Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parents should lose benefits /homes for persistently antisocial children?

317 replies

Soddingcat · 02/09/2026 06:31

This has been suggested, im not sure if it will happen , but i think this is a great idea, if the parents think they will lose their council house and benefits , they may attempt to to control their feral offspring .

My friend is in a local harriers group that starts at a local sports centre in the rough part of town, they are now having to stop their favourite route because of gangs of young teens who intimidate them , run along side them and are abusive, one delightful boy said “ lift your legs higher you c**t ,

How have we come to this ?
Do you think it will make any difference ?

I would remove child benefit from them too , maybe this will force them to parent if they risk losing money or their home

Obviously not all the parents are bad, but virtually all the awful kids round here riding motor bikes with hoods, abusing people are from the council estates near by

Im absolutely sick of it, and sick of decent people being targeted by them

What rules /sanctions would wise mumsnetters suggest ?

OP posts:
Sparklybutter · 02/09/2026 22:55

I think if you get done for antisocial behaviour then you get one warning. After that, you’re automatically taken out of school / taken off benefits and conscripted into national service until you’re 25.

As for the parents..probably a lost cause by now so let’s focus on the children. Doesn’t matter what your socio economic background is.

XenoBitch · 02/09/2026 22:57

Sparklybutter · 02/09/2026 22:55

I think if you get done for antisocial behaviour then you get one warning. After that, you’re automatically taken out of school / taken off benefits and conscripted into national service until you’re 25.

As for the parents..probably a lost cause by now so let’s focus on the children. Doesn’t matter what your socio economic background is.

What benefits would a school age child be on?

Sparklybutter · 02/09/2026 22:58

None , but it’s not just antisocial school children there are antisocial 18 year olds out of work. The army would sort them out.

JohnofWessex · 02/09/2026 23:06

Sparklybutter · 02/09/2026 22:58

None , but it’s not just antisocial school children there are antisocial 18 year olds out of work. The army would sort them out.

Poor Army

Its a fighting force not a social service and has plenty of issues already caused by recruiting very disadvantaged young people which this will simply make worse

seahorsessky · 02/09/2026 23:07

LarryForPrimeMinister · 02/09/2026 06:40

It won't happen but I think if they did do it, parents would just cry and plead its against their human rights putting them in poverty. What they should do is start parenting courses before people actually have these children.

The courses are offered, but most don't take them, and we can't stop people getting pregnant or remove the baby at birth (well, I know they used to with unmarried mums, but they wouldn't now).
Even when existing parents are referred on to parenting courses by SS, a lot of them just do it as a tick box exercise, not taking it seriously.
And there are some good parents who do their best, but if the kid falls in with a bad crowd at school/on the estate, it can be really difficult to fight that. Some really try, but the kid sneaks out.

CaptainMyCaptain · 02/09/2026 23:08

Sparklybutter · 02/09/2026 22:55

I think if you get done for antisocial behaviour then you get one warning. After that, you’re automatically taken out of school / taken off benefits and conscripted into national service until you’re 25.

As for the parents..probably a lost cause by now so let’s focus on the children. Doesn’t matter what your socio economic background is.

National Service - you mean the Army? Do they want people like that? Feral and uneducated.

likelysuspect · 02/09/2026 23:14

Tawneylittle · 02/09/2026 06:41

I know some people with say I am making excuses but seriously if this is implemented how do with punish the parents from “normal homes” who’s kids do stuff.

A lot of people receive benefits in some form or another, even child benefit.

OhNoooooooooooooooo · 03/09/2026 07:17

Sparklybutter · 02/09/2026 22:55

I think if you get done for antisocial behaviour then you get one warning. After that, you’re automatically taken out of school / taken off benefits and conscripted into national service until you’re 25.

As for the parents..probably a lost cause by now so let’s focus on the children. Doesn’t matter what your socio economic background is.

