Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling inherited house when sibling living in it

655 replies

Dutchhouse14 · 16/10/2026 11:50

Our DM passed away a few months ago and her will divides everything equally between me and my 2 siblings.
Im the sole executor.
Dsis ,mid 50s, has always lived at home, never moved out. Towards the end of mums life she became her carer.
She works limited hours although she has increased these with overtime since mum passed away but full time contracts are non existent in her sector.
Shes used to pay a small amount of housekeeping but this stopped when she was made redundant from full time work about 10 years ago.
DMs house is in a bad state of repair, none of us can afford to maintain it . Me and my other sibling want to sell.
But DSis is resisting ,not replying to texts, avoiding phones calls, went out when estates agents came round for valuations etc
She has limited income and savings but could get a small mortgage and with proceeds of sale she could get a 1 bed flat.
My other sibling agrees we need to sell but doesn't want to upset dsis and is generally very good at avoidance! They are happy to give Dsis a much bigger share ie 50% I would prefer 40% which i think is realistic for dsis to buy somewhere.
So ive become the wicked witch of the West in Dsis eyes and shes taking it all out on me, well basically stopped talking to me.
WIBU to put the house on the market?
Probate has been granted.
Anyone know what the legal situation is?
I dont want to fall out with Dsis, I love her, but she seems filled with resentment for me and frankly has said some very hurtful things.
Ive always been there for her but shes never ever reciprocated or supported me when ive needed it.
Although I live with DH and DC, the money would really help my future, my pension etc and I dont want to give my share to Dsis, which is what I think she really wants as shes used to being in charge of DMs money , always lived here so I think basically considers everything as hers.
Just dont know how to move things forward or if im being unreasonable selling the house and wanting my share

OP posts:
Boreded · 27/10/2026 10:23

sittingonabeach · 27/10/2026 10:20

The DM died a few months ago. OP says sister told her she has £50k in savings (not many people have that level of savings before any inheritance)

We obviously have to take what OP says (like all threads on MN) unless her sister appears on here too (and what she says might not be true either)

Yes the sister stepped up, but in my mind that was only fair when she had lived pretty much rent free for 30 years (hence the £50k in savings)

The savings if I recall were a redundancy payout.

Also the sister was unable to return to employment because she became full time carer to her mum…what about all of her lost earnings 🤷‍♀️

Bogofftosomewherehot · 27/10/2026 10:41

Boreded · 27/10/2026 10:09

Or not…because that poster is making up the savings pot etc…we don’t know whether at least half of what she has said is true, she is projecting

No she isn't. Her sister told her she had £50k in savings. That sounds pretty substantial to me.

sittingonabeach · 27/10/2026 10:41

That’s quite a hefty redundancy pay out for someone who only paid £100 per month housekeeping and who had their car bought for them

Seeingadistance · 27/10/2026 10:45

Boreded · 27/10/2026 10:23

The savings if I recall were a redundancy payout.

Also the sister was unable to return to employment because she became full time carer to her mum…what about all of her lost earnings 🤷‍♀️

The sister worked full time for at least 20 years, then part time for the last ten. Her claim to have £50,000 in savings is not credible as she has had her housing and living costs paid for by her parents, latterly her mother, for over 30 years. I’m a similar age and I have certainly spent much more than £140 a month on housing and bills in that time. Even back in the early 1990’s I paid more than that per month to live in a grotty bedsit.

Seeingadistance · 27/10/2026 10:48

Bogofftosomewherehot · 27/10/2026 10:41

No she isn't. Her sister told her she had £50k in savings. That sounds pretty substantial to me.

It’s certainly not an insignificant sum but if I had been kept by my parents my whole adult life I would have a lot more than that in savings.

Silverbirchleaf · 27/10/2026 10:50

Boreded · 27/10/2026 10:23

The savings if I recall were a redundancy payout.

Also the sister was unable to return to employment because she became full time carer to her mum…what about all of her lost earnings 🤷‍♀️

What about all her wages then? She doesn’t sound like she’s been living the high life, so what has she spent her money on? Things don’t add up.

sittingonabeach · 27/10/2026 10:56

OP says the sister had substantial savings before the redundancy. If all living costs, bills etc were paid by DM what has sister been spending on. And surely if she had half a brain cell she would have been putting money aside for when house was sold.

@Boreded do you also have an explanation why sister is being very cagey over parents’ personal possessions

Boreded · 27/10/2026 11:04

sittingonabeach · 27/10/2026 10:56

OP says the sister had substantial savings before the redundancy. If all living costs, bills etc were paid by DM what has sister been spending on. And surely if she had half a brain cell she would have been putting money aside for when house was sold.

@Boreded do you also have an explanation why sister is being very cagey over parents’ personal possessions

No because it’s all just guesses. The only thing we know for sure is the sister lived in the home and was the carer to her mum, the mum died, and now the siblings want to throw her out of her family home. 🤷‍♀️

All of the rest is speculation from posters and the OP, and recent court cases have shown just how much one sibling can do whilst another has absolutely no idea of the toll and cost for them. Ultimately, what decent person would force their sibling to leave their home one month after their mums death just so they could grab an inheritance.

FWIW my will specifically provides for my BIL to live in his home (which I own) for the rest of his life (if needed) and prevents my son from selling it or raising rent without the agreement of the trustees of the home. It is like that because decent people don’t see their family out of their homes just to grab money. My son knows that provision is there and is happy it is because it protects him too and gives rent control over to third parties. Everyone is looked after.

The mum SHOULD have added the daughters right to live in the property in the will, unfortunately she didnt. But it is the morally correct thing to do in this case to allow her to continue to live there, paying rent to the siblings or by raising a mortgage (maybe with 12m grace to arrange) to buy them out.

sittingonabeach · 27/10/2026 11:29

The OP is the executor, she has to follow the will unless deed of variation.

sittingonabeach · 27/10/2026 11:31

Boreded · 27/10/2026 11:04

No because it’s all just guesses. The only thing we know for sure is the sister lived in the home and was the carer to her mum, the mum died, and now the siblings want to throw her out of her family home. 🤷‍♀️

All of the rest is speculation from posters and the OP, and recent court cases have shown just how much one sibling can do whilst another has absolutely no idea of the toll and cost for them. Ultimately, what decent person would force their sibling to leave their home one month after their mums death just so they could grab an inheritance.

FWIW my will specifically provides for my BIL to live in his home (which I own) for the rest of his life (if needed) and prevents my son from selling it or raising rent without the agreement of the trustees of the home. It is like that because decent people don’t see their family out of their homes just to grab money. My son knows that provision is there and is happy it is because it protects him too and gives rent control over to third parties. Everyone is looked after.

The mum SHOULD have added the daughters right to live in the property in the will, unfortunately she didnt. But it is the morally correct thing to do in this case to allow her to continue to live there, paying rent to the siblings or by raising a mortgage (maybe with 12m grace to arrange) to buy them out.

I can’t see the sister agreeing to pay rent (never had to in the past, £100 per month does not equate to rent) or buying the other siblings out

sittingonabeach · 27/10/2026 11:35

Boreded · 27/10/2026 11:04

No because it’s all just guesses. The only thing we know for sure is the sister lived in the home and was the carer to her mum, the mum died, and now the siblings want to throw her out of her family home. 🤷‍♀️

All of the rest is speculation from posters and the OP, and recent court cases have shown just how much one sibling can do whilst another has absolutely no idea of the toll and cost for them. Ultimately, what decent person would force their sibling to leave their home one month after their mums death just so they could grab an inheritance.

FWIW my will specifically provides for my BIL to live in his home (which I own) for the rest of his life (if needed) and prevents my son from selling it or raising rent without the agreement of the trustees of the home. It is like that because decent people don’t see their family out of their homes just to grab money. My son knows that provision is there and is happy it is because it protects him too and gives rent control over to third parties. Everyone is looked after.

The mum SHOULD have added the daughters right to live in the property in the will, unfortunately she didnt. But it is the morally correct thing to do in this case to allow her to continue to live there, paying rent to the siblings or by raising a mortgage (maybe with 12m grace to arrange) to buy them out.

And how will the sister pay for repairs/maintenance?

PorridgeEater · 27/10/2026 11:49

If you had had to employ a live-in carer for your mum they would have had free accommodation but mum would still have had to pay - a lot! (see what agencies charge). Your mum did not need it because your sister provided it: the link to the BBC article shows that Courts recognise the value of care provided - it's information, not a provocative act unless you choose to interpret it that way.

I agree with previous opinion that Courts would hardly want to make someone homeless - hard to think mum would have wanted that either. Sister has to have somewhere to live. Even if house is sold funds are limited and it's not clear how she could afford somewhere else.
The mortgage broker has said they will apply for a mortgage (for a fee obviously) - until you actually get an offer you don't know how much this might be. And why automatically assume she is lying about her savings - is that what the people assuming it would do? But if she can raise the funds you hope for the easiest and most practical thing may be for her to buy you out. Would at least avoid selling / moving fees.

It may be helpful to get independent mediation on this if you can (cheaper than legal fees anyway).

sittingonabeach · 27/10/2026 11:57

PorridgeEater · 27/10/2026 11:49

If you had had to employ a live-in carer for your mum they would have had free accommodation but mum would still have had to pay - a lot! (see what agencies charge). Your mum did not need it because your sister provided it: the link to the BBC article shows that Courts recognise the value of care provided - it's information, not a provocative act unless you choose to interpret it that way.

I agree with previous opinion that Courts would hardly want to make someone homeless - hard to think mum would have wanted that either. Sister has to have somewhere to live. Even if house is sold funds are limited and it's not clear how she could afford somewhere else.
The mortgage broker has said they will apply for a mortgage (for a fee obviously) - until you actually get an offer you don't know how much this might be. And why automatically assume she is lying about her savings - is that what the people assuming it would do? But if she can raise the funds you hope for the easiest and most practical thing may be for her to buy you out. Would at least avoid selling / moving fees.

It may be helpful to get independent mediation on this if you can (cheaper than legal fees anyway).

In the court case it was shown that there were discussions between siblings that the sibling doing the caring should get some recompense. Also the mother moved in with daughter, so daughter and her husband’s lives changed from that point.. In the OP’s scenario the sibling living with DM had had it good for 30 years with pretty much paying a peppercorn rent

No discussions appear to have happened in this case. Also it would be unlikely that live in care would be required as soon as care was needed. My DM lives independently for now, but with care visits. At some point care home will be required. Also it looked like sister didn’t provide the care that was actually required.

sittingonabeach · 27/10/2026 12:08

I would feel differently towards the sister doing the caring if she had given up everything for the last 2 years and had paid her way beforehand (not in effect fleeced her parents for 30 years)

Seeingadistance · 27/10/2026 12:26

PorridgeEater · 27/10/2026 11:49

If you had had to employ a live-in carer for your mum they would have had free accommodation but mum would still have had to pay - a lot! (see what agencies charge). Your mum did not need it because your sister provided it: the link to the BBC article shows that Courts recognise the value of care provided - it's information, not a provocative act unless you choose to interpret it that way.

I agree with previous opinion that Courts would hardly want to make someone homeless - hard to think mum would have wanted that either. Sister has to have somewhere to live. Even if house is sold funds are limited and it's not clear how she could afford somewhere else.
The mortgage broker has said they will apply for a mortgage (for a fee obviously) - until you actually get an offer you don't know how much this might be. And why automatically assume she is lying about her savings - is that what the people assuming it would do? But if she can raise the funds you hope for the easiest and most practical thing may be for her to buy you out. Would at least avoid selling / moving fees.

It may be helpful to get independent mediation on this if you can (cheaper than legal fees anyway).

I’m assuming that the sister is lying about her savings because as a woman of a similar age I know that I have spent much, much more than £50k on housing and living expenses over the past 30 odd years. In addition the sister received a redundancy payment which it seems she hasn’t spent, her parents bought her a car and she will have benefitted from cumulative interest on her savings over the past three decades. Unless she has some extremely expensive secret vices it is simply not believable that she would have only £50k savings by now.

In addition, based on my own experience of a frail elderly parent who needs a hoist to move from bed to chair, she didn’t actually provide a very good level of care for her mother as she was happy to let her remain in bed all the time when she became immobile. She refused additional care visits as recommended by professionals and her siblings. Being cared for at home by one person isn’t always the best option for a frail elderly person. But it suited the sister as if her mother had gone into a nursing home (which would almost certainly have been better for her mother in the last couple of years) she would have had to find somewhere else to live when the house was sold to pay for care.

And this was inevitable and predictable. Her mother wasn’t going to live forever and any reasonable person would have planned ahead for the inevitable move. As I’ve said before - she isn’t being made homeless. People sell the house they live in and use the equity and/or mortgage to move into another one all the time!

SirenScream · 27/10/2026 13:21

I wonder if the sister really has the stomach for a court battle? She might think that hinting is enough to make OP comply with her wishes.
How's she going to pay for a court battle, it'll have to come out of her savings surely?
Maybe get half an hour free legal advice to try and establish if she really has a case, or even do some extensive research online.
Let her think you're scared of a court battle but don't actually back down.
Easy for me to say, she ain't my sister. When it comes to this kind of thing I am very relieved that I'm an only child.

SirenScream · 27/10/2026 13:25

If it does go to court and the sister claims that she will be made homeless, will she not have to disclose her financial position i.e that it's more like 250k not 50k and she therefore cannot claim that she's being left with nothing.

PorridgeEater · 27/10/2026 13:47

"But if she can raise the funds you hope for the easiest and most practical thing may be for her to buy you out."

If she could afford to do this it could be a possible solution.

BruFord · 27/10/2026 13:50

@SirenScream Sending the OP the court case article was just a passive-aggressive threat. The two situations are so different, plus all sorts would come out in the court case that wouldn't be positive, for example, allowing her Mum to stay in bed all day until the OP intervened and arranged a hoist and special chair; refusing to have carers as they cost money (her Mum's money); not activating her POA and spending her Mum's money anyway, etc. That type of behavior is the opposite of caring, and a judge wouldn't look kindly on it.

LadyLindaT · 27/10/2026 14:44

As soon as I saw this article in the news this morning, I thought of you, OP. A friend of mine is also going through this. Sometimes, it's not so much about taking responsibility for care, but about establishing territorial rights, for a complex and emotive mixture of reasons, unfortunately, often to do with finances. There is a thing called the Incumbency Advantage, which often paints the person trying to do the right thing in a bad light, when they are only trying to follow the explicit wishes in their parent's will. I hope you can get it resolved, as I am sure it must be very stressful.

Hotdogsandfries · 28/10/2026 11:42

sittingonabeach · 16/10/2026 16:33

But she must have had the chance to move out when younger. She hasn't been a carer all her life. She made different life choices than her siblings, living rent free, not helping to maintain the house she lived in. Why should she benefit financially?

😂😂😂😂😂 Do you make that many assumptions in real life?

sittingonabeach · 28/10/2026 13:10

Hotdogsandfries · 28/10/2026 11:42

😂😂😂😂😂 Do you make that many assumptions in real life?

What assumptions am I making? I am stating what OP has said

BruFord · 28/10/2026 13:36

Hotdogsandfries · 28/10/2026 11:42

😂😂😂😂😂 Do you make that many assumptions in real life?

@Hotdogsandfries Tbf, it was far easier for young people to move out 25-30 years ago. I'm also in my 50's and everyone I know moved out into shared houses/bedsits, etc. for a while before buying. It was v. different to nowadays.

Seeingadistance · 28/10/2026 14:49

Hotdogsandfries · 28/10/2026 11:42

😂😂😂😂😂 Do you make that many assumptions in real life?

What assumptions has that poster made?

Jamlighter · 28/10/2026 19:18

Mum knew what she meant. She knew what DSis contributed and she made her allocation accordingly. Tell your sister to get over it, put it up for sale and honour your mum's wishes.