Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling inherited house when sibling living in it

655 replies

Dutchhouse14 · 16/10/2026 11:50

Our DM passed away a few months ago and her will divides everything equally between me and my 2 siblings.
Im the sole executor.
Dsis ,mid 50s, has always lived at home, never moved out. Towards the end of mums life she became her carer.
She works limited hours although she has increased these with overtime since mum passed away but full time contracts are non existent in her sector.
Shes used to pay a small amount of housekeeping but this stopped when she was made redundant from full time work about 10 years ago.
DMs house is in a bad state of repair, none of us can afford to maintain it . Me and my other sibling want to sell.
But DSis is resisting ,not replying to texts, avoiding phones calls, went out when estates agents came round for valuations etc
She has limited income and savings but could get a small mortgage and with proceeds of sale she could get a 1 bed flat.
My other sibling agrees we need to sell but doesn't want to upset dsis and is generally very good at avoidance! They are happy to give Dsis a much bigger share ie 50% I would prefer 40% which i think is realistic for dsis to buy somewhere.
So ive become the wicked witch of the West in Dsis eyes and shes taking it all out on me, well basically stopped talking to me.
WIBU to put the house on the market?
Probate has been granted.
Anyone know what the legal situation is?
I dont want to fall out with Dsis, I love her, but she seems filled with resentment for me and frankly has said some very hurtful things.
Ive always been there for her but shes never ever reciprocated or supported me when ive needed it.
Although I live with DH and DC, the money would really help my future, my pension etc and I dont want to give my share to Dsis, which is what I think she really wants as shes used to being in charge of DMs money , always lived here so I think basically considers everything as hers.
Just dont know how to move things forward or if im being unreasonable selling the house and wanting my share

OP posts:
GentleIron · 24/10/2026 00:38

Whichever way you decide to split it, remember not to distribute any part of the estate until you have final clearance from the DWP to say that no part of income based benefits will need to be repayed for any reason. I was executor of two estates a couple of years ago, and the DWP contacted the executors quite a while after probate was granted (in one case almost a year later), in both cases requesting the deceased's accounts and a breakdown of any benefits, savings and income in order to determine whether any of it needed to be repaid, and with strict instructions not to distribute the estate until an assessment had been made and the case officially closed. We were told it could take up to 12 months, but it was actually more like 9 and 10 months respectively. The reason is, of course, that if there is money owed, it needs to be repayed from the estate. We did end up having to settle a discrepancy in a benefit payment totalling several thousand pounds in one case due to the deceased having accidentally gone over the savings limit. We were really glad we'd held off and not distributed any part of the estate until that point, but could just settle it straight out of the estate account, and then distribute the remainder to the beneficiaries, not having to claw it back as money owed to the DWP from them later.
Good luck, OP.

BruFord · 24/10/2026 02:34

50K in savings does surprise me tbh, given that she worked FT until she was in her 40's. She must've spent her salary on something to have only accumulated that amount, given that she's never had real living costs.

At least you're gradually moving forward and I'm afraid I agree with your friend that she's manipulating you into giving her more of the eventual sale proceeds.

Aluna · 24/10/2026 07:53

Dutchhouse14 · 23/10/2026 23:57

Thank you all for your comments.
Ive had a very fractious text conversation with Dsis. She wont talk answer my calls .
So upshot is I said that we do need to sell the house but if she would like to we can wait until the new year to put it on the market, she just went off into one about how dbro and me did nothing to earn our inheritance, what a selfish daughter i was ,didnt care from mum etc etc,same old vitriol, and waiting to new year was going to achieve nothing, i said i thought it would give her more time to grieve and process. So appointment with my first choice estate agent today went ahead as she said she had no real preference just wanted the cheapest. She has said she will need an amount that is likely to be 50% of the selling price to buy anywhere, she finally told me she has 50k in savings . She says she tried to get a mortgage in principle online but was turned down, but said I could try for her if I wanted, so I contacted a mortgage broker Ive used who with information given is confident they could get her a mortgage agreement in principle for her for approx 40k if she waits just 1 more month to apply to have another higher wage payslip at new hours. This wouldnt costvher anything but she wasnt impressed as broker then charges £150 to put in a mortgage application ( once an offer on a property has been accepted) and another £300 on mortgage completion. Which she says is too much, a waste of money and doesnt seem willing to speak to mortgage broker.
So I think basically she wants to spend as little of her savings as possible and live mortgage free .
I am mindful of how difficult she could make everything as shes living there so I basically agreed for her to have the amount she says she "needs" approx 50% because I felt so guilty as i know she cared fir mum and its a huge upheaval for her, I just want to move it forward. However my friend thinks shes manipulating me and Dbro and possibly she is!
Caring for mum particularly in the last 2 years was really hard and I think she resented it. I dont think it was in mums interests really at that point for to remain at home but as I said in my pp dsis refused to have more carer visits, refused respite and refused to consider a care home. If im honest I think it was more about protecting her position of living at home and living off mums pensions, attendance allowance, carers allowance etc. I had safety concerns as mum was in house by herself when dsis went out, as obv she had to go out sometimes.
But all thats by the by now I just want us to move on and hopefully still have a relationship with dsis whom I love , even thou shes said some truly awful things to me , I know im just her punchbag atm but hopefully we can move on.

