Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

I have spent the week sifting application for an admin role.

122 replies

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 16:52

It has been an eye opening week. I sift and interview regularly, the last time being in the early summer. In the summer we had 7 trainee roles with good prospects. I we had around 100 applications per role, interviews and had a great set of recruits and a strong reserve list which we will use.
This month we had 1 role an interesting admin role. Over a 1000 applications, so many good graduates, people with masters and even a few PhDs. People with professional qualifications, years of experience and fantastic experience. All kinds of background, academia, NHS, school, local government.

OP posts:
Hatty65 · Yesterday 16:53

That's really sad. It's ridiculous to have 1,000 applicants for any role, frankly, and shows that people are desperate.

2026londonvibes · Yesterday 16:54

How do you sift? Might be useful to know for the job hunters.

gonoodleoodle · Yesterday 16:56

Will you contact all the unsuccessful applicants? Just so they know. A blanket email is fine imo.

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 16:59

Where did you post the job?

I have previously used Indeed and got hundreds of spammed CVs for an admin role.

No, "Kirk" the now out of work ex lorry driver, you are not suitable for our admin/finance role that clearly says we want QuickBooks experience.

No, David from Guyana, you can not do our shop assistant role remotely from Africa.

Some people just click apply on anything, utter time wasters. You have to show you're "actively looking" for interviews to get your benefits. Out of interest, we invited "Kirk" for interview just to see what happened. Naturally he didn't even show up. It's just to keep his benefits coach happy.

bababamama · Yesterday 17:00

Unfortunately whilst the internet and specifically ai has made finding job openings easier, it means more applications if the job is looks good. To find vacancies you no longer have to sift through dozens of websites or even earlier, register with agencies and search newspapers, a few clicks and I get a list within 30 minutes of my house. I recruited 2 years ago, pt position minimum wage and got 570 applications though 95% were not suitable obviously, it was clear we were simply to make up the numbers their job coach told them we had to apply for (we have a genuine religious exemption due to the job). The person who got the job actually was far less qualified and had lots of reasons why they weren’t as good (medical) but I’ll give anyone a chance

Qualitypinnacle · Yesterday 17:01

Yup. This why my 25 year graduate daughter is still on a zero hours contract in a minimum wage retail job

throughthe · Yesterday 17:01

A lot of people who don't really want a job apply for unsuitable jobs so that they can show that they are job-hunting but not actually have to suffer the indignity of working

CloveRinse · Yesterday 17:03

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 16:59

Where did you post the job?

I have previously used Indeed and got hundreds of spammed CVs for an admin role.

No, "Kirk" the now out of work ex lorry driver, you are not suitable for our admin/finance role that clearly says we want QuickBooks experience.

No, David from Guyana, you can not do our shop assistant role remotely from Africa.

Some people just click apply on anything, utter time wasters. You have to show you're "actively looking" for interviews to get your benefits. Out of interest, we invited "Kirk" for interview just to see what happened. Naturally he didn't even show up. It's just to keep his benefits coach happy.

@StockingsByTheFire Guyana is not in Africa. FYI.

Gatekeeper · Yesterday 17:03

Qualitypinnacle · Yesterday 17:01

Yup. This why my 25 year graduate daughter is still on a zero hours contract in a minimum wage retail job

Mine too Sad

Pieceofpurplesky · Yesterday 17:07

Gatekeeper · Yesterday 17:03

Mine too Sad

Mine too

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 17:09

Qualitypinnacle · Yesterday 17:01

Yup. This why my 25 year graduate daughter is still on a zero hours contract in a minimum wage retail job

This is why the benefit bashers on here or judging those living with family, drive me mad.

Some people genuinely can’t find a job or only part time hours, even though they’re desperate to work.

Qualitypinnacle · Yesterday 17:16

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 17:09

This is why the benefit bashers on here or judging those living with family, drive me mad.

Some people genuinely can’t find a job or only part time hours, even though they’re desperate to work.

Yes, and the zero hours people don't even count in the statistics as they're not claiming benefits but still often earning no more than the £90 UC amount if living with parents

MFL · Yesterday 17:17

@NellietheNumpty You need better wording in the advertisement and job spec/description. You then need an application form where candidates highlight the key educational criteria and experience you need. If it’s not there, out it goes. Get this info on page 1. You need to try and cut out a vast number who clearly won’t be the right fit. Be precise about what you ask for and look evidence of fit on their application by making application forms work for you. If you don’t need a PhD, bin it. Likewise, no English GCSE, bin it. Make candidates list their attributes and match to the job clearly. Then apply your criteria and stick
to them.

Sunshineandrainbow · Yesterday 17:19

1000 applications, wow .... I have been in the NHS 25 years (band 4) and applied for a band 3 admin role recently and was gutted I wasn't shortlisted.. I think I need to sort my supporting department out as I keep getting rejected.

BurntBroccoli · Yesterday 17:23

Qualitypinnacle · Yesterday 17:01

Yup. This why my 25 year graduate daughter is still on a zero hours contract in a minimum wage retail job

Mine as well.

Monty36 · Yesterday 17:25

I can see your point but I would wonder if your job description was detailed enough to attract so many ?

BurntBroccoli · Yesterday 17:25

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 17:09

This is why the benefit bashers on here or judging those living with family, drive me mad.

Some people genuinely can’t find a job or only part time hours, even though they’re desperate to work.

Exactly and calling young people lazy!

They have absolutely no clue as to what’s going on right now when it comes to young people and the jack of employment opportunities.

LucyFreyaUrquhartDixon · Yesterday 17:26

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 16:59

Where did you post the job?

I have previously used Indeed and got hundreds of spammed CVs for an admin role.

No, "Kirk" the now out of work ex lorry driver, you are not suitable for our admin/finance role that clearly says we want QuickBooks experience.

No, David from Guyana, you can not do our shop assistant role remotely from Africa.

Some people just click apply on anything, utter time wasters. You have to show you're "actively looking" for interviews to get your benefits. Out of interest, we invited "Kirk" for interview just to see what happened. Naturally he didn't even show up. It's just to keep his benefits coach happy.

You really need an atlas!

PoppetDog · Yesterday 17:33

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 16:59

Where did you post the job?

I have previously used Indeed and got hundreds of spammed CVs for an admin role.

No, "Kirk" the now out of work ex lorry driver, you are not suitable for our admin/finance role that clearly says we want QuickBooks experience.

No, David from Guyana, you can not do our shop assistant role remotely from Africa.

Some people just click apply on anything, utter time wasters. You have to show you're "actively looking" for interviews to get your benefits. Out of interest, we invited "Kirk" for interview just to see what happened. Naturally he didn't even show up. It's just to keep his benefits coach happy.

Guyana in Africa 😖

CrystalRabbit · Yesterday 17:44

I’d agree that maybe your job description and application process needs tweaking. I don’t think this is new that generic role descriptions get lots of unsuitable applicants. About 7 years ago I had to sift through about 500 applicants for a corporate PA role. There were really only around 50 that were suitable, and part of the problem was the vague job advert that made it sound like anyone could have a go at it (not written by, or passed by any actual PAs in the company for their input), and also that they could apply with one click.

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 17:51

Thanks for all the comments and feedback. It is an entry level job and the criteria were specified. I was surprised at how many very highly qualified and experienced candidates there were. My team have read every one and will respond.

If you want pointers mostly to read the job spec very carefully. There were 4 aspects to cover and it was surprising how many candidates did not give evidence to cover those. Then after that then good examples are needed. Not just that you have IT skills,but what was achieved using the skills.

OP posts:
ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 17:52

You could ask for people to write in with a CV the old-fashioned way!

The cost of a stamp alone will put a lot of people off.

Piccallily · Yesterday 17:52

I had 2 applications from different people that were exactly the same! Done by AI!! Binned them both even though they could have been really good contenders

ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 17:53

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 17:51

Thanks for all the comments and feedback. It is an entry level job and the criteria were specified. I was surprised at how many very highly qualified and experienced candidates there were. My team have read every one and will respond.

If you want pointers mostly to read the job spec very carefully. There were 4 aspects to cover and it was surprising how many candidates did not give evidence to cover those. Then after that then good examples are needed. Not just that you have IT skills,but what was achieved using the skills.

And yet women get told to apply even if they don't meet every specification because men always do.

So is that nonsense advice? Should you indeed only apply if you meet every spec?

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 17:59

I feel for those with adult children struggling. I read how many people in their early 20s had a mixture of internships, retail jobs, gig work and so on.
Also how many professionals were applying. The aspects could be shown by the less experienced applicants but they needed to think carefully. Details changed but there was an excellent application from someone using a charity event they organised and some zero hours bar work. So I would encourage women to think through what they can do.

OP posts: