Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are so many YP going to uni, when uni isn't right for so many YP? AIBU to think fewer YP should go to uni as it's only giving them a huge debt?

404 replies

MerryAquaKoala · 18/10/2026 08:41

It seems such a waste of time for so many, racking up huge debt and gaining no benefit from their degree whatsoever. It seems to me that uni's accept such low grades from A Level these days, it's literally a scheme to keep money going to the university and definitely not for the benefit of the YP.

It probably even comes further back to A Levels - A Levels aren't right for so many YP yet currently it seems they're funnelled into doing them anyway.

Something doesn't feel right with it all and in the end it's a YP left with huge debt for the rest of their life (usually). Seems so wrong.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 20/10/2026 07:40

NorthernJim · 20/10/2026 00:46

I voted YABU because you sound as though you think it's new issue, when it's been the going on for at least 20 years. And I actually think we're well past 'peak uni', lots of young people are seeing straight through the higher ed sales pitch and getting the 'university experience'. But the problem is that higher education is an industry that (apparently) can't afford to fail, so it's being propped up by the state. Quite unfortunate when you consider that many actual, real industries have been sold down the river by our governments over the last 50 years.

Nail on the head. Governments are happy to prop up failing the failing uni industry but weren’t willing to prop up manufacturing nor other industries.

RampantIvy · 20/10/2026 07:40

ThisTicklishFatball · 20/10/2026 00:15

Why doesn’t the lad work to pay his university fees if no adults are able to pay them for him? A computer science degree, which you claim is a low-entry course, would presumably be less demanding than a highly regarded one, so there’s no reason he couldn’t work to cover the fees. If the adults around him didn’t teach him how to avoid debt, or if no one ever taught him to use the internet to improve his life, so be it. Good luck to him.

By the way, it is possible to find a job with a computer science degree from a university with lower entry requirements. University entry requirements are not important to employers, provided he can demonstrate his skills. He can do this by earning vendor certifications, researching online, completing plenty of programming projects and sharing them on GitHub and other platforms.

And the lad can still become a mechanic if he truly wishes to; there are ways to make it happen. There’s no need to give up on his dreams while he’s still young.

My eldest is doing A-levels, and my youngest is working towards their GCSEs. I’ve told them that, if they want to go to university, they can choose the one closest to home and continue living here, so they won’t need to take out loans to cover their living costs. We’ll pay their tuition fees too, so they won’t need loans for those either. Why burden them with debt when there are ways to avoid it? That’s how we see it.

If they want their own money, they can get jobs and earn it. Anyone who says they won’t learn to live independently is talking nonsense. It’s perfectly possible to learn to look after yourself while living with your parents. Parents just need to let their children take responsibility for household tasks that they don’t need to do themselves.

Edited

You are making a couple of assumptions here:

  1. That everyone lives within commuting distance of a university that does the course they want.
  1. That jobs are plentiful. There have been loads of posts about students not being able to get jobs, and "just get a job" isn't as simple as you think it is.
SpanThatWorld · 20/10/2026 07:42

cloudtreecarpet · 19/10/2026 08:35

Back in the 80s there were polytechnics & colleges too which offered different types of courses and required lower grades.

Polytechnics mostly offered degrees, exactly the same as universities. The great binary divide (as it was termed in the 80s/90s) was completely artificial. There was/is an idea that some courses are vocational and should be taught in one place and others academic and taught in a different way elsewhere.

Never held up when you suggested that medicine, law and architecture were vocational and should have therefore been studied at what was always dismissed as "the local poly".

Yes, you could HNDs at polytechnics but degrees were degrees and that's what polytechnics delivered.

The great expansion of higher education in the 1960s opened a number of new universities and expanded existing institutions into a larger number of polytechnics. The intention was to expand technical education skills but it was always a false dichotomy. Some of the original polytechnics had been established in the late 19th century to make academic study available to working people.

Is engineering vocational? It's taught at Cambridge. All the art schools that spawned 1960s counter culture were full of young people studying sign writing, technical drawing and advertising alongside the ones making sculpture out of their own gallstones.