Fwiw OP you sound like you have an incredibly kind heart, but I think you’re being taken for a ride by your sister. I’ve cared for my parents for the last five years and I’m not taking any penny more inheritance than any of my siblings. My choice to care for them is my choice. If I didn’t, they would’ve have gone into a care home where they would have been fine.

By the sounds of it “care” for your mother was all about money and accommodation and she doesn’t sound like she ever had your mother‘s best interests at heart. My parents are never left on their own. We’re spending a fortune on care to ensure that, even overnight care, but it’s their money not mine.

I don’t think you should ever have agreed to 50%. Nor is that all fair to your brother. You should’ve just supported your sister to reassure her that she’ll be fine. If she’s got 50k in savings she can take whatever she inherits the house sale and put it towards a deposit.

How much would her 30% potion be after IHT?

Silverbirchleaf · 24/10/2026 08:14

I’m suspicious about only £50000 in savings. That’s less than £200 per month for twenty five years. Really?! Plus you imply she lives a fairly frugal life, so not spending it on wine, women or horses so to speak.

A quick google tells me that in the year 2015 (final year of work?) take home net pay for minimum wage was around £1000, so even if she put half her wages in savings, she would have accrued £6000 in that year alone.

Treehorns · 24/10/2026 08:29

OP, you are being absolutely played here.
50k after 30 years spending next to nothing?
Not a chance.

She refused your mother proper care in her last years to suit herself and you seriously think she will tell you the truth about how much she has?

In your place nod your head to whatever bullshit she is saying.
Get the house sold and split it as per the will.

Stop trying to please her.
As for your inheritance, you have a husband taking the piss too?

Seems a pattern in your life.
Keep your inheritance AWAY FROM HIM.
Keep it in your own bank account.

You are being bullied, be very careful.

I wouldn't trust your sister an inch.

Alittlewordinyourear · 24/10/2026 08:38

She sounds terrified and hoping if she says no to everything than the status quo will remain. The fact that she has looked at mortgages online shows that deep down she knows she will have to move . It’s probably the process of packing up and moving forward to a new life on top of grief that’s making her like this. I think once she sees it’s inevitable she will come round . Not an easy situation for any of you.

Seeingadistance · 24/10/2026 09:29

I’m also sceptical about the £50k in savings. Not only has she has the time and earning capacity while being financially supported to have saved much more, but it’s a suspiciously round number.

catsandpolitics · 24/10/2026 09:33

OP, I'd be pointing out to your sister that the small fee paid to a broker will probably be recouped by the broker getting the best deal out there. I also think she may have more savings than she's letting on.

Elsvieta · 24/10/2026 09:33

I know you mean to be kind and fair to your sister, but I don't think you're handling this quite right. You didn't have the right to promise her 50% without your brother's input. As executor, you are legally obliged to execute the will as is, and if you don't, you are personally liable for that. I know your brother has said he'll go with the 50%, but if he subsequently changes his mind and decides he did want his full inheritance, he could sue you. You need to sell the place and split the money equally. After that's been done, whether you choose to sign over some of what is now actually your money is up to you, and what your brother does is up to him.

You've got to stop being manipulated by your sister's histrionics, as well as promising things that aren't yours to promise. You made a big mistake earlier on by framing it as a discussion or joint decision what was going to happen with the house and so on. Now you need to walk it back. She's an emotionally immature person who was still being babied by her mum in middle age and she still has the attitude that it's always someone else's role to look after her. She's going to cast you and your brother as her new parent figures if you let her. And I dare say that if she finds she can't quite get a mortgage, she'll remember that she's actually got a bit more in savings than she let on. You shouldn't be having to give up money that's rightfully yours because she doesn't want to spend her savings. Try not to respond to her manipulation.

LongDarkTeatime · 24/10/2026 09:50

@Dutchhouse14 I so sorry this is becoming harder, while you are grieving too.
From experience with my sibling, who I believe had similar issues, the money argument is just the acceptable face of greater fears. Just as you found when you managed the mortgage in principle issue she pivoted to the fee, next it will be something else. These may be socially acceptable ‘worries’ masking an overriding fear of losing the known home moving to somewhere new.
We had this with our sibling (who we now recognise is clearly autistic).

The reality is, the house has to be sold. You may feel pushed to offer more and more cash to solve the issue, but that won’t solve it. It’s like doing physio after major surgery. You can take more and more pain killers but they won’t make it better, they just mask it until you have get up and move.

Can you be firm with DBro that you both have to be consistent for the sake of your DSis. It’s going to be hard, and it’s going to feel horrid for you, but you are NOT being cruel (even if she suggests you are). Moving this forward, despite the upset, is the kindest thing you can do.

Seajaye · 24/10/2026 10:03

I don't think your sister is being manipulative, she is just desparate and worried where she is going to live and how she will manage. Whatever the reasons, she has been dependent upon your mother, as well as her carer, and therefore in law does have a potential claim for adequate provision to be made for her but at least she seems unlikely to spend her money on getting legal advice.

If assuming she can borrow 3 x her salary at age 50, she is unlikely to get a mortgage term beyond age 66. What is the amount and monthly installments likely to be. Can she realistically afford that.and all other other bills on her own, or is a reasonable financial provision settlement likely to be your only practical solution if you want the estate resolved quickly ?

Realistically she is still going to need some form of housing to persuade her to move out,especially if she doesn't have anywhere to go.. I don't see how you can put the house (which is her home, at least for the time being ) on the market without a guarantee of vacant possession. Spending some of the liquid assets in the estate on getting legal advice on how to secure a realistic timescale towards a definite vacant possession date would be a good idea..

On a practical basis are there any housing associations nearby that could offer social housing solution acceptable to her. That way she wouldn't have to use her savings, she might get help towards the rent, and her reasonable financial provision arguments are weakened if she makes a claim when she has a secured roof over her head?

PorridgeEater · 24/10/2026 10:40

GentleIron · 24/10/2026 00:38

Whichever way you decide to split it, remember not to distribute any part of the estate until you have final clearance from the DWP to say that no part of income based benefits will need to be repayed for any reason. I was executor of two estates a couple of years ago, and the DWP contacted the executors quite a while after probate was granted (in one case almost a year later), in both cases requesting the deceased's accounts and a breakdown of any benefits, savings and income in order to determine whether any of it needed to be repaid, and with strict instructions not to distribute the estate until an assessment had been made and the case officially closed. We were told it could take up to 12 months, but it was actually more like 9 and 10 months respectively. The reason is, of course, that if there is money owed, it needs to be repayed from the estate. We did end up having to settle a discrepancy in a benefit payment totalling several thousand pounds in one case due to the deceased having accidentally gone over the savings limit. We were really glad we'd held off and not distributed any part of the estate until that point, but could just settle it straight out of the estate account, and then distribute the remainder to the beneficiaries, not having to claw it back as money owed to the DWP from them later.
Good luck, OP.

Best take note, this is good practical advice from experience! Much more useful than pure speculation about whether your sister is being accurate about her savings.
This situation is going to take time to deal with.

rookiemere · 24/10/2026 11:24

Agree with getting the legal side sorted, but actually I think you have made real progress. If she gets 50% it means you and DB each get 25% rather than 33%, but that 8% could easily have been drained by her refusing to move or allow the household to be viewed or swallowed up in legal fees to force her hand , whereas it’s effectively her cost for allowing that to happen.

Whats done is done and I know from experience of elderly DPs the last couple of years must have been hard for her, whatever her motivations.

I believe having an agreement that allows you to move forward and recoup anything is better than a stalemate.

NovemberMorn · 24/10/2026 16:44

Thanks for the update, it must be really hard for you as well as your sister.

You say you dont think it was in your mums best inteterest to stay in the home over the last 2 years of her life, and you think your sister preferred it, thinking about the inheritence, but do you know what your mothers wanted?
It may have been her wish to stay there till she passed, and it could have also been her choice not to have cares in and out....I know my own mum hated that, and eventually refused because she felt it was like strangers invading her home.

If it was me, I would agree to her having 50% of the house profits, and you and your brother share the other 50%. ...it just sounds fairer on her, and easier for you.

Your sister is being very stubborn to refuse to talk to you, she should remember it's not all her inheritence, and if you insisted, you could follow the will and give her a third, I suspect that would cause more bother, trouble, time and money, if solicitors got involved though....and no one would be the winner then.

Dutchhouse14 · 24/10/2026 16:45

Thanks everyone, Dbro had already put a suggestion to me of 50% before conversation with dsis but I did tell her it would depend on dbros agreement.
I will distribute as per mums will then we can adjust after that so as executor im protected.
DWP has already been in contact with me about overpayment of attendance allowance and pension which ive repaid and ive had a small tax rebate from hmrc.
IHT tax isn't an issue as its below the threshold.
I think the point about the money issue hiding greater fears is spot on. She hasnt really become a fully fledged adult and I suspect ( high functioning ) autism maybe a factor.
I wish we had the means to settle her somewhere else before house sale goes through as that would be easier, I will look into housing association if she wants me to but I suspect she'd be low priority. Housing association would be a good solution as then she wouldnt have to worry about any maintenance which has been such an issue at my parents house.

OP posts:
NovemberMorn · 24/10/2026 16:58

If your sister didn't have the insight to stop benifits and pensions after your mum died, presuming she wasn't deliberately trying to cheat, it sounds like she is very unused to coping on her own.
That's not your responsibility obviously, just an observation.

Yorkshirelass50 · 24/10/2026 17:23

Dutchhouse14 · 24/10/2026 16:45

Thanks everyone, Dbro had already put a suggestion to me of 50% before conversation with dsis but I did tell her it would depend on dbros agreement.
I will distribute as per mums will then we can adjust after that so as executor im protected.
DWP has already been in contact with me about overpayment of attendance allowance and pension which ive repaid and ive had a small tax rebate from hmrc.
IHT tax isn't an issue as its below the threshold.
I think the point about the money issue hiding greater fears is spot on. She hasnt really become a fully fledged adult and I suspect ( high functioning ) autism maybe a factor.
I wish we had the means to settle her somewhere else before house sale goes through as that would be easier, I will look into housing association if she wants me to but I suspect she'd be low priority. Housing association would be a good solution as then she wouldnt have to worry about any maintenance which has been such an issue at my parents house.

Is she the youngest child @Dutchhouse14? I'm just wondering how that changes the dynamic.

PorridgeEater · 24/10/2026 17:46

"You say you don't think it was in your mums best interest to stay in the home over the last 2 years of her life, and you think your sister preferred it, thinking about the inheritance, but do you know what your mother wanted?
It may have been her wish to stay there till she passed, and it could have also been her choice not to have carers in and out....I know my own mum hated that, and eventually refused because she felt it was like strangers invading her home".

This is so often the case - my mother too wanted to stay in her own house and was in denial about needing carers - she would tell them to go away. She only wanted to be looked after by family and was unable to acknowledge there could be any burden (she too had dementia).

People are making all sorts of assumptions about the sister and are being very judgemental, but have not heard her side of the story.

Justonemorething82 · 24/10/2026 17:59

I wouldn’t put anything in writing. Nod and agree to whatever to get the sale done. Distribute it as per the will.

I seem to recall that the house was about 280k (unless I’ve imagined it) so she wants 140k free and clear and to have at minimum 190k, assuming she’s telling the truth.

if you really feel like handing over thousands of your own money afterwards, as that’s what it is, I’d be very surprised. I wouldn’t do it and certainly not after how she’s behaved.

Chilihealer · 24/10/2026 18:38

She’s taking the piss op she wants all her savings to remain and your mums estate to provide her with a house, give her her fair share her free ride is over!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/10/2026 19:02

Dbro had already put a suggestion to me of 50% before conversation with dsis but I did tell her it would depend on dbros agreement.
I will distribute as per mums will then we can adjust after that so as executor im protected

I really like your idea of distributing it in line with your mum's wishes, OP, then making any adjustments you wish later

Apart from anything else you could refuse to hand over a penny more unless she fully discloses what she has saved ...

SirenScream · 24/10/2026 19:07

50K?
haha pull the other one it's got bells on!
She wont speak on the phone because she doesn't want to be put on the spot in case she lets something slip that contradicts her story.
She's taking you for a mug OP.

BruFord · 24/10/2026 19:10

Over-55's accommodation is sometimes easier to find so it might be worth looking into that as well. If she's close to 60, maybe even over-60's accommodation.

I agree with @Silverbirchleaf that she likely has more savings than she's letting on, unless she's had a secret gambling habit or spent it all on luxury holidays.

gardenflowergirl · 24/10/2026 19:27

You could try looking at shared ownership flats with a housing association. Lots of new build estates have a proportion of affordable housing which means rented or shared ownership via a housing association.

PorridgeEater · 24/10/2026 21:26

You need to know what the house could sell for (unlikely to be estate agents asking price).If she had the funds you imagine it could be easier to let her buy you out, which might be less traumatic for her - but I suspect it's not as simple as that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread