Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really worry about the future of homeschooled children?

614 replies

AgeingMillennial · 02/10/2026 20:06

Please don’t think this is a goady thread designed to rile the masses about home education. I’m very much not referring to children with SEN whose parents are homeschooling because they’re desperate, or ‘serious’ homeschoolers who do an incredible job and produce very well educated kids by following a dedicated programme. I follow several such families on social media and their energy and commitment is way beyond anything I could do.

However I’m noticing a huge uptick in people ‘deregistering’ their kids to promote a kind of off-grid, traditional lifestyle on social media. Not because the child is struggling or unhappy at school but ‘I want to spend more time with them’, ‘the government want to create tax paying robots’, ‘I don’t want the state to raise my kids with transgender ideology’ etc.

The problem is the ‘homeschooling’ is then very substandard and then consists mostly of nature walks, crafts and visits to National Trust properties. All very wholesome but the sort of things most families do at weekends anyway. They might do a couple of pages of the sort of workbooks you find in WH Smith, but that’s it. Where there are siblings they all do the same basic things, none of it tailored to be specific to their age.

AIBU to worry about the future of these kids and to cynically wonder if it’s a ‘social media stream’ in many cases?

OP posts:
Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 09:25

YABU - those ‘nature walks’ are often prepped for with some science, maths, geography, history, environmental studies, PSGE etc, then built upon during the walk and then followed up as part of a project. It’s not just a bloody nature walk. ,

Fuckmyliferightnow · 21/10/2026 09:59

Persephonia1966 · 20/10/2026 23:44

I disagree it's a parents right to unschool and their business. All children have the right to an education. Parents should have a choice over the type of education etc they know their child best. But unschooling is not providing an education. It's denying a child of their right to an education. That's completely different to a parent taking their struggling child out of school and actively educating them (teaching them to read, write, do maths, science etc)

A parent should within limits be able to choose what is best for their children. But not when that leads to the child being deprived of their basic rights.

Again, if the LA aren’t satisfied that a child is being educated then they force that child into school.
Unschooled children DO receive an education, just not in the way that you know as normal. For example, sitting in a classroom staring at a board and listening to someone talk at them, some children don’t learn in this environment.
Have you taken the time to actually read and look into this, as you’re so concerned for these children.

Fuckmyliferightnow · 21/10/2026 10:04

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/10/2026 08:32

Yes but again the issue is not that everyone thinks home educators are all neglectful or abusive. I am fully aware most aren’t.

The point is that beyond the point where a child is deregistered from school there is no way to tell who is and who isn’t. There’s no proper oversight.

There is oversight, regular reporting, GPs and any healthcare provider also report to the LA when they see a Home Education child. The laws are also changing and families will be looked into more, stricter rules are being put into place.
By the way, Home Education is the default, schools are a choice that we sign up for.

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 10:38

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 09:25

YABU - those ‘nature walks’ are often prepped for with some science, maths, geography, history, environmental studies, PSGE etc, then built upon during the walk and then followed up as part of a project. It’s not just a bloody nature walk. ,

Follow up is good if it happens.
I have read accounts of how learning is incorporated into those nature walks and it is usually very basic. The kind of thing good parents with kids at school do at weekends anyway. If you talk to your kids this happens on top of their learning at school.

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 10:40

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/10/2026 09:22

@Scamworried

Yet, why do people only care about children possibly not having an education at home but those failed by a school with oversight are expendable.

Because for all the multitude of faults of school, children in school do not completely drop off the radar and become totally invisible to the educational authorities, social services etc.

