Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and toddler coat debacle

117 replies

DrWhosJazzyScarf · 09/10/2026 07:58

So, husband takes daughter to nursery in the morning. She is being a little rascal and won’t put her coat on. Fridays is ice cream day, so I said to her, ‘Pop on your coat and we’ll have ice cream later. But only if you put your coat on…’

Husband then gets very angry and says, ‘Thank you VERY much. Now she’ll be screaming for ice cream on the way to nursery.’ I said it’s a Friday tradition, and - to me - a bit of screeching en route to nursery is standard toddler practice, especially when tired on Fridays.

He then says the problem is that I always have to be right - that I couldn’t accept being ‘wrong’ about this. From my point of view, I was just explaining my thought process - she responds well to a potential reward. He then told me, ‘I don’t want to speak to you any more. Say goodbye to DC, we’re going now’.

Some of you may recognise me from previous husband issues (most recently inset days) - clearly, we’re having issues at the moment. I do the vast majority of everything for our child (he drops DC off 4x a week and that’s pretty much it.) I don’t know if I’m being unreasonable - my sense of self is pretty shot at the moment, TBH.

People of Mumsnet, please do weigh in. If I’m in the wrong, I’ll take it.

OP posts:
FlowerVases · 09/10/2026 08:00

I am with dh.

NotSmallButFunSize · 09/10/2026 08:02

Tbh I wouldn't have bothered with the coat - just take it with her and get in the car, it's not that cold.

Then bribery doesn't need to happen!

HettyTagliatelli · 09/10/2026 08:02

Your DH has a point. He can’t reward with ice cream every day to get a child to wear her coat.

Let her learn about coat wearing through natural consequences.

mynameiscalypso · 09/10/2026 08:02

I totally understand why when you’re frustrated with someone, that everything they do is wrong but I am with DH a bit here. Children of nursery age don’t always have a good sense of time or what ‘later’ means. To them, later = 5 minutes time.

Needmorelego · 09/10/2026 08:02

Never fight a toddler over a coat.
If they realise they are cold they will put it on.
If she's not wearing her coat....does it matter?

Bobloblaw84 · 09/10/2026 08:04

In their younger years kids aren’t able to understand delayed gratification and will nag from the minute you mention a reward. Team DH.

DrWhosJazzyScarf · 09/10/2026 08:04

All good points, thanks for sharing.

Just to clarify - it’s not ice cream every day, just a Friday treat as she’s exhausted by this point.

Perhaps I’m conflating two almost separate issues - ice cream as a reward, and the fact that I have a real dislike for how DH speaks to me in disagreements.

OP posts:
MeowDoku · 09/10/2026 08:05

I wouldn't be bribing with ice cream, she either puts her coat on or gets cold

ThatGreenFawn · 09/10/2026 08:05

Sorry, agree with DH here. You completely undermined him. He was taking her to nursery, so you should have let him deal with nit rather than butting in and offering her a treat.

DrWhosJazzyScarf · 09/10/2026 08:05

NotSmallButFunSize · 09/10/2026 08:02

Tbh I wouldn't have bothered with the coat - just take it with her and get in the car, it's not that cold.

Then bribery doesn't need to happen!

We walk to nursery, and it’s about 20 mins so coat seemed necessary. Will let her rough it out next time, I think.

OP posts:
ColdAsAWitches · 09/10/2026 08:05

Your husband was dealing with her when you jumped in with a bribe, leaving him to deal with the consequences. You shouldn't have said anything, let him sort things out when it's his turn without interfering.

Shoobadadoo · 09/10/2026 08:06

You’re my husband. Constantly promising sweets or chocolates for normal expected behaviour as he sees it as easy way to parent. It’s not

DrWhosJazzyScarf · 09/10/2026 08:06

ThatGreenFawn · 09/10/2026 08:05

Sorry, agree with DH here. You completely undermined him. He was taking her to nursery, so you should have let him deal with nit rather than butting in and offering her a treat.

I can understand this. He’s actually called on me to dress her at this point as she was being tricky, which was why I suggested ice cream. I see how this has backfired now.

OP posts:
Mulledjuice · 09/10/2026 08:07

I'm also with DH.

Theunamedcat · 09/10/2026 08:07

DrWhosJazzyScarf · 09/10/2026 08:05

We walk to nursery, and it’s about 20 mins so coat seemed necessary. Will let her rough it out next time, I think.

You just carry the coat until they get cold offer it regularly ive had to do it often with ds he doesn't always feel the cold though

rwalker · 09/10/2026 08:07

Sorry team DH
our youngest was the same middle of winter and marched him to school with no coat not going to do them any harm
I’d say it took a few weeks but he cracked and put his coat on without asking

your on a slippery slope when you start to bribe them there a child there not in charge you are

nothing worse than one parent saying something then leaving it to the other parent to instigate it

just take her with no coat she’ll learn

DrWhosJazzyScarf · 09/10/2026 08:08

Shoobadadoo · 09/10/2026 08:06

You’re my husband. Constantly promising sweets or chocolates for normal expected behaviour as he sees it as easy way to parent. It’s not

Not entirely fair to judge my entire parenting style based on one issue. Normally I’m the firm parent.

OP posts:
CaptainCalm · 09/10/2026 08:10

I’m with DH on the icecream for a coat issue, not wise and not helpful.

I’m also in the ‘ok, I’ll carry it incase you get cold later’ group. I had a coat refusing toddler, not worth the hassle and if she was cold she’d put it on.

Perhaps you can sit down and agree on an approach for when this happens next time

I can’t comment on how he spoke to you but tbh it just sounds like a fairly standard ‘it’s been a long week and we’re all frazzled’ grumbling minor disagreement.

jacks11 · 09/10/2026 08:21

I think YABU on this occasion. It’s not going to harm her to walk without a coat, if it gets cold she’ll put it on. Children of that age have little concept of time- later is likely to be on her walk and she’s been promised ice cream “later”, so it is likely she is going to be expecting it soon and may well whine/moan when she isn’t getting it. You did set your DH up to have a more difficult trip to nursery than was necessary and I’d be annoyed in his shoes too. I think the fact that you argued your point and suggested toddler tantrums are inevitable so you don’t see why he’s complaining, rather than just say “yeah, sorry, perhaps that wasn’t the wisest strategy”, would have annoyed me further. He did get a bit short with you, though.

if your relationship is going through a tough patch, it’s common for little things to feel out of proportionally irritating. I think it applies to both of you here/

DrWhosJazzyScarf · 09/10/2026 08:22

@CaptainCalmI think you’ve hit the nail on the head. Both tired, both stressed - think I went for the option that works for me, not necessarily for him. Some good suggestions here, thank you.

OP posts:
Comtesse · 09/10/2026 08:22

Needmorelego · 09/10/2026 08:02

Never fight a toddler over a coat.
If they realise they are cold they will put it on.
If she's not wearing her coat....does it matter?

I agree. Some kids run hotter than others. Not worth the fight….

CoraLdn · 09/10/2026 08:25

Oh Gosh, people are so awful to you on this, OP. I understand what you mean - you tried to explain what works for you and he left in a huff.

My honest opinion is that it’s just life with a toddler and the juggle. EVERYONE is disregulated. You feel like you know best because you deal with her more than your OH, so you’re just trying to be helpful (and I don’t accept the sweeping assumption that you bribe her all the time, I really don’t know where that came from). He asked you for help, but you were supposed to do it with your mouth shut and without giving input, which is a bit unfair.

However, he is allowed to have his own opinion, but assume his behaviour is just a result of stress which led to him acting grumpy/ rude.

It’s awful to have those petty arguments and also for your child to have to participate in them. Absolutely no judgment - My OH and I were ratty with each other in those toddler years. We eventually sat down and decided to just try to be more patient and kinder. It worked (ish), but the real game changer was DC growing up a bit and the pressures of every day easing up. We are back to being a great, loving team now. Try to be kinder to each other.

PS - and I had to LOL at your OH talking about to who’s “in the right”. My OH is the same and now I just laugh it off. Seems childish to argue who’s right and who’s wrong.

HettyTagliatelli · 09/10/2026 08:25

DrWhosJazzyScarf · 09/10/2026 08:04

All good points, thanks for sharing.

Just to clarify - it’s not ice cream every day, just a Friday treat as she’s exhausted by this point.

Perhaps I’m conflating two almost separate issues - ice cream as a reward, and the fact that I have a real dislike for how DH speaks to me in disagreements.

Of course it’s not an ice cream every day, but presumably you will want her to wear a coat every day as we’re coming into winter, which is why is a bad idea to link the two things.

CaptainCalm · 09/10/2026 08:26

@DrWhosJazzyScarf

We had our own very similar argument this morning, over something totally daft which escalated into ‘I’m going to sit in the car and wait there if you all can’t be nice to me’. Everyone here is just tired and grumpy today.

So lots of sympathy and hopefully it’s just a minor thing that blows over.

dreamingofgoodhair · 09/10/2026 08:26

DrWhosJazzyScarf · 09/10/2026 08:06

I can understand this. He’s actually called on me to dress her at this point as she was being tricky, which was why I suggested ice cream. I see how this has backfired now.

That’s wrong of him. He’s taking her , he needs to get her ready. What if you were not there ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread