Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being selfish about him not being ready?

188 replies

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:29

Maybe it's a bit cliche but hey ho.

New job, met a bloke, fell in love.

We kissed on a works do (out of the blue really, we both just went for it) and since then we got closer, agreed we both enjoyed it, met up more often and got to know each other very intimately. This was about half a year after I got the job, so we weren't total strangers, just work acquaintances until the kiss.

He confided in some very dark events in his childhood which he has struggled with since, and is in therapy and medicated for. He knows I champion mental health and support him fully.

Started sending nudes to each other, then sleeping together. He'd pat my arse from time to time, we'd snuggle and kiss. We said we loved each other.

Then, the day before he goes on holiday for a week, he says he needs to take a step back and he doesn't see things working. I react as well as you'd imagine, then he's gone for a week. He comes back and says he regrets what he said and "part of him" wants to try again, but because of his past he doesn't want a proper relationship (yet). And the same day he came back and I was dreading what was going to happen, he showed me a pic of him in sexy wear on the phone. It sent a very confusing message.

Anyway three months later I sat him down and said "If it's a definite no, tell me right now" He hesitated and said it was not a definite no, and he "can't deny his feelings for me" but that his past trauma is blocking him from making a proper decision.

I am completely in love with him. To a hopeless degree. I would do anything for him. He seems oblivious to how much I feel for him. My heart flutters every time he enters the office in the morning. It hurts.

Am I being selfish?

I am one thousand percent certain there isn't another love interest behind the curtain.

OP posts:
GreyCarpet · 14/10/2026 07:51

He says he's still happy to have sex and be physically close but he can't get past the hurdle of emotional commitment.

Yeah, I bet he is! And 10 years older? He's living the dream, isn't he?

Come on, OP. You must want more for yourself than this?

Championing mental health in others is all well and good but what about your own? Or are you going to set yourself on fire to keep him warm?

I'm going to assume you're early 20s? Because otherwise you'd see straight through this. I can guarantee that in another 10 years when you're the same age that he is now, you'll look back and see this for the bullshit it is.

Sounds harsh? Maybe but I'm 52 and have chldren in their 20s and this is exactly what I'd be saying to them. This might be the first but it won't be the last time you encounter a man like this.

DoubtfulCat · 14/10/2026 07:53

Yes, he’s a using arsehole and you have been strung along. Sorry.

These lines become cliche for a reason.

FWIW I have been where you are now and I can tell you, these men don’t want to be ‘fixed’ because they like having all the benefits of a relationship with none of the effort. They like having you at their beck and call like a girlfriend, but they don’t want to be a boyfriend in return.

End things and block contact (he will try to creep back in). Don’t share nudes (ever). He will steal years of your life and potentially stop you from actually meeting someone lovely and having a family, you will never know where you stand and it will be miserable.

malefields · 14/10/2026 07:55

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:36

He says he's still happy to have sex and be physically close but he can't get past the hurdle of emotional commitment. Usually I'd say that's typical but because of his background, I can believe it's deeper than that and he genuinely wants to try. Or maybe I'm just naive.

I was in your situation.

For the love of god, do not make this man and his childhood your problem. He’ll just break your heart. Run for the hills.

He uses his childhood as a shield to justify his bad behaviour. Nothing will change until he wants it to change, and he doesn’t.

socialbatteryisdead · 14/10/2026 07:59

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:36

He says he's still happy to have sex and be physically close but he can't get past the hurdle of emotional commitment. Usually I'd say that's typical but because of his background, I can believe it's deeper than that and he genuinely wants to try. Or maybe I'm just naive.

I bet he’s still happy to have sex. What a load of rubbish.

BriarTime · 14/10/2026 08:00

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 14/10/2026 07:32

Additionally, what makes me really irritated is that these sort of men leave a complete clusterfuck behind them.

