Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS and I are not in the wrong? Will related…

646 replies

IfIHadAHeart · 10/10/2026 23:57

A relative of my exH died recently and has left a fairly substantial inheritance to my DCs. This has some as a complete surprise. One of my DCs is over 18 but the other is not.

The relative has not left anything to my DCs cousin. No idea why, or whether the will might even predate the cousin’s birth. If so, there were still many years in which to update the will if the relative had wanted to, and they were of sound mind throughout.

exMIL believes my DC should split their inheritance with the cousin. She believes my eldest DC should give the majority of their share to the cousin upon receiving the money, and that my youngest DC should then top up eldest when they turn 18 and can access the funds.

Eldest DC has said no, with my backing. I’m now getting rather unpleasant messages from my exH, MIL and SIL (parent of the excluded cousin) about the unfairness of it all and that my DC are selfish.

AIBU to support eldest DC to stand their ground?

OP posts:
SwirlyGates · 12/10/2026 12:44

Change2banon · 12/10/2026 12:16

A family member died, didn’t leave a will, no children. The money from her estate went to her closest/next in line living blood relative - she’d not spoken to this person in MANY years due to a family/personal nasty fallout. The deceased would have been turning in her grave knowing this relative had all her money. The relative took, and kept, all of the money, even though she despised the deceased. Is this fair? Should she have taken the money of a woman she vehemently despised? Or should she have passed it up? Given it to more distant blood relatives, but those who actually played a part in the daily life of the deceased person?

I don't see the relevance of this, since there was no will.

As for "turning in her grave" - well, why didn't she make a will if the consequences of not doing so would be so awful to her?

Tryingtokeepgoing · 12/10/2026 12:56

LilacReader · 12/10/2026 10:41

Hey, calm down. I just know that me 'personally' would also find it a little unfair if the cousin didn't receive any. I'm not saying what the OP 'should' do but that I think it's a nice gesture and one that I would do if I was in that situation. I would feel really sorry for the cousin.

But the OP has absolutely no ability to do anything, becuase she hasn’t been left any money. The only two that have it appears are her sons, one of whom is not old enough to give it away, and because it is held in trust until he’s 18 neither can the trustee even if that is the OP. The other beneficiary is an adult and is under no obligation to give any of his share away, certainly not on the ‘promise’ of it being ‘evened out’ when the youngest is 18. Because by then the youngest might not be able or willing to give away a third of his inheritance. So, in the OPs situation what is it exactly that you would do? What gesture can you make?

InterIgnis · 12/10/2026 12:56

Change2banon · 12/10/2026 12:16

A family member died, didn’t leave a will, no children. The money from her estate went to her closest/next in line living blood relative - she’d not spoken to this person in MANY years due to a family/personal nasty fallout. The deceased would have been turning in her grave knowing this relative had all her money. The relative took, and kept, all of the money, even though she despised the deceased. Is this fair? Should she have taken the money of a woman she vehemently despised? Or should she have passed it up? Given it to more distant blood relatives, but those who actually played a part in the daily life of the deceased person?

‘Fair’ is irrelevant. What happened is entirely correct, and I see no issue with it. The deceased could have prevented this by making a will, but she chose not to. That’s on her.

TheOvertGardener · 12/10/2026 13:00

InterIgnis · 12/10/2026 12:42

“I display my generosity of spirit by giving copious amounts of shit”

Calm down! Say, what is that you’ve got there? Spare a bit for me?

InterIgnis · 12/10/2026 13:22

TheOvertGardener · 12/10/2026 13:00

Calm down! Say, what is that you’ve got there? Spare a bit for me?

Lol. Who isn’t calm?

It’s pride, and no. I prefer to share my surplus with those who want it.

TheOvertGardener · 12/10/2026 13:29

InterIgnis · 12/10/2026 13:22

Lol. Who isn’t calm?

It’s pride, and no. I prefer to share my surplus with those who want it.

Ha!! Bravo! 😂

SnoopyIsReal · 12/10/2026 13:35

Follow the Will and leave your DCs inheritance alone. I suspect they will have fuck all to do with their cousins or your SIL in future anyway, particularly after this.

WearyAuldWumman · 12/10/2026 13:54

wildnwilde · 12/10/2026 09:23

You won't be anything as you will be dead . I find it bizarre that ppl want to control money even when they're dead . 🤣🤣 Money truly is the root of all evil .

Of course I'll be dead. But before I die, I'd rather know that I'll be helping those for whom I care rather than some random person with whom I have no connection.

I cannot imagine that anyone would make such a flippant comment to someone who wanted to make sure that they were leaving their estate to their children and/or grandchildren.

I'm not using my estate - such as it is - for coercive control. House prices round my way are not high. If/When I go into a care home, it'll be used for costs. Anything left over will go to those whom I name (or to their heirs).

WearyAuldWumman · 12/10/2026 13:58

Kirschcherries · 12/10/2026 10:07

The other recipients are charities who are notorious for watching every penny of inheritances.

That's why I make my charity donations now and have resisted charity requests to mention them in my will - I've heard that it can cause difficulties when it comes to distributing the estate.

Kirschcherries · 12/10/2026 14:56

@WearyAuldWumman I know of cases where charities have taken a fine tooth comb to the estate accounts.

I agree with you about not leaving money to charities in my will and donating now.

LittleOwl153 · 12/10/2026 15:03

The only thing I would do is find a financial advisor for your kids ready for if/when the funds arrive.

I say this so your eldest has rhe right advise to protect their share until they are ready to use it and your youngest has an appropriate trust with responsible trustees and open records!

WearyAuldWumman · 12/10/2026 15:05

Kirschcherries · 12/10/2026 14:56

@WearyAuldWumman I know of cases where charities have taken a fine tooth comb to the estate accounts.

I agree with you about not leaving money to charities in my will and donating now.

Thank you. I wouldn't want to cause unnecessary stress after I'm gone.

Elsvieta · 12/10/2026 15:40

IfIHadAHeart · 11/10/2026 10:01

I understand your point. Unfortunately the reality is that the will could have been written a fortnight ago and exPIL would be behaving in the same way - it’s just who they are.

I don’t really want to engage with them. Once probate is granted or DC physically see the will we can establish the date. Perhaps that will make DC feel differently, perhaps it won’t.

You can see it as soon as it's been filed with a probate court - anyone can. Not that the date matters.

Depressing to think of anyone being pestered by bossy interfering in-laws even after they're bloody divorced. Once this is all sorted, block 'em all.

I think you'll be doing your kids (and other family members, probably) a favour by role-modelling that it's possible to stand up to exMIL and exSIL and the one everybody's "terrified" of (if that isn't the same person as exSIL, I'm a bit confused). I know these queen-bee types who think it's their role to boss the whole family around over stuff that isn't even their business. Having somebody say no to them for once will do them good - doesn't sound like it happens nearly often enough. Coach your kids on a few stock replies they can give if the in-laws try pressuring them face to face and don't engage further.

Celtic1hair · 12/10/2026 16:51

I wonder if your deceased relative knew more than she let on as to the difficulties you had faced over the years and this was their way of supporting you? Or had her opinions on the way the rest of the family seem to conduct themselves and took some comfort in trying to help financially where she was able?
I suppose in the end her reasons for doing what she has done don't matter, she was entitled to have her wishes honoured, but as wonderful as you have been to try and remain impartial to telling the truth to your children about your ex in laws, perhaps giving a modified version of the truth may be appropriate now, or they will be much more susceptible to emotional blackmail and all of the consequences that entails.

Change2banon · 12/10/2026 16:54

InterIgnis · 12/10/2026 12:56

‘Fair’ is irrelevant. What happened is entirely correct, and I see no issue with it. The deceased could have prevented this by making a will, but she chose not to. That’s on her.

This is exactly the type of message I hoped someone would say. In my case it was exactly correct that this person got, and kept, the money. In OP’s case, there is a will .. but some are saying, no that’s wrong, you must share. The whole point is the will should be adhered to. End of.

It makes sense to me, apologies if it doesn’t to others 🫣

MerelyPlaying · 12/10/2026 16:56

This thread just keeps on giving! It’s highly unlikely that the family will ‘lose’ the will. Without a will it would all go to the deceased’s brother, and who knows whether he would offer Emily anything? Or indeed anyone else. But in any event the will has probably been made by and stored with a solicitor.

It occurs to me, however, that the expectation by exMiL that OP’s eldest child could be persuaded/bullied to give up his inheritance says a lot about the family dynamics. Presumably this is how she expects people to respond, and probably how she brought up her son, OP’s ex-husband. I’m picturing a sort of East End matriarch - grown men can be reduced to tears by a tongue-lashing from ‘Ma’, who rules the family and holds the purse-strings … Lou Beale or Peggy Mitchell!

caringcarer · 12/10/2026 19:12

Forgedsnak · 11/10/2026 00:11

In the interests of fairness I would split it the three ways if it were me. I’d feel extremely uncomfortable knowing one cousin had nothing. But then I like to think I’m a good person.

You can't take money away from DC if they inherited it. It doesn't belong to you to take away anything.

caringcarer · 12/10/2026 19:18

Always best to stick to the will.

Toothfairypaypal · 12/10/2026 19:46

Don’t do it! This is incredibly dodgy. There can’t be a Deed of Variation due to the age of your youngest DC, as has already been established. The parents of ‘Emily’ are therefore asking your eldest DC to hand over a large amount of money to them with zero legal safeguards and zero guarantee that it will even go to ‘Emily.’ Something is deeply rotten here. Tell them to do one.

CecilyP · 12/10/2026 21:38

If the great aunt had chosen to leave her money to any one of these people FIL, MIL, ex DH, ex SIL, ex BIL, it would have been in their gift to share it with 'little Emily'. But she chose not to, she chose not too, she chose your sons. They should really stop trying to bully them, and shouldn't be harassing you as it is nothing to do with you.

I think it's significant that she skipped a generation and chose not to leave anything to her actual niece and nephew. I wonder why! I take it that neither she nor her brother had any children of their own.

So if she had made the will over 10 years ago, she would have chosen to leave legacies to 2 small children rather than two adults with young/ potential young families. This doesn't seem likely.

If she has made the will more recently, she has chosen to leave most of her money to charity and nothing to any other family member except your 2 sons. Think of that for a minute. She probably chose to leave money to your 2 boys as they have helped her and were her favourite teenagers rather than because they were related.

If the family pesters you, you just have to reiterate that it is nothing to do with you. It is your son's choices. All you can do is support them. They could start by saying to their dad, 'great aunt Mary, left the money to us, not to you, not to auntie Sue, not to gran and not to grandad, we will choose what we do with it!' They could also add, 'I wonder why she did that?'

Stolengoat · 13/10/2026 18:48

StockingsByTheFire · 11/10/2026 10:45

Well, yeah that's the point.

If it's written when the kids are 2 then they weren't included for their "helping out" were they.

If it was written after the cousin was born, then that's different context.

How do you know the person intentionally didn't update their will? I would imagine op knows more about this family's dynamics than you do.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page