Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that I think Catherine of Aragon slept with Arthur

171 replies

achristmaswish · 25/10/2026 00:27

AIBU to think Catherine of Aragon did sleep with her first husband, Arthur?

I’ve been reading about Catherine of Aragon and her first marriage to Arthur, Prince of Wales, and I’m curious what other people think.

Arthur apparently said something along the lines of “I was in Spain last night” after their wedding night, which has always made me wonder whether they did consummate the marriage.

I know Catherine maintained that her marriage to Arthur had never been consummated, which later became hugely important when Henry VIII wanted to marry her.

But here’s what I don’t understand. After Arthur died in 1502, Catherine was left waiting to see whether she was pregnant. Surely, if they had never slept together, wouldn’t she have said so at the time? Why would there have been any uncertainty about a possible pregnancy?

I know there are arguments on both sides, and obviously we can’t know for certain what happened between them behind closed doors.

So, AIBU to think that Catherine and Arthur probably did sleep together, and that Catherine’s later insistence that they hadn’t was influenced by the circumstances surrounding her marriage to Henry VIII?

I’d love to hear what other history buffs think!

OP posts:
Mrcollinswave · 25/10/2026 08:23

I lean towards believing nothing happened between Arthur and Katherine. His remark about "being in Spain last night" could have been just teenage boy bravado! He was only 15 and I think a bit sickly. K was a devout catholic. She consistently maintained she was a virgin when she married Henry, right up to when she was on her deathbed. Surely if she was lying she'd have been in fear for her immortal soul!
On the other hand I guess she could have confessed at the last minute! She was also desperately trying to protect her daughter and may have lied because of that. We'll never know, but it's very interesting!

ThisWiseRobin · 25/10/2026 08:26

Timenowforanamechange · 25/10/2026 05:38

In theory I think
Catherine was descended from John of gaunt second wife so a legitimate claim
henry through
John of gaunt third wife but an illegitimate claim as the children were born before the marriage and legitimated years after. However Henry’s also the son of the yorkist claimant so a mixed bag!

im sure someone with better history than me will come along as this sounds too garbled 😁

However Henry’s also the son of the yorkist claimant so a mixed bag!
Henry was the son of a Lancastrian claimant.
The Yorks Richard 3 was defeated by Henry 7. He married Elizabeth of York ending the War of the Roses and joining the 2 houses.
Henry's frantic need for a son and his decent into madness was i think also driven by this fear.
Yorks were everywhere....he even beheaded an 80 year old Margaret Pole , daughter of the Yorkist George Duke of Clarence for fear of her and her children.
The Tudor claim to the throne was tenuous at best and there were not a whole lot of them.
He was a true example of what can go wrong with Divine Right if kings...you end up with a monster.

tripleginandtonic · 25/10/2026 08:28

Henry V111 wanted it both ways to suit himself. The likelihood is that the marriage was consummated but not necessarily, Katherine was very religious amd it was a sin to marry your brother in law and to swear before God that she was untouched.

Laurmolonlabe · 25/10/2026 08:32

MagicMarkers · 25/10/2026 00:30

It wasn't unusual for royals to marry their children off young and then they waited before consummating the marriage. Arthur was young when he died. I think it's possible that they didn't have sex.

Edited

He was 16, doesn't sound like any 16 year olds I know.

Roomforapony · 25/10/2026 08:35

Thank you @achristmaswish for this thread, it’s been an unexpected pleasure during a sleepless night ☺️

OttersOnAPlane · 25/10/2026 08:44

I don't think the managed sex, whether through ignorance, incompetence or fear. I can't see the absolutely rigid and pious Catherine lying about that.

Henry, on the other hand, could argue black was white when it suited his latest whim.

He disposed of her because she hit menopause and all chances of a make heir were gone. The Tudors had a shaky hold at best, and he needed heirs more than anything.

He was also a psychopath. Margaret de la Pole, for heavens sake!

Timenowforanamechange · 25/10/2026 08:44

ThisWiseRobin · 25/10/2026 08:26

However Henry’s also the son of the yorkist claimant so a mixed bag!
Henry was the son of a Lancastrian claimant.
The Yorks Richard 3 was defeated by Henry 7. He married Elizabeth of York ending the War of the Roses and joining the 2 houses.
Henry's frantic need for a son and his decent into madness was i think also driven by this fear.
Yorks were everywhere....he even beheaded an 80 year old Margaret Pole , daughter of the Yorkist George Duke of Clarence for fear of her and her children.
The Tudor claim to the throne was tenuous at best and there were not a whole lot of them.
He was a true example of what can go wrong with Divine Right if kings...you end up with a monster.

Edited

Yes I know, that’s why I said Henry through the illegitimate line, I was replying to the poster about Arthur’s claim, through their mother Elizabeth’s line as the yorkist heir! 😁 got to love a bit of Plantagenet and Tudor history. Although to be fair at that time of the morning it did sound very garbled.

TheNightScentedStock · 25/10/2026 08:50

I've always found it ironic that it was Catherine's devout refusal to lie that hastened the fall of the Catholic faith in England.

shinny · 25/10/2026 08:57

I’ve recently read Phillips Gregory’s book about Catherine of Aragon (picked it up in a telephone box round Norwich way) and she portrays her as super ambitious & believing it was indeed her destiny to be Queen of England and as such she did anything necessary to reach the throne… including lying about being a virgin. Arthur is shown as a having great plans for the country & they are very much in love. I’ve never thought of this side of Catherine and it was very thought provoking.

I think she slept with him and then lied to fulfill her destiny. The quote ‘I’ve been in Spain’ is also in the book! I also think Henry VIII was a pig.

BertSymptom · 25/10/2026 09:05

My opinion, based on nothing really but a few podcasts, documentaries and entry level books, is that Catherine truly believed the marriage with Arthur was not consummated.

Whether that’s because it genuinely wasn’t or because her definition or understanding of consumated was slightly different I haven’t decided. I’ve heard plausible arguments for both.

But I really don’t think she knowingly lied. She was a devout catholic and she lost everything by not giving in.

Quicknamechange2025 · 25/10/2026 09:07

PinkWaffleMaker · 25/10/2026 02:27

I enjoyed having it in AIBU 😂

I was going to post the same thing, I'm glad she didn't post it in History

ViciousCurrentBun · 25/10/2026 09:19

I think when looking at any history people struggle to understand just how much faith influenced people especially if they have never had any faith themselves. I read Foxes Book of Martyrs when I was young, a book about Protestant Martyrs. People died both Catholic and Protestant rather than recant so were deemed heretics. They were burned at the stake. That’s how much their religion meant to them.

There is no way such a devout woman would have knowingly lied as it meant eternal damnation. Swearing an oath to God in court and then lying is a mortal sin.

Douglasmummy · 25/10/2026 09:19

I've found some of Phillipa Gregory's later books to be quite rubbish. I liked her Plantagenet ones but the Tudor stuff- I'm wading through one at the moment about Kathryn Parr.
But on the question, I agree, I don't think the marriage was consummated. Arthur must have been sickly if he died so soon after the marriage, especially if he had testicular cancer. Re Henry being a psychopath, surely he must have had an STD to have had so many young wives but so many dead babies. Boy babies are weaker at birth which is why there are naturally a few more of them born. His parents were very fertile. If he had syphilis it could have caused some kind of brain issue.
I'm not sure about the Princes in the tower. I went to the Richard Iii exhibition in Leicester and thought it was Margaret Beaufort but that would have been far more difficult for her to do than for Richard. Also, would Elizabeth of York have legitimised Henry's reign by marrying him if he'd killed her brothers? Apparently they had a happy marriage.

Mossyfox · 25/10/2026 09:22

I think it is possible. But I like to think she wouldn't have lied. But on the other hand she may have thought lying was excusable under the circumstances.

Douglasmummy · 25/10/2026 09:26

TheNightScentedStock · 25/10/2026 08:50

I've always found it ironic that it was Catherine's devout refusal to lie that hastened the fall of the Catholic faith in England.

Henry was Catholic until his death. He just wanted to be head of the Catholic church in England instead of the Pope. Kathryn Parr had to hide her Protestantism from him for fear of being beheaded. Lutheran Protestantism was about speaking directly to God, so no need for intermediaries like Kings or Popes or saints intercessions. Henry wouldn't have wanted to give up his role as Gods intermediary on earth.

DevastatingFinish · 25/10/2026 09:39

@Douglasmummy word on the street is that poor old Catherine was Rh neg and her babies died from rhesus disease. I think it’s unlikely Henry would have contracted syphillis so young and not be really
disfigured by it all those years later when he died. Also Henry wasn’t a particularly sexual guy, even at the time they would comment how few affairs he had. I think post brain injury he probably wasn’t very sexually active.

LlynTegid · 25/10/2026 09:41

UkuleleRose · 25/10/2026 02:11

Forgive my ignorance, but wasn't this a time when consummations where witnessed (or at least heard beyond the bed curtains) for royal couples? I've always defaulted to them not consummating, but I can see both sides.

Certainly in the Lucy Worsley version of history.

As for whether they did or didn't, we never will know. I think it of less importance than if Henry VIII had married anyone else and no sons born, the outcome of the Reformation would have happened in some form or other.

YYURYYUCICYYUR4ME · 25/10/2026 09:41

Interesting and I find this period in history fascinating. Catherine was indoctrinated with her place in the world being one of importance, a strong mother, an empire behind her, so duty v religion must have been a massive conflict in her life, but not where her daughter was involved, as I think she would want her in her rightful place. There is a theory that one of the only things Catherine could control in her life was her weight and she was anorexic, which might be true given her health, difficulties with conceiving and is another possible factor to add to this tale of woe. I had no idea of a history section, off to find it now!

DuckDuckG00se · 25/10/2026 09:43

TheNightScentedStock · 25/10/2026 00:46

Why would Catherine, a devout Catholic, risk her soul by swearing that she was a virgin when she married Henry. She wouldn't risk eternal damnation.

As for the Spain remark, I hardly think he would have come out of the bed chamber and said, "Well, I couldn't do it."

The very religious always found ways to justify sinning - especially when a crown was involved.

The truth is just don't know for certain. Either scenario is equally plausible. It's easy to believe Catherine was whiter than white because of her Catholic devotion and embodiment of being the perfect early modern Queen, but there was so much as at stake - not least her daughter's position and future - I can easily believe she lied.

It's also entirely believable that Arthur did.

Catherine and Henry received a papal disposition to marry, so even if she had lied Catherine may have felt it was a white lie. And it's not a stretch to think that a young Henry may have wanted the reassurance that his bride was a virgin, rather than always being second to his dead brother, the first heir to the throne.

Kings had been dissolving/annulling marriages for centuries for political reasons, it wasn't unusual that Henry should do so. As a model queen, Catherine could have gone along with it, that she didn't tells us a lot about her personal relationship with royal power. She was the daughter of Spain, the most powerful empire in the known world.

Notably, the only reason the Pope didn't grant Henry an annulment was because Catherine's nephew Charles, emperor of Spain had him by the short & curlies.

There are many reasons for Catherine to have lied. People put too much weight on religiosity and concern for her soul, there were always ways around these things.

HobnobsChoice · 25/10/2026 09:45

Douglasmummy · 25/10/2026 09:19

I've found some of Phillipa Gregory's later books to be quite rubbish. I liked her Plantagenet ones but the Tudor stuff- I'm wading through one at the moment about Kathryn Parr.
But on the question, I agree, I don't think the marriage was consummated. Arthur must have been sickly if he died so soon after the marriage, especially if he had testicular cancer. Re Henry being a psychopath, surely he must have had an STD to have had so many young wives but so many dead babies. Boy babies are weaker at birth which is why there are naturally a few more of them born. His parents were very fertile. If he had syphilis it could have caused some kind of brain issue.
I'm not sure about the Princes in the tower. I went to the Richard Iii exhibition in Leicester and thought it was Margaret Beaufort but that would have been far more difficult for her to do than for Richard. Also, would Elizabeth of York have legitimised Henry's reign by marrying him if he'd killed her brothers? Apparently they had a happy marriage.

Henry VIII was quite concerned with disease, hence legging it to another castle every time there was a report of plague or the sweat. The records of his physicians show no record of him having been given the usual treatment for syphilis which was mercury. Even though many of his children died or were stillborn they didn't show signs of congenital syphilis either.
A more modern theory is that he had Kell positive blood which would have meant his wives would be able to have one child and then subsequent babies would die. There's also a condition linked to Kells which causes mental decline and rages in middle age.

As for Katherine of Aragon, I think she told the truth. She was so devout she wouldn't risk her soul and even though Henry punished her and Mary she didn't change her view. God was a much bigger influence in her life than Henry. I think Arthur had a fumble, probably ejaculated but that he and Mary didn't have penetrative sex.

Fortuity · 25/10/2026 09:56

Though ironically his daughters were good rulers.

Elizabeth I yes, but would you really say that Bloody Mary was a good ruler?

Monty36 · 25/10/2026 10:00

My view is no. They did not.
Catherine was devoutly religious and would not have lied about such a thing. To do so would have risked her soul after she died.
Arthur may well have said he had been in Spain, but knew what was expected of him to say.
The delay to see if she was pregnant was normal. Not to do so would be to accept they had not. Nobody was going to do that. It would have been an insult to the dead Prince. The King, his father was still alive. Nobody wanted to upset him further.
Character wise he was gentle, studious and introverted. Quiet. The prospect of what was required may not have filled him with a great deal of zeal for the task.
He was not built as Henry was. He was slight and not robustly healthy.
She would have understood only a little of what to expect. Raised in a very strict Catholic environment in Spain as a Princess she would have been completely virginal. No man would have ever have gone near her. Her experience would have been nil.
Married in November. They moved to Wales in December. Five months later he was dead. A lot of which he spent becoming weaker and ill.
No doubt they were gentle with each other, two young people with enormous expectations thrown at them, both very innocent and both had led somewhat sheltered lives. Even Arthur whose father kept him rather excluded from others.

I can see why people might say she lied. A strong willed and very stubborn girl and then woman ( she was). Protecting the rights of her daughter Mary, as this became an issue when Henry wanted to divorce her. Perhaps she convinced herself that saying no was justified ? And God would understand.
But fundamentally, I think she would not have lied to God. And risked the soul of herself and her daughter in doing so.
So I am a no. It didn’t happen. A bit of fumbling perhaps. Not more.

Douglasmummy · 25/10/2026 10:00

Fortuity · 25/10/2026 09:56

Though ironically his daughters were good rulers.

Elizabeth I yes, but would you really say that Bloody Mary was a good ruler?

Elizabeth and Henry both killed more people that Mary.

Notonthestairs · 25/10/2026 10:07

Douglasmummy · 25/10/2026 10:00

Elizabeth and Henry both killed more people that Mary.

Elizabeth ruled for 44 years. Henry for 37. Mary for 5.

Monty36 · 25/10/2026 10:10

ThisWiseRobin · 25/10/2026 08:26

However Henry’s also the son of the yorkist claimant so a mixed bag!
Henry was the son of a Lancastrian claimant.
The Yorks Richard 3 was defeated by Henry 7. He married Elizabeth of York ending the War of the Roses and joining the 2 houses.
Henry's frantic need for a son and his decent into madness was i think also driven by this fear.
Yorks were everywhere....he even beheaded an 80 year old Margaret Pole , daughter of the Yorkist George Duke of Clarence for fear of her and her children.
The Tudor claim to the throne was tenuous at best and there were not a whole lot of them.
He was a true example of what can go wrong with Divine Right if kings...you end up with a monster.

Edited

Henry was very much like his Yorkist grandfather Edward IV. Extrovert, physically tall, built robustly, intelligent, liked the ladies overtly, charming when he wanted to be. But also with an ego the size of a planet. A spendthrift, who had a fear of disease, he loved to hunt and largely left running matters to Wolsey then Cromwell. Detail bored him.
He took after the York side of his family hands down.
He was the opposite of his father who was not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread