Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unvaccinated children shouldn't be allowed in mainstream childcare or school

430 replies

ApronSprings · 11/10/2026 21:42

To think children shouldn't be allowed in nurseries or schools if their parents refuse to vaccinate them..

I'm excluding children who medically can't have them for some reason, and this will be too rare to cause a problem, and they deserve the benefit of herd immunity.

But I'm growing tired of the nutcase conspiracy theorists who failed GCSE science but think they've somehow found something missed by experts.

The only argument against this is that it keeps them home with their quack parents and reduces the opportunity for them to be exposed to normal people. But I don't think we should risk other people's lives for it if their parents aren't willing to do the same.

OP posts:
BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 09:36

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 08:10

There appears to be such aggression to those who hold a view that parents have a choice whether to vaccinate. Choosing not to vaccinate is not case of child cruelty or neglect and suggestions that the parents are unhinged, uneducated or loons shows a lack of tolerance.

Parents who choose not to vaccinate their children are either unhinged, uneducated or simply selfish. That is a fact.

The ‘aggression’ stems from the fact that because of people like you, measles is now circulating in the UK again, after over 50 years of near-zero transmission rates. That makes me incredibly angry and I won’t moderate my anger to mollify selfish idiots.

Celtic1hair · 12/10/2026 09:37

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 09:13

Well I wasn't even alive in the 60s to experience their medicine. I'm not that old.

You don't know my family medical history and why we delayed some vaccines. I'm not prepared to share that kind of personal information about my children either. It was not something I took lightly. Fortunately, when my children got outside the age children usually experience these sicknesses less severely (because there are age brackets these things were more usual in), after more medical consultation I very hesitantly took the risk with my eldest and found that things were different now they were older. I don't know why. More developed immune system? Bigger body size? With the exception of one who ended up in hospital with one of the vaccines, so we abandoned that one for them.

Mumps at 18 is definitely better avoided.

It's understandable to make an informed decision backed by science, you had the luxury to do this because herd immunity would have protected your child to a significant level even without them having the vaccine. With the uptake levels now dropping below the required threshold, the decision you would now have to make would have been much more difficult I think, because realistically your child would now have a much higher risk of catching a disease with potentially fatal concequences versus the theoretical risk of vaccine injury you were concerned about.
This is exactly why mandatory immunisations are absolutely vital where there is absolutely no reason to not administer, parents with genuine medical reasons to be wary of having the jabs are being forced into making risk v benefit decisions with their child's health when the odds are stacked against them.

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 09:38

BePeachNewt · 11/10/2026 23:27

And you think that the sort of parents who believe they know better than trained scientists are capable of providing their kids with a good home education?

No I don't, but I don't think everybody else should be put at risk and what's more, why should their children benefit from herd immunity? They feel validated because everyone else is vaccinated so their child doesn't get sick, so it maintains this idiotic belief. If they think their child can catch diseases and their natural immunity will save them then let them see. Fuck around and find out.
Why should other people be put at risk?!

OP posts:
ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 09:41

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 09:36

Parents who choose not to vaccinate their children are either unhinged, uneducated or simply selfish. That is a fact.

The ‘aggression’ stems from the fact that because of people like you, measles is now circulating in the UK again, after over 50 years of near-zero transmission rates. That makes me incredibly angry and I won’t moderate my anger to mollify selfish idiots.

This a million times over!

OP posts:
TealHacks · 12/10/2026 09:42

Those who willfully deny what the science says by choosing to not vaccinate, should be denied medical access for anything else.

Let them go to YouTube to treat their broken arm, cancer, diabetes 1 etc.

10 pages in and some posters are still not understanding that anti-vaxers do put vaccinated children at risk. Their level of stupid should be legislated against.

Thesillysocks · 12/10/2026 09:44

Scamworried · 12/10/2026 08:40

And what happens if a parent in France doesn't vaccinated and the yearly checks indicated that the child wasn't getting an appropriate education?

Because a thread recently wanted to ban or only allow specific people to home educate.
You can not simultaneously reduce the ability to home educate while banning unvaccinated children from school

I believe social services would get involved.

It has worked like this for decades (vaccine requirements for school / check on home ed), more mandatory vaccines were even added to the list circa 2018.
From a quick google search: MMR vaccine rate in children is 95% in Fr vs 89% in the UK (« the worst performer among G7 nations »). So cleary something could be improved.

allthingsinmoderation · 12/10/2026 09:45

Which vaccinations specifically?
What exemptions would there be? medical,religious or philosophical?
Personally i think coercion causes a backlash and may result in a backlash.
Vaccination is not compulsory in the uk and presumably a change in the law would be needed to make it compulsory?

Gealach · 12/10/2026 09:46

fashionqueen0123 · 12/10/2026 09:21

But now because of the minority not vaccinating it makes that more likely to happen to an adult. Because they may not be immune anymore or someone who couldn’t have the jab or who was born at the wrong time. Like the teacher on this thread.

The number of adults who get the mumps today is a fraction of what it was during the 1960’s and before. Because there is simply less mumps circulating because of vaccination.

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 09:47

Celtic1hair · 12/10/2026 09:37

It's understandable to make an informed decision backed by science, you had the luxury to do this because herd immunity would have protected your child to a significant level even without them having the vaccine. With the uptake levels now dropping below the required threshold, the decision you would now have to make would have been much more difficult I think, because realistically your child would now have a much higher risk of catching a disease with potentially fatal concequences versus the theoretical risk of vaccine injury you were concerned about.
This is exactly why mandatory immunisations are absolutely vital where there is absolutely no reason to not administer, parents with genuine medical reasons to be wary of having the jabs are being forced into making risk v benefit decisions with their child's health when the odds are stacked against them.

I have genuine medical reasons. I knew there was an issue with how my child had reacted to the vaccines, so held back on vaccines. My instincts were proven correct only much later with a proper medical diagnosis. I do think I made the right decision at the time. I do still have one child who cannot have any vaccines without specialist approval. So, yes, he relies on herd immunity, although we were able to give him the MMR later on, thankfully, as I wouldn't want a teenage boy to get mumps.

I do agree that it would be less straight forward now to make that same decision with less herd immunity around for some of the vaccines. The fact is though, due to genetic issues, we do still often react strongly and strangely to various medications and things, so each vaccine (and medical intervention that isn't a vaccine) is weighed up in light of this. Sometimes it's a matter of choosing your risk, but it is always the best choice I can make with good information.

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 09:47

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 09:36

Parents who choose not to vaccinate their children are either unhinged, uneducated or simply selfish. That is a fact.

The ‘aggression’ stems from the fact that because of people like you, measles is now circulating in the UK again, after over 50 years of near-zero transmission rates. That makes me incredibly angry and I won’t moderate my anger to mollify selfish idiots.

That is not “a fact” medical research has resulted in a number of drugs on the market that at the time were held to be perfectly safe, with time the was shown not to be the case. People have different views , they are neither unhinged, uneducated or whatever other insult people wish to level. People are allowed to have those views, I have deliberately not given examples of specific vaccines or drugs, as I think the principle of choice and freedom to make that choice or hold that view is the issue. Hurling insults is rude and does nothing to support a view.

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 09:52

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 09:47

That is not “a fact” medical research has resulted in a number of drugs on the market that at the time were held to be perfectly safe, with time the was shown not to be the case. People have different views , they are neither unhinged, uneducated or whatever other insult people wish to level. People are allowed to have those views, I have deliberately not given examples of specific vaccines or drugs, as I think the principle of choice and freedom to make that choice or hold that view is the issue. Hurling insults is rude and does nothing to support a view.

Yes, x-rays for acne, thalidomide, DES. I learned about teratogens at university, so when offered morning sickness medication made an educated resounding NO. For a few months of feeling like hell, I felt safer than taking the risk.

Livingoverseas123 · 12/10/2026 09:53

The vast majority of unvaccinated children in UK come from disorganised households where parent(s) for whatever reason have just not taken the children to be vaccinated at the correct time. If you want to improve vaccination rates it is much more productive to focus on this group rather than on the children of vaccine refusers.

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 09:53

swimsong · 12/10/2026 02:15

Who are they a danger to?

It's frightening to think you don't know this.
You are willfully ignorant.

As has been said several times already - unvaccinated children are a danger to everybody else. They keep the diseases in population. They spread them. They catch them and die themselves through no fault of their own. There are children, babies, staff, other parents etc who should be able to attend school without the fear of deadly diseases because they are immunocompromised.

I think to opt out of vaccines, parents should need to provide a reason. It should be recorded on their medical file. They should be made to explain this to their children that they have made a medical decision which goes against their child's best interests. Decisions like refusing medical treatment comes with consequences, and this should include restrictions on mixing with others.

No nursery, no school, no university, until they are vaccinated. Workplaces can make their own rules. The NHS requires staff to be vaccinated as part of their employment.

There are parents in other countries who would give anything to have free vaccinations and medicine that we get handed to us.

OP posts:
Makebelieveanotherlife · 12/10/2026 09:54

Pyjamatimenow · 11/10/2026 22:01

Isn’t that what they do in USA? I agree. I have no time for anti vaxxers

Agree. My kids are in private school and you are asked to send in their vaccine schedules.

allthingsinmoderation · 12/10/2026 09:57

IronEverything · 12/10/2026 06:05

My children are unvaccinated. I've never used any kind of nursery or childcare for them but they'll be attending school.

Why did you decide not to vaccinate your children ? Was it medical,religious or philosophical reasons?
Would you change you mind if as suggested by some in this thread that your children wouldnt be able to attend school?

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 09:58

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 09:47

That is not “a fact” medical research has resulted in a number of drugs on the market that at the time were held to be perfectly safe, with time the was shown not to be the case. People have different views , they are neither unhinged, uneducated or whatever other insult people wish to level. People are allowed to have those views, I have deliberately not given examples of specific vaccines or drugs, as I think the principle of choice and freedom to make that choice or hold that view is the issue. Hurling insults is rude and does nothing to support a view.

Nothing in life is perfectly safe. Nearly everything we do carries a very tiny risk of going horribly wrong and killing or harming us. Every time you eat you accept the very low risk of choking, which could kill you or leave you permanently brain damaged. Every time you get in your car or take a flight you accept the very low risk of crashing and dying in a ball of flames.

Your problem is that you are statistically illiterate and completely incapable of weighing up relative risks.

Firstly, all the vaccines included in the routine vaccination schedule for kids have been around for decades. These are not new drugs. We know exactly what the risks are. Every possible side effect has already been seen.

The risk of vaccine injury resulting in severe harm from the measles vaccine, for example, is approximately 2 in a million. But 1 in 20 unvaccinated people who contract measles will develop pneumomia. 1 in 1000 will die.

The only reason that people like you have chosen not to vaccinate is because herd immunity (created by responsible, educated parents making the correct choice to vaccinate our kids) has, until now, protected your children. But as vaccination rates fall and measles begins to circulate again, you will be confronted with the reality of that 1 in 1000 risk. I bet the 2 in a million risk of a severe vaccine injury won’t seem so bad when thousands of children are dying from measles, and tens of thousands more are left permanently disabled, every year.

fashionqueen0123 · 12/10/2026 09:58

Gealach · 12/10/2026 09:46

The number of adults who get the mumps today is a fraction of what it was during the 1960’s and before. Because there is simply less mumps circulating because of vaccination.

Right - but we don't want to reverse those numbers!

Greatexpect · 12/10/2026 10:00

I have children in my family who have compromised immune systems. Unvaccinated children could spread dangerous illnesses that could kill them. None of these parents who choose not to vaccinate their perfectly healthy children know better than the scientists and doctors who decide on the evidence based vaccine schedules. I’d love to know where they think they have managed to find more trustworthy information.

AmberPeaches · 12/10/2026 10:01

TealHacks · 12/10/2026 09:42

Those who willfully deny what the science says by choosing to not vaccinate, should be denied medical access for anything else.

Let them go to YouTube to treat their broken arm, cancer, diabetes 1 etc.

10 pages in and some posters are still not understanding that anti-vaxers do put vaccinated children at risk. Their level of stupid should be legislated against.

Absolutely this! The cognitive dissonance is astounding.

fashionqueen0123 · 12/10/2026 10:03

Livingoverseas123 · 12/10/2026 09:53

The vast majority of unvaccinated children in UK come from disorganised households where parent(s) for whatever reason have just not taken the children to be vaccinated at the correct time. If you want to improve vaccination rates it is much more productive to focus on this group rather than on the children of vaccine refusers.

I watched a short documentary/news article on this it was quite interesting. They are starting to provide pop up clinics which were pretty successful for these families. It was literally people not bothering to phone up to get appts etc.

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 10:03

Livingoverseas123 · 12/10/2026 09:53

The vast majority of unvaccinated children in UK come from disorganised households where parent(s) for whatever reason have just not taken the children to be vaccinated at the correct time. If you want to improve vaccination rates it is much more productive to focus on this group rather than on the children of vaccine refusers.

I don't think public money should be wasted on campaigns for people who can't organise themselves to get to a doctor's surgery. They are just as unlikely to go to a community drop in hub. It'll be sorry I forgot it was Tuesday, could they come to my house instead 🙄

There are few things in my life as a parent more important than my children's health and education.
Perhaps doctor's surgeries could hold a 6pm drop in clinic once a month but I suspect it'll be a potential waste of time if those people are that disorganised.

Do pharmacies offer it? I've got my free flu one there but I think it'll be the same thing of needing to book.

OP posts:
attichoarder · 12/10/2026 10:07

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 09:58

Nothing in life is perfectly safe. Nearly everything we do carries a very tiny risk of going horribly wrong and killing or harming us. Every time you eat you accept the very low risk of choking, which could kill you or leave you permanently brain damaged. Every time you get in your car or take a flight you accept the very low risk of crashing and dying in a ball of flames.

Your problem is that you are statistically illiterate and completely incapable of weighing up relative risks.

Firstly, all the vaccines included in the routine vaccination schedule for kids have been around for decades. These are not new drugs. We know exactly what the risks are. Every possible side effect has already been seen.

The risk of vaccine injury resulting in severe harm from the measles vaccine, for example, is approximately 2 in a million. But 1 in 20 unvaccinated people who contract measles will develop pneumomia. 1 in 1000 will die.

The only reason that people like you have chosen not to vaccinate is because herd immunity (created by responsible, educated parents making the correct choice to vaccinate our kids) has, until now, protected your children. But as vaccination rates fall and measles begins to circulate again, you will be confronted with the reality of that 1 in 1000 risk. I bet the 2 in a million risk of a severe vaccine injury won’t seem so bad when thousands of children are dying from measles, and tens of thousands more are left permanently disabled, every year.

Edited

Thanks for assessment of my abilities and what actions I have taken regarding my own children. You are correct that nothing is totally a
safe but you are incorrect in your comments about myself. We are discussing the fact that free to make choices and as we know there are lies, dam lies and statistics also statistics can only deal with the known facts , as we know what is said now might not be true in the future. One poster cited the example of specific drugs in the 1960s whilst there have been numerous example since then. People have different views and I would insult those who held different views from myself.

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 10:08

fashionqueen0123 · 12/10/2026 10:03

I watched a short documentary/news article on this it was quite interesting. They are starting to provide pop up clinics which were pretty successful for these families. It was literally people not bothering to phone up to get appts etc.

It is wild to me how much we take free healthcare for granted that people can't call up to organise an appointment. A lot of the time now parents are provided an appointment when their child gets to that age.
There are parents walking miles in scorching conditions to just get water, but people in the UK can't be arsed to take their baby to the doctor's to get a jab. Nuts.

OP posts:
BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 10:08

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 10:03

I don't think public money should be wasted on campaigns for people who can't organise themselves to get to a doctor's surgery. They are just as unlikely to go to a community drop in hub. It'll be sorry I forgot it was Tuesday, could they come to my house instead 🙄

There are few things in my life as a parent more important than my children's health and education.
Perhaps doctor's surgeries could hold a 6pm drop in clinic once a month but I suspect it'll be a potential waste of time if those people are that disorganised.

Do pharmacies offer it? I've got my free flu one there but I think it'll be the same thing of needing to book.

Your convictions are leading you down the wrong path here. Don’t cut your nose off to spite your face.

Keeping vaccination levels high enough to maintain herd immunity represents a humongous cost saving for the public purse. A mass vaccination campaign targeting disorganised parents, including home visits, is far, far cheaper than a measles outbreak resulting in hundreds of people in hospital with severe disease.

And as we have discussed repeatedly on this thread, vaccinating an individual is about protecting society as a whole as much as it is about protecting that individual.

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 10:16

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 10:07

Thanks for assessment of my abilities and what actions I have taken regarding my own children. You are correct that nothing is totally a
safe but you are incorrect in your comments about myself. We are discussing the fact that free to make choices and as we know there are lies, dam lies and statistics also statistics can only deal with the known facts , as we know what is said now might not be true in the future. One poster cited the example of specific drugs in the 1960s whilst there have been numerous example since then. People have different views and I would insult those who held different views from myself.

You are free to make choices but there are consequences. Even toddlers know this.

You exercise your right to not vaccinate your child, but no thought as to the rights of your child, denying another human medical care. You also shouldn't have the right to put others in danger.

Don't want to vaccinate your child? Fine. But as a consequence they will not be provided with group education, they will miss out. But hey, if the parents know more than scientists who dedicate their lives to researching vaccines, then home educating should be easy peasy.
Other public places will also be able to exercise their rights to not have unvaccinateds in their buildings, that might mean swimming pools, gymnastics classes, ballet, Brownies. Other countries who have very low cases and have virtually eradicated it, should then have the right to not allow unvaccinated in.

The unvaccinated aren't the only ones with rights.

OP posts: