Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think dh did the right thing in a very difficult situation?

137 replies

FeelSoSorry · 14/10/2026 17:15

At the start of the year we were totally blindsided by an ex of dh from a long long time ago getting in touch to say that dh was the father of her 19 year old.
She had cheated on her husband who had then demanded paternity testing for the children and (she has 3) he was not the father of 2. She has then alleged that dh was actually her ds1 father and got in touch via family.

It caused us a lot of stress and heartbreak. Dh had to choose whether to meet with him and then get tested or have a test and if he was his son to then build a relationship. He said that he didn’t remember ever having unprotected sex with her and yet he couldn’t rule out that he was his dad and if he had missed 19 years of a relationship he didn’t want to miss a day more so they met.

The test showed that dh was not the father. To be honest this wasn’t the result we expected as even I thought looking at them that they looked similar.

Ever since dh family have been criticising his ‘hasty actions’ in meeting first rather than waiting for the test results. I feel it’s really unfair as he was trying to do his best? It was a shitty situation to find ourselves in and he tried really hard to quickly do the right thing.

MIL made a comment yet again today about it (she is friends with a relative of the woman concerned) about her still not being able to identify the father and saying how dh was trigger happy to take on someone else’s child and lucky that he bothered to get the test done ?!

AIBU to think they should all be proud of him as I am for trying to step up ?

OP posts:
Dancingsquirrels · 16/10/2026 08:35

Ikeatears · 15/10/2026 08:39

I’ve been on the son’s side of this and, over a few weeks, built a relationship with the man who I was told was my father. We were both shocked that he wasn’t. However, I will be eternally grateful for the kindness and care that he showed me in those few weeks. He didn’t confuse me, he valued me as his child, if only for a short time. He made it very clear that my feelings were the most important thing in any of this and even checked in on me a couple of weeks later to see how I was.
I wasn’t upset by any of his actions, I was grateful that a thoroughly decent man had been willing to step up, even without proof. It gave me the courage to go on and find my actual father. I didn’t have the same reaction from him but the first man had shown me that that is a problem with my father, not me.
be proud that you married a man who is kind, decent and empathetic.

Edited

That's a v interesting perspective. Thanks for sharing

My instinct was that OP's DH was foolish to rush to meet. But perhaps the lad did benefit from knowing that someone was happy to 'claim' him. Food for thought

lottiegarbanzo · 16/10/2026 08:51

Both things are true.

He was hasty not waiting for the test. Such an odd decision and not kind to the already confused 19yo.

You can also be proud that he was willing to step up if the child had been his.

Does he usually jump into things feet first without thinking, or because he’s easily led by others’ expectation? He sounds like someone who doesn’t fully know his own mind and relies on others for cues. Sounds like his family are used to treating him that way too, which is why they still consider his choices their business.

topcat2014 · 16/10/2026 08:53

I hope the man who acted as father is not now being a dick about this

FckThisShit · 16/10/2026 08:53

topcat2014 · 16/10/2026 08:26

The young man had/ has a "father" all these years.

I don't understand why they risked that by taking a test.

She cheated on her husband and he wanted the kids paternity tested.. and rightly so considering he isn't the father to two of them! He must be heartbroken, he's bought them up for almost 20 years. Yes he is their 'dad' but raising someone else's kids should be a choice not something that you're unaware of.

MadnessInMyMethod · 16/10/2026 09:00

Your husband did the right thing - waiting for a test result would have made the whole thing feel very clinical and if the young man is 19, he could have said if he'd rather have waited for the test results before meeting.

LowlandLucky · 16/10/2026 09:43

Why is it even spoken about now? It is done and dusted and that is what you need to tell your MIL. Of course your husband should never have told anyone especially his mother who thought she was getting an extra grandchild then was suddenly told sorry it was a mistake.
Tell you don't want to hear of it again.

lottiegarbanzo · 16/10/2026 09:48

The important person in all this is the young man, of course. Was he ok with meeting then losing your DH in such a short time?

I guess kind of interesting to meet one of your mum’s old boyfriends and to discover he’s a decent guy, which might give you hope that the actual father was too.

All depends how much hope he’d pinned on the meeting.

HammockFace · 16/10/2026 09:53

Why have they got their neb so far into this situation? Some stuff you keep within your own four walls until you know what's what surely?

Hildegard25 · 16/10/2026 11:13

Am I missing something here.
Everyone thought he was the Father, you, him, and his ex.
This was a foregone conclusion to everyone, and the only reason your DH took a paternity test was to make it all legal and above board.

What a surprise to everyone especially DH to find out that his ex had fabricated it all. She is the villain.

Make no mistake, your DH met up with suspected son in the firm 100% belief he was the Father. What a shock to him it must have been to find out that he had been cruelly deceived. Now he is being castigated, and humiliated for trying to do the right thing.

Yes, in hindsight, and with everything laid out before him, it was an error of judgement, but let's be honest, nobody told him not to meet up beforehand, or before being tested. "Could've, should've, would've". Hindsight is a wonderful weapon methinks.

Stop blaming the poor man for a complete error of judgement, which no one pointed out until the truth emerged.
Oh, and tell that MIL to "shut the fuck up".

SorcererGaheris · 16/10/2026 11:33

topcat2014 · 16/10/2026 08:26

The young man had/ has a "father" all these years.

I don't understand why they risked that by taking a test.

@topcat2014

I think it's understandable that the ex's husband, after discovering she cheated, would want to establish whether he is in fact the biological father of his children. That doesn't change the fact that, in an emotional sense, he's been the father all this time (and hopefully that relationship will continue) but I can certainly see why someone would want to establish whether there is another biological father out there.

moderate · 16/10/2026 15:16

lottiegarbanzo · 16/10/2026 08:51

Both things are true.

He was hasty not waiting for the test. Such an odd decision and not kind to the already confused 19yo.

You can also be proud that he was willing to step up if the child had been his.

Does he usually jump into things feet first without thinking, or because he’s easily led by others’ expectation? He sounds like someone who doesn’t fully know his own mind and relies on others for cues. Sounds like his family are used to treating him that way too, which is why they still consider his choices their business.

He sounds like someone who doesn’t fully know his own mind and relies on others for cues.

To me it sounds the exact opposite: he stepped up without hesitation to what he believed his responsibility to be.

Pinadaqx2 · 16/10/2026 17:51

IButtleSir · 14/10/2026 17:29

I'm sure your husband meant well, but it was incredibly stupid to meet this boy before getting the test done. Can you not see how distressing it must be for his ex's son to have found out twice in quick succession that the man he thought was his biological father was, in fact, not?

Obviously the blame lies totally with your husband's ex for repeatedly cheating on her husband without using contraception, but your husband should have had the sense to wait and see whether or not he was actually this young man's father before meeting him.

Tomorrow is not promised. Tell your DH to tell his family to back off! Its was a terrible situation but I don't see he did anything "wrong" just some may have choosen a different option. Poor man. Sounds like a good man all the same!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page