Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really worry about the future of homeschooled children?

614 replies

AgeingMillennial · 02/10/2026 20:06

Please don’t think this is a goady thread designed to rile the masses about home education. I’m very much not referring to children with SEN whose parents are homeschooling because they’re desperate, or ‘serious’ homeschoolers who do an incredible job and produce very well educated kids by following a dedicated programme. I follow several such families on social media and their energy and commitment is way beyond anything I could do.

However I’m noticing a huge uptick in people ‘deregistering’ their kids to promote a kind of off-grid, traditional lifestyle on social media. Not because the child is struggling or unhappy at school but ‘I want to spend more time with them’, ‘the government want to create tax paying robots’, ‘I don’t want the state to raise my kids with transgender ideology’ etc.

The problem is the ‘homeschooling’ is then very substandard and then consists mostly of nature walks, crafts and visits to National Trust properties. All very wholesome but the sort of things most families do at weekends anyway. They might do a couple of pages of the sort of workbooks you find in WH Smith, but that’s it. Where there are siblings they all do the same basic things, none of it tailored to be specific to their age.

AIBU to worry about the future of these kids and to cynically wonder if it’s a ‘social media stream’ in many cases?

OP posts:
Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:34

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 17:10

Yes just like school reports. People can and do make up stuff in school...
Most people don't through. Schools however, are renowned for copy and paste on school reports.

Most people who are active in online he groups seem to at minimum exaggerate the education their children are recieving.
A school report is very different to a parent pretending their child is being educated when they are not.

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 17:37

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:34

Most people who are active in online he groups seem to at minimum exaggerate the education their children are recieving.
A school report is very different to a parent pretending their child is being educated when they are not.

How do you know?

roaringdragon · 21/10/2026 17:56

It is the LA rather than the school who is ultimately responsible for ensuring DC unable to attend school still receive a suitable full-time education.

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:57

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 17:37

How do you know?

Because they post things like,

Help I have to write a report but my DC spends all day sleeping and all night gaming what should I do?

Answer, I am sure they are not only gaming. Have they ever went to the shops with you? Well that's practising maths and social interaction. Have you ever watched a documentary together? Okay they watched one about the third reich, talk about how they study history and you use documentaries and discussion afterwards and use that documentary as an example. Have they ever done any cooking? Great they make microwave chips. Talk about how you cook together and they have leant about temperature controls and food hygiene.

And so on. Seem it so many times that it is embarrassing

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 18:18

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:32

@Scamworried that is not good enough.

However it does not detract from the reality that many he parents children are suffering educational neglect.

It's easy for people to judge when their children haven't suffered educational neglect while at school.

But when the LA has neglected your child education and damaged their wellbeing - you don't want that same authority negatively judging the home Ed provision you provide (which is 100 times more effective and educational then they provided).
Especially as if that authority decides on a back to school order (because it's easier to target us and be seen to be doing something) that will not only result in child education being less than at home but also be extremely damaging to their mental health and wellbeing

Unfortunately, some of us know just how useless and yet simultaneously problematic the LA can be.

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 18:21

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:34

Most people who are active in online he groups seem to at minimum exaggerate the education their children are recieving.
A school report is very different to a parent pretending their child is being educated when they are not.

A school report which states child a is excelling in maths but behind in sport when that child is actually unable to count at all but represents their county in sport is not only wrong it is extremely damaging and it is not at all acceptable

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 18:26

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:57

Because they post things like,

Help I have to write a report but my DC spends all day sleeping and all night gaming what should I do?

Answer, I am sure they are not only gaming. Have they ever went to the shops with you? Well that's practising maths and social interaction. Have you ever watched a documentary together? Okay they watched one about the third reich, talk about how they study history and you use documentaries and discussion afterwards and use that documentary as an example. Have they ever done any cooking? Great they make microwave chips. Talk about how you cook together and they have leant about temperature controls and food hygiene.

And so on. Seem it so many times that it is embarrassing

But you have absolutely no idea why that child is gaming.
That child could have had their well-being destroyed by school. They may be in recovery.

For sone children a back to school order could result in them becoming suicidal. Many people end up home educating to keep their child alive.

A dead child can not learn and exams results are absolutely irrelevant if they end up killing themselves.

Some people are so unaware.

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 18:31

Which brings us full circle to if schools and LA got it together and actually provided for SEN and disabled pupils far less would be home educating in the first place.

Those who opt to home Ed for other reasons. Are low in numbers and are providing great education.

Those children at risk in school or home Ed will be able to monitor easier IF services could focus on them rather than be diluted by having g to do additional oversight on every home Ed family.

If a fireman has to dampen every house in a town everyday they aren't available to go to the actual house that's on fire because they are too busy at the house not on fire.
A house with smoke streaming out of the windows needs attention bot the house with none

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 18:39

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:57

Because they post things like,

Help I have to write a report but my DC spends all day sleeping and all night gaming what should I do?

Answer, I am sure they are not only gaming. Have they ever went to the shops with you? Well that's practising maths and social interaction. Have you ever watched a documentary together? Okay they watched one about the third reich, talk about how they study history and you use documentaries and discussion afterwards and use that documentary as an example. Have they ever done any cooking? Great they make microwave chips. Talk about how you cook together and they have leant about temperature controls and food hygiene.

And so on. Seem it so many times that it is embarrassing

Of course.

I spent many years home adding and still hang around groups online - never once have seen anything like this.

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 18:41

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:32

@Scamworried that is not good enough.

However it does not detract from the reality that many he parents children are suffering educational neglect.

Many?

Do show the figures you’re relying on

However, perhaps you’d like to focus your attention on the schools abx LAs who are wilfully neglecting children’s education first…..and the deaths of children that have arisen due to that willful neglect. Quite a few were mentioned in parliament recently

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 18:44

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 18:26

But you have absolutely no idea why that child is gaming.
That child could have had their well-being destroyed by school. They may be in recovery.

For sone children a back to school order could result in them becoming suicidal. Many people end up home educating to keep their child alive.

A dead child can not learn and exams results are absolutely irrelevant if they end up killing themselves.

Some people are so unaware.

Incredibly unaware.

must be nice to be so unaware of the reality for many SEN children and families.

ItsNotLoveActually · 22/10/2026 17:54

I'm sure some of you remember home schooling during Covid. And you remember how tough it was at the start. We were all clueless. My DC got away with a lot at first, watching the schools downloaded material but split screening and playing video games. I caught on and set to work. At first it was incredibly hard, following a curriculum when you're not an experienced teacher. But, together we got the hang of it, had a laugh, learning together sometimes. I missed it when life went back to normal. However, schooling is much more than education, it's about social interaction, accepting institutionalism, discipline, heiracty, which I think home schoolers must lack.

FedUpCelery · 22/10/2026 18:16

ItsNotLoveActually · 22/10/2026 17:54

I'm sure some of you remember home schooling during Covid. And you remember how tough it was at the start. We were all clueless. My DC got away with a lot at first, watching the schools downloaded material but split screening and playing video games. I caught on and set to work. At first it was incredibly hard, following a curriculum when you're not an experienced teacher. But, together we got the hang of it, had a laugh, learning together sometimes. I missed it when life went back to normal. However, schooling is much more than education, it's about social interaction, accepting institutionalism, discipline, heiracty, which I think home schoolers must lack.

Home educating is not like having work set by a school during COVID.

It was a hideous time when our groups were cancelled. They weren't allowed to see their friends. They couldn't go to their usual classes, workshops, sports, social meetups etc.

I remember when they said we could meet up for academic reasons only and risk assessments were written and laminated, lesson plans written, windows kept open etc. Things were put in place the minute we were able.

Fiftyandme · 22/10/2026 18:18

ItsNotLoveActually · 22/10/2026 17:54

I'm sure some of you remember home schooling during Covid. And you remember how tough it was at the start. We were all clueless. My DC got away with a lot at first, watching the schools downloaded material but split screening and playing video games. I caught on and set to work. At first it was incredibly hard, following a curriculum when you're not an experienced teacher. But, together we got the hang of it, had a laugh, learning together sometimes. I missed it when life went back to normal. However, schooling is much more than education, it's about social interaction, accepting institutionalism, discipline, heiracty, which I think home schoolers must lack.

Here we go again with the ‘unsocialised feral kids’ trope

ItsNotLoveActually · 22/10/2026 19:51

@Fiftyandme - you sure? Whatever camp you're in - check yourself, ok

Fiftyandme · 22/10/2026 20:04

ItsNotLoveActually · 22/10/2026 19:51

@Fiftyandme - you sure? Whatever camp you're in - check yourself, ok

Check myself?

Goodness.

If I’ve misunderstood your last sentence in your previous post then please, do elaborate.

Newsenmum · 22/10/2026 20:05

AgeingMillennial · 20/10/2026 12:55

’Home Education’ isn’t a monolith with everyone following the same framework.

Just look at ‘the unconventional parent’ (as they call themselves). Son is now a full time gamer with no social life, high anxiety etc all through ‘child lead unschooling’.

Is this an article?

AgeingMillennial · 22/10/2026 20:47

Newsenmum · 22/10/2026 20:05

Is this an article?

No, that’s the name of the social media account.

OP posts:
AgeingMillennial · 22/10/2026 20:49

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 18:26

But you have absolutely no idea why that child is gaming.
That child could have had their well-being destroyed by school. They may be in recovery.

For sone children a back to school order could result in them becoming suicidal. Many people end up home educating to keep their child alive.

A dead child can not learn and exams results are absolutely irrelevant if they end up killing themselves.

Some people are so unaware.

Everyone seems to live in fear of their child ending their lives, but to the extent where probably thousands of kids are being shielded in this way for every child that sadly has bad enough MH to do it.

OP posts:
Constantrunner · 22/10/2026 21:22

And a child gaming all night is stuck in unhealthy patterns that would damage anyone's mental health.

herewegoagainonwednesday · 23/10/2026 08:30

We know several home educating families. Most of them are great - either home educating to allow a lifestyle with frequent travel, or engaged and informed home educating due to SENDs ( which they shouldn’t have to, but most schools are awful for SENDs children). No concerns about these. Yes, some of the, likely won’t get a full set of gcses, but they wouldn’t get them in school either, even a very good school. Kids are in plenty of hobbies groups, socialized etc.
However, for two i have a lot of concerns. One child has alcoholic parents with mental health challenges who didn’t like school sending social services after they came drunk to collect. Social services had a phone call with the parents and then said all ok, child went to two different schools in 6 months and is now home educated. Social services not interested, kids sees other children only when the local cheap holiday club is on ( about 6 weeks per year).
Another set didn’t like the school run (which is admittedly a pain, we are rural), so child is now home “educated”. Parents don’t see much point in education, so I can’t see this going well. Not even paying for a holiday club, so no social contacts (we are rural, you can’t just play with the neighbours child).
Both kids are on youtube and roblox most of the day (both primary school age).
the home education community is not doing themselves any favours by defending all home educating parents.
Yes, there are (many) crap schools, but at least the children have access to other adults….

Constantrunner · 23/10/2026 08:38

Yes I have known mums decide to home educated because they found getting the kids up early, and getting them to school on time too difficult. Their kids were often late. I do question how good a home education will be if getting your kids to school on time is too difficult to achieve.

But the worst cases I come across is where mum is home educating, but is also ill and spends days in bed. One woman in particular I knew who obviously struggled with simply having suitable food in and keeping the house going due to illness. She was a single mum and her child only attended clubs if another parent gave them a lift. Her child was old enough to make simple meals, otherwise they would have not had any meals most days.

I took have known brilliant home education. So I am not against home education. But it's a lie to say there is suitable over sight.

Scamworried · 23/10/2026 08:39

herewegoagainonwednesday · 23/10/2026 08:30

We know several home educating families. Most of them are great - either home educating to allow a lifestyle with frequent travel, or engaged and informed home educating due to SENDs ( which they shouldn’t have to, but most schools are awful for SENDs children). No concerns about these. Yes, some of the, likely won’t get a full set of gcses, but they wouldn’t get them in school either, even a very good school. Kids are in plenty of hobbies groups, socialized etc.
However, for two i have a lot of concerns. One child has alcoholic parents with mental health challenges who didn’t like school sending social services after they came drunk to collect. Social services had a phone call with the parents and then said all ok, child went to two different schools in 6 months and is now home educated. Social services not interested, kids sees other children only when the local cheap holiday club is on ( about 6 weeks per year).
Another set didn’t like the school run (which is admittedly a pain, we are rural), so child is now home “educated”. Parents don’t see much point in education, so I can’t see this going well. Not even paying for a holiday club, so no social contacts (we are rural, you can’t just play with the neighbours child).
Both kids are on youtube and roblox most of the day (both primary school age).
the home education community is not doing themselves any favours by defending all home educating parents.
Yes, there are (many) crap schools, but at least the children have access to other adults….

In relation to the drunk parents. If that is accurate can you not realize that the problem here is social services.

The school flagged an issue but social services did not have concerns.
I can also flag concerns here but unless social services are robust and effective children will always fall through the cracks.

It doesn't make any difference to do additional checks Unless the services and processes actually work.

It's not bout defending every home educating parent it is about actual meaningful services and processes

Children like the ones bove won't be anymore protected by extra checks if those checks just don't do anything. Just like they didn't do anything when school raised concerns.

What extra check will do is cause further issues to families already failed by school system those with SEND.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/10/2026 08:46

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:57

Because they post things like,

Help I have to write a report but my DC spends all day sleeping and all night gaming what should I do?

Answer, I am sure they are not only gaming. Have they ever went to the shops with you? Well that's practising maths and social interaction. Have you ever watched a documentary together? Okay they watched one about the third reich, talk about how they study history and you use documentaries and discussion afterwards and use that documentary as an example. Have they ever done any cooking? Great they make microwave chips. Talk about how you cook together and they have leant about temperature controls and food hygiene.

And so on. Seem it so many times that it is embarrassing

Exactly. Its genuinely frightening that people are convincing themselves that this is equivalent to an education.

If the LA was actually doing its job it would be impossible to pass this off as home education.

herewegoagainonwednesday · 23/10/2026 09:07

Scamworried · 23/10/2026 08:39

In relation to the drunk parents. If that is accurate can you not realize that the problem here is social services.

The school flagged an issue but social services did not have concerns.
I can also flag concerns here but unless social services are robust and effective children will always fall through the cracks.

It doesn't make any difference to do additional checks Unless the services and processes actually work.

It's not bout defending every home educating parent it is about actual meaningful services and processes

Children like the ones bove won't be anymore protected by extra checks if those checks just don't do anything. Just like they didn't do anything when school raised concerns.

What extra check will do is cause further issues to families already failed by school system those with SEND.

Yes, social services are a problem. But now he’s completely off the radar. nobody will notice, nobody there for him to contact if he’s scared. Nobody. At school he would at least have adults to talk to, and keep flagging. Now, there is nobody. Nobody for him to talk to without his parents being present. He has no chance, and he’s only 8.

Swipe left for the next trending thread