Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

I have spent the week sifting application for an admin role.

122 replies

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 16:52

It has been an eye opening week. I sift and interview regularly, the last time being in the early summer. In the summer we had 7 trainee roles with good prospects. I we had around 100 applications per role, interviews and had a great set of recruits and a strong reserve list which we will use.
This month we had 1 role an interesting admin role. Over a 1000 applications, so many good graduates, people with masters and even a few PhDs. People with professional qualifications, years of experience and fantastic experience. All kinds of background, academia, NHS, school, local government.

OP posts:
TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · Today 15:29

throughthe · Yesterday 17:01

A lot of people who don't really want a job apply for unsuitable jobs so that they can show that they are job-hunting but not actually have to suffer the indignity of working

I did want a job (and got a job), but I was expected to apply for anything that came up when I was on jobseekers.

Never mind that none of the jobs they expected me to apply for wanted a graduate who'd fuck off as soon as they found the right job. Just apply apply apply and fill in your diary.

Rashmanfred · Today 15:58

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 19:50

There are very few of the lower level roles who bother to complete a covering letter. Any that do stand out instantly.

Also to PP who has finance qualifications and can't find work. This is my bread and butter. There are lots of remote bookkeeping roles at the mo.

It depends. I don't want a covering letter. I do however use software to sift out the unsuitable applicants. Its not perfect and probably means we miss out on a few good ones, but it's almost impossible to effectively screen 100s of applicants.

StockingsByTheFire · Today 17:14

thaegumathteth · Yesterday 23:19

I mean I don’t know what to say to that. Unfortunately I can’t magic away my disability to make employers more likely to hire me. I wish I bloody could.

As a parent to a disabled child, I feel you. There's zero you can do, but when it comes to business, people make business decisions. You're a higher risk employee (as is DS) so why would I voluntarily opt for extra risk when I don't need too.

This is why you need to have an extra hot CV. I'll hire you if you're clearly that excellent, it mitigates the risk so you're the overall best option. Is that fair? Not really, no. Is it realistic? Yep.

StockingsByTheFire · Today 17:21

Cars4Gov · Today 12:46

I can see the recruitment issues on both sides as have DC applying but I also recruit.

The job market is really, really tough, objectively so because most employers are expecting low growth, they anticipate AI will reduce roles and the recent legislation means you can't take a chance on a person, unless you have a robust HR process which could be costly given the day1 rights.

However I also think the younger applicants do need a mindset change. Perhaps it's due to social media focus but there does seem to be weaker communication skills and less inclination to work hard. This shows up in interviews but I've also seen students who were fortunate enough to get an internship demonstrate low effort whilst working, such as not showing up on time or spending time on their phone. A recent grad for accountancy turned up in the first week dressed in clothes more suitable for the gym, oblivious to the formal work culture. These grads were let go.

It also seems that the universities are not doing enough to help with careers, they are keen to accept students to get the funding when realistically the courses they offer will not make their grads competitive candidates in the job market.

Yes the changes in legislation are an absolute minefield. So if you give us any hint that you're "I know my rights" and start any Spidey senses that you're the poster child for an ACAS claim, then I can't be bothered with you. In 9/10 cases these people always turn out to be the pain in the arse you suspected.

My last hire was age 61. She's brilliant.

BoredZelda · Today 17:24

Where are you? We’ve been recruiting for various levels of job a there aren’t that many applicants. Particularly for the senior roles.

thaegumathteth · Today 17:39

BoredZelda · Today 17:24

Where are you? We’ve been recruiting for various levels of job a there aren’t that many applicants. Particularly for the senior roles.

Any of them remote? 😉

Also thanks @iamnotalemon I’ll take a look.

SpanThatWorld · Today 18:19

LlynTegid · Today 09:16

Fewer people should be going to university, far more going into apprenticeships or other jobs where you start as a school leaver. Much more chance of knowing about the real world and its expectations than leaving it until you are 21 or 22 years old.

Therr are far fewer straight-from-school jobs than there used to be. Lots have been automated out of existence.

Apprenticeships are incredibly competitive.

Whatever age you start working, it's a rapid learning curve. If our young people are going to be working into their 70s, there's plenty of time to start that process.

The problem is that whether you are 16 or 21, there are far fewer jobs as copy typists, lathe operators or filing clerks than there used to be.

riceuten · Today 18:21

The jobs market for certain sectors at the moment is ridiculous. Young people, career changers, people over 55 really don't stand a chance nowadays. With AI taking up so many roles, firms/recruiters can afford to be ridiculously fussy with applications and brutally sift on even the tiniest aspect of a JD/PS, and still be left with hundreds of applicants.

Put simply, it's an employers' market. Why take a risk when you can be sure you can get more or less what you want on your own door step? I even heard of people being sifted on the basis of A Level results...from 20 years previously. Or people being sifted on the basis of stuff that wasn't even in the JD/PS...because they can.

JobCentrePlus are putting pressure on people to apply for a certain number of even vaguely suitable jobs - hence the high level of spammed applications.

StMarie4me · Today 18:39

Qualitypinnacle · Yesterday 17:16

Yes, and the zero hours people don't even count in the statistics as they're not claiming benefits but still often earning no more than the £90 UC amount if living with parents

They do count, and they can claim UC on earnings that low.

Qualitypinnacle · Today 18:56

Well ok they can count, but often don't if living at home as the hours are up and down and claiming UC would be not worth it for the few pounds you might sometimes get. My DD doesn't claim it and I'm sure a lot of others don't eother

141mum · Today 19:03

Qualitypinnacle · Yesterday 17:01

Yup. This why my 25 year graduate daughter is still on a zero hours contract in a minimum wage retail job

It’s bloody horrible for the young generation, my dd 24, graduate, said why did she bother with a levels and a degree, you can see the sadness, all they want is a bloody job

RosieFoxRox · Today 19:13

My son and his friends are 16/17/18. They have been looking for part time jobs since they turned 16. Everyone expects them to write a flawless CV and have experience, but they barely have life experience at this age. My son has been doing unpaid work experience to bulk his CV, but even finding someone to let him work with them for free took months as no one wanted the hassle! He is restricted further because he wants to work around his college hours. He’s applied for hundreds of vacancies, most of which were via recruitment agencies. He got 2 interviews from those applications and the worst thing, when jobs come up with the same companies again, they block him from reapplying even tho it’s been 6 months since his previous application and he has now got months of work experience to bring to the table. The government want to lower youth unemployment but there’s no capacity to get them into work!

my son got a job this week as a Christmas temp. He just started chatting to a staff member, who turned out to be the manager, in a shop and he pointed out a way things could be done better (he has autism and sees patterns better than most). The manager asked if he wanted a job as a joke and my son ran to grab a cv from his car. He got a call for an interview the next day and he starts on Monday! But this was sheer opportunity. It’s just Christmas work but it means he now will have retail experience to hopefully help him get his next job (and crucially a second reference that isn’t a college teacher). It’s taken 18 months to line up a job for 5 weeks work.

Illbethereinaminute · Today 19:15

The job market is insane. I've been looking for a more grown up job rather than waitressing for months and got nowhere. I have a degree and years in hospitality but I'm getting nowhere.

So I have just applied for a second job, weekends only just to boost my income. I want a zero hours contract, no security, just a few hours here and there if there are any but I fear being 40 will go against me because I can't turn up at the drop of a hat and I'm over qualified with 20+ years in the industry.

On the plus side though I'm a perfect candidate, can work the busiest times, have a ton of experience and so need little training, just training in the actual job and their own systems rather than the generic "how to be a waitress/bar tender"

I feel like companies want someone who can do all the hours with 2 hours notice and be available 24/7. Young enough to be walked all over but not too old that they can't do the job.

DontSayItsOver · Today 19:20

You can put the one that didn’t know where Guyana was in the no pile.

AllRighterrrr · Today 19:36

In the last 2 years I have employed 2 young people. One aged 21 and one aged 24. Both are exceptionally capable, working incredibly collaboratively in a high pressure environment. There's only one other 21 year old I've worked with who is as exceptional. They are now a professor somewhere. Not all young people are professionally unemployable. I'm proud of the fact 50% of my team is under 28. Giving them opportunities is absolutely crucial for their future and the future of the organisation I'm in.

We're really specific about the skills we need but open to how people get them. The 21 year old it was their first job after uni but they had volunteering and personal initiative coming out of their ears.

Rashmanfred · Today 19:44

BoredZelda · Today 17:24

Where are you? We’ve been recruiting for various levels of job a there aren’t that many applicants. Particularly for the senior roles.

Are you offering genuine hybrid working (assuming it's a desk job) and are you offering a market rate wage (and advertising salary).

Neither DH, not I will apply for a role that isn't hybrid (more than 1 day a week) and where the salary isn't clearly advertised.

I recently got contacted by an internal recruiter who I vaguely knew through networking and had previously seen the role advertised. I did explain I didn't apply because I didn't see the salary on the advert and 'hybrid' wasnt enough ingo. After some back and forth it became really clear they're expecting 80% office base on the bottom end of the market salary (and actually below market given what they actually wanted). I told him that (given I also recruit and understand the current market). A couple of months later it was advertised again with a better salary and the hybrid expectations set out in the advert and both better than previously. I spoke with the recruiter after that at another networking event and they'd got loads of applications that time.

Aydel · Today 19:48

Qualitypinnacle · Yesterday 17:01

Yup. This why my 25 year graduate daughter is still on a zero hours contract in a minimum wage retail job

Mine too. And my 28 year old.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · Today 19:49

socialdilemmawhattodo · Yesterday 19:02

Those on this thread recruiting, and any other recruiters. Do any of your companies do anything about the job hunting requirements for benefit claimants? Eg contact the local MP, Business Secretary etc. It certainly sounds to me as if businesses are becoming very inefficient on recruitment due to the sheer numbers applying. That impacts everyone adversely.

There's nothing you can do. A job application is open to anyone to apply for. If you are a recruiter, as I used to be years ago, you know this and just weed them out.

Mazanna123 · Today 19:53

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 16:59

Where did you post the job?

I have previously used Indeed and got hundreds of spammed CVs for an admin role.

No, "Kirk" the now out of work ex lorry driver, you are not suitable for our admin/finance role that clearly says we want QuickBooks experience.

No, David from Guyana, you can not do our shop assistant role remotely from Africa.

Some people just click apply on anything, utter time wasters. You have to show you're "actively looking" for interviews to get your benefits. Out of interest, we invited "Kirk" for interview just to see what happened. Naturally he didn't even show up. It's just to keep his benefits coach happy.

Guyana is in South America

cerealmover · Today 20:56

Job market is awful for the youngsters I know, including my own. I know many 16-18 year olds that can't get the usual part time Saturday jobs that used to be so easy to get. So many of them won't gain work experience for the next step.

Apprenticeships and degree apprenticeships are like hens teeth, harder to get than an Oxbridge place. So kids go to uni instead and kick the can down the road, still with no experience.

My own DC - one has a 1st class STEM degree from Oxbridge. Managed to get a part time job 4 years ago and held onto it. Also has another zero hours job. Is very hard working, reliable and well thought of in work. Also some micro internships. But has applied to dozens of jobs with no luck. They all seem to want experience and the customer service experience they have is no good for a science role. DC is getting very down about it.

Other DC is going through the grad scheme process and getting nowhere, despite doing a good degree from one of the best uni's in the country for it. Failed to get any internships this year despite spending half of last year applying. Very pessimistic and sees no point in applying any more.

Both the grad scheme and internship process has been brutal - some have up to 7 stages just for a few weeks summer work. These kids are supposed to spend hours on just one application, when some kids are applying for 100 or more and still not getting anywhere.

It's desperate times and Labour keep implementing policies that are making it worse. AI has come along just to kill off the jobs market when it's in a bad state as it is.

ItalianoSl · Today 21:02

The jobs market for certain sectors at the moment is ridiculous. Young people, career changers, people over 55 really don't stand a chance nowadays.

That is somewhat of an overstatement.
At least I hope so. I am 56 and looking for work.
I presume you are not in any of those sector, otherwise maybe you would not have been so flippant with your words. I am profoundly worried about my future.

ItalianoSl · Today 21:06

even heard of people being sifted on the basis of A Level results...from 20 years previously. Or people being sifted on the basis of stuff that wasn't even in the JD/PS...because they can.

How do you know this? Can you explain how the rejected person was told it was because of their 20 year old A level results?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page