Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are so many YP going to uni, when uni isn't right for so many YP? AIBU to think fewer YP should go to uni as it's only giving them a huge debt?

404 replies

MerryAquaKoala · 18/10/2026 08:41

It seems such a waste of time for so many, racking up huge debt and gaining no benefit from their degree whatsoever. It seems to me that uni's accept such low grades from A Level these days, it's literally a scheme to keep money going to the university and definitely not for the benefit of the YP.

It probably even comes further back to A Levels - A Levels aren't right for so many YP yet currently it seems they're funnelled into doing them anyway.

Something doesn't feel right with it all and in the end it's a YP left with huge debt for the rest of their life (usually). Seems so wrong.

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 20/10/2026 12:25

ThePelican · 20/10/2026 10:31

At the end of the 1980's only one in ten people got an A at A level. 20 years later it was one in four. Grade inflation is a very real thing. You can't compare the grades your father got with what subsequent generations got.

This is incorrect.

In the 1980s the grading system was completely different. The proportion of grades given at A, B, C etc. was set as a proportion for each grade for each subject, this meant that grades could be highly variable each year.

If lots of pupils had performed to a similar level, the bands between grades could be very small I.e. only a few points difference between A and B. That meant that in one year a cohort of students could be performing at a much lower level of ability than the previous year for example. The lack of consistency is why the grading system was changed, without standardisation, a grade's value is questionable and actually makes it harder for universities to determine whether the applicant is working at the level of educational attainment that their course requires.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · 20/10/2026 12:27

JudgeJ · 20/10/2026 11:43

I doubt that, I went to a College of Education in 1967 and we certainly needed A levels, not only O levels.

Before 1979 you did not need A levels, you could train to be a teacher with O levels.

BigFatLiar · 20/10/2026 12:52

Sartre · 20/10/2026 12:11

Well, that’s what she told me. She only had O Levels and went to teacher training college in the early 60s, must have been 62/63ish in Yorkshire. Taught reception at the same school for 40 years.

A quick Google suggests that the move to graduate teachers started in the 60s/70s prior to that there were special training courses. So assuming a period of switch over she may have gone through the non graduate route.

Newbutoldfather · 20/10/2026 13:27

@SpanThatWorld ,

‘Are people with AAB qualitatively different to those with BCC? Probably not. Once you control for family background, school experience, level of interest/commitment i doubt that you could demonstrate a clear difference in capacity to benefit from a particular course. Someone with mid level A levels from secondary school in a depressed agricultural area might have a thirst for education very different to the half-hearted alumnus of a home counties private school despite very similar A levels.’

I do think people with AAB grades are qualitatively different to those with BCC grades! Of course, there are individual circumstances, but that is where contextual offers and special consideration comes in. on average, the person with AAB grades has grasped the vast majority of the course whilst the candidate with BCC has not accessed most of the truly advanced parts at all.

Even if (which I suspect is not that common) the BCC candidate has genuine reasons for not performing better, that still means they need extra time to catch up, which just wouldn’t be possible in an intense degree.

‘Do I think a degree from the University of Aston or Stirling is the same as one from Oxford Brookes?’

You have picked extreme examples, They are currently ranked 42nd and 45th respectively. If I had a choice between someone who had graduated in engineering from York or Kingston, it would be an easy choice.

KookyBrickReader · 20/10/2026 13:52

You got yours though, didn't you OP.

MerryAquaKoala · 20/10/2026 14:32

KookyBrickReader · 20/10/2026 13:52

You got yours though, didn't you OP.

I got my what?

OP posts:
Bubbaliciousss · 20/10/2026 21:49

godmum56 · 18/10/2026 18:36

As I have already pointed out, they and their clinical and social care colleagues have needed a degree equivalent professional qualifcation and membership of a professional oversight register for many years. Nurses are the oldest regulated profession, their examination based registration and professional oversight register started in the 1920's! Compulsory State registration for nurses began in 1943. Over time scope of practice has widened for all health and social care staff.

Yes.... scope of practice has widened further and further, to the point where a degree level qualidication is now required, which is what I replied to the poster I was talking to.

cloudtreecarpet · 20/10/2026 22:20

SpanThatWorld · 20/10/2026 07:42

Polytechnics mostly offered degrees, exactly the same as universities. The great binary divide (as it was termed in the 80s/90s) was completely artificial. There was/is an idea that some courses are vocational and should be taught in one place and others academic and taught in a different way elsewhere.

Never held up when you suggested that medicine, law and architecture were vocational and should have therefore been studied at what was always dismissed as "the local poly".

Yes, you could HNDs at polytechnics but degrees were degrees and that's what polytechnics delivered.

The great expansion of higher education in the 1960s opened a number of new universities and expanded existing institutions into a larger number of polytechnics. The intention was to expand technical education skills but it was always a false dichotomy. Some of the original polytechnics had been established in the late 19th century to make academic study available to working people.

Is engineering vocational? It's taught at Cambridge. All the art schools that spawned 1960s counter culture were full of young people studying sign writing, technical drawing and advertising alongside the ones making sculpture out of their own gallstones.

The reason for the 1992 reorganisation of higher education was that there was no real dichotomy between the University of Brunel and Hatfield Polytechnic.

Polys might have offered degrees but it was much easier to get into them.

We all applied to Universities via UCAS and Polys/colleges - as "insurance" in case we didn't get our grades - via PCAS.

The grades required for Polys were way below those required for Universities & they were commonly regarded amongst students as being lower down the pecking order.

godmum56 · 20/10/2026 22:22

Bubbaliciousss · 20/10/2026 21:49

Yes.... scope of practice has widened further and further, to the point where a degree level qualidication is now required, which is what I replied to the poster I was talking to.

its always been degree level, it just wasn't called a degree.

SpanThatWorld · 20/10/2026 22:29

cloudtreecarpet · 20/10/2026 22:20

Polys might have offered degrees but it was much easier to get into them.

We all applied to Universities via UCAS and Polys/colleges - as "insurance" in case we didn't get our grades - via PCAS.

The grades required for Polys were way below those required for Universities & they were commonly regarded amongst students as being lower down the pecking order.

I applied to both too and the grades weren't that much lower. There was a small spectrum of grade requirements across my UCCA form and a much larger spread across my polytechnic applications (too old for PCAS). There was overlap across the sectors.

As i keep saying, there is and always has been a spectrum across the HE sector, not a dichotomy between 2 different types or levels of education.

Badbadbunny · 21/10/2026 07:02

godmum56 · 20/10/2026 22:22

its always been degree level, it just wasn't called a degree.

And you didn’t need to go to uni.

MrsB2603 · 21/10/2026 17:02

Uni teaches things beyond the course subject however, for example how to write academically, how to research from reliable sources etc, you can make friends for life at uni and gain life experience, it also looks good on a CV to an employer. You shouldn’t go if you have no idea what you want to do and shouldn’t pick a course at random just to get into debt but if you have a vague idea of a career route or you’re just extremely interested in a subject then I think it’s a good idea, equally if you want to learn a trade instead that’s also a good idea!

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2026 14:39

Uni teaches things beyond the course subject however, for example how to write academically, how to research from reliable sources etc, you can make friends for life at uni and gain life experience

You can do all that without getting £50k into debt and not earning for 3 years.

I did all that alongside a full time job after leaving school and living at home then buying my first flat after a couple of years. No student loan debt. 3 years employment history and earnings and a couple of promotions. Lots of friends due to local socialising. Fully qualified accountant in year 4. My contemporaries who went to Uni were only just starting in the workplace the same year I qualified and if they were going on to professional qualifications, they had another 2/3/4 years of additional study and were on the same kind of low/trainee wages I'd been on 3 years earlier whereas at that time, my wages were double/treble theirs.

cloudtreecarpet · 22/10/2026 15:41

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2026 14:39

Uni teaches things beyond the course subject however, for example how to write academically, how to research from reliable sources etc, you can make friends for life at uni and gain life experience

You can do all that without getting £50k into debt and not earning for 3 years.

I did all that alongside a full time job after leaving school and living at home then buying my first flat after a couple of years. No student loan debt. 3 years employment history and earnings and a couple of promotions. Lots of friends due to local socialising. Fully qualified accountant in year 4. My contemporaries who went to Uni were only just starting in the workplace the same year I qualified and if they were going on to professional qualifications, they had another 2/3/4 years of additional study and were on the same kind of low/trainee wages I'd been on 3 years earlier whereas at that time, my wages were double/treble theirs.

When was this?

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2026 15:49

cloudtreecarpet · 22/10/2026 15:41

When was this?

For me, it was the 80s, but lots of accountancy trainees do the same today, except of course for being able to buy a flat. Otherwise, it's all just the same, i.e. earlier to fully qualify and earning money instead of getting into debt.

Bigfattwatt · 22/10/2026 16:07

I left school at 16 as I wanted to be a sound engineer. I got a job in a recording studio, making tea at first, then being trained up in the studio. Obviously paid peanuts at first, but I earned more as time went on.

Later, I met friends through work who at 21, had just left university after doing degrees in music technology. They had come to work at studios that I was working in, for free, mainly making tea. No studios were impressed by degrees. They wanted experience.

We were the same age, only I had trained on the job and by 21, was working as an engineer and had 5 years of experience under my belt.

They were pretty pissed off that they had spent lots of money to get to the same level as I had been at fresh out of school at 16.

I learned very early on that for a lot of things, university is a waste of time and money.

cloudtreecarpet · 22/10/2026 17:04

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2026 15:49

For me, it was the 80s, but lots of accountancy trainees do the same today, except of course for being able to buy a flat. Otherwise, it's all just the same, i.e. earlier to fully qualify and earning money instead of getting into debt.

Is it still the same today? Can someone train to be an accountant with just A levels and are there lots of opportunities to do so?

I am genuinely asking because I don't know but I do think it can be hard to compare the 80s to now with most things. Maybe accountancy is different?

Bubbaliciousss · 22/10/2026 17:38

godmum56 · 20/10/2026 22:22

its always been degree level, it just wasn't called a degree.

It wasn't, you had to do extra exams to become a registered nurse and it was more in depth.

godmum56 · 22/10/2026 17:45

Bubbaliciousss · 22/10/2026 17:38

It wasn't, you had to do extra exams to become a registered nurse and it was more in depth.

yup. there used to be SEN's who were nurses not auxiliaries but could only take on limited responsibilities and then you could do a conversion course. It was possible to train to SRN in one go though. The places where you trained were called "schools of nursing" and nurses received a diploma, not a degree. It was the same, pretty much for Occupational Therapists and Physiotherapists, we trained in schools and received diplomas but the educational qualfication was at degree level.

godmum56 · 22/10/2026 17:48

Badbadbunny · 21/10/2026 07:02

And you didn’t need to go to uni.

the premises were called "schools of nursing/physiotherapy/occupational therapy" but the education provided was at degree level. The qualification was a diploma and not a degree but for all proactical purposes it was considered to be equivalent to a degree.

and please don't argue with me, I was there.

Bubbaliciousss · 22/10/2026 18:37

godmum56 · 22/10/2026 17:45

yup. there used to be SEN's who were nurses not auxiliaries but could only take on limited responsibilities and then you could do a conversion course. It was possible to train to SRN in one go though. The places where you trained were called "schools of nursing" and nurses received a diploma, not a degree. It was the same, pretty much for Occupational Therapists and Physiotherapists, we trained in schools and received diplomas but the educational qualfication was at degree level.

The majority of your post is accurate but the diploma wasn't at degree level, and certainly not at the same level it is now.

godmum56 · 22/10/2026 18:43

Bubbaliciousss · 22/10/2026 18:37

The majority of your post is accurate but the diploma wasn't at degree level, and certainly not at the same level it is now.

Edited

the SRN diploma definitely was at degree level, as were the OT and physio diplomas. I agree that all three degrees now contain more content than they did but we are comparing degree vs diploma at the time.

cloudtreecarpet · 22/10/2026 19:02

godmum56 · 22/10/2026 17:48

the premises were called "schools of nursing/physiotherapy/occupational therapy" but the education provided was at degree level. The qualification was a diploma and not a degree but for all proactical purposes it was considered to be equivalent to a degree.

and please don't argue with me, I was there.

Edited

My close friend did the diploma and has been a nurse for nearly 30 years.
She was recently given the opportunity to upgrade her diploma to a degree and had to study really hard to do so, writing various essays etc and going to University one day a week. It nearly killed her but she did it and had a graduation ceremony.

godmum56 · 22/10/2026 19:06

cloudtreecarpet · 22/10/2026 19:02

My close friend did the diploma and has been a nurse for nearly 30 years.
She was recently given the opportunity to upgrade her diploma to a degree and had to study really hard to do so, writing various essays etc and going to University one day a week. It nearly killed her but she did it and had a graduation ceremony.

i am talking about "at the time" comparisons, as I just said.

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2026 19:09

cloudtreecarpet · 22/10/2026 17:04

Is it still the same today? Can someone train to be an accountant with just A levels and are there lots of opportunities to do so?

I am genuinely asking because I don't know but I do think it can be hard to compare the 80s to now with most things. Maybe accountancy is different?

Yes, it's the same today. Lots of firms, big and small, take on school leavers with A levels and support them to train/study on the job.

Swipe left for the next trending thread