Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

I have spent the week sifting application for an admin role.

122 replies

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 16:52

It has been an eye opening week. I sift and interview regularly, the last time being in the early summer. In the summer we had 7 trainee roles with good prospects. I we had around 100 applications per role, interviews and had a great set of recruits and a strong reserve list which we will use.
This month we had 1 role an interesting admin role. Over a 1000 applications, so many good graduates, people with masters and even a few PhDs. People with professional qualifications, years of experience and fantastic experience. All kinds of background, academia, NHS, school, local government.

OP posts:
StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 18:15

God forbid my auto swipe keyboard opted for Guyana instead of Ghana.

Yes that's the point to note....

CloveRinse · Yesterday 18:36

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 18:15

God forbid my auto swipe keyboard opted for Guyana instead of Ghana.

Yes that's the point to note....

The point is that if you are going to be snippy and sneering about people who are struggling to find work, then you should at last make sure your mocking posts are at least accurate.

I am not looking at graduate level jobs, but I have been looking for work for a very long time. I have professional qualifications and over 15 years of experience and it has been the most soul destroying experience of my life.

I never ever thought I would be in this position. I have worked all my life - part time jobs, Uni jobs, graduate scheme, and worked ever since. I lost my job through no fault of my own (outsourced to AI and offshore), and had a divorce (and accompanying legal fees) to navigate all at the same time.

Your derisory post has really annoyed me. It is really hard out there at the moment.

I also want to let you know that when you go to Job Centres, they FORCE you to apply for jobs that are totally unsuitable.

I reference your lorry driver example with personal experience. I was sent jobs to be an HGV driver when my experience and education relates to accountancy, finance in financial services specifically; I posted about it at the time. I would never be chosen for an HGV driver role. I would be "sifted out" as @NellietheNumpty described. However, if I didn't make the applications, they threatened to sanction me ie not make the next payment which I needed.

I really hope you never have the misfortune to be out of work in this current economy. It's awful.

Also, buy yourself a world map for Christmas. In your haste to mock, you didn't even read back your post, and if you had, and if you knew your countries, you would have easily spotted the mistake. But you were rushing to be rude.

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 18:38

Interestingly we've interviewed lots of early to mid twenties. And frankly they're all useless. I know everyone will leap to insist their child is nothing of the sort, but I will take a 40yr old over the graduates I see, every day of the week.

One chap told me "I worked for the council, so I know my rights" (thanks for letting me know, ACAS boy, you can be someone else's headache on long term sick pay)

Another kept stroppily correcting my colleague for not using they/them as pronouns. No thanks, you're another headache waiting to happen. My p.a is called, eg "Jean" and lots of people mispronounce her as "Jane" when they first meet her. It's not a big deal, she often lets it slip. This girl was professionally offended and it just went to show how she would interact within the office. She also had a degree in something like marine biology which she was quite smug about. I mean, good for you. Less helpful in a commercial office environment.

One we took on and she made it 3 weeks before her timekeeping was so poor she was told that this probably wasn't the job for her.

They all want to put in the minimum required to get their pay. They think anything requiring 1% more effort is exploiting them and whine or are "sick". They have poor work ethic. And it's a generational thing. I have a child at uni who is just the same. I love him dearly. I categorically would not employ him.

I have recently employed a 26yr old graduate. He is on minimum wage. The concept of him having responsibility over much more than the bare minimum is as inconceivable to him as it is to me.

It's not about the proved academic intelligence. It's about the ability to just go to work and be a valuable employee, and that's what's lacking. Trust me, employers are crying out for decent new workers. I have yet to find one under 25 that has been an exception to the rule, and I interview for probably 8 - 9 positions a year, I see hundreds of them in this age group.

Thortour · Yesterday 18:39

Where are you based OP?

Luckyingame · Yesterday 18:40

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 18:38

Interestingly we've interviewed lots of early to mid twenties. And frankly they're all useless. I know everyone will leap to insist their child is nothing of the sort, but I will take a 40yr old over the graduates I see, every day of the week.

One chap told me "I worked for the council, so I know my rights" (thanks for letting me know, ACAS boy, you can be someone else's headache on long term sick pay)

Another kept stroppily correcting my colleague for not using they/them as pronouns. No thanks, you're another headache waiting to happen. My p.a is called, eg "Jean" and lots of people mispronounce her as "Jane" when they first meet her. It's not a big deal, she often lets it slip. This girl was professionally offended and it just went to show how she would interact within the office. She also had a degree in something like marine biology which she was quite smug about. I mean, good for you. Less helpful in a commercial office environment.

One we took on and she made it 3 weeks before her timekeeping was so poor she was told that this probably wasn't the job for her.

