Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are so many YP going to uni, when uni isn't right for so many YP? AIBU to think fewer YP should go to uni as it's only giving them a huge debt?

404 replies

MerryAquaKoala · 18/10/2026 08:41

It seems such a waste of time for so many, racking up huge debt and gaining no benefit from their degree whatsoever. It seems to me that uni's accept such low grades from A Level these days, it's literally a scheme to keep money going to the university and definitely not for the benefit of the YP.

It probably even comes further back to A Levels - A Levels aren't right for so many YP yet currently it seems they're funnelled into doing them anyway.

Something doesn't feel right with it all and in the end it's a YP left with huge debt for the rest of their life (usually). Seems so wrong.

OP posts:
Shatenoeuf · 19/10/2026 06:42

Its the poorer young people who are hurt the most. They tend to borrow more than better off peers, then spend the rest of their lives paying 9% graduate tax. Earnings often peak in 40s, so people spend 20 years accruing massive interest, then are hammered by extra 9% when they should be saving for retirement.

Sartre · 19/10/2026 06:46

I think anyone who wants to go to uni should be able to. I hate the notion of any working class young person being deterred from studying something they love just because of the debt. The debt is stupid, the interest is so high the vast majority of people will never repay it. You only actually start paying down the interest once you earn over 40k I believe and even then it’s a nominal amount. It seems absurd to even hand out loans as a result. It should be free as it once was and as it still is in Scotland.

Sartre · 19/10/2026 06:47

Shatenoeuf · 19/10/2026 06:42

Its the poorer young people who are hurt the most. They tend to borrow more than better off peers, then spend the rest of their lives paying 9% graduate tax. Earnings often peak in 40s, so people spend 20 years accruing massive interest, then are hammered by extra 9% when they should be saving for retirement.

They’re also hurt by being told they shouldn’t go to uni because it isn’t for people like them, it’s a middle class vocation.

Meadowfinch · 19/10/2026 06:52

GreenLemonade · 18/10/2026 15:26

Living costs are likely the largest element of this total but you would have those regardless. Uni student or not, everyone needs food, clothes, transport and a place to live.

But young people usually live at home with their family for the period 18-21 so they have no discernable housing costs and food is much cheaper included within the family meal. While ds was living with me, he cost me no more than £40 a week.
At uni he's costing about £250 a week.

MerryAquaKoala · 19/10/2026 07:38

Sartre · 19/10/2026 06:46

I think anyone who wants to go to uni should be able to. I hate the notion of any working class young person being deterred from studying something they love just because of the debt. The debt is stupid, the interest is so high the vast majority of people will never repay it. You only actually start paying down the interest once you earn over 40k I believe and even then it’s a nominal amount. It seems absurd to even hand out loans as a result. It should be free as it once was and as it still is in Scotland.

Plan 5 threshold for loan repayments is over 25k pa salary. Who knows when the 'interest' part kicks in. It's all one big blob of debt, in the end.

OP posts:
HoraceCope · 19/10/2026 07:40

so many jobs require degrees now, nursing for example
even admin
and some jobs that used to require degrees, now require masters
are you advocating an apprenticeship degree?

Sartre · 19/10/2026 07:40

MerryAquaKoala · 19/10/2026 07:38

Plan 5 threshold for loan repayments is over 25k pa salary. Who knows when the 'interest' part kicks in. It's all one big blob of debt, in the end.

Indeed. I meant when it starts actually getting paid off because prior to around 40k you’re just paying part of the interest.

Sartre · 19/10/2026 07:41

HoraceCope · 19/10/2026 07:40

so many jobs require degrees now, nursing for example
even admin
and some jobs that used to require degrees, now require masters
are you advocating an apprenticeship degree?

Teaching as well. When my Gran trained as a teacher she went to teacher college so only needed O Levels.

HoraceCope · 19/10/2026 07:55

and there is far less manufacturing now -

Stowickthevast · 19/10/2026 07:59

I think it's pretty depressing that I'm most other European countries, you can go to university for around £3k over 3 years. Far more affordable.

BadSkiingMum · 19/10/2026 08:07

CurlyKoalie · 18/10/2026 22:07

Totally agree with this.
We lose some of the people with the best empathic skills and common sense in these jobs because they are not good at academic studies.
I think it's a scandal that unemployment figures have been massaged for decades now by funnelling young people into FE to hide the fact that entry level jobs for school leavers have become so scarce.

This argument can be true for individuals but I don’t think it is helpful in general, as it sets up a polarity between ‘care’ and ‘education’, whereas ideally you want someone to have both, as shown in many of the recent maternity care scandals.

Yes there should be slower and more accessible routes towards qualification but a certain level of education is needed to evaluate evidence and make decisions, which is a key part of modern nursing, social work and midwifery.

Nor would an old-style qualification necessarily be fit for purpose in today’s hospital environment, where patients’ needs are far more acute and so many more treatments are available.

A family member (by marriage) had one of the old-style nursing qualifications from the late sixties/early seventies (which she entered without A Levels) and has occasionally talked about her training. It seemed to involve a lot of cleaning (obviously important for infection control), a lot of bed-making and the occasional lecture. It was clear that each ward was ruled by a fearsome matron with a rod of iron, implementing the god-given decisions of the doctors, so the idea of a mere nurse making any kind of decision about patient care would have been completely far-fetched.

She is a lovely caring person, now in later life, but her grasp of science is shaky (I know this because it has led her into some sticky situations domestically!) and I am not sure that I would ever have trusted her to evaluate symptoms in an unfamiliar patient or get a dosage right, as is required of modern nurses.

Interestingly, she did look at returning to nursing in the late nineties and was told that she would have to completely re-qualify with a degree, so she didn’t pursue it. Obviously what they probably should have said was that she could start work as a healthcare assistant and be supported to re-qualify gradually, which I think is what would be offered now.

disgracefullyyours · 19/10/2026 08:10

Sartre · 19/10/2026 07:40

Indeed. I meant when it starts actually getting paid off because prior to around 40k you’re just paying part of the interest.

And even then the plan five graduates will be paying off the loans for decades, because of the debt itself and the compounding interest. That could be money used to invest or saving for a house deposit. It’s the middle earners who’re really screwed, especially those who only have one income coming in.

cloudtreecarpet · 19/10/2026 08:14

OtterlyMad · 18/10/2026 08:53

FYI, universities have always accepted low A Level grades. My father got CDE in his A Levels in the 80s but was still got accepted onto a prestigious course at a red brick university simply because there was less competition for places. Whereas I got BBB in the 2010s, missed my target (ABB) by two marks and had to go through clearing to get into a very average institution! So please don’t use that as a basis to de-value degrees. Students are no less intelligent or hard-working these days than they were before (in fact, I would argue that the fierce competition means students work much harder than the previous generations who knew their degree would guarantee them a foot in the door and a decent career path!)

But you can't compare A levels from the 80s to A levels taken now. Fewer people got high grades then, A grades were very unusual and so subsequently offers made were much lower.
It would have been unusual to have to get three A grades to study something then whereas now that is pretty standard.

Also obviously university education was free but far fewer people went and fewer people stayed on for A levels because you could leave at 16 and get a job.

It was a very, very different time and I don't think you can make a direct comparison with now.

Newbutoldfather · 19/10/2026 08:25

@OtterlyMad and @cloudtreecarpet ,

Since the introduction of the A* grade at A level, you have to mark down every grade by 1 compared to before the introduction.

So AAA today was equivalent to BBB before its introduction.

In the old days grades were strictly adjusted to fit percentages. So maybe 10% would get As 20% Bs etc, with the average being a C. Since it was decided (randomly) thag pupils were getting smarter and working harder, that was abandoned and grade inflation started.

The A grade was introduced to distinguish the very best candidates, with the idea it was reserved for the top 5-6% of candidates. However last summer, nearly 10% of all A level grades were A and nearly 18% of Maths A levels. Boards are companies and schools choose the boards where their students will get the best grades.

Nearly 60% of A levels were A* to B. This makes universities’ selection very hard.

The type of study pursued at the top universities just isn’t accessible to that many people.

Newbutoldfather · 19/10/2026 08:26
  • A* grade
OtterlyMad · 19/10/2026 08:34

cloudtreecarpet · 19/10/2026 08:14

But you can't compare A levels from the 80s to A levels taken now. Fewer people got high grades then, A grades were very unusual and so subsequently offers made were much lower.
It would have been unusual to have to get three A grades to study something then whereas now that is pretty standard.

Also obviously university education was free but far fewer people went and fewer people stayed on for A levels because you could leave at 16 and get a job.

It was a very, very different time and I don't think you can make a direct comparison with now.

I dislike the undertone of comments that suggest students are less intelligent or hardworking than previous generations, because it is simply untrue. People unable to think critically say “look how many students get As now, A Levels are sooo much easier these days!” instead of realising that students work their bloody arses off to get As because if they don’t, they won’t get accepted onto their course. Whereas in the 80s, those fortunate kids like my dad who came from wealthy middle class families knew they were going to university no matter what, and could put in minimal effort for maximum reward.

cloudtreecarpet · 19/10/2026 08:35

Newbutoldfather · 19/10/2026 08:25

@OtterlyMad and @cloudtreecarpet ,

Since the introduction of the A* grade at A level, you have to mark down every grade by 1 compared to before the introduction.

So AAA today was equivalent to BBB before its introduction.

In the old days grades were strictly adjusted to fit percentages. So maybe 10% would get As 20% Bs etc, with the average being a C. Since it was decided (randomly) thag pupils were getting smarter and working harder, that was abandoned and grade inflation started.

The A grade was introduced to distinguish the very best candidates, with the idea it was reserved for the top 5-6% of candidates. However last summer, nearly 10% of all A level grades were A and nearly 18% of Maths A levels. Boards are companies and schools choose the boards where their students will get the best grades.

Nearly 60% of A levels were A* to B. This makes universities’ selection very hard.

The type of study pursued at the top universities just isn’t accessible to that many people.

Back in the 80s there were polytechnics & colleges too which offered different types of courses and required lower grades.

HoraceCope · 19/10/2026 08:35

what other choice is there?

OtterlyMad · 19/10/2026 08:44

Newbutoldfather · 19/10/2026 08:25

@OtterlyMad and @cloudtreecarpet ,

Since the introduction of the A* grade at A level, you have to mark down every grade by 1 compared to before the introduction.

So AAA today was equivalent to BBB before its introduction.

In the old days grades were strictly adjusted to fit percentages. So maybe 10% would get As 20% Bs etc, with the average being a C. Since it was decided (randomly) thag pupils were getting smarter and working harder, that was abandoned and grade inflation started.

The A grade was introduced to distinguish the very best candidates, with the idea it was reserved for the top 5-6% of candidates. However last summer, nearly 10% of all A level grades were A and nearly 18% of Maths A levels. Boards are companies and schools choose the boards where their students will get the best grades.

Nearly 60% of A levels were A* to B. This makes universities’ selection very hard.

The type of study pursued at the top universities just isn’t accessible to that many people.

But why is “grade inflation” the only possible explanation for students getting higher grades on average? Now that there is more competition for places, it makes perfect sense that students are studying harder than ever before to attain those higher grades, to ensure they can get into their chosen university and career path.

Newbutoldfather · 19/10/2026 08:45

@OtterlyMad ,

‘I dislike the undertone of comments that suggest students are less intelligent or hardworking than previous generations, because it is simply untrue. People unable to think critically say “look how many students get As now, A Levels are sooo much easier these days!” instead of realising that students work their bloody arses off to get As because if they don’t, they won’t get accepted onto their course.’

I went to Uni in the 80s and that’s not how I recall it at all. How could it have been easier when only about 7% of people went to a traditional university?!

Oxbridge had their own exam, which was biased towards private schools, because most took it ‘7th term’, but it was very hard and was taken in the first term of Year 13 for those without the luxury of a 7th term. There were also ‘s levels’ which were way harder than A levels and were a part of your offer from a top university like Oxford, Cambridge or Imperial.

The reality is that students used to work harder but it probably didn’t feel as hard as there was less ‘noise’ around the work. No internet, no mobiles and 4 TV channels meant there was only work, family time and seeing friends, which mostly didn’t happen on school nights.

It’s no one’s fault but, for the last 10 years or so, IQs have actually declined for the first time in history. The excess of 2 1s and 1sts given to very average people is a disgrace.

The reality is that, with the exception of the Russell Group unis (at most), a degree is more a sign of class than ability, as many cannot pay and don’t have the confidence to build up a huge student debt.

CeeJay81 · 19/10/2026 08:56

I think it's cause there arent a lot of options these days. A lot less apprenticeships than there used to be. My 17 year old DS is applying to University but he hasn't decided if he def wants to go. He isnt accedemic but will just about pass his A Levels/BTEC courses. Probably do better in the ICT one. He likes Computers, so is considering Computer Science/Cyber Security degree. It is hard to know what you want to do at that age and what are the options? He could try and find a job but we live in a very rural part of the country. The options are limited.

Sartre · 19/10/2026 08:59

CeeJay81 · 19/10/2026 08:56

I think it's cause there arent a lot of options these days. A lot less apprenticeships than there used to be. My 17 year old DS is applying to University but he hasn't decided if he def wants to go. He isnt accedemic but will just about pass his A Levels/BTEC courses. Probably do better in the ICT one. He likes Computers, so is considering Computer Science/Cyber Security degree. It is hard to know what you want to do at that age and what are the options? He could try and find a job but we live in a very rural part of the country. The options are limited.

Edited

If he isn’t academic and will just scrape a pass in A Levels as you say, something like computer science will be tough going. It’s also unlikely he’d be accepted if he’s set to get C’s.

CeeJay81 · 19/10/2026 09:06

Sartre · 19/10/2026 08:59

If he isn’t academic and will just scrape a pass in A Levels as you say, something like computer science will be tough going. It’s also unlikely he’d be accepted if he’s set to get C’s.

I think he will get a B equivalent in ICT and the other ones Cs. Fair enough if he doesnt get in. It's hard to know what he can do next though. If he tries the local University and struggles, it's less debt(we get some grant here in Wales). He is trying this year though. What are young people suppose to do if they arent academic? Just find work? Which isn't easy these days. He currently works in a pub around studies. So at least he has some experience.

Newbutoldfather · 19/10/2026 09:12

@OtterlyMad ,

Why do you think that there is more competition for places? That isn’t evidenced at all bar maybe Oxbridge, Imperial, LSE and medicine/veterinary science.

The fact that so many people go to uni means that, by definition, it is less competitive. In addition, since we left the EU and are trying to continue immigration, a lot of European candidates no longer apply to British unis.

It is an open secret that uni offers are also inflated on the whole. So, if a candidate is offered AAA and gets AAB (or sometimes even ABB), he will get a message from the uni saying that they will be offered a place anyway.

Sartre · 19/10/2026 09:13

Newbutoldfather · 19/10/2026 09:12

@OtterlyMad ,

Why do you think that there is more competition for places? That isn’t evidenced at all bar maybe Oxbridge, Imperial, LSE and medicine/veterinary science.

The fact that so many people go to uni means that, by definition, it is less competitive. In addition, since we left the EU and are trying to continue immigration, a lot of European candidates no longer apply to British unis.

It is an open secret that uni offers are also inflated on the whole. So, if a candidate is offered AAA and gets AAB (or sometimes even ABB), he will get a message from the uni saying that they will be offered a place anyway.

That’s because the government removed caps so Russell groups were able to take a whole host more students than they previously could. It’s business, they got greedy and wanted to start hoovering up the talent who either may have got slightly lower grades or actually got the grades but previously wouldn’t have been allowed in if the course was full anyway. This is also partly why post 92s are suffering.