What are the armed forces going to do with a 12 year old?

sodoffbeforemycupofcoff · 03/09/2026 10:19

Sparklybutter · 02/09/2026 22:58

None , but it’s not just antisocial school children there are antisocial 18 year olds out of work. The army would sort them out.

Uneducated suggestion for them to sign up to the army.

That being said, employment is a great idea. The difference between me and my friends growing up was that I was employed from before I even got my NI number (paper round) and they were out at the ripe age of 14,15,16 smoking weed, sniffing cocaine and taking MDMA, believe it or not. I use the word friends loosely, I spoke to them because the spoke to me. I knew my path and I chose it well.

Ileithyia · 03/09/2026 10:47

Sparklybutter · 02/09/2026 22:58

None , but it’s not just antisocial school children there are antisocial 18 year olds out of work. The army would sort them out.

The army is not a dumping ground, and conscription is unethical, you can’t force people to do a job that involves risking their life, that has to something they are willing to do and sign up for.

tsmainsqueeze · 03/09/2026 22:03

Soddingcat · 02/09/2026 08:04

My kids are not perfect at all, they are young adults now, we have all had terrible racist abuse, my 26 year old son was punched in the chest by a tracksuit clad cyclist when walking across a bridge recently

My post was intended to discuss what people think solutions are,

I just think that the current acceptance and excuses made for them do not help in the long term .

Im happy to be wrong , it all just feels a bit desperate now.
I live near Middlesbrough and it is lawless there.

I am sorry for your son and i loathe racism ,it disgusts me that people behave like this.
I am thankful to live in an area that is quite peaceful compared to Middlesbrough.
I accept no excuse for the appalling behaviour that we constantly hear about in the media, i don't know what the answer is -probably harsher punishments , but i think you are very unfair to put the blame on social housing tenants and their kids.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 03/09/2026 22:09

No it isn’t a great idea. They won’t be an only child. They’ll have to be housed in homeless accommodation. It’ll encourage further crime if there is no money for food.
I would like to see parents held criminally responsible for their teenage terrorists, but again it’s not always black or white.

Jane379 · 04/09/2026 09:38

seahorsessky · 02/09/2026 23:07

The courses are offered, but most don't take them, and we can't stop people getting pregnant or remove the baby at birth (well, I know they used to with unmarried mums, but they wouldn't now).
Even when existing parents are referred on to parenting courses by SS, a lot of them just do it as a tick box exercise, not taking it seriously.
And there are some good parents who do their best, but if the kid falls in with a bad crowd at school/on the estate, it can be really difficult to fight that. Some really try, but the kid sneaks out.

'we can't stop people getting pregnant or remove the baby at birth (well, I know they used to with unmarried mums, but they wouldn't now).'

  • that's isn't fully true : babies CAN be removed at birth, but the risk of harm has to be very high.
Awkwardisfunny · 02/10/2026 21:12

Soddingcat · 02/09/2026 06:31

This has been suggested, im not sure if it will happen , but i think this is a great idea, if the parents think they will lose their council house and benefits , they may attempt to to control their feral offspring .

My friend is in a local harriers group that starts at a local sports centre in the rough part of town, they are now having to stop their favourite route because of gangs of young teens who intimidate them , run along side them and are abusive, one delightful boy said “ lift your legs higher you c**t ,

How have we come to this ?
Do you think it will make any difference ?

I would remove child benefit from them too , maybe this will force them to parent if they risk losing money or their home

Obviously not all the parents are bad, but virtually all the awful kids round here riding motor bikes with hoods, abusing people are from the council estates near by

Im absolutely sick of it, and sick of decent people being targeted by them

What rules /sanctions would wise mumsnetters suggest ?

Army.

Dameputtingonabraveface · 02/10/2026 21:40

FFS, as a child protection social worker we are already overwhelmed because the few remaining services that still have funding can shut their door. We cannot, so sending more homeless children and families our way on top of all the shit we have to deal with which should be with CAMHS, no recourse to public funds, every other service then deciding stuff is child protection including the police (apparently we have the experience to undertake work around radicalisation and anti terrorism when police cannot find enough evidence to stay involved but think we should). We cannot say we are full and we are drowning and the families that need us are not getting the support they need. Homeless children becomes a child protection issue, my time and experience should not be used this way due to anti social behaviour. People need to start looking at the bigger picture and understanding how we have got to this point as a society rather than these bloody sound bites. None of this is new, but the intolerance, lack of understanding of communities, expectations that other people (including the state) just fix stuff and a bloody sense of entitlement and privilege has really ramped up over the last decade

Awkwardisfunny · 02/10/2026 21:52

CaptainMyCaptain · 02/09/2026 23:08

National Service - you mean the Army? Do they want people like that? Feral and uneducated.

Yeah, sadly they historically have done so and tbf, chain gangs are a thing too.

Nodramalama85 · 03/10/2026 07:50

Deeply saddened by some of the views held by people on this post. Suggesting that all antisocial children are from council estates and on benefits is elitist and exacerbates poverty stigma. Ignoring the deeply ingrained systemic issues across the country that are contributing to these issues isn’t going to help our young people.

It’s reasonable to want to feel safe in the community. It is not reasonable to apply punitive measures so broadly whilst ignoring the circumstances and vulnerabilities of each individual child.

There are so many systemic issues behind antisocial behaviour that are being completely ignored here. Poverty and the cost-of-living crisis, incomes not keeping up with rising costs, lack of affordable after-school clubs and activities, cuts to youth services, lack of safe spaces for young people, school exclusion and disengagement, trauma, exploitation, peer influence and unmet needs can all contribute.
That doesn’t excuse ASB, but reducing it to “bad parents” and “feral children” is incredibly simplistic.

This cohort of children is very vulnerable and comes from a multitude of backgrounds. What they need is support, places to go and the government to reinvest in youth services. Research by the Ministry of Justice in 2026 found that 47% of young people cautioned or sentenced for antisocial behaviour/acquisitive offences had previously been recorded as children in need, 73% had experienced school suspension and 74% had experienced persistent absence.

Whilst I accept that some parents do neglect their children, the idea that we increase a child’s vulnerability instead of safeguarding them is deeply problematic. Holding parents accountable when there is evidence of parental neglect or deliberate facilitation of offending and saying “your child behaves badly, therefore you should lose your home”are not the same proposition.

We are talking about removing people's homes during a housing and homelessness crisis, when social housing is already in desperately short supply. Losing a council home does not mean there is another suitable home waiting for that family. It can mean temporary accommodation, homelessness, disruption to the child’s education and relationships, and further instability. How does making an already vulnerable child homeless help to safeguard them or reduce antisocial behaviour?

Numerous studies involving children already within the youth justice system show high levels of adverse childhood experiences, unmet needs, vulnerability to exploitation and neurodevelopmental difficulties. These factors don’t excuse offending, but they are highly relevant to understanding it and deciding what intervention is most likely to work.

As a society we need to move away from the idea that punitive measures alone will solve this and towards prevention, early intervention, reintegration and restorative approaches. The question isn’t simply what rules and sanctions should we implement, but what support and wider societal changes are needed to address the needs of this cohort and reduce the behaviour?

For those who agree with cutting benefits or adding sanctions, I suggest reading the Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s latest cost-of-living research. Their latest research found that 7.4 million low-income households were unable to afford at least one essential item in the previous six months, and 47% of low-income families reported going hungry, reducing meal sizes or skipping meals because they couldn’t afford enough food.

I find it deeply worrying that cutting financial support and making families homeless is being presented as a solution to antisocial behaviour when so many low-income families are already struggling.

Record numbers cannot afford the essentials: JRF’s cost of living tracker, summer 2026

More people than ever are going without essentials, and an increasing range of families are being affected by the cost of living crisis, but it doesn’t have to be this way — as our latest survey also shows, government policy can have an impact.

https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/jrfs-cost-of-living-tracker-summer-2026

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread