Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really worry about the future of homeschooled children?

614 replies

AgeingMillennial · 02/10/2026 20:06

Please don’t think this is a goady thread designed to rile the masses about home education. I’m very much not referring to children with SEN whose parents are homeschooling because they’re desperate, or ‘serious’ homeschoolers who do an incredible job and produce very well educated kids by following a dedicated programme. I follow several such families on social media and their energy and commitment is way beyond anything I could do.

However I’m noticing a huge uptick in people ‘deregistering’ their kids to promote a kind of off-grid, traditional lifestyle on social media. Not because the child is struggling or unhappy at school but ‘I want to spend more time with them’, ‘the government want to create tax paying robots’, ‘I don’t want the state to raise my kids with transgender ideology’ etc.

The problem is the ‘homeschooling’ is then very substandard and then consists mostly of nature walks, crafts and visits to National Trust properties. All very wholesome but the sort of things most families do at weekends anyway. They might do a couple of pages of the sort of workbooks you find in WH Smith, but that’s it. Where there are siblings they all do the same basic things, none of it tailored to be specific to their age.

AIBU to worry about the future of these kids and to cynically wonder if it’s a ‘social media stream’ in many cases?

OP posts:
Constantrunner · 23/10/2026 09:29

Scamworried · 23/10/2026 08:39

In relation to the drunk parents. If that is accurate can you not realize that the problem here is social services.

The school flagged an issue but social services did not have concerns.
I can also flag concerns here but unless social services are robust and effective children will always fall through the cracks.

It doesn't make any difference to do additional checks Unless the services and processes actually work.

It's not bout defending every home educating parent it is about actual meaningful services and processes

Children like the ones bove won't be anymore protected by extra checks if those checks just don't do anything. Just like they didn't do anything when school raised concerns.

What extra check will do is cause further issues to families already failed by school system those with SEND.

Social services do not investigate education. Outcomes for children taken into care is poor. So if the child is physically safe, with food and clothes, SS are unlikely to do anything.
But they are being educationally neglected.

BestZebbie · 23/10/2026 09:55

AgeingMillennial · 22/10/2026 20:49

Everyone seems to live in fear of their child ending their lives, but to the extent where probably thousands of kids are being shielded in this way for every child that sadly has bad enough MH to do it.

Little kids have much less impulse control, big emotions, no real understanding of how horrific dying and/or near-death can be and much less perception of the future and either gradual improvement or permanent consequences - and they are fast, and they wake up early. If one tells you they are actively suicidal you have to take it seriously (and yes, it is possible to distinguish a brief dramatic strop and deep ongoing distress).

Just because you don't see many kids in KS1 actually dying from suicide doesn't mean they aren't actively suicidal - it just means that their parents are giving up their jobs to be with them 24/7, sleeping across the door of their bedroom on the inside, keeping all the household knives, chemicals and medications in the car, child-locking the back seats so they can't be opened on the move and no longer taking them anywhere near busy roads, physically restraining them when they try to self-harm (a child in an empty room can still hit/bite/scratch/ choke themselves and throw themselves against walls or floor), whilst also paying for therapy privately in order to access it without a waiting list in double figure months. Because young children are physically small and still under parental control the above has a better chance of working than with a large teenager.

Scamworried · 23/10/2026 10:35

herewegoagainonwednesday · 23/10/2026 09:07

Yes, social services are a problem. But now he’s completely off the radar. nobody will notice, nobody there for him to contact if he’s scared. Nobody. At school he would at least have adults to talk to, and keep flagging. Now, there is nobody. Nobody for him to talk to without his parents being present. He has no chance, and he’s only 8.

Yes but if they had done their job in the first place or if school had completed the deregister paperwork and flagged concerned and social services had done their job in the second place he would be under their services.

Have you reported your concerns to social services? If not - why not? If you have and social services haven't acted for the third time - this is a systemic issue and do you really think they would act on 5th, 6th,100th time ?
Either he isbt actually at risk and you are mistaken or he is t risk and being failed by system already in place to protect

Btw IF I believed a child was being neglected home Ed, at school or under school age I would report.

But experience has shown me that services rarely act on actual at risk children
But increasing workload and paperwork will give the illusion of doing something while simultaneously allowing actual at risk children to slip through the net.

Do we want an illusion or do we want children protected?

Scamworried · 23/10/2026 10:36

Constantrunner · 23/10/2026 09:29

Social services do not investigate education. Outcomes for children taken into care is poor. So if the child is physically safe, with food and clothes, SS are unlikely to do anything.
But they are being educationally neglected.

And the LA manage education. But in the case of drunk parents neglect outside of education should also be a concern

AgeingMillennial · 23/10/2026 10:37

Scamworried · 23/10/2026 10:35

Yes but if they had done their job in the first place or if school had completed the deregister paperwork and flagged concerned and social services had done their job in the second place he would be under their services.

Have you reported your concerns to social services? If not - why not? If you have and social services haven't acted for the third time - this is a systemic issue and do you really think they would act on 5th, 6th,100th time ?
Either he isbt actually at risk and you are mistaken or he is t risk and being failed by system already in place to protect

Btw IF I believed a child was being neglected home Ed, at school or under school age I would report.

But experience has shown me that services rarely act on actual at risk children
But increasing workload and paperwork will give the illusion of doing something while simultaneously allowing actual at risk children to slip through the net.

Do we want an illusion or do we want children protected?

What ‘job’ didn’t the school do?

OP posts:
Scamworried · 23/10/2026 10:40

AgeingMillennial · 23/10/2026 10:37

What ‘job’ didn’t the school do?

