Katherine was there for one sole reason to produce an heir. And the sooner the better to secure the Tudor succession
She probably lied thinking it was for the greater good she married Henry.
I just cant see two teenagers sharing a bed and not!

Marie Antoinette and Louis XVI married at 14 and 15 in 1770, about 4 years before he became king, and it took them 7 years to consummate the marriage, despite the official bedding ceremony and no lack of opportunity afterwards. By the time it was finally consummated the situation had become a major embarrassment and was used to cast doubt on the paternity of the children afterwards. The marriage was eventually consummated after the intervention of the Holy Roman Emperor, who was Marie Antoinette’s brother, and whose reaction (and account of his conversation with the bridegroom) are recorded. He described them as ‘a couple of complete blunderers’ and indicated that lack of interest and laziness played a part. Interestingly, his surviving letters indicate there was some sexual activity between the pair, but that according to Louis himself it had never reached completion, and so seemingly in contemporary thought this wasn’t regarded as sufficient for consummation to be said to have occurred.

I don’t understand all the people who keep saying that no teenagers would behave like this - they’re basing it purely on their own experience of teenagerhood. But teenagers aren’t all all alike, and some at that age are immature, not yet experiencing sexual feeling, not attracted to the person they’re with, or not attracted to the opposite sex at all, and when marriages were based primarily on factors other than attraction, it is documented that this problem sometimes occurred.

5128gap · 25/10/2026 17:38

piscofrisco · 25/10/2026 00:41

She definitely did. And it’s always struck me as absolute stupidity that she maintained she didn’t and clung on til death. She was surely the first ‘pick me ‘ woman. She could have just retired to obscurity , gone to a nunnery or done an Anne of cleves and ended up quite happy and wealthy to boot on her own . Instead she attempted to stay married to an utter psychopath and died in penuary without seeing her only child again. Just why?

Because she wanted her daughter Mary to be in the succession. She was the daughter of two monarchs to whom passing down the crown was the most important thing in her life. Far more than personal comfort. Lots of historical figures lived lives far more miserable and dangerous than need be to further their families interests and retain their birthright. It was the defining motivation of their lives.

Motuihe · 25/10/2026 18:14

SO she didnt LTB! eyeroll

Snowyowl99 · 25/10/2026 18:16

AdmiralJaneRoland · 25/10/2026 17:25

Marie Antoinette and Louis XVI married at 14 and 15 in 1770, about 4 years before he became king, and it took them 7 years to consummate the marriage, despite the official bedding ceremony and no lack of opportunity afterwards. By the time it was finally consummated the situation had become a major embarrassment and was used to cast doubt on the paternity of the children afterwards. The marriage was eventually consummated after the intervention of the Holy Roman Emperor, who was Marie Antoinette’s brother, and whose reaction (and account of his conversation with the bridegroom) are recorded. He described them as ‘a couple of complete blunderers’ and indicated that lack of interest and laziness played a part. Interestingly, his surviving letters indicate there was some sexual activity between the pair, but that according to Louis himself it had never reached completion, and so seemingly in contemporary thought this wasn’t regarded as sufficient for consummation to be said to have occurred.

I don’t understand all the people who keep saying that no teenagers would behave like this - they’re basing it purely on their own experience of teenagerhood. But teenagers aren’t all all alike, and some at that age are immature, not yet experiencing sexual feeling, not attracted to the person they’re with, or not attracted to the opposite sex at all, and when marriages were based primarily on factors other than attraction, it is documented that this problem sometimes occurred.

I know of Louis and Marie. He required a small procedure to enable him. So an entirely different situation
It was extremely important Arthur and Katherine consummated the marriage...for legality sake. Therefore its most likely they did
The situation you refer to is far from typical
Wirh regard to teenagers they were considered more grown up at that time when life was much shorter. Im not basing it on personal experience at all!!!but rather at that time it was of utmost importance and from.all reports Katherine and Arthur were fond of each other and bonded

WaffleMacGubbins · 25/10/2026 18:41

She was an intelligent, politically astute woman. Her mother was a warrior queen. Her nephew was the emperor. She was raised from infancy to be the main character. To be bold, to not accept defeat. She had a role mapped out for her and a lot to live up to. At no point was she going to roll over and meakly do what someone else wanted against what she perceived was her right, her responsibility, her duty and in what she thought were her best interests.

She married Arthur. Whether or not they had sex, she had to maintain the illusion that they did in his lifetime, or she would have failed as a wife. After his death she had no status, no money (Henry 7 refused to pay the remainder of her flowery), she was kicked out of her rooms at court. She had to play the what if I'm pregnant card whether or not she knew there to be any hope. She was buying time and cultivating other opportunities for herself. She couldn't go back to Spain defeated. There was nothing for her there but shame, she would have been blamed for failing to keep married or get pregnant quick enough.

Fortunately Henry 8 fancied her, and Henry 7 thought it was a good deal. They had to wait to be married for the pope to ok it and she had to deny sleeping with Arthur. These were the conditions if the marriage, because of the line in the bible about not marrying your brothers wife. At that point the truth didn't matter to anyone. The marriage was a good deal for everyone.

