Deeply saddened by some of the views held by people on this post. Suggesting that all antisocial children are from council estates and on benefits is elitist and exacerbates poverty stigma. Ignoring the deeply ingrained systemic issues across the country that are contributing to these issues isn’t going to help our young people.
It’s reasonable to want to feel safe in the community. It is not reasonable to apply punitive measures so broadly whilst ignoring the circumstances and vulnerabilities of each individual child.
There are so many systemic issues behind antisocial behaviour that are being completely ignored here. Poverty and the cost-of-living crisis, incomes not keeping up with rising costs, lack of affordable after-school clubs and activities, cuts to youth services, lack of safe spaces for young people, school exclusion and disengagement, trauma, exploitation, peer influence and unmet needs can all contribute.
That doesn’t excuse ASB, but reducing it to “bad parents” and “feral children” is incredibly simplistic.
This cohort of children is very vulnerable and comes from a multitude of backgrounds. What they need is support, places to go and the government to reinvest in youth services. Research by the Ministry of Justice in 2026 found that 47% of young people cautioned or sentenced for antisocial behaviour/acquisitive offences had previously been recorded as children in need, 73% had experienced school suspension and 74% had experienced persistent absence.
Whilst I accept that some parents do neglect their children, the idea that we increase a child’s vulnerability instead of safeguarding them is deeply problematic. Holding parents accountable when there is evidence of parental neglect or deliberate facilitation of offending and saying “your child behaves badly, therefore you should lose your home”are not the same proposition.
We are talking about removing people's homes during a housing and homelessness crisis, when social housing is already in desperately short supply. Losing a council home does not mean there is another suitable home waiting for that family. It can mean temporary accommodation, homelessness, disruption to the child’s education and relationships, and further instability. How does making an already vulnerable child homeless help to safeguard them or reduce antisocial behaviour?
Numerous studies involving children already within the youth justice system show high levels of adverse childhood experiences, unmet needs, vulnerability to exploitation and neurodevelopmental difficulties. These factors don’t excuse offending, but they are highly relevant to understanding it and deciding what intervention is most likely to work.
As a society we need to move away from the idea that punitive measures alone will solve this and towards prevention, early intervention, reintegration and restorative approaches. The question isn’t simply what rules and sanctions should we implement, but what support and wider societal changes are needed to address the needs of this cohort and reduce the behaviour?
For those who agree with cutting benefits or adding sanctions, I suggest reading the Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s latest cost-of-living research. Their latest research found that 7.4 million low-income households were unable to afford at least one essential item in the previous six months, and 47% of low-income families reported going hungry, reducing meal sizes or skipping meals because they couldn’t afford enough food.
I find it deeply worrying that cutting financial support and making families homeless is being presented as a solution to antisocial behaviour when so many low-income families are already struggling.