Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are so many YP going to uni, when uni isn't right for so many YP? AIBU to think fewer YP should go to uni as it's only giving them a huge debt?

404 replies

MerryAquaKoala · 18/10/2026 08:41

It seems such a waste of time for so many, racking up huge debt and gaining no benefit from their degree whatsoever. It seems to me that uni's accept such low grades from A Level these days, it's literally a scheme to keep money going to the university and definitely not for the benefit of the YP.

It probably even comes further back to A Levels - A Levels aren't right for so many YP yet currently it seems they're funnelled into doing them anyway.

Something doesn't feel right with it all and in the end it's a YP left with huge debt for the rest of their life (usually). Seems so wrong.

OP posts:
Sartre · 19/10/2026 09:15

CeeJay81 · 19/10/2026 09:06

I think he will get a B equivalent in ICT and the other ones Cs. Fair enough if he doesnt get in. It's hard to know what he can do next though. If he tries the local University and struggles, it's less debt(we get some grant here in Wales). He is trying this year though. What are young people suppose to do if they arent academic? Just find work? Which isn't easy these days. He currently works in a pub around studies. So at least he has some experience.

This is why I like Burnham’s push for technical/vocational education and more apprenticeships because you’re right, not every young person is academic and there’s nothing wrong with this at all. Nobody should feel pushed into uni because there’s no other option, nor should anyone feel pushed out due to the threat of debt.

ViciousCurrentBun · 19/10/2026 09:19

It was very obviously going to happen. When Blair started pushing for expanded numbers in 1999. DH and I were still relatively fresh faced junior staff in higher education. I can remember the rumblings back then especially among senior staff. Unless those numbers were going to match a sudden leap needed in graduate level jobs needed there would be too many graduates.

My friend married a French guy in the mid nineties who came to England because his degree was worth much more in England because in France the push for more numbers getting a degree had already happened. He was an exceptionally clever man but he was just one among a too huge number by that point in France.

@Newbutoldfather RG Universities exist because a bunch of Vice Chancellors decided to call themselves that when they had a meet up at the Russell hotel in Russell Square. They were and are research led institutions that self selected themselves, a lobbying group. They are dreadful at resting on their laurels though. I have studied at one and worked in two and DH has studied at one and worked in one and also an ex poly.

DS retired recently as head of a dept, he said there was a decline in the level of students coming, especially post Covid, well more their attitude. I left before Covid.

RaggedRocks · 19/10/2026 09:21

Eventually, a lot of our young people will end up in India, delivery fast food on e bikes.

cloudtreecarpet · 19/10/2026 09:24

OtterlyMad · 19/10/2026 08:34

I dislike the undertone of comments that suggest students are less intelligent or hardworking than previous generations, because it is simply untrue. People unable to think critically say “look how many students get As now, A Levels are sooo much easier these days!” instead of realising that students work their bloody arses off to get As because if they don’t, they won’t get accepted onto their course. Whereas in the 80s, those fortunate kids like my dad who came from wealthy middle class families knew they were going to university no matter what, and could put in minimal effort for maximum reward.

I didn't say that it was harder then, just that the way grades were awarded was different, the teaching was different, we didn't have computers or access to the wealth of information on the internet. We just studied from certain set texts & articles, everything was more limited.

Actually, I think my own kids worked way harder than I did to get their A levels and work way harder at University too.

All I was saying is that when your dad (and I) did A levels and went to University the whole landscape was entirely different so a direct comparison with now doesn't make sense.

Newbutoldfather · 19/10/2026 09:35

It amazes me how many people want to believe that young people are somehow meriting their top uni grades and A levels and then assume, as a corollary, that previous generations were either stupider or less hard working.

There is literally no real evidence to support this! If anyone has any evidence, I would love to see it.

IQs have been dropping ever since smart phones existed, as we fail to learn how to concentrate and, however hard working you are, you cannot get a strong degree without a certain level of innate intelligence.

Of course, there are loads of individual exceptions and wonderful young people but, on average, people are less intelligent and less hard working than previous (pre internet, pre smartphone) generations.

I guess the whole university factory depends on us accepting an Orwellian version of the truth.

RaggedRocks · 19/10/2026 09:40

To get closer to the EU, AB will have to offer the EU freedom of movement for under 30s. There will be another wave of East European migrants, and it will become even tougher for our YP to get work. They can't go abroad because they couldn't even buy a sandwich using their GCSE grade 4 French.

MerryAquaKoala · 19/10/2026 09:41

'It amazes me how many people want to believe that young people are somehow meriting their top uni grades and A levels and then assume, as a corollary, that previous generations were either stupider or less hard working.'

The crux of your statement being 'want to believe'. ie. a personal narrative built around justifying one's own conclusions. Very common these days.

Nothing else can reasonably explain why, for example in the mid 90's, 5% (max) got a first on the degree I did. And now it is apparently, about 40%. That simply does not add up.

OP posts:
BigFatLiar · 19/10/2026 10:07

When I was younger you went to uni for what we now see as stem subjects. Arts type subjects you were essentially going to be a teacher. If you didn't want to go to uni there were usually plenty of 5 year apprenticeships going which would normally allow you to do city and guilds. If you wanted to work in stem there were the equivalent of apprenticeships where you started as a lab technician and went to day release for ONC or HNC maybe even leading to graduate level qualifications eg Graduate of the Institute of Physics (or Chemistry etc). These technicians type jobs are now being filled by graduates and Phds as entry level.

I didn't graduate uni but gained a professional qualification studying part time (paid by work) while working. It's sad seeing so many push to graduate only to end up in unfullfilling jobs they're over qualified for and taking an opportunity that someone less qualified would be grateful for.

Goldenbear · 19/10/2026 10:29

Newbutoldfather · 18/10/2026 16:59

@LoudWriter ,

‘Actually, now I'm writing it, maybe it is for the best- avoid any higher education or institution which might teach us about anything existential that will help us see how enslaved hypercapitalism is going to make us and instill us with cold dread...’

Do you have any idea what percentage of the population have the population have a cognitive ability to write a paragraph like that? My bet is 15% tops.

The reality is that, unless you are getting a bunch of 7-9s at GCSE, decent grades at A levels are highly unlikely. And, unless you are at least getting an A and a couple of Bs at A level, how unsuited you are to tertiary education.

I couldn’t agree more that if you genuinely love Fourier transformations in optics or carefully parsing historical documents and analysing them, then uni is for you. The average IQ of the population is 100. I would bet that you probably don’t have any friends with an IQ of below 110.

For a lot of people uni is a con. Unless you can access a degree at a really good uni or a vocational qualification (say nursing), then there is no point in tertiary education.
Other countries do things a lot better than us by giving academic education to the few who can access it and good quality vocational education to the majority who cannot.

Your assertion that a young person's intellectual capacity for undertaking a degree at a good university can be determined by the number of GCSES grades 7-9 is part of the bigger problem with education. Education has become so standardised, measured and managed that we are losing the essence of what an 'education' is and we come to conclusions like yours, that children not awarded 10 7-9s at GCSE level, should really resign themselves at 16 to the idea that they are not cut out for the the intellectual demands of higher education. Whereas this is actually a pretty unreliable indicator of intelligence because all it shows is that at the school they attended they haven't been taught the script, this maybe because at an intellectual level they reject this corporate notion of an 'education', they won't play the game, it maybe because their teachers don't even notice them which let's face it is a high number of kids these days if they are not exceptional and don't have SEND or it could be because they have not peaked at 15/16 and don't have the maturity of thought to apply this cynical awareness to the pathway they choose to take.
The education system in schools is where the problems of potential being reached begin and his is only going to get worse with AI being used so freely to create lessons that are uniform and a loss of grass roots innovation occurs.

Newbutoldfather · 19/10/2026 10:34

@Goldenbear ,

‘Your assertion that a young person's intellectual capacity for undertaking a degree at a good university can be determined by the number of GCSES grades 7-9 is part of the bigger problem with education.’

That isn’t my assertion at all! People are individuals and should be treated as such.

However, I do assert it at a population level. That is completely different. I think that GCSEs are a good measure at population level. For every SEN student with a spiky profile or late developer, there will be a very well taught slightly stupider pupil or an early developer who achieved above their expectations.

There are correlations published between GCSE grades and A level grades and, especially in the STEM subjects, the correlations are very strong.

BigMartin · 19/10/2026 10:35

I don’t think you are necessarily being unreasonable but I think for a lot of jobs where a bright school leaver with decent O Levels would be employed they now give the job to graduates. This does reinforce your point that there are too many graduates though.

RaggedRocks · 19/10/2026 10:41

There is a bleak future ahead for many, sadly.

Newbutoldfather · 19/10/2026 10:53

I do feel a bit scared for the future, but maybe that is a sign of age.

We do need to decide what we want, or don’t want, to do with AI. Ideally, before it is too late.

However, it does seem to me that humans will always need interaction with other humans and there are a lot of mid skilled jobs in the service sector that need training, but nothing like a degree. Think things like waiters, chefs, personal trainers, fitness staff etc etc, as well as nurses and carers.

There will be fewer and fewer jobs for average graduates and expecting a job just because you have an average degree (which, sadly, even includes a 2(1) now) from an average university is a road to cruel disappointment.

Ndrw · 19/10/2026 10:54

RaggedRocks · 19/10/2026 09:40

To get closer to the EU, AB will have to offer the EU freedom of movement for under 30s. There will be another wave of East European migrants, and it will become even tougher for our YP to get work. They can't go abroad because they couldn't even buy a sandwich using their GCSE grade 4 French.

But I thought FOM was the bestest thing ever

Goldenbear · 19/10/2026 12:57

RaggedRocks · 19/10/2026 09:40

To get closer to the EU, AB will have to offer the EU freedom of movement for under 30s. There will be another wave of East European migrants, and it will become even tougher for our YP to get work. They can't go abroad because they couldn't even buy a sandwich using their GCSE grade 4 French.

Are you basing that assumption on your own poor foreign language skills!

Goldenbear · 19/10/2026 12:57

RaggedRocks · 19/10/2026 10:41

There is a bleak future ahead for many, sadly.

No there isn't.

ThisTicklishFatball · 20/10/2026 00:15

Cars4Gov · 18/10/2026 09:46

The issue is two fold. The current job market means even well educated and talented young people are not getting jobs..Plus too many young people have gone to University. The AI secure jobs include the trades yet this is disregarded by many schools and parents.

I know a lad who has a strong interest in mechanics and cars but is now on a poorly rated computer sciences degree instead of training as a mechanic. Why? The Uni pathway was straightforward...the mechanic training pathway was not sign posted. It was way easier to get onto a low entry degree course that needed bums on seats than a local mechanic training course. He's attending only a few hours a week, lives at home, will have fees debt and importantly isn't developing a work ethic.

If he drops out of the course he will feel a failure and be less motivated to get a job. If he completes the degree he will not be competitive enough to get a grad job. I think this scenario is happening to many young people.

Why doesn’t the lad work to pay his university fees if no adults are able to pay them for him? A computer science degree, which you claim is a low-entry course, would presumably be less demanding than a highly regarded one, so there’s no reason he couldn’t work to cover the fees. If the adults around him didn’t teach him how to avoid debt, or if no one ever taught him to use the internet to improve his life, so be it. Good luck to him.

By the way, it is possible to find a job with a computer science degree from a university with lower entry requirements. University entry requirements are not important to employers, provided he can demonstrate his skills. He can do this by earning vendor certifications, researching online, completing plenty of programming projects and sharing them on GitHub and other platforms.

And the lad can still become a mechanic if he truly wishes to; there are ways to make it happen. There’s no need to give up on his dreams while he’s still young.

My eldest is doing A-levels, and my youngest is working towards their GCSEs. I’ve told them that, if they want to go to university, they can choose the one closest to home and continue living here, so they won’t need to take out loans to cover their living costs. We’ll pay their tuition fees too, so they won’t need loans for those either. Why burden them with debt when there are ways to avoid it? That’s how we see it.

If they want their own money, they can get jobs and earn it. Anyone who says they won’t learn to live independently is talking nonsense. It’s perfectly possible to learn to look after yourself while living with your parents. Parents just need to let their children take responsibility for household tasks that they don’t need to do themselves.

NorthernJim · 20/10/2026 00:46

I voted YABU because you sound as though you think it's new issue, when it's been the going on for at least 20 years. And I actually think we're well past 'peak uni', lots of young people are seeing straight through the higher ed sales pitch and getting the 'university experience'. But the problem is that higher education is an industry that (apparently) can't afford to fail, so it's being propped up by the state. Quite unfortunate when you consider that many actual, real industries have been sold down the river by our governments over the last 50 years.

MandemChickenShop · 20/10/2026 06:20

PoliteSquid · 18/10/2026 08:54

Applying for uni is considerably easier than securing a full time job or apprenticeship.

You can apply to 5 courses and be pretty much guaranteed a place by completing one form. Whereas each job and apprenticeship has a different form and multiple stages in the recruitment process.

I don't think you can generalise like that. Depends on the course, depends on the job

Stowickthevast · 20/10/2026 07:09

BigFatLiar · 19/10/2026 10:07

When I was younger you went to uni for what we now see as stem subjects. Arts type subjects you were essentially going to be a teacher. If you didn't want to go to uni there were usually plenty of 5 year apprenticeships going which would normally allow you to do city and guilds. If you wanted to work in stem there were the equivalent of apprenticeships where you started as a lab technician and went to day release for ONC or HNC maybe even leading to graduate level qualifications eg Graduate of the Institute of Physics (or Chemistry etc). These technicians type jobs are now being filled by graduates and Phds as entry level.

I didn't graduate uni but gained a professional qualification studying part time (paid by work) while working. It's sad seeing so many push to graduate only to end up in unfullfilling jobs they're over qualified for and taking an opportunity that someone less qualified would be grateful for.

I don't think this is true. People have been doing humanities at uni ever since they began pretty much. Look how many PMs did PPE or Greats at Oxford.

The STEM push is relatively recent.

PlinketyplonkSlinketyslonk · 20/10/2026 07:14

How much guidance are young people actually given on the different paths they can take once they leave school?

lljkk · 20/10/2026 07:21

"Uni is a good destination for my children not yours" is a favourite topic of MNers, yes.

Start a thread suggesting they join the military instead OP. See how that goes down.

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2026 07:37

Employers need to start reversing their stupid recruitment criteria where a degree, any degree, any subject, any grade, is a basic requirement where you can’t get past the first application stage without one. Not only big business, but public sector too. Police, nursing, teaching etc need to have better alternative entry routes, as does social services, councils, etc. We need to stop the lazy recruitment processes. Then young people will have better options for entering the workplace straight from school/college without being ostracised for lack of a degree.

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2026 07:38

PlinketyplonkSlinketyslonk · 20/10/2026 07:14

How much guidance are young people actually given on the different paths they can take once they leave school?

Bugger all, but they get bugger all careers advice within schools too!

Jimmyjumpy · 20/10/2026 07:39

Are you personally involved? If not why are you so concerned.