Sigh

When a child is deregistered the school must complete paperwork. On this paperwork they are to highlight any concerns they have in relation to education by parents and any concerns they have over wellbeing and safeguarding.

Either the school didn't bother to highlight these concerns or they did and then the LA didn't act or the LA did follow up BUT social services didn't have concerns

zingally · 23/10/2026 11:26

I agree. A cousin of mine has two kids, a daughter who should be in Year 5, and a son, who should be Year 1, who she is "home educating". That home education seems to primarily consist of "going to groups" with other home educating families, where they just seem to play in the woods and do crafts. And it's all ages, toddlers up to almost secondary age children.
The 10yo can read... ish. The 5yo (almost 6) has not a clue. The 10yo can do basic adding and subtraction, but doesn't know any times tables. They don't do anything like science, history, geography.
I don't have much to do with them day to day, but I do know that certainly both sets of grandparents are quite concerned.

PocketSand · 23/10/2026 15:31

My son’s school actively wanted me to deregister him so they could wash their hands of him. They even wrote to me claiming I had deregistered him. I refuted this and refused to do so and the LA had to fund home education via internet school and home tutors and therapists. This was only possible because he already had an EHCP and so received a bespoke package. His school had no idea how to cope with a highly intelligent child who was also autistic and had ADHD so they ignored cognitive ability and sat him at the back of the classroom and let him doodle so he didn’t disturb the rest of the class.

He achieved 11 GCSE’s grades 7-9 at internet school and then went to a brick 6th form college to study A level maths, further maths and physics (2 A stars and an A) and is now in third year of MEng at uni.

Are the stats capturing the reasons why DC are removed from school eg unmet need in relation to Send or bullying? Whether the push to deregister comes from schools or parents etc? Ime experience parents with undiagnosed DC without an EHCP dealing with the reality of reduced timetables and illegal exclusions are often forced to deregister to take the pressure off an intolerable situation.

I imagine that the number of competent HEs has stayed the same. It’s bloody hard work and suggests that one parent can afford not to be in paid employment. Is increased ‘HE’ (more accurately deregistration) an indication of the failure of schools and LAs (and treats of legal action) or an indication of the power of social media and poor parenting?

Fuckmyliferightnow · 25/10/2026 01:52

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 13:04

The LA read a written report that could be made up. And reading parts of some reports parents post in groups, is at least exaggeration.
I also know one parent who provided pre written reports to many many parents that they could use with some minor changes. It took the local authority a long time to catch on.
Many HE parents use templates provided in groups for reports and even if their child spends all their time gaming, manage to write a report that sounds as if their child is getting an actual education

This is wrong, I’ve not seen a template for a report as it’s so personal.
Templates exist for more formal letters.

NarnianQueen · 25/10/2026 07:58

To be fair I’d be more worried about the kids IN school…

throwaway3749574 · 25/10/2026 08:15

I do worry about kids today who aren’t in school but from a slightly different angle - the seemingly large number who can’t manage in the mainstream school environment but can’t get an EHCP, thinking of friends kids whose anxiety was too high to manage school, or another friend who’s daughter struggles with fatigue and so does online school. 2 of my own have found it hard - both with ASD - eldest has left school now and is at uni thriving, she struggled a lot socially but got through it as she’s very academic and loved the learning side. My younger one it’s not going well and she struggles with the environment, socially and academically. Home Ed is not an option really but I worry about what I’ll do if she becomes a school refuser which is a real possibility.

how will these kids manage when they’re older? How will they get on in a workplace?

Scamworried · 25/10/2026 08:58

throwaway3749574 · 25/10/2026 08:15

I do worry about kids today who aren’t in school but from a slightly different angle - the seemingly large number who can’t manage in the mainstream school environment but can’t get an EHCP, thinking of friends kids whose anxiety was too high to manage school, or another friend who’s daughter struggles with fatigue and so does online school. 2 of my own have found it hard - both with ASD - eldest has left school now and is at uni thriving, she struggled a lot socially but got through it as she’s very academic and loved the learning side. My younger one it’s not going well and she struggles with the environment, socially and academically. Home Ed is not an option really but I worry about what I’ll do if she becomes a school refuser which is a real possibility.

how will these kids manage when they’re older? How will they get on in a workplace?

I think if you look at autistic adults a lot are working despite struggling or unable to attend school.
From my generation I definitely attended school with peers who struggled to attend and had low attendance but this was prior to fines and some would end up leaving school early to work. Every one of them worked as adults some in high level careers

In our case school has no benefits for our child and causes them a lot of damage.
Home Ed has allowed them to start recovering. As well as autism they have SEN but they have found things they are good at since home educating. I don't know what their work future will look like but it feels far more possible now than previously.

The difficulty of getting EHCPs is a big concern and with the plans to remove this further along with the increased attendance pressures - I am concerned what will happen to SEN and disabled young people in education.

I hope things improve for your youngest.

Hatepancakes · 04/11/2026 15:10

Most parents are capable of delivering primary education, but my concern is what happens when children are secondary school age. Either parents pay huge amounts for tutors or the child fails to be educated in many curriculum subjects. Most jobs ask for passes in GCSE maths and English. Are parents who home school capable of delivering this?

Scamworried · 11/11/2026 11:52

Those who don't understand why home Ed is needed. Watch this video

This new short is very accurate snap shot to our experience but it is only a snapshot of some of the challenges we faced. Actually, living it is far far worse than even this video can show.

Without having the option to home Ed I can not bear to think where we would have ended up but running into traffic was a definite risk we faced daily.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page