Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unvaccinated children shouldn't be allowed in mainstream childcare or school

430 replies

ApronSprings · 11/10/2026 21:42

To think children shouldn't be allowed in nurseries or schools if their parents refuse to vaccinate them..

I'm excluding children who medically can't have them for some reason, and this will be too rare to cause a problem, and they deserve the benefit of herd immunity.

But I'm growing tired of the nutcase conspiracy theorists who failed GCSE science but think they've somehow found something missed by experts.

The only argument against this is that it keeps them home with their quack parents and reduces the opportunity for them to be exposed to normal people. But I don't think we should risk other people's lives for it if their parents aren't willing to do the same.

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 12/10/2026 10:16

Firefly24 · 11/10/2026 21:46

So punish children for their parents choices.. nice one.

Or, punish other children because of those parents’ choices. Children who can’t be vaccinated have to be more at risk because children who can’t be vaccinated aren’t. Why do anti-vax parents get to make that choice for other children?

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:17

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 10:07

Thanks for assessment of my abilities and what actions I have taken regarding my own children. You are correct that nothing is totally a
safe but you are incorrect in your comments about myself. We are discussing the fact that free to make choices and as we know there are lies, dam lies and statistics also statistics can only deal with the known facts , as we know what is said now might not be true in the future. One poster cited the example of specific drugs in the 1960s whilst there have been numerous example since then. People have different views and I would insult those who held different views from myself.

That ungrammatical stream of consciousness is doing nothing to convince me of your intellectual capabilities, I’m afraid.

It’s very telling how much people like you cling to the example of thalidomide. It was made available in 1957 and had been pulled off the market worldwide by early 1962, after the harm it caused had become clear. The combined Diphtheria, Tetanus and Polio vaccine has been in use since 1948 and the MMR since 1971. The whooping cough vaccine has been in use since WW1! If these vaccines were truly ‘dangerous’, it would have been discovered long before now. Billions of people have received these vaccines. Billions of people have suffered no negative side-effects.

Also, I will repeat, you only care about the statistically insignificant 2 in a million risk of vaccine injury because you have the luxury of not having to care about the 1 in 20 risk of permanent disability and 1 in 1000 risk of death. You have that luxury because of herd immunity, because of parents like me who vaccinated our kids. You’re welcome!

BoredZelda · 12/10/2026 10:18

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 10:07

Thanks for assessment of my abilities and what actions I have taken regarding my own children. You are correct that nothing is totally a
safe but you are incorrect in your comments about myself. We are discussing the fact that free to make choices and as we know there are lies, dam lies and statistics also statistics can only deal with the known facts , as we know what is said now might not be true in the future. One poster cited the example of specific drugs in the 1960s whilst there have been numerous example since then. People have different views and I would insult those who held different views from myself.

Numerous? Name them?

Firefly24 · 12/10/2026 10:21

🤣🤣 ignoring? I haven't "ignored" anything, I don't have time to sit and read the entire thread. I have 3 vaccinated children under 5 who keep me quite busy.

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 10:22

Pointless discussing issues here. Insulting others says more about the poster. I deliberately haven’t given examples as it’s the principle that is stake. I just wonder if in real life posters are as rude.

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:23

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 10:22

Pointless discussing issues here. Insulting others says more about the poster. I deliberately haven’t given examples as it’s the principle that is stake. I just wonder if in real life posters are as rude.

You deliberately haven’t given examples because you don’t actually know any.

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:24

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:17

That ungrammatical stream of consciousness is doing nothing to convince me of your intellectual capabilities, I’m afraid.

It’s very telling how much people like you cling to the example of thalidomide. It was made available in 1957 and had been pulled off the market worldwide by early 1962, after the harm it caused had become clear. The combined Diphtheria, Tetanus and Polio vaccine has been in use since 1948 and the MMR since 1971. The whooping cough vaccine has been in use since WW1! If these vaccines were truly ‘dangerous’, it would have been discovered long before now. Billions of people have received these vaccines. Billions of people have suffered no negative side-effects.

Also, I will repeat, you only care about the statistically insignificant 2 in a million risk of vaccine injury because you have the luxury of not having to care about the 1 in 20 risk of permanent disability and 1 in 1000 risk of death. You have that luxury because of herd immunity, because of parents like me who vaccinated our kids. You’re welcome!

Edited

The two in a million risk doesn't seem so small if your child is one of the two.

Sometimes you're just stuck between a rock and a hard place. My young adult child isn't allowed any vaccines without specialist approval. He is meant to get the flu vaccine every year but didn't this year. Yes, the flu could put him in hospital, but he might not get the flu. Getting the vaccine means he'll have pain and serious effects for two weeks. This year, he decided to forgo the vaccine. He's old enough to decide that for himself.

So yes, it's helpful if other people get their flu vaccines to reduce his risk, but I prefer that people retain the right to make that decision for themselves. Their health is just as important as my sons.

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 10:25

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:17

That ungrammatical stream of consciousness is doing nothing to convince me of your intellectual capabilities, I’m afraid.

It’s very telling how much people like you cling to the example of thalidomide. It was made available in 1957 and had been pulled off the market worldwide by early 1962, after the harm it caused had become clear. The combined Diphtheria, Tetanus and Polio vaccine has been in use since 1948 and the MMR since 1971. The whooping cough vaccine has been in use since WW1! If these vaccines were truly ‘dangerous’, it would have been discovered long before now. Billions of people have received these vaccines. Billions of people have suffered no negative side-effects.

Also, I will repeat, you only care about the statistically insignificant 2 in a million risk of vaccine injury because you have the luxury of not having to care about the 1 in 20 risk of permanent disability and 1 in 1000 risk of death. You have that luxury because of herd immunity, because of parents like me who vaccinated our kids. You’re welcome!

Edited

Couldn't agree more.

If everyone in a room was infected with measles, would they spend the day in there with their newborn? If they want to build their immunity naturally then surely they should visit countries where the ebola virus is rife? See if they would prefer a vaccine or take their chances.

OP posts:
ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:26

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:23

You deliberately haven’t given examples because you don’t actually know any.

I can give you one. My paternal grandmother took DES which they later found to cause issues in the daughters. Lucky for me, she had a son. It has since been found, a whole generation later, that the granddaughters of the women who took it are often even more affected than their own daughters. What will happen in the next generation? We don't even know yet. I approach all medical interventions in a carefully considered way as everything is a matter of weighing risks and benefits.

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:26

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 10:22

Pointless discussing issues here. Insulting others says more about the poster. I deliberately haven’t given examples as it’s the principle that is stake. I just wonder if in real life posters are as rude.

I am being a bit rude on the internet. You are contributing to the end of herd immunity in the UK and circulation of previously eradicated diseases that will kill and disable tens of thousands of people, including, potentially, your own children. Which is worse?

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:28

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 10:25

Couldn't agree more.

If everyone in a room was infected with measles, would they spend the day in there with their newborn? If they want to build their immunity naturally then surely they should visit countries where the ebola virus is rife? See if they would prefer a vaccine or take their chances.

Well, that was exactly how parents got their young children immunity (not babies) well before the vaccine. They knew the risks of the diseases increased as you got older. They had chicken pox and measles parties. Not that I'd recommend that.

Glazerblazer · 12/10/2026 10:30

I think it is taken into account that not everyone is vaccinated, that’s why they offer it to everyone to cover that, not sure if it would make that much difference if the small amount that are not vaccinated were.

Scamworried · 12/10/2026 10:31

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:17

That ungrammatical stream of consciousness is doing nothing to convince me of your intellectual capabilities, I’m afraid.

It’s very telling how much people like you cling to the example of thalidomide. It was made available in 1957 and had been pulled off the market worldwide by early 1962, after the harm it caused had become clear. The combined Diphtheria, Tetanus and Polio vaccine has been in use since 1948 and the MMR since 1971. The whooping cough vaccine has been in use since WW1! If these vaccines were truly ‘dangerous’, it would have been discovered long before now. Billions of people have received these vaccines. Billions of people have suffered no negative side-effects.

Also, I will repeat, you only care about the statistically insignificant 2 in a million risk of vaccine injury because you have the luxury of not having to care about the 1 in 20 risk of permanent disability and 1 in 1000 risk of death. You have that luxury because of herd immunity, because of parents like me who vaccinated our kids. You’re welcome!

Edited

It doesn't matter what examples because vaccines have done a huge amount of good. We are lucky to have the option to vaccinate against many many illnesses
But it is an option that we can choose

Removing that choice is a a slippery slope, that I can not agree with.
Remember COVID - COVID caused deaths and long term illness. The vaccine also caused deaths and long term health implications

Having the choice to vaccinate or not is important. Remember the NHS staff and carers who didn't want to be vaccinated and how much flax they received and how so e lost their jobs if they didn't get vaccinated

That was their choice. Without the vaccine they could have died but equally with the vaccine they could die.
While in most cases childhood vaccines are safe and the benefit of the vaccine far outweighs the risk we can not say all vaccines for ever more will be.
If we remove individual choice / parental choice we remove it forever.
If the next vaccine is unproven to be safe or the risk outweighs the benefits do you want to be able to choose or do you want to have no choice.

The number of people not vaccinating due to anti vac stance is very very small. Forcing vaccination is only likely to feed into their anti vac views further.

drspouse · 12/10/2026 10:31

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:24

The two in a million risk doesn't seem so small if your child is one of the two.

Sometimes you're just stuck between a rock and a hard place. My young adult child isn't allowed any vaccines without specialist approval. He is meant to get the flu vaccine every year but didn't this year. Yes, the flu could put him in hospital, but he might not get the flu. Getting the vaccine means he'll have pain and serious effects for two weeks. This year, he decided to forgo the vaccine. He's old enough to decide that for himself.

So yes, it's helpful if other people get their flu vaccines to reduce his risk, but I prefer that people retain the right to make that decision for themselves. Their health is just as important as my sons.

But the risk is so much higher if you don't vaccinate (and I have read your posts re risk in your family and it's great you were able to give MMR later, but the simple 2 in a million risk does NOT cancel out the risk of actually having measles and dying from it).

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:37

drspouse · 12/10/2026 10:31

But the risk is so much higher if you don't vaccinate (and I have read your posts re risk in your family and it's great you were able to give MMR later, but the simple 2 in a million risk does NOT cancel out the risk of actually having measles and dying from it).

But the risks aren't even over the lifespan either, which is why I later revisited whether the MMR was a possibility for us. We all choose our risk when it comes to any medical intervention. Any vaccine or medication does carry a small risk with it. So does not using that vaccine or medication. I do hate feeling like I'm darned if I do and darned if I don't sometimes. Most of the time it has worked out just fine when we revisited it. In fact, there was no reaction at all for any MMRs later. Catching my son up on one of the other ones did still lead to an unusual and serious reaction that meant we didn't do the follow up shot of that one. It's all got to be weighed up, and weighed up again over time.

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 10:39

Glazerblazer · 12/10/2026 10:30

I think it is taken into account that not everyone is vaccinated, that’s why they offer it to everyone to cover that, not sure if it would make that much difference if the small amount that are not vaccinated were.

It's the difference between it being eliminated Vs not being eliminated.

OP posts:
Tel12 · 12/10/2026 10:39

Free country. People have the right to choose as a result.

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:40

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:26

I can give you one. My paternal grandmother took DES which they later found to cause issues in the daughters. Lucky for me, she had a son. It has since been found, a whole generation later, that the granddaughters of the women who took it are often even more affected than their own daughters. What will happen in the next generation? We don't even know yet. I approach all medical interventions in a carefully considered way as everything is a matter of weighing risks and benefits.

Firstly, it’s pretty telling that you’re having to go back to a drug that hasn’t been prescribed since the end of WW2. Clinical testing has come on leaps and bounds since then. We have learnt from failures like DES and thalidomide and implemented protocols that mean these are far less likely to happen again.

Secondly, the global pharmaceutical industry has developed hundreds of thousands of drugs and treatments since 1900. Failures like DES and thalidomide represent a minuscule proportion of these drugs.

Thirdly, the vast majority of vaccines are not new! If there were serious issues akin to those caused by DES we would have discovered them by now. Most of these vaccines have been in use since the 1960s, and have been given to billions of people worldwide.

Finally, less than 0.01% of flights crash. I’m sure you, like most people, are happy enough with those odds when it comes to your summer holiday. Why is it only with vaccines that you are proud to be statistically illiterate?

