Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling inherited house when sibling living in it

655 replies

Dutchhouse14 · 16/10/2026 11:50

Our DM passed away a few months ago and her will divides everything equally between me and my 2 siblings.
Im the sole executor.
Dsis ,mid 50s, has always lived at home, never moved out. Towards the end of mums life she became her carer.
She works limited hours although she has increased these with overtime since mum passed away but full time contracts are non existent in her sector.
Shes used to pay a small amount of housekeeping but this stopped when she was made redundant from full time work about 10 years ago.
DMs house is in a bad state of repair, none of us can afford to maintain it . Me and my other sibling want to sell.
But DSis is resisting ,not replying to texts, avoiding phones calls, went out when estates agents came round for valuations etc
She has limited income and savings but could get a small mortgage and with proceeds of sale she could get a 1 bed flat.
My other sibling agrees we need to sell but doesn't want to upset dsis and is generally very good at avoidance! They are happy to give Dsis a much bigger share ie 50% I would prefer 40% which i think is realistic for dsis to buy somewhere.
So ive become the wicked witch of the West in Dsis eyes and shes taking it all out on me, well basically stopped talking to me.
WIBU to put the house on the market?
Probate has been granted.
Anyone know what the legal situation is?
I dont want to fall out with Dsis, I love her, but she seems filled with resentment for me and frankly has said some very hurtful things.
Ive always been there for her but shes never ever reciprocated or supported me when ive needed it.
Although I live with DH and DC, the money would really help my future, my pension etc and I dont want to give my share to Dsis, which is what I think she really wants as shes used to being in charge of DMs money , always lived here so I think basically considers everything as hers.
Just dont know how to move things forward or if im being unreasonable selling the house and wanting my share

OP posts:
knockyknees · 25/10/2026 00:37

Your friend is correct- your sister is manipulating you.

I would stick to the exact wording of the will and only give your sister the 1/3 she is entitled to and not a penny more.

XenaSharples · 25/10/2026 01:50

Don't take her word for it regarding her savings.

GabriellaFaith · 25/10/2026 21:17

You shouldn't 'love' and forgive someone just because they are family. She is acting awful, proper spoilt brat, lazy, unreasonable, rude, manipulative and you are encouraging it.

Have her removed if needed, she needs to grow up.

Sizzlingsnowdrop · 26/10/2026 13:29

Sibling wins care costs.

sittingonabeach · 26/10/2026 13:37

But that is different as mum moved into daughter’s home. So specially moved in for care

In this instance, sister had been freeloading for years (maybe siblings could claim unpaid rent as part of the estate) well before care was needed

Sizzlingsnowdrop · 26/10/2026 14:03

sittingonabeach · 26/10/2026 13:37

But that is different as mum moved into daughter’s home. So specially moved in for care

In this instance, sister had been freeloading for years (maybe siblings could claim unpaid rent as part of the estate) well before care was needed

Not so very different - the sibling in the news story didn’t claim for costs associated with a stay in her home, indeed this is exactly
what the ‘estate’ agreed to pay at
£50 a week (lol). She claimed for care. So it is irrelevant where the location of that care
took place. The sum claimed for also equates to roughly what 2.5 years in a care home would have cost. So, yes, I would say it sets a precedent and is relevant to this thread.

sittingonabeach · 26/10/2026 14:10

Sizzlingsnowdrop · 26/10/2026 14:03

Not so very different - the sibling in the news story didn’t claim for costs associated with a stay in her home, indeed this is exactly
what the ‘estate’ agreed to pay at
£50 a week (lol). She claimed for care. So it is irrelevant where the location of that care
took place. The sum claimed for also equates to roughly what 2.5 years in a care home would have cost. So, yes, I would say it sets a precedent and is relevant to this thread.

So what about the lack of rent from the sister for 30 years

Yorkshirelass50 · 26/10/2026 15:22

sittingonabeach · 26/10/2026 14:10

So what about the lack of rent from the sister for 30 years

The OP said her sister was paying housekeeping until recent years. Does all her years of care count for nothing? She could have spent that time working. She may have sacrificed her personal income to care for their mother.

Another2Cats · 26/10/2026 15:33

This wasn't so much a case of whether the daughter should be paid (that had already been decided at an earlier hearing) but rather, how much.

What is different in that reported case is that it is accepted that the mother agreed to be cared for by the daughter "for a reasonable price".

It was found that the mother

"was a lady who knew she had sufficient resources, who did not want charity, and wanted to be looked after properly, preferably in her own home, but, failing that, living with one of her children"

and that

"She insisted, not only to the claimant but also to the claimant's husband and children, that the claimant had to be paid "properly" for looking after her, notwithstanding that the claimant was her daughter"

Just by way of background, the daughter had worked as an auxiliary nurse when she was younger and her husband is a GP. The judge said:

"...between them they were capable of providing a level of care equal to or exceeding that of a professional trained carer."

The daughter claimed payment for services at £150 per day and the judge decided that figure "falls comfortably within the range of reasonable remuneration which the parties must have objectively be taken to have intended."

Everything depends on the facts of a case. This reported case appears to be somewhat different from the OPs situation. Unless there is evidence that the mother had specifically said to the daughter that she would be paid.

Link to the judgment

https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWHC/Ch/2026/2231.html

Rogers v Wills [2026] EWHC 2231 (Ch) (25 August 2026)

https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=%2Few%2Fcases%2FEWHC%2FCh%2F2026%2F2231.html

sittingonabeach · 26/10/2026 15:34

Yorkshirelass50 · 26/10/2026 15:22

The OP said her sister was paying housekeeping until recent years. Does all her years of care count for nothing? She could have spent that time working. She may have sacrificed her personal income to care for their mother.

The housekeeping appears to be less than your average student would pay for keep. She appears then to have stopped paying this nominal sum when made redundant a good few years before she started to care for her mum. Her mum was paying all the bills. It appears she has benefitted hugely from not having to pay for housing, bills food etc for about 30 years. I would say her caring for her mum was in lieu of this (and I say that as someone who is caring for an elderly relative)
She was illegally spending her DM’s money (should go through POA) and potentially providing sub standard care for her DM. In this time she has amassed quite healthy savings pot
Not sure I would see her as hard done by

Sizzlingsnowdrop · 26/10/2026 16:42

Another2Cats · 26/10/2026 15:33

This wasn't so much a case of whether the daughter should be paid (that had already been decided at an earlier hearing) but rather, how much.

What is different in that reported case is that it is accepted that the mother agreed to be cared for by the daughter "for a reasonable price".

It was found that the mother

"was a lady who knew she had sufficient resources, who did not want charity, and wanted to be looked after properly, preferably in her own home, but, failing that, living with one of her children"

and that

"She insisted, not only to the claimant but also to the claimant's husband and children, that the claimant had to be paid "properly" for looking after her, notwithstanding that the claimant was her daughter"

Just by way of background, the daughter had worked as an auxiliary nurse when she was younger and her husband is a GP. The judge said:

"...between them they were capable of providing a level of care equal to or exceeding that of a professional trained carer."

The daughter claimed payment for services at £150 per day and the judge decided that figure "falls comfortably within the range of reasonable remuneration which the parties must have objectively be taken to have intended."

Everything depends on the facts of a case. This reported case appears to be somewhat different from the OPs situation. Unless there is evidence that the mother had specifically said to the daughter that she would be paid.

Link to the judgment

https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWHC/Ch/2026/2231.html

That’s a really hard read detailing the level of care provided by the claimant and her husband, neither of whom were young. I’m not sure their medical backgrounds is relevant, accept to show that they were not incompetent; the settlement figure is based on Home Instead commercial rates and their carers have basic care training and are
not required to be medically qualified. It certainly wouldn’t exclude a claim by anyone not medically experienced.