The reason for the 1992 reorganisation of higher education was that there was no real dichotomy between the University of Brunel and Hatfield Polytechnic.

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2026 07:43

Jimmyjumpy · 20/10/2026 07:39

Are you personally involved? If not why are you so concerned.

We should all be concerned at the effects on the country, ie very high young unemployment at the same time as skills and recruitment shortages in some trades and professions. Something is clearly going wrong with our education and training systems. Just because someone isn’t directly affected personally doesn’t mean they don’t have a voice at societal level.

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2026 07:45

@SpanThatWorld

Polytechnics mostly offered degrees, exactly the same as universities.

Nope. I studied part time evening classes to become a qualified accountant at my nearest Poly. They did a huge range of adult education, part time, professional courses, not just degrees. Now it’s a uni, they don’t do any of that - it’s all degree courses. A degree in accounting doesn’t make you an accountant, you still have to do at least the final stage exams of the professional body which unis don’t offer courses for whereas in less time you could have taken all the professional body exams having been taught part time at a poly alongside work.

Newbutoldfather · 20/10/2026 07:50

@SpanThatWorld ,

‘Yes, you could HNDs at polytechnics but degrees were degrees and that's what polytechnics delivered’

’Degrees are degrees’ is another Orwellian truth that people are expected to believe. Suddenly these CCC A level students at a ‘new’ university are expected to tackle the same engineering course that an AAA* Cambridge student is tackling and, if they both come out with a 2(1), employers are expected to believe that they are equally capable?!

If you believe that I can sell you a great recipe for transforming lead into gold!

Some degrees have a lot of value, others very little. Employers are well aware of that and it is really unfair to sell degrees to 18 year olds who won’t really benefit from tertiary study, simultaneously loading the UK with yet more debt we can’t afford, both at the private and government level.

Goldenbear · 20/10/2026 07:52

Stowickthevast · 20/10/2026 07:09

I don't think this is true. People have been doing humanities at uni ever since they began pretty much. Look how many PMs did PPE or Greats at Oxford.

The STEM push is relatively recent.

I agree, tbh I am not convinced anyone thinks this, like the title, they are the argument is just incendiary rhetoric.

If you didn't have graduates of Humanities, Arts and Social sciences degrees where would the Lawmakers, Policy writers, those with critical thinking skills, those who explore ethical dilemmas, are committed to highlighting them and the consequences of ignoring them come from?

Goldenbear · 20/10/2026 07:54

Goldenbear · 20/10/2026 07:52

I agree, tbh I am not convinced anyone thinks this, like the title, they are the argument is just incendiary rhetoric.

If you didn't have graduates of Humanities, Arts and Social sciences degrees where would the Lawmakers, Policy writers, those with critical thinking skills, those who explore ethical dilemmas, are committed to highlighting them and the consequences of ignoring them come from?

The argument 'is' incendiary, that should read, not that 👆

disgracefullyyours · 20/10/2026 08:01

if no adults are able to pay them for him? A computer science degree, which you claim is a low-entry course, would presumably be less demanding than a highly regarded one, so there’s no reason he couldn’t work to cover the fees. If the adults around him didn’t teach him how to avoid debt, or if no one ever taught him to use the internet to improve his life, so be it. Good luck to him.

Because it would take him years to save the money for the fees (£30k for a three-year degree). You make it sound as if it would be as easy as saving for an expensive textbook or something.

SpanThatWorld · 20/10/2026 08:01

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2026 07:45

@SpanThatWorld

Polytechnics mostly offered degrees, exactly the same as universities.

Nope. I studied part time evening classes to become a qualified accountant at my nearest Poly. They did a huge range of adult education, part time, professional courses, not just degrees. Now it’s a uni, they don’t do any of that - it’s all degree courses. A degree in accounting doesn’t make you an accountant, you still have to do at least the final stage exams of the professional body which unis don’t offer courses for whereas in less time you could have taken all the professional body exams having been taught part time at a poly alongside work.

Edited

The offer often depended on which colleges had been subsumed into the Polytechnic over time.

When I worked at South Bank we had just taken over the National Baking School so continued to offer the ND Baking. No other NDs offered.

It also depended upon which other institutions were in the area. We were based in London so no shortage of places to study courses at other levels.

The majority of our courses were degrees but the major difference with local universities was that they could be staged (eg some were available as HNCs, most of them offered an HND if BTEC offered the option or a DipHE if not) and degrees were often offered in part time or evening only mode which was much rarer in the traditional university that I'd worked at previously. We had a couple of degree courses that were taught 9am-9pm over 1 or 2 days a week to fit around work.

There were professional courses offered - PSB had a big built environment offering - but they were increasingly converted into degree or masters level qualifications.

But in the 1980s, the majority of students were doing post A level study and course development was primarily focused on degrees.

SpanThatWorld · 20/10/2026 08:14

Newbutoldfather · 20/10/2026 07:50

@SpanThatWorld ,

‘Yes, you could HNDs at polytechnics but degrees were degrees and that's what polytechnics delivered’

’Degrees are degrees’ is another Orwellian truth that people are expected to believe. Suddenly these CCC A level students at a ‘new’ university are expected to tackle the same engineering course that an AAA* Cambridge student is tackling and, if they both come out with a 2(1), employers are expected to believe that they are equally capable?!

If you believe that I can sell you a great recipe for transforming lead into gold!

Some degrees have a lot of value, others very little. Employers are well aware of that and it is really unfair to sell degrees to 18 year olds who won’t really benefit from tertiary study, simultaneously loading the UK with yet more debt we can’t afford, both at the private and government level.

Cambridge and Oxford are really outliers. Most pre-92 universities aren't Oxbridge

Are people with AAB qualitatively different to those with BCC? Probably not. Once you control for family background, school experience, level of interest/commitment i doubt that you could demonstrate a clear difference in capacity to benefit from a particular course. Someone with mid level A levels from secondary school in a depressed agricultural area might have a thirst for education very different to the half-hearted alumnus of a home counties private school despite very similar A levels.

Do I think a degree from the University of Aston or Stirling is the same as one from Oxford Brookes?

Yeah, pretty much.

MerryAquaKoala · 20/10/2026 09:21

lljkk · 20/10/2026 07:21

"Uni is a good destination for my children not yours" is a favourite topic of MNers, yes.

Start a thread suggesting they join the military instead OP. See how that goes down.

Compulsory military service for all, at a certain age for a year or two, isn't a bad idea.

OP posts:
MerryAquaKoala · 20/10/2026 09:23

Jimmyjumpy · 20/10/2026 07:39

Are you personally involved? If not why are you so concerned.

Personally involved in what?

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 20/10/2026 09:23

MerryAquaKoala · 20/10/2026 09:21

Compulsory military service for all, at a certain age for a year or two, isn't a bad idea.

How old are you- 90s? As I'm wondering why you could suggest that without having done it yourself, unless of course you aren't from the UK?

MerryAquaKoala · 20/10/2026 09:28

NorthernJim · 20/10/2026 00:46

I voted YABU because you sound as though you think it's new issue, when it's been the going on for at least 20 years. And I actually think we're well past 'peak uni', lots of young people are seeing straight through the higher ed sales pitch and getting the 'university experience'. But the problem is that higher education is an industry that (apparently) can't afford to fail, so it's being propped up by the state. Quite unfortunate when you consider that many actual, real industries have been sold down the river by our governments over the last 50 years.

I don't think it's a new issue - I think its got much worse recently. Perhaps because of the current government moves to reduce YP employment, definitely because of AI, there's so many fewer roles available. Degree or no degree. But with a degree and huge debt? Horrendous. I agree totally with your comment about our governments ditching proper industries.

OP posts:
MerryAquaKoala · 20/10/2026 09:33

Goldenbear · 20/10/2026 09:23

How old are you- 90s? As I'm wondering why you could suggest that without having done it yourself, unless of course you aren't from the UK?

Why is that relevant. Other countries have done it more recently, and still do it. I don't understand why people are so against it. They'd expect to be protected in a war but not prepared to protect? I'd have done if it was compulsory - but as you say it wasn't a thing. My family is English and also from another country where military service is mandatory (for males) for a period.

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 20/10/2026 09:48

MerryAquaKoala · 20/10/2026 09:33

Why is that relevant. Other countries have done it more recently, and still do it. I don't understand why people are so against it. They'd expect to be protected in a war but not prepared to protect? I'd have done if it was compulsory - but as you say it wasn't a thing. My family is English and also from another country where military service is mandatory (for males) for a period.

Of course it's relevant as in a counterfactual world, you 'would' have been a young person willing to undertake National Service, at your current age you will never be asked. Equally, you are English and from another country, so you have dual nationality? Why can't you state the other country does it only have a population of three people so you would be identifiable?

MerryAquaKoala · 20/10/2026 09:51

Goldenbear · 20/10/2026 09:48

Of course it's relevant as in a counterfactual world, you 'would' have been a young person willing to undertake National Service, at your current age you will never be asked. Equally, you are English and from another country, so you have dual nationality? Why can't you state the other country does it only have a population of three people so you would be identifiable?

The point is for some it is mandatory (would be) mandatory, not a choice. Hard for some to understand. But anyway this isn't a thread about military service. I was answering a question. No derail please.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 20/10/2026 10:05

Totally agree, but there just aren’t enough good alternatives.

I’d love to see proper thought/resources put behind establishing decent apprenticeships and other preparation for the working world.

Goldenbear · 20/10/2026 10:07

MerryAquaKoala · 20/10/2026 09:51

The point is for some it is mandatory (would be) mandatory, not a choice. Hard for some to understand. But anyway this isn't a thread about military service. I was answering a question. No derail please.

Yes, for some people in different parts of the world it's mandatory and? It's not hard to understand but it certainly seems like you don't know why National Service came to an end in Britain.

ThePelican · 20/10/2026 10:31

OtterlyMad · 18/10/2026 08:53

FYI, universities have always accepted low A Level grades. My father got CDE in his A Levels in the 80s but was still got accepted onto a prestigious course at a red brick university simply because there was less competition for places. Whereas I got BBB in the 2010s, missed my target (ABB) by two marks and had to go through clearing to get into a very average institution! So please don’t use that as a basis to de-value degrees. Students are no less intelligent or hard-working these days than they were before (in fact, I would argue that the fierce competition means students work much harder than the previous generations who knew their degree would guarantee them a foot in the door and a decent career path!)

At the end of the 1980's only one in ten people got an A at A level. 20 years later it was one in four. Grade inflation is a very real thing. You can't compare the grades your father got with what subsequent generations got.

JudgeJ · 20/10/2026 11:43

Sartre · 19/10/2026 07:41

Teaching as well. When my Gran trained as a teacher she went to teacher college so only needed O Levels.

I doubt that, I went to a College of Education in 1967 and we certainly needed A levels, not only O levels.

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2026 12:02

JudgeJ · 20/10/2026 11:43

I doubt that, I went to a College of Education in 1967 and we certainly needed A levels, not only O levels.

My mother trained to be a teacher in the 60s and she didn't have any A levels. She took courses by evening classes at a local college of further education and some correspondence courses. I'm not even sure she had any O levels. She retrained from being a secretary once she had children. Perhaps she was doing O and A levels by evening class - I can't remember the specifics!

Sartre · 20/10/2026 12:11

JudgeJ · 20/10/2026 11:43

I doubt that, I went to a College of Education in 1967 and we certainly needed A levels, not only O levels.

Well, that’s what she told me. She only had O Levels and went to teacher training college in the early 60s, must have been 62/63ish in Yorkshire. Taught reception at the same school for 40 years.

OtterlyMad · 20/10/2026 12:18

ThePelican · 20/10/2026 10:31

At the end of the 1980's only one in ten people got an A at A level. 20 years later it was one in four. Grade inflation is a very real thing. You can't compare the grades your father got with what subsequent generations got.

See my other responses, not going to keep repeating myself.