Tell that to the families in crisis - who can't get a single iota of support

It's no good having them on the radar if it means their needs are ignored

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 10:45

Gps do NOT report to the la every time they see a HE child. That would be a ridiculous requirement.
The legislation to push a child back into school is pretty weak. Some la do push it to it's absolute edge and do issue school attendance orders. Many don't.
S9 last year 38 local authorities issued no school attendance orders. My local authority is one of these and the oversight is incredibly weak. Most school attendance orders were issued by a handful of local authorities

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 11:52

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 10:45

Gps do NOT report to the la every time they see a HE child. That would be a ridiculous requirement.
The legislation to push a child back into school is pretty weak. Some la do push it to it's absolute edge and do issue school attendance orders. Many don't.
S9 last year 38 local authorities issued no school attendance orders. My local authority is one of these and the oversight is incredibly weak. Most school attendance orders were issued by a handful of local authorities

GPs can and do report if they have any concerns. When concerns exist they act

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 11:56

Yes GPs report any concerns about abuse as do many professionals. Their job is not to assess educational input. But they will report injuries suggesting physical abuse.

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 12:28

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 11:56

Yes GPs report any concerns about abuse as do many professionals. Their job is not to assess educational input. But they will report injuries suggesting physical abuse.

And the LA assess the education provided

Already safeguards in place.

You may not think they are robust enough but I don't think the school system checks and safety measures are robust enough

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 13:04

The LA read a written report that could be made up. And reading parts of some reports parents post in groups, is at least exaggeration.
I also know one parent who provided pre written reports to many many parents that they could use with some minor changes. It took the local authority a long time to catch on.
Many HE parents use templates provided in groups for reports and even if their child spends all their time gaming, manage to write a report that sounds as if their child is getting an actual education

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 13:04

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 10:40

Tell that to the families in crisis - who can't get a single iota of support

It's no good having them on the radar if it means their needs are ignored

This

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 13:05

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 13:04

The LA read a written report that could be made up. And reading parts of some reports parents post in groups, is at least exaggeration.
I also know one parent who provided pre written reports to many many parents that they could use with some minor changes. It took the local authority a long time to catch on.
Many HE parents use templates provided in groups for reports and even if their child spends all their time gaming, manage to write a report that sounds as if their child is getting an actual education

Out of curiosity, what do you consider an ‘actual education’?

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 13:11

An actual education should cover a range of skills such as literacy and critical thinking, as well as covering at minimum the main subjects of literature, science, maths, history, geography and equipping pupils with necessary educational qualifications

Gooseinthewood · 21/10/2026 13:16

Id be really interested to know the stats around in gainful employment in adulthood in the population withdrawn from school because " it can't meet their needs"

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 14:09

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 13:11

An actual education should cover a range of skills such as literacy and critical thinking, as well as covering at minimum the main subjects of literature, science, maths, history, geography and equipping pupils with necessary educational qualifications

Tell that to the Local Authorities who claim that 5 hours per week of tutoring is an ‘actual education’

As for critical thinking skills? I’ve yet to come across a school that teaches that.

Dutch1e · 21/10/2026 14:59

Gooseinthewood · 21/10/2026 13:16

Id be really interested to know the stats around in gainful employment in adulthood in the population withdrawn from school because " it can't meet their needs"

So would I, and I was both home educated and home educate one of my children.

Unfortunately the data is scant, and what little there is tends to be provided by self-selecting participants so basically meaningless.

No-one (pro-, anti-, or neutral on homeschooling) can offer any insight on that question. We simply have no idea.

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 15:20

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 14:09

Tell that to the Local Authorities who claim that 5 hours per week of tutoring is an ‘actual education’

As for critical thinking skills? I’ve yet to come across a school that teaches that.

Don't the tutors give work for the children to complete outside those five hours?

Schools do teach critical thinking e.g. in history lessons. But it is rarely as thorough as it should ideally be.
I actually support HE and think it can work well. I have just seen so few examples of this happening and lots of terrible examples. At the worst kids game all day and their mum writes a report pretending they have learnt lots from this without saying they just game all day.

roaringdragon · 21/10/2026 15:37

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 15:20

Don't the tutors give work for the children to complete outside those five hours?

Schools do teach critical thinking e.g. in history lessons. But it is rarely as thorough as it should ideally be.
I actually support HE and think it can work well. I have just seen so few examples of this happening and lots of terrible examples. At the worst kids game all day and their mum writes a report pretending they have learnt lots from this without saying they just game all day.

No, most don’t give homework or other work to be completed independently.

Even if they did (and the child could access it, independent work isn’t suitable for many who have s19 provision), it wouldn’t relieve the LA of their duty to ensure a suitable full-time education is provided to those unable to attend school. Work sent home or given to the child, doesn’t fulfil that.

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 15:46

I didn't know they didn't give independent work. I can see why they can't find 1 to 1 for children for 30 hours a week, it would be very expensive.

roaringdragon · 21/10/2026 15:54

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 15:46

I didn't know they didn't give independent work. I can see why they can't find 1 to 1 for children for 30 hours a week, it would be very expensive.

It wouldn’t be 30 hours under section 19 of the Education Act 1996. The LA has a duty to ensure CSA pupils who are unable to attend school still receive a suitable full-time education. For this purpose, full time isn’t defined in law. The LGO judges it to be 22-25 hours depending on age. Although 1:1 can be fewer hours as more intense. But 5hrs is nowhere near enough, 1:1 or not. Sadly, too often LAs try to get away with providing nothing/very little unless parents enforce provision. They also try to limit provision to core subjects only. That is also unlawful. The LA cannot use funding as an excuse for breach of the s19 duty.

More hours are possible with EOTAS/EOTIS/C packages via EHCPs under section 61 of the Children and Families Act 2014. I have 2 DSs who have EOTAS/EOTIS packages. Both have more than 30hrs per week. Although not all tutoring. EOTAS/EOTIS/C packages are based on the provision in F of EHCPs to meet the needs in B of EHCPs, not costs.

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 16:24

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 15:46

I didn't know they didn't give independent work. I can see why they can't find 1 to 1 for children for 30 hours a week, it would be very expensive.

And yet they are still legally required to provide a full education - and they do not.

Id wager they provide far less of one than your average home edders

Fiftyandme · 21/10/2026 16:26

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 15:20

Don't the tutors give work for the children to complete outside those five hours?

Schools do teach critical thinking e.g. in history lessons. But it is rarely as thorough as it should ideally be.
I actually support HE and think it can work well. I have just seen so few examples of this happening and lots of terrible examples. At the worst kids game all day and their mum writes a report pretending they have learnt lots from this without saying they just game all day.

Nope, they do not.

Is it legal? Nope.

Do LAs give a shit? Nope.

Why? Because a slap on the wrist from the ombudsman costs them far far far less than actually fulfilling their legal duty.

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 17:10

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 13:04

The LA read a written report that could be made up. And reading parts of some reports parents post in groups, is at least exaggeration.
I also know one parent who provided pre written reports to many many parents that they could use with some minor changes. It took the local authority a long time to catch on.
Many HE parents use templates provided in groups for reports and even if their child spends all their time gaming, manage to write a report that sounds as if their child is getting an actual education

Yes just like school reports. People can and do make up stuff in school...
Most people don't through. Schools however, are renowned for copy and paste on school reports.

Scamworried · 21/10/2026 17:15

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 15:20

Don't the tutors give work for the children to complete outside those five hours?

Schools do teach critical thinking e.g. in history lessons. But it is rarely as thorough as it should ideally be.
I actually support HE and think it can work well. I have just seen so few examples of this happening and lots of terrible examples. At the worst kids game all day and their mum writes a report pretending they have learnt lots from this without saying they just game all day.

Lol most people getting tutor via school are unlikely to get 5 hours of tuition never mind work to do in-between.
We were offered 20 minutes a week in school building which they could access and told to look online to find stuff ourselves.

Do you really think those home educating could do any worse than that?

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:32

@Scamworried that is not good enough.

However it does not detract from the reality that many he parents children are suffering educational neglect.