The agreement to ‘pay her way’ had some
recorded evidence but as the Defendant obviously majored on, what that meant was not outlined clearly . The judge decided that there was sufficient evidence to award though and I think this opens up similar claims as the BBC report highlights.

As a person who provides care whilst my sibling opts out and lives in La-la land regarding what is needed to maintain our parent at home, I am always naturally inclined to support the carer. However, I can also see the Defendant’s point of view; an obligation as
executor to defend the estate and no formal agreement to pay a commercial care rate in place. And it’s this latter point that changes the landscape. It seems to open up the field to claims where arrangements have evolved and no clear and recorded decisions were
made.

*just editing to add, what a nasty situation this turned out to be as well. The successful claimant was reported to the police as she removed 100k on the death of her mother. I can’t help but feel that this was unwise and that, like many situations, there was a lack of communication on all sides.the case
went to trial and the claimant was cleared however, better that the care payments were pre-agreed and paid during the period of care than to help yourself to a notional amount just as the person dies.

wombat1a · 26/10/2026 17:21

You need to go down the legal route, you can put it on the marker but it won't sell/complete without her agreeing to move out - unless you can sell it as a buy-to-rent and it gets rented back to her perhaps by the new owner?

NovemberMorn · 26/10/2026 17:26

sittingonabeach · 26/10/2026 15:34

The housekeeping appears to be less than your average student would pay for keep. She appears then to have stopped paying this nominal sum when made redundant a good few years before she started to care for her mum. Her mum was paying all the bills. It appears she has benefitted hugely from not having to pay for housing, bills food etc for about 30 years. I would say her caring for her mum was in lieu of this (and I say that as someone who is caring for an elderly relative)
She was illegally spending her DM’s money (should go through POA) and potentially providing sub standard care for her DM. In this time she has amassed quite healthy savings pot
Not sure I would see her as hard done by

Where did the OP say the sister was 'illegally spending her DM.s money'?.
We have no idea what arrangment the carer/sister had with her mother when mum was alive.
We also have no idea whether it was the mothers wish to stay in her family home till she died, and we dont know whether she refused different carers going in several times a day....which is upsetting and disruptive for many elderly people.

catsandpolitics · 26/10/2026 17:42

NovemberMorn · 26/10/2026 17:26

Where did the OP say the sister was 'illegally spending her DM.s money'?.
We have no idea what arrangment the carer/sister had with her mother when mum was alive.
We also have no idea whether it was the mothers wish to stay in her family home till she died, and we dont know whether she refused different carers going in several times a day....which is upsetting and disruptive for many elderly people.

She just used the mother's debit card, rather than officially through POA. That is illegal. I wonder if she did that so the spending appeared to be the mother's. I think the OP said POA had been set up for the sister.

NovemberMorn · 26/10/2026 17:46

catsandpolitics · 26/10/2026 17:42

She just used the mother's debit card, rather than officially through POA. That is illegal. I wonder if she did that so the spending appeared to be the mother's. I think the OP said POA had been set up for the sister.

You are right....I have just been reading how things have changed since I looked after my own mums finances.
We had an understanding between us, and also the local bank knew I was dealing with mums money matters, bills etc.

It's gotten a lot stricter now, and POA is needed when someone cannot deal with their own finances.

Sizzlingsnowdrop · 26/10/2026 18:57

catsandpolitics · 26/10/2026 17:42

She just used the mother's debit card, rather than officially through POA. That is illegal. I wonder if she did that so the spending appeared to be the mother's. I think the OP said POA had been set up for the sister.

Technically yes, however it’s very common as POA takes time and effort to both set up and activate. Re: banking, I have my own card but it took months for the bank to get
it sorted - they were lovely many times on the phone and many times they sent out an additional card with my parents name on it not a ‘rep’ card. What was I to have done in those months?

