Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS and I are not in the wrong? Will related…

646 replies

IfIHadAHeart · 10/10/2026 23:57

A relative of my exH died recently and has left a fairly substantial inheritance to my DCs. This has some as a complete surprise. One of my DCs is over 18 but the other is not.

The relative has not left anything to my DCs cousin. No idea why, or whether the will might even predate the cousin’s birth. If so, there were still many years in which to update the will if the relative had wanted to, and they were of sound mind throughout.

exMIL believes my DC should split their inheritance with the cousin. She believes my eldest DC should give the majority of their share to the cousin upon receiving the money, and that my youngest DC should then top up eldest when they turn 18 and can access the funds.

Eldest DC has said no, with my backing. I’m now getting rather unpleasant messages from my exH, MIL and SIL (parent of the excluded cousin) about the unfairness of it all and that my DC are selfish.

AIBU to support eldest DC to stand their ground?

OP posts:
ParrotPeach · 12/10/2026 08:48

YANBU but I can still understand why they're upset. Assuming no fall outs etc, it is hurtful to leave to one set of cousins and not the other. Shock and hurt isn't an unreasonable reaction and can make people act a certain way.

If the relative wasn't of sound mind in the years after the cousin's birth, I would say it would be fair to split the inheritance (assuming the relative had a positive relationship with ex-SIL). Otherwise, this is just a decision that the deceased apparently was happy to make and they weren't bothered about the inevitable drama it would cause.

Somethinggg · 12/10/2026 09:09

Sleepdeprivedandcaffinated · 12/10/2026 07:13

What a brilliant message for the children. Hand over large amounts of cash that you and you alone are entitled to, otherwise the adults in the family that are supposed to love you might punish you by no longer talking to you or seeing you because they don’t think it’s fair that the person you maintained a relationship with left you something but not someone else.

Frankly the DCs would be better off without such abusive people in their lives. The right thing is adults not coercing money out of young people.

Yes, do people really not understand that the risk of alienating some family relationships is now entirely baked in?

The advice OP is being given here is to try and make her elder DC give away a substantial part of his inheritance, with the promise of eventually being repaid by a child who is currently too young to really understand any of this, much less consent to it, and who might very well say fuck this. Even if OP does manage to pull it off, the risk of this backfiring on her is very obvious. Either or both of her sons might later come back to blame her, and DC2 might not want to repay DC1 or consider himself bound by decisions made by other people when he was like 14. Plus none of this is guaranteed to placate the relatives anyway.

So OP might end up with rifts between her own sons, one or both of them blaming her and their father for not standing up to their violent loon of an uncle, and the kids with no house deposits from anywhere.

wildnwilde · 12/10/2026 09:23

WearyAuldWumman · 11/10/2026 23:07

I'll be leaving my estate to family members on my side and family members on my husband's side with whom I feel I have a connection.

I have three cousins in North America. In spite of the best efforts of those of us in the UK, we lost touch with the cousins.

A great-uncle died intestate, leaving behind a fair amount of money - enough to incur Inheritance Tax in those days.

Those of us in Scotland dutifully helped the solicitor taking care of matters to trace the 'missing' cousins and they got their share of G-U's estate. I think it was split about 15 ways in the end.

One of the cousins wrote to the solicitor in effusive terms, claiming that they'd lost all our details.

Most family members hadn't moved home since two of the cousins had been on holiday over here as teens. My last communication from one of them had been a chain letter promising ill fortune and death if I broke the chain. We were both high school pupils at the time. I broke the chain.

My parents were still at the house to which she'd sent the chain letter. Our aunts and remaining uncle were all still at the same addresses where they'd hosted the cousins.

Some of my other cousins had tried writing to the cousin who sent me the chain letter, but had never received a reply.

The solicitor kindly sent the North American cousins our addresses. That was 30 years ago. None of us heard a thing from the effusive cousin, but her brother has kept in touch with us all and has been over with his family. He, his wife and children continue to communicate with the family in Scotland and England.

When I kick the bucket, his children will get a small amount from my estate. His siblings' children will get nothing. I'd be rather annoyed if someone tried to redistribute the money in the interest of 'fairness'.

You won't be anything as you will be dead . I find it bizarre that ppl want to control money even when they're dead . 🤣🤣 Money truly is the root of all evil .

saveforthat · 12/10/2026 09:32

wildnwilde · 12/10/2026 09:23

You won't be anything as you will be dead . I find it bizarre that ppl want to control money even when they're dead . 🤣🤣 Money truly is the root of all evil .

The love of money is the root of all evil. Frequently misquoted.

Peachghost · 12/10/2026 09:39

wildnwilde · 12/10/2026 09:23

You won't be anything as you will be dead . I find it bizarre that ppl want to control money even when they're dead . 🤣🤣 Money truly is the root of all evil .

What a bizarre attitude. Do you not have a will then?
And its the the love of money, not money, that is said to be the root of all evil.

Kirschcherries · 12/10/2026 10:07

DadBodAlready · 11/10/2026 20:21

I seriously doubt that the relative of your exH left everything to your DCs.
In which case why can't the other recipients contribute?

The other recipients are charities who are notorious for watching every penny of inheritances.

wildnwilde · 12/10/2026 10:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LilacReader · 12/10/2026 10:21

No, you don't have to but unless there is some awful family feud that we don't know about, I would absolutely give a token if nothing else, to the excluded cousin. You may be on your son's side but how would you feel if it was the other way round?

MathsMum3 · 12/10/2026 10:37

I've been following this thread, but haven't posted yet. Something just occurred to me (forgive me if someone has already mentioned it). If your ex-in-laws, including the cousin's violent father, really think that you'll never share the money, do you think the will might become "lost"? In other words, do you think they're vindictive enough to make sure your sons don't inherit if the cousin doesn't? I believe you said the deceased had a sibling, so the estate would go to them if no will existed.

For clarity, I think you're doing the right thing here. I'm just concerned that if you appear adamant that the cousin will receive nothing, the in-laws may take drastic action. Might be worth sounding a little more "unsure" until the will has been registered and probate granted.

jennikr · 12/10/2026 10:37

It's risky for your eldest to do this since it's difficult to predict the future and they will be in the worst position. If anything, eldest could put aside some for their sibling in a savings account earning interest, then when your youngest inherits, they/everyone could then consider giving some of that (and some of theirs, to share the amount equally) to the cousin. It's definitely unfair to expect the only one currently entitled to inherit to give most of it away now for that money to earn interest for the cousin who should not receive anything for several years even assuming the relative did make an oversight.

Somethinggg · 12/10/2026 10:38

LilacReader · 12/10/2026 10:21

No, you don't have to but unless there is some awful family feud that we don't know about, I would absolutely give a token if nothing else, to the excluded cousin. You may be on your son's side but how would you feel if it was the other way round?

Setting aside that it's not OPs money to give away so there are significant practical problems with the suggestion, a token might be the worst of all worlds.

Still unequal, so no reason to think it'd be seen as fair or acceptable by the people currently kicking off. Indicating to OPs kids that they can be berated into giving away what's legally theirs if someone else causes enough fuss over it, meaning the wider family have an incentive to continue trying to extract the money. And still with the risk of causing discord between OP, her kids and each other- because DC2 can't do anything with their share yet, so DC1 would have to be made to give some of their share now in the hope that a kid of maybe 14 who can't consent to or fully understand the situation will make it up at a later date.

LilacReader · 12/10/2026 10:41

Somethinggg · 12/10/2026 10:38

Setting aside that it's not OPs money to give away so there are significant practical problems with the suggestion, a token might be the worst of all worlds.

Still unequal, so no reason to think it'd be seen as fair or acceptable by the people currently kicking off. Indicating to OPs kids that they can be berated into giving away what's legally theirs if someone else causes enough fuss over it, meaning the wider family have an incentive to continue trying to extract the money. And still with the risk of causing discord between OP, her kids and each other- because DC2 can't do anything with their share yet, so DC1 would have to be made to give some of their share now in the hope that a kid of maybe 14 who can't consent to or fully understand the situation will make it up at a later date.

Hey, calm down. I just know that me 'personally' would also find it a little unfair if the cousin didn't receive any. I'm not saying what the OP 'should' do but that I think it's a nice gesture and one that I would do if I was in that situation. I would feel really sorry for the cousin.

Somethinggg · 12/10/2026 10:45

LilacReader · 12/10/2026 10:41

Hey, calm down. I just know that me 'personally' would also find it a little unfair if the cousin didn't receive any. I'm not saying what the OP 'should' do but that I think it's a nice gesture and one that I would do if I was in that situation. I would feel really sorry for the cousin.

Bit bemused by the idea that responding to a post is un-calm behaviour. Try chilling out a bit, sometimes on MN people write things and other people say they don't think it's a good idea.

You wouldn't do it in that situation btw, as it wouldn't be your money. You'd be feeling very sorry for the cousin whilst being unable to access the bequest yourself. Closest you'd be able to get is giving the cousin some of your own funds instead.

Owl55 · 12/10/2026 10:47

Maybe the uncle who left the money to the children thought the ex dad had treated his family badly and that’s why he left them money???

Darker · 12/10/2026 11:15

Weird answers on here. As if the OP is inheriting.

Her children are inheriting. She gets nothing. And its not her family so it’s frankly nothing to do with her, except in terms of supporting her kids who seem to be being put under pressure from people who want their money.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 12/10/2026 11:22

LilacReader · 12/10/2026 10:41

Hey, calm down. I just know that me 'personally' would also find it a little unfair if the cousin didn't receive any. I'm not saying what the OP 'should' do but that I think it's a nice gesture and one that I would do if I was in that situation. I would feel really sorry for the cousin.

Are you able to explain why you think it's unfair? The money is coming from the child's great-uncle's widow. Not a close relative, not a blood relation at all. She had a brother and has chosen to leave nothing to him. She has left the bulk of her money to a charity and smaller sums to two young men who visited her and helped her out. She has left nothing to any of her husband's other relatives, including the 10yo 'Emily'. Why should she have done?

PetulaGordeno · 12/10/2026 11:25

LilacReader · 12/10/2026 10:41

Hey, calm down. I just know that me 'personally' would also find it a little unfair if the cousin didn't receive any. I'm not saying what the OP 'should' do but that I think it's a nice gesture and one that I would do if I was in that situation. I would feel really sorry for the cousin.

I personally wouldn’t give a toss considering her father assaulted OP physically.
Life’s tough.

saraclara · 12/10/2026 12:04

If you or your DS are messaged again @IfIHadAHeart is simply say "relative has not even been buried yet. These messages are inappropriate and disrespectful of his/her memory"

WeybridgeWitch · 12/10/2026 12:04

Continue to respect the deceased person's wishes, OP.

My will is similarly deliberate and I would be rolling in my grave if anyone tried to cut across my express wishes.

thepariscrimefiles · 12/10/2026 12:04

LilacReader · 12/10/2026 10:21

No, you don't have to but unless there is some awful family feud that we don't know about, I would absolutely give a token if nothing else, to the excluded cousin. You may be on your son's side but how would you feel if it was the other way round?

There is some awful and illegal behaviour from OP's ex-husband's family. OP's ex-DH wouldn't accept the divorce and he stalked her for over a year and the father of the child that they are pestering OP's children to share their inheritance with has physically assaulted OP.

OP's children were close to the deceased relative while the rest of the family didn't bother with her. They sound like a family of criminal and violent arseholes that don't deserve a single penny of OP's sons' inheritances.

Change2banon · 12/10/2026 12:16

A family member died, didn’t leave a will, no children. The money from her estate went to her closest/next in line living blood relative - she’d not spoken to this person in MANY years due to a family/personal nasty fallout. The deceased would have been turning in her grave knowing this relative had all her money. The relative took, and kept, all of the money, even though she despised the deceased. Is this fair? Should she have taken the money of a woman she vehemently despised? Or should she have passed it up? Given it to more distant blood relatives, but those who actually played a part in the daily life of the deceased person?

InterIgnis · 12/10/2026 12:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mmhmm. Finding happiness in giving away money to hateful and grasping people that think they’re entitled to demand it, sounds less something to aspire to and more a perversity. May that type of happiness never find me.

TheOvertGardener · 12/10/2026 12:39

InterIgnis · 12/10/2026 12:18

Mmhmm. Finding happiness in giving away money to hateful and grasping people that think they’re entitled to demand it, sounds less something to aspire to and more a perversity. May that type of happiness never find me.

“I’d be extraordinarily generous if I had anything to give. Conveniently, I do not so will just bash others.”

InterIgnis · 12/10/2026 12:42

TheOvertGardener · 12/10/2026 12:39

“I’d be extraordinarily generous if I had anything to give. Conveniently, I do not so will just bash others.”

“I display my generosity of spirit by giving copious amounts of shit”

Winter2020 · 12/10/2026 12:44

Change2banon · 12/10/2026 12:16

A family member died, didn’t leave a will, no children. The money from her estate went to her closest/next in line living blood relative - she’d not spoken to this person in MANY years due to a family/personal nasty fallout. The deceased would have been turning in her grave knowing this relative had all her money. The relative took, and kept, all of the money, even though she despised the deceased. Is this fair? Should she have taken the money of a woman she vehemently despised? Or should she have passed it up? Given it to more distant blood relatives, but those who actually played a part in the daily life of the deceased person?

It’s fine. The laws of intestacy are public information and if the person who died didn’t like what would happen to their estate without a will then they should have made a will.
https://www.gov.uk/inherits-someone-dies-without-will

Intestacy - who inherits if someone dies without a will?

Find out who is entitled to a share of someone’s property, possessions and money if they die without making a will

https://www.gov.uk/inherits-someone-dies-without-will