She didn't give birth to a boy who lived past being newborn. Henry always slept around. But now he was going after a woman Ann, who refused to sleep with him until he married her. Catherine couldn't believe that Ann wouldn't just be another affair. She couldn't comprehend the possibility of her marriage ending. If she said she had slept with Arthur and allowed the annulment to proceed she would have failed. There was no other role for her in life than queen of England. God put her there and she was deeply religious. She couldn't imagine a different possibility. And she didn't see the need to because she thought Henry would sleep with Ann and get bored and move on as he did with all the other women he went after, and she would remain queen and their daughter Mary would inherit. Because importantly, by saying she slept with Arthur and allowing the annulment, Princess Mary would become illegitimate and not inherit. Her place in society, her worth her marriage prospects, her future would all be up ended. So Catherine was acting for herself and her daughter to maintain their purpose in life

LobeliaCider · 25/10/2026 18:44

DevastatingFinish · 25/10/2026 12:54

Not true…. Rhesus disease only affects Rh pos babies so some of her children could have been rh neg. Also it causes anaemia and can easily present as a live birth but then a sickly ailing baby that subsequently dies. Equally could have been something to do with a different type of antibody, or something else completely of course.

...and most likely nothing to do with Rhesus at all.

AdmiralJaneRoland · 25/10/2026 18:46

Snowyowl99 · 25/10/2026 18:16

I know of Louis and Marie. He required a small procedure to enable him. So an entirely different situation
It was extremely important Arthur and Katherine consummated the marriage...for legality sake. Therefore its most likely they did
The situation you refer to is far from typical
Wirh regard to teenagers they were considered more grown up at that time when life was much shorter. Im not basing it on personal experience at all!!!but rather at that time it was of utmost importance and from.all reports Katherine and Arthur were fond of each other and bonded

If you know of them, you'll know there's no direct evidence he had such a procedure, and that although he was examined a number of times, there's no recorded evidence that he was ever found to have such an abnormality.

TomHanksIsMyHero · 25/10/2026 18:55

Weren’t people employed to check that the marriage had been consummated…I’m sure there’s something like that in Marie Antoinette?

Londonmummy66 · 25/10/2026 18:55

Timenowforanamechange · 25/10/2026 05:38

In theory I think
Catherine was descended from John of gaunt second wife so a legitimate claim
henry through
John of gaunt third wife but an illegitimate claim as the children were born before the marriage and legitimated years after. However Henry’s also the son of the yorkist claimant so a mixed bag!

im sure someone with better history than me will come along as this sounds too garbled 😁

Catherine was descended from John of Gaunt's second wife Constanza who was the heir to the throne of Castile but her father was usurped by her uncle - the idea was that she would pass her right to the throne of Castile on to John of Gaunt but he was unable to win it back for her. Their daughter then married the king of Castile to resolve the issue and Catherine of Aragon was descended from her.

John of Gaunt then married a third time to his long term mistress Catherine Swynford. As a result of that marriage their four (previously born) children were legitimised by act of parliament which gave them all rights of children who were legitimate at birth except that they could not claim the throne. Margaret Beaufort was descended from the legitimised son of John and Catherine Swynford which made her claim to the throne pretty tenuous.

Futurehappiness · 25/10/2026 19:39

There were actually precedents for the children of an annulled royal marriage retaining their legitimacy. 2 daughters of Louis VII and Eleanor of Aquitaine kept their legitimacy and all their status despite their parents' marriage being annulled. The Doctrine of Putative Marriage was a mechanism for this as it stipulates that where the parties originally entered into the marriage in good faith, the children remain legitimate. So the same might have been applied to Mary (especially if Catherine had chosen to argue for this as an accommodation of the annulment, rather than fight the annulment itself).

I can't say whether Catherine was right or wrong to fight to the bitter end. The thing is though: she did win, as the Pope decreed the validity of the marriage; but it did neither her nor Mary any good at all as Henry broke with the Catholic Church rather than have his will crossed. I don't know whether she knew him enough beforehand to know that he was never going to allow her to outmanoeuvre him or allow even the Pope to get in his way.

InterIgnis · 25/10/2026 19:53

Were it not for the political situation at the time Henry would have probably got his annulment. Catherine’s nephew was the Hapsburg Emperor, and in 1527 imperial forces had invaded and were occupying Rome. The Pope was not going to act in opposition to Charles V, and Charles V opposed the annulment.

GingersOwner26 · 25/10/2026 19:57

45fh · 25/10/2026 00:31

I am reading Three Sisters, Three Queens atm and agree with you. They were married for 5/6 months before he died and I can't imagine two 15 year olds, desperate for a son, abstaining for that long

I remember when I read The Constant Princess, also Philippa Gregory, she said in the afterword that she believed that the marriage was consummated.

Either way, Henry VIII was a complete cock.

ScrollingLeaves · 25/10/2026 20:14

45fh · 25/10/2026 00:31

I am reading Three Sisters, Three Queens atm and agree with you. They were married for 5/6 months before he died and I can't imagine two 15 year olds, desperate for a son, abstaining for that long

I think people were not generally sexually mature until age 16-17 in those days.

Grammarnut · 25/10/2026 20:36

UkuleleRose · 25/10/2026 02:11

Forgive my ignorance, but wasn't this a time when consummations where witnessed (or at least heard beyond the bed curtains) for royal couples? I've always defaulted to them not consummating, but I can see both sides.

This is a myth that consummations were witnessed. Everyone relied on what the couple said generally speaking. There were exceptions e.g. the marriage between Catherine de Medici and Louis (? can't remember which) was publicly consummated with his mistress in attendance mainly because said Louis had a DSD - I think the urethra opening was at the base of his penis - so that special measures were taken to produce an heir. Poor Catherine de Medici!

wellington77 · 25/10/2026 20:54

History teacher here. I read Arthur’s exclamation of being “ inside Spain” as male bravado. Personally. Also Catherine was extremely religious, I don’t think she would be able to allow herself to lie on oath personally.

TheNightScentedStock · 25/10/2026 22:22

TheNightScentedStock · 25/10/2026 07:51

I'm not so sure.

It certainly benefitted The Usurper, Henry V11 to have them out of the way.

PS. I wouldn't have seen this thread and all the interesting comments if it hadn't been in AIBU.
I didn't even know there was a History section and because of this, now I do and I'll have a root around in it. So, thanks @achristmaswish

Quoting myself here to say that I have started two threads in History Club, on topics which interest me.

It would be really good to have active discussions on that board, as this thread was a delightful find!

The topics I've started aren't top notch-I'm not a brain box- but the knowledge shown by posters here and on my Anne Boleyn thread shows that there are some really clever history buffs around and I would really love there to be a place where I could read their thoughts!

LBFseBrom · 25/10/2026 22:34

wellington77 · 25/10/2026 20:54

History teacher here. I read Arthur’s exclamation of being “ inside Spain” as male bravado. Personally. Also Catherine was extremely religious, I don’t think she would be able to allow herself to lie on oath personally.

That's exactly what I believe, she swore that to the grave. When you think about it, Henry wanted to make her out as a liar because he intended to move on to the next one, He cared nothing for his devoted wife's sensibilities.

Sunbringer · 25/10/2026 22:43

Men say a lot of things to show off. None of us know the truth of what happened.

JuliaAgrippina · 25/10/2026 23:10

Impossible to know.

Very likely Author was boasting as teen boys do.

However his health was good before marriage and in early months - contemporary reports describe Arthur Tudor as tall, handsome, and physically well-developed for his age. He grew up without a record of chronic illness. So two heathy 15 year old under pressure for an heir - likely sex would be on cards in four months of marrage.

Would catherine lie - well she was very relgious so many think it unlikely.

However she had a bloody awful time before she married Henry - seven-year period of isolation, poverty, and political limbo. She was very worried about her daughters position and her mother was a powerful queen so she refused to see issue with England never having had a queen regnant and had only just made it out a civil war generation before.

Plus Pope did issue a dispensation that was deliberately worded to cover the marriage even if Catherine and Arthur had slept together - so in her eyes it should have been a non issue.

She may have though lying was the lesser evil.

If people at time and who knew the couple in question were unsure - no one centures later will have a clue.

LobeliaCider · 26/10/2026 00:46

Futurehappiness · 25/10/2026 13:59

If Catherine had agreed to the annulment when Henry raised it (I think around the late 1520s) with the condition of Mary retaining her place in the succession, then Henry could have married Anne Boleyn straight away, giving her several valuable extra childbearing years. She may well then have had a son which would have displaced Mary.....if not Mary would have had precedent over Elizabeth. As in fact she did anyway after the 1544 Act of Succession.

I don't think that Catherine's refusal to capitulate did Mary any favours, any more than it did Catherine. Mary was later forced, after years of bullying, to agree to her own illegitimacy. After which her position drastically improved. Although Henry could be cruel it was not an arbitrary cruelty, he could be generous enough toward those who did not stand in the way of what he wanted.

I completely agree. It was Catherine's choices that made Mary's life so unhappy.

The papal dispensation meant that the marriage was made in good faith and the children of Henry and Catherine legitimate even if the marriage was later annulled. But Catherine refused to cooperate. Had she cooperated, Pope Clement VII could have overturned his predecessor's decision without detriment to Princess Mary or Catherine herself.

Instead, she forced Henry's hand, so the only option left open to him was to declare the marriage null from the start making Mary illegitimate.

If Catherine hadn't been so stubborn, Henry would have given her a generous settlement, Mary would have remained a legitimate Princess with her place in the succession (after legitimate sons) assured.

She could have remained in good favour with both her parents, made a good marriage while she was young enough to produce heirs and been happy. It was her own mother who denied her a happy life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread