Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that I think Catherine of Aragon slept with Arthur

171 replies

achristmaswish · 25/10/2026 00:27

AIBU to think Catherine of Aragon did sleep with her first husband, Arthur?

I’ve been reading about Catherine of Aragon and her first marriage to Arthur, Prince of Wales, and I’m curious what other people think.

Arthur apparently said something along the lines of “I was in Spain last night” after their wedding night, which has always made me wonder whether they did consummate the marriage.

I know Catherine maintained that her marriage to Arthur had never been consummated, which later became hugely important when Henry VIII wanted to marry her.

But here’s what I don’t understand. After Arthur died in 1502, Catherine was left waiting to see whether she was pregnant. Surely, if they had never slept together, wouldn’t she have said so at the time? Why would there have been any uncertainty about a possible pregnancy?

I know there are arguments on both sides, and obviously we can’t know for certain what happened between them behind closed doors.

So, AIBU to think that Catherine and Arthur probably did sleep together, and that Catherine’s later insistence that they hadn’t was influenced by the circumstances surrounding her marriage to Henry VIII?

I’d love to hear what other history buffs think!

OP posts:
Bumcake · 25/10/2026 10:17

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/10/2026 00:45

She believed it was her calling from God to be Queen of England. She’d been brought up to think this since she was a tiny child - three years old I think. Called “Princess of Wales” from that time onwards.

For her it was unthinkable for her not to become Queen.

I agree, I think she wasn’t a virgin but saw that as secondary to her calling.

MumofGreyhound · 25/10/2026 10:25

I agree with all of the comments about Katherine being so devoutly religious that she would not have lied. I also agree with the comments that Arthur was in general not in good health, he was often referred to as ‘sickly’, and quite possibly just couldn’t do it.

I find it hard to believe that two healthy 15/16 year olds under pressure to produce an air would not have conceived quickly if they were in a normal physical relationship. Katherine was pregnant almost every year in the first decade of her marriage to Henry, so she was physically able, although tragically only one survived long enough to become an heir as we know. (Spin off thread - how would history have played out if Katherine and Henry’s eldest son Prince Henry has survived longer than he did).

So only balance, I don’t think Katherine and Arthur consummated their marriage.

Snowyowl99 · 25/10/2026 10:25

5foot5 · 25/10/2026 00:33

Have you read the Alison Weir books on the Tudor Queen? So far I have only read the Katherine of Aragon book and her take is that it wasn't consummated because his health wasn't up to it so they were advised not to

However, she has a scene where Arthur is boasting and trying to imply that things had gone further. Believable I suppose given how young they were.

There is actually no original source that says they were not advised to sleep together
Alison Weir is just commenting that that could be the case
In any event there is no record that Arthur was ill or weak at this time
Both Catherine and him became ill...she survived. He did not . But he was perfectly healthy til that point.

45fh · 25/10/2026 10:31

damemaggiescurledupperlip · 25/10/2026 06:54

Arthur’s grandmother, Margaret Beaufort, had Henry VII at only 13 , and it nearly killed her. She never had another child, despite two further marriages, and it is believed she had been too injured from Henry’s birth

She later wrote or contributed to a bookl on childbirth procedures , so it was clearly a subject she felt strongly about

she had a good deal of influence in Henry VII’s court, and Arthur’s own mother had died so there was a vacuum there for her to fill. I have often thought it possible that she put her foot down and said ‘no sex until you are older, children’..

Arthur's mother died 10 months after he did, not before, after trying to produce another male heir

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 25/10/2026 10:32

StayCoolLikeAPenguin · 25/10/2026 00:34

Teenage boys have been know to exaggerate how 'far they've got' sexually. Just look at the Inbetweeners, or American Pie. Personally I'd take Catherine's word before his.

I was about to say the same. Teenage boy, knowing what was expected of him on his wedding night, bragging in front of his servants.

Snowyowl99 · 25/10/2026 10:32

Of course we will never know. But I do believe they would have consummated the marriage. For one thing it was necessary to make it legally binding
Katherine was there for one sole reason to produce an heir. And the sooner the better to secure the Tudor succession
She probably lied thinking it was for the greater good she married Henry.
I just cant see two teenagers sharing a bed and not!

damemaggiescurledupperlip · 25/10/2026 10:37

45fh · 25/10/2026 10:31

Arthur's mother died 10 months after he did, not before, after trying to produce another male heir

You’re right, thank you

SiegfriedSassoon · 25/10/2026 10:41

I've always thought she did. Or there at least were attempts made.

She could have become incredibly devout in later life partly because she was trying to atone for the lie.

I think she felt it was her duty and destiny to be queen.

MummingIt2018 · 25/10/2026 10:42

I honestly think this is one of the best threads I've ever seen on Mumsnet. One of my proudest moments was on a tour of the houses of commons where they showed portraits of Henry VIII and his wives and asked why Catherine was placed ahead of him - and I was the only one in the group who knew she'd been married to his brother first. As for whether they consummated I'm not sure where I land but have really enjoyed reading all the different opinions here. I love history!

LBFseBrom · 25/10/2026 10:44

I think her first marriage was not consummated, Arthur was a delicate boy and probably a late developer. I've no doubt they were affectionate.

She was an extremely devout person, would not have lied about something so important at that time, certainly not taken a solemn oath. Also, had she not been a virgin, she could have returned to Spain and her parents, whom she always loved and missed dreadfully, eventually marrying some rich nobleman who treated her well.

"Catherine maintained under oath to the end of her days that nothing had happened on their wedding night". Lucy Worsley.

However the only people who really knew were Catherine and Arthur and they are not around to ask.

David Starkey believes she did (well he would, wouldn't he). I don't.

SiegfriedSassoon · 25/10/2026 10:45

Didnt Henry VII consider marrying her himself after his wife died?

Dontlletmedownbruce · 25/10/2026 10:50

I know very little about this but on a general point, if someone is a devout Catholic, sex and lying about it risks eternal damnation so I would absolutely believe someone who said they didn't. The idea of oh horny young people can't help themselves is a fairly new narrative, if your eternal soul is at risk you will control yourself.

TheNightScentedStock · 25/10/2026 10:52

DuckDuckG00se · 25/10/2026 09:43

The very religious always found ways to justify sinning - especially when a crown was involved.

The truth is just don't know for certain. Either scenario is equally plausible. It's easy to believe Catherine was whiter than white because of her Catholic devotion and embodiment of being the perfect early modern Queen, but there was so much as at stake - not least her daughter's position and future - I can easily believe she lied.

It's also entirely believable that Arthur did.

Catherine and Henry received a papal disposition to marry, so even if she had lied Catherine may have felt it was a white lie. And it's not a stretch to think that a young Henry may have wanted the reassurance that his bride was a virgin, rather than always being second to his dead brother, the first heir to the throne.

Kings had been dissolving/annulling marriages for centuries for political reasons, it wasn't unusual that Henry should do so. As a model queen, Catherine could have gone along with it, that she didn't tells us a lot about her personal relationship with royal power. She was the daughter of Spain, the most powerful empire in the known world.

Notably, the only reason the Pope didn't grant Henry an annulment was because Catherine's nephew Charles, emperor of Spain had him by the short & curlies.

There are many reasons for Catherine to have lied. People put too much weight on religiosity and concern for her soul, there were always ways around these things.

You misunderstand me. I'm not saying that Catherine was whiter than white but her faith wasn't flexed to suit herself.

It was the major thing in her life, more important than anything even her daughter. It is perfectly reasonable to understand that she would not risk the eternal damnation of her soul.

She-and others who were prepared to to burn for their faith-didn't look for ways around it.

Sometimes, we apply modern minds to minds past, especially in matters of religion but before we do that, it is always helpful to remember that, "The Past is Another Country. They Do Things Differently There" and no-where more so than in how faith was viewed.

LBFseBrom · 25/10/2026 10:54

SiegfriedSassoon · 25/10/2026 10:45

Didnt Henry VII consider marrying her himself after his wife died?

He briefly considered it, wanted to cement relations with Spain and keep Catherine's dowry, but not for long; it was too complicated a process so he arranged for his son, Arthur, to become betrothed to Catherine..

LobeliaCider · 25/10/2026 10:56

DevastatingFinish · 25/10/2026 09:39

@Douglasmummy word on the street is that poor old Catherine was Rh neg and her babies died from rhesus disease. I think it’s unlikely Henry would have contracted syphillis so young and not be really
disfigured by it all those years later when he died. Also Henry wasn’t a particularly sexual guy, even at the time they would comment how few affairs he had. I think post brain injury he probably wasn’t very sexually active.

word on the street is that poor old Catherine was Rh neg and her babies died from rhesus disease

Word on the street is definitely wrong.

Catherine gave birth to at least three living babies, two of which - Henry Duke of Cornwall and a daughter that lived for a few hours - were born before Princess Mary who survived into adulthood.

Catherine's marriage to Arthur was almost definitely consummated. The question as to whether or not it was only arose years later when Henry VIII wanted to annul his marriage to Catherine.

Arthur and Catherine were young, fit and healthy and expected to provide an heir as soon as possible to secure an uncertain succession. No one wanted another War of the Roses.

Royal marriages were highly political matters of state. A young couple of 16 and 17 failing to consummate their marriage after six months living together would have caused great concern. Catherine herself would have been unhappy about it.

Arthur's death - probably caused by sweating sickness - was completely unexpected. His marriage to Catherine was a great match for the Tudor royal family. She could have had any prince in Europe. Her parents - the most powerful monarchs in Europe at the time - chose Arthur, at least in part because he was healthy and and believed to be capable of siring heirs. A sickly man would have been completely unacceptable.

Following Arthur's death, Catherine faced the possibility of returning to Spain as a widow with considerably reduced status and prospects.

She was devoutly religious, but she was also ferociously ambitious and believed in her God-given right to be Queen. Of course she was going to say what she needed to say to secure her future and her "rightful" position.

Henry VII knew this and took care to ensure that the papal dispensation given by Pope Julius II in 1503 allowed his younger son's marriage to Catherine, whether or not her marriage to his older son had been consummated.

In other words, Catherine didn't need to lie to get the dispensation. She only needed to lie later when Henry VIII wanted to annul the marriage on the basis that - in his opinion - the Pope Julius II erred in giving the dispensation.

In the late 1520s/early 1530s Pope Clement VII remained steadfast in upholding his predecessor's decision - despite considerable political pressure to do otherwise. Again, the consummation or non-consummation of Arthur's and Catherine's marriage made no difference to the papal dispensation.

The arguments around this matter resulted in England's separation from Rome.

GettingThereEveryDay · 25/10/2026 10:59

DevastatingFinish · 25/10/2026 09:39

@Douglasmummy word on the street is that poor old Catherine was Rh neg and her babies died from rhesus disease. I think it’s unlikely Henry would have contracted syphillis so young and not be really
disfigured by it all those years later when he died. Also Henry wasn’t a particularly sexual guy, even at the time they would comment how few affairs he had. I think post brain injury he probably wasn’t very sexually active.

I think you are confusing her with Anne Boleyn

GettingThereEveryDay · 25/10/2026 11:03

The theory is that Anne’s rhesus negative blood meant that during childbirth (to Elizabeth) the baby’s rpostive blood mixed with hers and caused Anne’s immune system to attack future foetuses as a result

RinklyRomaine · 25/10/2026 11:03

Ofc, no one will ever know, but I always felt on balance that the marriage was in some fumbling way consummated.

Catherine had seen herself as Queen of England all her life. Two 15 year olds, isolated off in Wales from the family, expected to seal the deal from an international perspective, for 5 whole months. They waited to see if she was pregnant, too.

She was ofc extremely devout, but I think people misunderstand religious devotion at that time. If the Pope himself provided a dispensation, then a religious woman with a massive sense of herself as destined to be Queen would easily believe that for this purpose, she WAS a virgin. Henry VII himself floated the idea of marrying her, and would probably have gone through with it if her mother hadn’t been adamantly opposed. She had spent her life seeing him as a father and protector, and would have felt that authority too.

By the time of the marriage, she was stuck in an awful position. In absolute penury and isolation, her family didn’t want her back, her father in law didn’t want to return her dowry, and she’d been in limbo
for 7 years, after a lifetime of being told she WAS Queen of England. I’d not back down on that situation, either.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 25/10/2026 11:04

I don't understand why it would have mattered ahead of her marriage to Henry, given Arthur was dead?

LBFseBrom · 25/10/2026 11:09

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 25/10/2026 11:04

I don't understand why it would have mattered ahead of her marriage to Henry, given Arthur was dead?

It was at that time against the law of the land and of the Church to marry deceased siblings widow or widower. As Catherine and Arthur's marriage was not consummated, it could be annulled.

PS in my previous post I said, "Arthur" when I meant Henry. Too late to edit post.

HideousKinky · 25/10/2026 11:17

MummingIt2018 · 25/10/2026 10:42

I honestly think this is one of the best threads I've ever seen on Mumsnet. One of my proudest moments was on a tour of the houses of commons where they showed portraits of Henry VIII and his wives and asked why Catherine was placed ahead of him - and I was the only one in the group who knew she'd been married to his brother first. As for whether they consummated I'm not sure where I land but have really enjoyed reading all the different opinions here. I love history!

I was on this very tour yesterday afternoon MummingIt2018 !

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 25/10/2026 11:17

Oh that's interesting thank you

DancingonmyOwn88 · 25/10/2026 11:17

shinny · 25/10/2026 08:57

I’ve recently read Phillips Gregory’s book about Catherine of Aragon (picked it up in a telephone box round Norwich way) and she portrays her as super ambitious & believing it was indeed her destiny to be Queen of England and as such she did anything necessary to reach the throne… including lying about being a virgin. Arthur is shown as a having great plans for the country & they are very much in love. I’ve never thought of this side of Catherine and it was very thought provoking.

I think she slept with him and then lied to fulfill her destiny. The quote ‘I’ve been in Spain’ is also in the book! I also think Henry VIII was a pig.

I enjoy Phillippa Gregory, she really does tell a great story and makes a really accessible, readable insight into the Plantagenet (these were her peak writings I think) and the Tudor court in most of her books. (The latest about Jane Rochford’s involvement in Catherine Howard’s downfall is dire)

However, she’s a sensationalist, she writes for drama. She takes the information that’s available and spins it into a good story. The books wouldn’t be an enjoyable otherwise, nor would those tv series have been commissioned.

Twogingercats · 25/10/2026 11:19

I’ve been thinking of Marie Antoinette and Louis 16th, who married, I think in 1770 but did not consummate their marriage until 1777, largely to Louis’ inexperience., but of course Antoinette was censured. She was awfully young, only 14 when she married? Forgive me though, I do not have access to a history book ,, only Wikimedia. Loving the thread, thank you everyone. .

CinnamonJellyBeans · 25/10/2026 11:20

I think that Arthur and Catherine consummated their marriage.

Henry's claim to the throne was tenuous and there were many remaining plantagenets who would have been popular choices as a successor. He needed a male heir to secure the tudor throne and ensure he died leaving a nation safe from civil war and possible invasion.

Catherine stuck to her story to ensure her daughter remained in the line of succession and to maintain the English royal association with Spain and the Catholic church. I think she was steadfast and wise.

(On a separate note: I am convinced that Jane Seymour was pregnant when Anne Boleyn was tried and executed and Jane's marriage to Henry took place)

Swipe left for the next trending thread