Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really worry about the future of homeschooled children?

614 replies

AgeingMillennial · 02/10/2026 20:06

Please don’t think this is a goady thread designed to rile the masses about home education. I’m very much not referring to children with SEN whose parents are homeschooling because they’re desperate, or ‘serious’ homeschoolers who do an incredible job and produce very well educated kids by following a dedicated programme. I follow several such families on social media and their energy and commitment is way beyond anything I could do.

However I’m noticing a huge uptick in people ‘deregistering’ their kids to promote a kind of off-grid, traditional lifestyle on social media. Not because the child is struggling or unhappy at school but ‘I want to spend more time with them’, ‘the government want to create tax paying robots’, ‘I don’t want the state to raise my kids with transgender ideology’ etc.

The problem is the ‘homeschooling’ is then very substandard and then consists mostly of nature walks, crafts and visits to National Trust properties. All very wholesome but the sort of things most families do at weekends anyway. They might do a couple of pages of the sort of workbooks you find in WH Smith, but that’s it. Where there are siblings they all do the same basic things, none of it tailored to be specific to their age.

AIBU to worry about the future of these kids and to cynically wonder if it’s a ‘social media stream’ in many cases?

OP posts:
Minasama · 15/10/2026 22:47

maggisimpson · 02/10/2026 21:49

If the system is designed so a significant minority of children won't get the bare minimum to get anywhere in life, why is there the concern that some home educated children won't get GCSEs?

Because clearly it’s a shame if a capable child loses out on a qualification because their parent decided to deprive them of that opportunity.

Scamworried · 15/10/2026 23:06

Minasama · 15/10/2026 22:47

Because clearly it’s a shame if a capable child loses out on a qualification because their parent decided to deprive them of that opportunity.

What is it when a capable child is failed by school system?
What is it when a child is destroyed by a school system that leaves them mentally unwell?
What is it when a school system leaves 30% classed as failures after 12 years of a system that hasn't worked for them?

Has it not occured to you that those who home educate will be a mix of those who gain qualifications via home ed and those who have been saved from the damage from school who wouldn't have gained anything from school and there more were saved from school damage

Scrambledomelette · 16/10/2026 08:42

The vast and increasing majority of home educated kids are those for whom school education failed to be accessible to them.

Among those children are those who could have muscled along in the system only to be jettisoned out of it without even a passing grade in English and Maths - about 30% of pupils. And they will have only been saved from a crushing sense of failure. Which seems like a fair choice.

And there will also be children who will have been hauled out and find a liferaft back to learning.

Scamworried · 16/10/2026 09:37

Scrambledomelette · 16/10/2026 08:42

The vast and increasing majority of home educated kids are those for whom school education failed to be accessible to them.

Among those children are those who could have muscled along in the system only to be jettisoned out of it without even a passing grade in English and Maths - about 30% of pupils. And they will have only been saved from a crushing sense of failure. Which seems like a fair choice.

And there will also be children who will have been hauled out and find a liferaft back to learning.

So well put and so absolutely right.

This is why it is so annoying when home ed is attacked. Home ed has literally been a life raft for some children.
People like OP like to give the impression that they care out the children but in reality they are quite happy for children to drown aslong as it's in school. Those children are dispensable when they are in the school system

They say it is t hour those children. Without realising that attacking the right to home ed will impact those children hardest of all. It's literally taking away a life raft so only the strongest float

CarbootJunction · 16/10/2026 16:11

Maybe it should be illegal to home-school your kids unless you are a qualified teacher?

FunPartyIdeas · 16/10/2026 16:21

@CarbootJunction Tbf you don't need to be qualified to teach these days. Unqualified teachers are a thing (unfortunately).

FedUpCelery · 16/10/2026 16:39

Scrambledomelette · 16/10/2026 08:42

The vast and increasing majority of home educated kids are those for whom school education failed to be accessible to them.

Among those children are those who could have muscled along in the system only to be jettisoned out of it without even a passing grade in English and Maths - about 30% of pupils. And they will have only been saved from a crushing sense of failure. Which seems like a fair choice.

And there will also be children who will have been hauled out and find a liferaft back to learning.

In my area it's closer to 50% of pupils. Some schools will have a miniscule failure rate (< grade 4) and others will have far more than their fair share of the lower end of the bell curve.

Does that mean kids in other parts of the country are brighter? Or that many kids in my town have the odds stacked against them?

Fuckmyliferightnow · 16/10/2026 23:55

Minasama · 15/10/2026 22:47

Because clearly it’s a shame if a capable child loses out on a qualification because their parent decided to deprive them of that opportunity.

Tell us you know nothing about Home education, without telling us you know nothing about Home Education.

Minasama · 17/10/2026 18:10

Fuckmyliferightnow · 16/10/2026 23:55

Tell us you know nothing about Home education, without telling us you know nothing about Home Education.

You assume every parent who does Home Ed does it well and responsibly. We know for a fact that is not the case. Of course there are families that do a great job and their children thrive. But there are more questionable ones and so it makes sense to have a good system of monitoring.

Scamworried · 17/10/2026 23:08

Minasama · 17/10/2026 18:10

You assume every parent who does Home Ed does it well and responsibly. We know for a fact that is not the case. Of course there are families that do a great job and their children thrive. But there are more questionable ones and so it makes sense to have a good system of monitoring.

And yet you assume that all schools can meet all children's needs yet we know for a fact that she me children are doing so failed by schools

Fuckmyliferightnow · 19/10/2026 20:48

Minasama · 17/10/2026 18:10

You assume every parent who does Home Ed does it well and responsibly. We know for a fact that is not the case. Of course there are families that do a great job and their children thrive. But there are more questionable ones and so it makes sense to have a good system of monitoring.

I could put money on the VAST majority of Home Ed parents doing a good job and doing their very best.
Every single Home Ed parent I know is fully engaged and they’ve sacrificed an awful lot.
People need to stop bashing Home Ed, especially when it doesn’t affect anyone else.

Persephonia1966 · 20/10/2026 12:52

Fuckmyliferightnow · 19/10/2026 20:48

I could put money on the VAST majority of Home Ed parents doing a good job and doing their very best.
Every single Home Ed parent I know is fully engaged and they’ve sacrificed an awful lot.
People need to stop bashing Home Ed, especially when it doesn’t affect anyone else.

It's likely that the ones you know are your friends/acquaintances because you share similar values though. Especially if you connected through home schooling activities. I also know people who home school because their children struggle in mainstream schools (educational needs) and it's basically a more than full time job for their mother to make lesson plans, follow the curriculum etc.

But there are also the "unschooling" home ed types or the ones who believe education should be fully parent led. Or the people who struggle to teach their children either because they aren't naturally skilled at it (I am not and know I am not) or because they don't have the required level of knowledge. And who hand wave away the fact their children are very behind their peers in terms of reading/writing/maths skills and likely wouldn't be able to slot into A-level courses at college or easily get into Universities because they don't have the foundation or qualifications. If you are around home schooling parents you will know those people exist. And there have been those people on the thread

I don't think parents home schooling their children and doing a good job is a problem. I do think it's a big problem that a minority are home schooling and doing a bad job. Frankly there should be better oversight and mechanisms for correcting that.

AgeingMillennial · 20/10/2026 12:55

’Home Education’ isn’t a monolith with everyone following the same framework.

Just look at ‘the unconventional parent’ (as they call themselves). Son is now a full time gamer with no social life, high anxiety etc all through ‘child lead unschooling’.

OP posts:
Scamworried · 20/10/2026 13:00

Persephonia1966 · 20/10/2026 12:52

It's likely that the ones you know are your friends/acquaintances because you share similar values though. Especially if you connected through home schooling activities. I also know people who home school because their children struggle in mainstream schools (educational needs) and it's basically a more than full time job for their mother to make lesson plans, follow the curriculum etc.

But there are also the "unschooling" home ed types or the ones who believe education should be fully parent led. Or the people who struggle to teach their children either because they aren't naturally skilled at it (I am not and know I am not) or because they don't have the required level of knowledge. And who hand wave away the fact their children are very behind their peers in terms of reading/writing/maths skills and likely wouldn't be able to slot into A-level courses at college or easily get into Universities because they don't have the foundation or qualifications. If you are around home schooling parents you will know those people exist. And there have been those people on the thread

I don't think parents home schooling their children and doing a good job is a problem. I do think it's a big problem that a minority are home schooling and doing a bad job. Frankly there should be better oversight and mechanisms for correcting that.

And the children in school who are being failed?

The schools have 'oversight' and yet children are still being failed within the system.
There are secondary children with SEN having an hour a day in the wellbeing centre to play chess and colour. This is considered by school and LA to be adequate education and parents are being robbed off when they complain.

Why with all the oversight schools have is unsuitable and inadequate education in schools not only happening but accepted?

Quite frankly as a parent who's child was failed so badly at schools with 'oversight' I do not welcome oversight by the same local authority who happily and knowingly failed my child in order to save money short term. Despite the fact it is well known that early support saves money long term.

Scamworried · 20/10/2026 13:05

AgeingMillennial · 20/10/2026 12:55

’Home Education’ isn’t a monolith with everyone following the same framework.

Just look at ‘the unconventional parent’ (as they call themselves). Son is now a full time gamer with no social life, high anxiety etc all through ‘child lead unschooling’.

You seem to mistakenly think that school would have magically resulted in a better result.
When in all likelihood school would have resulted in causing higher anxiety, suicidal tendencies and worse.

Is what you want ND young people to go to school so they can become suicidal and kill themselves thus removing them from adult life.

The likely outcome of forcing ND young people into our current education system is not going to end well.

Please do some research.

The benefits of home education is you do not have to follow the narrow limited curriculum. It means you can tailor the curriculum to met the child's needs and aims.

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/10/2026 13:28

@Scamworried

This is why it is so annoying when home ed is attacked. Home ed has literally been a life raft for some children.
People like OP like to give the impression that they care out the children but in reality they are quite happy for children to drown aslong as it's in school. Those children are dispensable when they are in the school system

The thing is you're correct that some children are utterly failed by the school system. But it doesn't automatically follow from this that home ed is a panacea to this. For many it is as you say a life raft. For some it's a fast road into being neglected or overlooked by parents who don't have the capability to home ed.

From my perspective the problem is not that home ed is universally bad: in many cases I think it's excellent, but the problem is that there is no adequate oversight which can distinguish the good from the bad.

It's not "attacking" home ed to point this out and I wish people could accept that we're not out to attack it. I don't think it's inconsistent that people feel a) that home ed can be the right choice for many children but b) that there is nowhere near adequate scrutiny of it.

Scamworried · 20/10/2026 13:55

But you mistakenly assume that school has adequate and effective oversight, but this is not the case. More and more children are being failed by the school system. The results of which are horrendous.

Prior to our experience I would have thought as you do.

The issue is while schools can not provide adequate and non damaging education for all there will always be people who have to be able to have an alternative like home education.

The oversight used by schools is not effective or adequate and so it stands to reason that heavily handed oversight into home education will result in mistakes happening.
The oversight stating that child A can remain home educated because the person checking makes that judgement but person B can not because of an opinion of one person is dangerous.

If a decision resulted in a child like mine being forced to return to a school system that had already failed them and caused so much damage - the outcome is going to be disastrous.

When the systems have already failed your child and the LA has shown they do not care about your child's education or wellbeing - we can not trust that oversight will be in the child's best interest at all and will cause untold damage.

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/10/2026 14:43

@Scamworried

The issue is while schools can not provide adequate and non damaging education for all there will always be people who have to be able to have an alternative like home education.
The oversight used by schools is not effective or adequate and so it stands to reason that heavily handed oversight into home education will result in mistakes happening.
The oversight stating that child A can remain home educated because the person checking makes that judgement but person B can not because of an opinion of one person is dangerous.

I'm sorry because it sounds like you've had a bad experience but I think this logic is flawed. Schools can indeed fail some children badly, I don't think there's any question about that. Our school system is far from perfect and in certain cases such as where there is ND or bullying it's entirely appropriate for them to be home educated. But the majority of children are not damaged by school and for the majority of children there is oversight and critically there is contact with children while they remain at school.

Some children who are home educated do much better than they would at school but some literally drift off the radar of the authorities and get a substandard or nonexistent education at all or worse are neglected or abused by parents. When children are in school there is at the very least a way to keep track of them. Children who get no education at home because their parents neglect them are being failed to a greater degree than children at a poorly performing school.

At present there is literally no way for the authorities to tell the difference between these two categories of children, particularly if parents refuse to cooperate with them. This is not a sustainable situation.

Fuckmyliferightnow · 20/10/2026 22:42

Persephonia1966 · 20/10/2026 12:52

It's likely that the ones you know are your friends/acquaintances because you share similar values though. Especially if you connected through home schooling activities. I also know people who home school because their children struggle in mainstream schools (educational needs) and it's basically a more than full time job for their mother to make lesson plans, follow the curriculum etc.

But there are also the "unschooling" home ed types or the ones who believe education should be fully parent led. Or the people who struggle to teach their children either because they aren't naturally skilled at it (I am not and know I am not) or because they don't have the required level of knowledge. And who hand wave away the fact their children are very behind their peers in terms of reading/writing/maths skills and likely wouldn't be able to slot into A-level courses at college or easily get into Universities because they don't have the foundation or qualifications. If you are around home schooling parents you will know those people exist. And there have been those people on the thread

I don't think parents home schooling their children and doing a good job is a problem. I do think it's a big problem that a minority are home schooling and doing a bad job. Frankly there should be better oversight and mechanisms for correcting that.

You’re correct in saying that it’s the minority, it will be a tiny fraction of Home Ed parents.
You seem to think it’s a much bigger problem, it isn’t.
Also it isn’t called Home Schooling, it’s Home Education, entirely different concepts.
Yes, some do Unschool but that’s their right and their business.
We also have to write progress reports to the LA and this has to demonstrate how the child has progressed and is learning Numeracy and Literacy, if they’re not satisfied then they’ll proceed with a School Attendance Order, so anyone not doing enough will ultimately end up back in school.
I really think you don’t know much about this and you’re making assumptions based on what you’ve heard.

Fuckmyliferightnow · 20/10/2026 22:47

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/10/2026 14:43

@Scamworried

The issue is while schools can not provide adequate and non damaging education for all there will always be people who have to be able to have an alternative like home education.
The oversight used by schools is not effective or adequate and so it stands to reason that heavily handed oversight into home education will result in mistakes happening.
The oversight stating that child A can remain home educated because the person checking makes that judgement but person B can not because of an opinion of one person is dangerous.

I'm sorry because it sounds like you've had a bad experience but I think this logic is flawed. Schools can indeed fail some children badly, I don't think there's any question about that. Our school system is far from perfect and in certain cases such as where there is ND or bullying it's entirely appropriate for them to be home educated. But the majority of children are not damaged by school and for the majority of children there is oversight and critically there is contact with children while they remain at school.

Some children who are home educated do much better than they would at school but some literally drift off the radar of the authorities and get a substandard or nonexistent education at all or worse are neglected or abused by parents. When children are in school there is at the very least a way to keep track of them. Children who get no education at home because their parents neglect them are being failed to a greater degree than children at a poorly performing school.

At present there is literally no way for the authorities to tell the difference between these two categories of children, particularly if parents refuse to cooperate with them. This is not a sustainable situation.

Home Educators don’t tend to be abusers, but abusers do remove their children from school and hide behind Home Education. These are the only kind of stories that get reported in the news, creating a negative narrative around Home Education.

Persephonia1966 · 20/10/2026 23:44

Fuckmyliferightnow · 20/10/2026 22:42

You’re correct in saying that it’s the minority, it will be a tiny fraction of Home Ed parents.
You seem to think it’s a much bigger problem, it isn’t.
Also it isn’t called Home Schooling, it’s Home Education, entirely different concepts.
Yes, some do Unschool but that’s their right and their business.
We also have to write progress reports to the LA and this has to demonstrate how the child has progressed and is learning Numeracy and Literacy, if they’re not satisfied then they’ll proceed with a School Attendance Order, so anyone not doing enough will ultimately end up back in school.
I really think you don’t know much about this and you’re making assumptions based on what you’ve heard.

I disagree it's a parents right to unschool and their business. All children have the right to an education. Parents should have a choice over the type of education etc they know their child best. But unschooling is not providing an education. It's denying a child of their right to an education. That's completely different to a parent taking their struggling child out of school and actively educating them (teaching them to read, write, do maths, science etc)

A parent should within limits be able to choose what is best for their children. But not when that leads to the child being deprived of their basic rights.

Scamworried · 20/10/2026 23:53

Persephonia1966 · 20/10/2026 23:44

I disagree it's a parents right to unschool and their business. All children have the right to an education. Parents should have a choice over the type of education etc they know their child best. But unschooling is not providing an education. It's denying a child of their right to an education. That's completely different to a parent taking their struggling child out of school and actively educating them (teaching them to read, write, do maths, science etc)

A parent should within limits be able to choose what is best for their children. But not when that leads to the child being deprived of their basic rights.

Unschooling isn't what you think it is.

Unschooling means not following traditional school methods.
It means not rushing the child to do things to a set timetable.

In school a child who takes longer to read is seen as behind. With unschooling they may not read as soon as children in school would be expected to but still do learn to read.
For some children to act of pushing reading (school like approach) before they are ready can cause a lifelong hatred for reading.

My child for example. Loved books and stories until school started on the reading scheme and the pressure to read. They can read beautifully now - but the school really caused them to believe reading is bad and that they aren't good at it. The things they read are all linked to their interests but story books are still a barrier.

I have seen unschooling in action and it can be amazing.
People do mistakenly think it means doing nothing but it doesn't.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/10/2026 08:32

Fuckmyliferightnow · 20/10/2026 22:47

Home Educators don’t tend to be abusers, but abusers do remove their children from school and hide behind Home Education. These are the only kind of stories that get reported in the news, creating a negative narrative around Home Education.

Yes but again the issue is not that everyone thinks home educators are all neglectful or abusive. I am fully aware most aren’t.

The point is that beyond the point where a child is deregistered from school there is no way to tell who is and who isn’t. There’s no proper oversight.

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 08:47

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/10/2026 14:43

@Scamworried

The issue is while schools can not provide adequate and non damaging education for all there will always be people who have to be able to have an alternative like home education.
The oversight used by schools is not effective or adequate and so it stands to reason that heavily handed oversight into home education will result in mistakes happening.
The oversight stating that child A can remain home educated because the person checking makes that judgement but person B can not because of an opinion of one person is dangerous.

I'm sorry because it sounds like you've had a bad experience but I think this logic is flawed. Schools can indeed fail some children badly, I don't think there's any question about that. Our school system is far from perfect and in certain cases such as where there is ND or bullying it's entirely appropriate for them to be home educated. But the majority of children are not damaged by school and for the majority of children there is oversight and critically there is contact with children while they remain at school.

Some children who are home educated do much better than they would at school but some literally drift off the radar of the authorities and get a substandard or nonexistent education at all or worse are neglected or abused by parents. When children are in school there is at the very least a way to keep track of them. Children who get no education at home because their parents neglect them are being failed to a greater degree than children at a poorly performing school.

At present there is literally no way for the authorities to tell the difference between these two categories of children, particularly if parents refuse to cooperate with them. This is not a sustainable situation.

Not all schools are bad for all children just like home Ed isn't bad for all children.

Yet, why do people only care about children possibly not having an education at home but those failed by a school with oversight are expendable.

Im sorry but children being failed in school is an absolute tragedy that is totally avoidable if the school and LA provides what they are legally responsible to provide.
When they do not provide this, despite it being illegal there is no easy way for families to challenge. Parents are blamed, gaslighted and exhausted by fighting a system that is not held to accountability. The only legal resource is tribunal which takes time (during which the child doesn't receive an education or their well-being is continued to be bashed. The LA play all manor or tricks to delay and avoid support. Even after the exhausting tribunal. School and LA continue to play games and fail the pupil.

Their is no accountability. The LA can lose a tribunal over and over gain. They can be taken back for failure to implement over and over again. Nothing happens to the school or LA.
Meanwhile the child and the family are living in hell that people do not understand.
The government are currently trying to bring in laws to remove the few rights SEN /Disabled children need. Why? Because the say the LA don't need any laws despite proof that they fail pupils over and over again.

So it may only be 5% or 2% of school pupils being failed. BUT they count too.

Why is the possible 1% of home Ed children not getting an education more important than the larger number being failed by schools?

And even more importantly, those failed by schools will be the same children most impacted by intrusive home Ed oversight. They would be failed yet again at a time when they are in recovery from the school failures.

Those children really at risk will continue to slip through the net because it is easier to target low hanging fruit than target the real at risk. The LA will be seen to be doing something but it's all smoke and mirrors.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/10/2026 09:22

@Scamworried

Yet, why do people only care about children possibly not having an education at home but those failed by a school with oversight are expendable.

Because for all the multitude of faults of school, children in school do not completely drop off the radar and become totally invisible to the educational authorities, social services etc.