Many carers, even those with POA,
find it easier to just speak as though they were the parent in many scenarios. I say this as someone wh is currently embroiled in a dispute with a service provider that has gone to the Ombudsman as the service provider is incapable of understanding or enacting the POA. Long story short - it would have been easier for me to pose as my parent and many people do exactly that.

catsandpolitics · 26/10/2026 19:20

Sizzlingsnowdrop · 26/10/2026 18:57

Technically yes, however it’s very common as POA takes time and effort to both set up and activate. Re: banking, I have my own card but it took months for the bank to get
it sorted - they were lovely many times on the phone and many times they sent out an additional card with my parents name on it not a ‘rep’ card. What was I to have done in those months?

Many carers, even those with POA,
find it easier to just speak as though they were the parent in many scenarios. I say this as someone wh is currently embroiled in a dispute with a service provider that has gone to the Ombudsman as the service provider is incapable of understanding or enacting the POA. Long story short - it would have been easier for me to pose as my parent and many people do exactly that.

My cousin used to pretend to be her Mum and suggested I do the same with my Mum as I had to prove lack of capacity before I could activate the POA. I wasn't prepared to do this though because of my occupation (financial services). Didn't fancy losing my job if I got caught.

rookiemere · 26/10/2026 19:22

Getting POA registered at financial institutions is a bit of a pallaver with lots of form filling.

I was very fortunate as a friend recommended getting it put on all DPs accounts before it was needed and did it in tranches, also lucky as this was a few years ago so most places still had physical branches which operated in normal business hours. I can see if the Dsis isn’t terribly confident and was also spending most of her time looking after her DM, why doing things officially never happened. I don’t think OP has suggested anywhere that there was any irregularities or overspending done by the Dsis.

Boreded · 26/10/2026 20:12

Yorkshirelass50 · 26/10/2026 15:22

The OP said her sister was paying housekeeping until recent years. Does all her years of care count for nothing? She could have spent that time working. She may have sacrificed her personal income to care for their mother.

Poster won’t agree with you. They’ve already made a determination that the daughter who put her life on hold to care for her mum rather than going and getting a new job and abandoning her, is a sponger. Despite caring for an elderly relative right to their death being one of the most difficult things a person can do.

Sewingbeedamned · 26/10/2026 20:18

BruFord · 24/10/2026 19:10

Over-55's accommodation is sometimes easier to find so it might be worth looking into that as well. If she's close to 60, maybe even over-60's accommodation.

I agree with @Silverbirchleaf that she likely has more savings than she's letting on, unless she's had a secret gambling habit or spent it all on luxury holidays.

This! Might be a better solution.

Boreded · 26/10/2026 20:18

catsandpolitics · 26/10/2026 17:42

She just used the mother's debit card, rather than officially through POA. That is illegal. I wonder if she did that so the spending appeared to be the mother's. I think the OP said POA had been set up for the sister.

That’s not actually automatically illegal. It may be against the terms of the card agreement, but you can use the card with explicit consent:

Under Section 2 of the Fraud Act 2006, fraud by false representation requires dishonesty. Using a card with genuine permission is materially different from dishonestly using it without authority.

So if her mum had consented to her using the debit card to buy groceries, she would be allowed to do that. It may be against card terms and conditions, but it is not fraud or another crime.

sittingonabeach · 26/10/2026 20:20

Boreded · 26/10/2026 20:18

That’s not actually automatically illegal. It may be against the terms of the card agreement, but you can use the card with explicit consent:

Under Section 2 of the Fraud Act 2006, fraud by false representation requires dishonesty. Using a card with genuine permission is materially different from dishonestly using it without authority.

So if her mum had consented to her using the debit card to buy groceries, she would be allowed to do that. It may be against card terms and conditions, but it is not fraud or another crime.

But if POA registered?

Boreded · 26/10/2026 20:31

sittingonabeach · 26/10/2026 20:20

But if POA registered?

You’re going to have to use more words, I’m missing the context so I don’t know what you’re asking?

sittingonabeach · 26/10/2026 20:34

Boreded · 26/10/2026 20:31

You’re going to have to use more words, I’m missing the context so I don’t know what you’re asking?

If the POA is registered as DM no longer has capacity would her previous consent for another person to use her card still apply