If they just want a quick shag, there's any number of women that are quite happy with that and will be open that they don't want a relationship. They will be clear with people: this is just a friends-with-benefit situation, or there's prostitutes.

You don't have to completely fuck up a woman's life that's actually looking for a relationship.

Yep. No fun in that for him, though. The woman’s attachment (and then heartbreak) is the point.

AshCullen1894 · 14/10/2026 08:06

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:50

Ten year age gap (he's the older one) if relevant

The point of the recent chat was to give him the chance to get off scot free. "If it's a no, say it" and even then he couldn't be decisive.

Of course he wasn't decisive. You have a vagina that's available to him. Please walk away.

TheLastSilverSaint · 14/10/2026 08:08

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:36

He says he's still happy to have sex and be physically close but he can't get past the hurdle of emotional commitment. Usually I'd say that's typical but because of his background, I can believe it's deeper than that and he genuinely wants to try. Or maybe I'm just naive.

He says he’s still happy to have sex

That’s convenient.

Shoxfordian · 14/10/2026 08:10

He will still have sex with you. Lucky girl. Is that supposed to be something you'll accept? Just offering you crumbs of affection and wondering why you're starving.

Make the decision yourself that this isn't good enough for you and end it decisively.

TheMessyMermaid · 14/10/2026 08:15

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:50

Ten year age gap (he's the older one) if relevant

The point of the recent chat was to give him the chance to get off scot free. "If it's a no, say it" and even then he couldn't be decisive.

He doesn't want to say no because he's using you as a friend with benefits. He knows if he says an outright no he'll lose access to you

Maddy70 · 14/10/2026 08:18

No. He's not into you sorry. You are being a fool

Silverbirchleaf · 14/10/2026 08:32

Who randomly has pictures of themselves in sexy underwear on their phone? A bit creepy if you ask me ( and who took the photo?).

Biscuitsforbreakfastt · 14/10/2026 08:32

You’re not being selfish; you’re being played.

He’s just not that into you.

Sorry.

notagainyoufool · 14/10/2026 08:38

I ended up in a relationship like this - I also had a background in helping people with their mental health. Don’t do it. He literally drained my soul. He had the emotional intelligence of someone aged between 8-11 - also due to childhood trauma. All of the meds/counselling did nothing long term. He’d always default to what he knew. It’s really sad really, but I wish I’d walked away when I had the chance. I suppose I just thought if I could explain to him and support him he would understand and change. He didn’t. He managed to hold down a successful job, but anything to do with emotions or when things got tough he was essentially abusive in the end.

waterrat · 14/10/2026 08:39

God stop analysyiing what he did - and listen to him saying he isn't interested in commitment.

Floatingdownriver · 14/10/2026 08:41

You’re not in love with him.

Your in love with the potential of him.

Thst doesn’t exist. Only the reality of a man who is treating you badly and using his health as a rationale. Run. Or you’ll spend the next 20 years on here asking for help when you’re saddled with a selfish man who had never put you first.

Go find better. You deserve it.

Mulledjuice · 14/10/2026 08:44

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:36

He says he's still happy to have sex and be physically close but he can't get past the hurdle of emotional commitment. Usually I'd say that's typical but because of his background, I can believe it's deeper than that and he genuinely wants to try. Or maybe I'm just naive.

I'm afraid I thought you'd missed a chunk of the story - he tells you he's not ready, shows you a pic or him in his mankini or whatever, and you just carry on as you were for THREE months?

never mind what he wants or needs to work on - what do you need to work on that you expect better for yourself than this.

he can and should do the work on himself but not on your time.

ByWittyLimePoet · 14/10/2026 08:46

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:36

He says he's still happy to have sex and be physically close but he can't get past the hurdle of emotional commitment. Usually I'd say that's typical but because of his background, I can believe it's deeper than that and he genuinely wants to try. Or maybe I'm just naive.

I bet he does! How convenient that he can still shag you but can't commit to anything else.

Stop 'giving' him your body...until he can decide he wants ALL of you...just not your pussy!

Coconutter24 · 14/10/2026 08:48

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:36

He says he's still happy to have sex and be physically close but he can't get past the hurdle of emotional commitment. Usually I'd say that's typical but because of his background, I can believe it's deeper than that and he genuinely wants to try. Or maybe I'm just naive.

So he wanted to go on holiday so he can act as a single man and do as he pleases with no guilt or commitment to you, then he wants to come back to you just for sex? And you think you’re being selfish? Naive yes!

ByWittyLimePoet · 14/10/2026 08:48

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:40

It makes no sense that he'd introduce me to his mother (briefly mind you, saw her through a car window but he deliberately asked me to come over and say hi) and then a few weeks later he steps back. Like what was the point of that then?

He could have explained you away as a friend. It's no big deal.

Wake up!

28andgreat · 14/10/2026 08:48

This happened to me when I first met my partner.

He had not long broken up with his girlfriend of 6 years, in the process of selling their house when we met.
Our connection was undeniable, but the timing was awful.

Que a few months of back and forth, him calling it off because he didn't feel ready to be in another relationship - which I did really understand.

I kept it low maintenance, didn't push for a decisive decisions because I thought - well I have nothing to lose. I love the man, I can either be patient until he decides either way, or push him away by trying to force a commitment before he was ready.
Perhaps seems weak to some, but like I said I didn't feel like I had anything to lose. It will either work itself out and we would be together, or it wouldn't and I've still managed to spend time with a man I adore and had the most amazing times with.

Eventually, he realised his feelings for me were stronger than his desire to be single. 8 years later we are still together, have a beautiful daughter and are engaged!

If the aim is a lifetime, what difference does a couple of months with low pressure and enjoying yourselves mean?

Cars4Gov · 14/10/2026 09:06

Silverbirchleaf · 14/10/2026 08:32

Who randomly has pictures of themselves in sexy underwear on their phone? A bit creepy if you ask me ( and who took the photo?).

Op, you won't be the only one who he is sharing pictures with. This won't be his first rodeo!

The over sharing of childhood is used to manipulate your emotions, and it's worked. You thought because he shared his trauma it meant you connected on a deeper level..it doesn't mean that, he's just learned that it works so well.

I think you need to do work on yourself. Once you have good boundaries you will see his behaviour isn't appropriate or good for you.

Beautifulhaiku · 14/10/2026 09:07

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:36

He says he's still happy to have sex and be physically close but he can't get past the hurdle of emotional commitment. Usually I'd say that's typical but because of his background, I can believe it's deeper than that and he genuinely wants to try. Or maybe I'm just naive.

Does it matter what the reason is? He’s told you that he feels unable to make an emotional commitment - are you happy to continue sleeping with him without anything more? If not then he’s currently not able to give you what you need and it’s best to end things now. It sounds like he needs to do a lot of work before he’s ready to be in a proper relationship - it’s not your job to ‘fix’ him and you wouldn’t be able to if you tried. It will be difficult as you have to see him all the time but that’s the down-side of work relationships.

Or more succinctly as another poster said: don’t set fire to yourself to keep others warm.

AbsolutelyAppeal · 14/10/2026 09:15

He wanted to be free for his holiday, to do what (or who!) he wanted without worrying about you.

He is the selfish one.

If he wanted to be with you properly, he would be. Take time to get over him and then go find someone else x

Cornishclio · 14/10/2026 11:43

I would walk away. You are far too intense and he is obviously stringing you along. Also sending nudes to a work colleague? How old are you?

PrayForPlagues · 14/10/2026 11:47

daftsod92 · 13/10/2026 19:50

Ten year age gap (he's the older one) if relevant

The point of the recent chat was to give him the chance to get off scot free. "If it's a no, say it" and even then he couldn't be decisive.

You are being played like a fiddle.

Swipe left for the next trending thread