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:41

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:37

But the risks aren't even over the lifespan either, which is why I later revisited whether the MMR was a possibility for us. We all choose our risk when it comes to any medical intervention. Any vaccine or medication does carry a small risk with it. So does not using that vaccine or medication. I do hate feeling like I'm darned if I do and darned if I don't sometimes. Most of the time it has worked out just fine when we revisited it. In fact, there was no reaction at all for any MMRs later. Catching my son up on one of the other ones did still lead to an unusual and serious reaction that meant we didn't do the follow up shot of that one. It's all got to be weighed up, and weighed up again over time.

You are highly unreasonable for acting like the risks of vaccinating and not vaccinating are equivalent.

godmum56 · 12/10/2026 10:41

Motomum23 · 11/10/2026 22:11

How do you know you caught it from non-vaccinated child? And where did that child get it from?? Isn't it more likely to come from a recently vaccinated child. And why aren't your vaccines up to date if you are an adult who can catch mumps aren't you a risk to the immunocompromosed children??

unlikely to have caught it from a newly vaccinated child unless you are immunocompromised. If you are immunocompromised, its unlikely that you could have mumps vaccine.

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:41

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:41

You are highly unreasonable for acting like the risks of vaccinating and not vaccinating are equivalent.

Actually, for my child some of the vaccines are more risky and he's not allowed them as per specialist, so no, not unreasonable.

RedCatta · 12/10/2026 10:42

Batties · 11/10/2026 22:58

How could something which had been eradicated return?

Illnesses can be eradicated in a specific region or country and remain that way because of herd immunity and continued vaccination, in spite of global migration. If vaccine levels go down, herd immunity weakens, which creates a reoccurrence.

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:46

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:40

Firstly, it’s pretty telling that you’re having to go back to a drug that hasn’t been prescribed since the end of WW2. Clinical testing has come on leaps and bounds since then. We have learnt from failures like DES and thalidomide and implemented protocols that mean these are far less likely to happen again.

Secondly, the global pharmaceutical industry has developed hundreds of thousands of drugs and treatments since 1900. Failures like DES and thalidomide represent a minuscule proportion of these drugs.

Thirdly, the vast majority of vaccines are not new! If there were serious issues akin to those caused by DES we would have discovered them by now. Most of these vaccines have been in use since the 1960s, and have been given to billions of people worldwide.

Finally, less than 0.01% of flights crash. I’m sure you, like most people, are happy enough with those odds when it comes to your summer holiday. Why is it only with vaccines that you are proud to be statistically illiterate?

I hate flying. We're not meant to be shooting around the sky in metal tubes.

When I was pregnant with one of my children the doctor wanted me to take a prophylactic antibiotic after exposure to a sickness. No idea if I had it or not, no offer to test, just take the antibiotic. I informed him I was pregnant and was told that they didn't know if the antibiotic was safe in pregnancy but they thought it was. Some women had taken it not knowing they were pregnant and it seemed to have been just fine. That's much more recent. I declined because me and my baby aren't anyone's guinea pig. I wasn't prepared to take the risk and they hadn't demonstrated any good reason I should.

DES was an issue for my family, which is why it's so strong in my mind to raise.

I am actually extremely statistically literate and researched. I have had to be as each decision is critical to my child. Maybe you'd like to tell my son's specialist that he's statistically illiterate when he says my son isn't allowed any vaccinations unless he has given approval?

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:47

godmum56 · 12/10/2026 10:41

unlikely to have caught it from a newly vaccinated child unless you are immunocompromised. If you are immunocompromised, its unlikely that you could have mumps vaccine.

Generally any live vaccines are excluded, which I think mumps is.

fashionqueen0123 · 12/10/2026 10:48

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 10:08

It is wild to me how much we take free healthcare for granted that people can't call up to organise an appointment. A lot of the time now parents are provided an appointment when their child gets to that age.
There are parents walking miles in scorching conditions to just get water, but people in the UK can't be arsed to take their baby to the doctor's to get a jab. Nuts.

Its mad. It was interesting to see how well it worked though. They were in things like shopping centres so managed to catch passers by!

Swipe left for the next trending thread