This argument can be true for individuals but I don’t think it is helpful in general, as it sets up a polarity between ‘care’ and ‘education’, whereas ideally you want someone to have both, as shown in many of the recent maternity care scandals.
Yes there should be slower and more accessible routes towards qualification but a certain level of education is needed to evaluate evidence and make decisions, which is a key part of modern nursing, social work and midwifery.
Nor would an old-style qualification necessarily be fit for purpose in today’s hospital environment, where patients’ needs are far more acute and so many more treatments are available.
A family member (by marriage) had one of the old-style nursing qualifications from the late sixties/early seventies (which she entered without A Levels) and has occasionally talked about her training. It seemed to involve a lot of cleaning (obviously important for infection control), a lot of bed-making and the occasional lecture. It was clear that each ward was ruled by a fearsome matron with a rod of iron, implementing the god-given decisions of the doctors, so the idea of a mere nurse making any kind of decision about patient care would have been completely far-fetched.
She is a lovely caring person, now in later life, but her grasp of science is shaky (I know this because it has led her into some sticky situations domestically!) and I am not sure that I would ever have trusted her to evaluate symptoms in an unfamiliar patient or get a dosage right, as is required of modern nurses.
Interestingly, she did look at returning to nursing in the late nineties and was told that she would have to completely re-qualify with a degree, so she didn’t pursue it. Obviously what they probably should have said was that she could start work as a healthcare assistant and be supported to re-qualify gradually, which I think is what would be offered now.