They all want to put in the minimum required to get their pay. They think anything requiring 1% more effort is exploiting them and whine or are "sick". They have poor work ethic. And it's a generational thing. I have a child at uni who is just the same. I love him dearly. I categorically would not employ him.

I have recently employed a 26yr old graduate. He is on minimum wage. The concept of him having responsibility over much more than the bare minimum is as inconceivable to him as it is to me.

It's not about the proved academic intelligence. It's about the ability to just go to work and be a valuable employee, and that's what's lacking. Trust me, employers are crying out for decent new workers. I have yet to find one under 25 that has been an exception to the rule, and I interview for probably 8 - 9 positions a year, I see hundreds of them in this age group.

Spot on. ☝️

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 19:01

Your comments are really interesting and give a lot of context. For example of being required to apply for unsuitable roles. The applications I saw were generally good and some of them were excellent. It was the amount and quality that surprised me.
The role I am advertising can be undertaken anywhere in the uk, there would be a mixture of on line and in person training and then so many days a week in a team and the rest work from home.

OP posts:
socialdilemmawhattodo · Yesterday 19:02

Those on this thread recruiting, and any other recruiters. Do any of your companies do anything about the job hunting requirements for benefit claimants? Eg contact the local MP, Business Secretary etc. It certainly sounds to me as if businesses are becoming very inefficient on recruitment due to the sheer numbers applying. That impacts everyone adversely.

PamelaShipman80 · Yesterday 19:07

CloveRinse · Yesterday 18:36

The point is that if you are going to be snippy and sneering about people who are struggling to find work, then you should at last make sure your mocking posts are at least accurate.

I am not looking at graduate level jobs, but I have been looking for work for a very long time. I have professional qualifications and over 15 years of experience and it has been the most soul destroying experience of my life.

I never ever thought I would be in this position. I have worked all my life - part time jobs, Uni jobs, graduate scheme, and worked ever since. I lost my job through no fault of my own (outsourced to AI and offshore), and had a divorce (and accompanying legal fees) to navigate all at the same time.

Your derisory post has really annoyed me. It is really hard out there at the moment.

I also want to let you know that when you go to Job Centres, they FORCE you to apply for jobs that are totally unsuitable.

I reference your lorry driver example with personal experience. I was sent jobs to be an HGV driver when my experience and education relates to accountancy, finance in financial services specifically; I posted about it at the time. I would never be chosen for an HGV driver role. I would be "sifted out" as @NellietheNumpty described. However, if I didn't make the applications, they threatened to sanction me ie not make the next payment which I needed.

I really hope you never have the misfortune to be out of work in this current economy. It's awful.

Also, buy yourself a world map for Christmas. In your haste to mock, you didn't even read back your post, and if you had, and if you knew your countries, you would have easily spotted the mistake. But you were rushing to be rude.

I hope you find something soon

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 19:08

To respond to what @StockingsByTheFire that had not been my experience. I recruit on a twice a year schedule. I am recruiting at a higher level and was assisting this week due to the high volume of applicants. Many of the applications were as good as the ones I receive for the higher post and occasionally better.
I use a scenario for my interview centres and that seems to produce good outcomes. No complaints over the last few years.

OP posts:
StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 19:24

socialdilemmawhattodo · Yesterday 19:02

Those on this thread recruiting, and any other recruiters. Do any of your companies do anything about the job hunting requirements for benefit claimants? Eg contact the local MP, Business Secretary etc. It certainly sounds to me as if businesses are becoming very inefficient on recruitment due to the sheer numbers applying. That impacts everyone adversely.

A fellow member of the Board is quite high up in DWP. Another is an MP. Funny that you picked examples so close to home.

The former knows it's a broken system.

The latter says nothing about it.

I sit in on interviews from the most basic roles, to executive level, depending on who else is free. We like to have a panel at interview for anything over minimum wage.

We aren't bombarded at senior level, but we will still get 20-30 "Kirk's" from Zimbabwe in Antarctica auto sending in their benefit complying applications. You get quite quick at sifting. I had a CV with a smiley emoji on last month.

See also "full time mummy." If you can't grasp why it shouldn't be on your CV under the employment history section, then I appreciate you saving me the waste of time interviewing you.

I've been successful for every job I've applied for since my first job at 16, bar one. And the one was a volunteer role bizarrely enough. I know I won't have been the most competent or best qualified in all these cases. I interview well, I look very presentable, I work hard, people like working for me, I get results.

It's no good being the smartest guy in the room if you've pissed off everyone by lunchtime. If people are struggling, my recommendations would be to work on their interview technique and have a recruitment agency go through their CV to streamline it.

Netcurtainnelly · Yesterday 19:36

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 16:52

It has been an eye opening week. I sift and interview regularly, the last time being in the early summer. In the summer we had 7 trainee roles with good prospects. I we had around 100 applications per role, interviews and had a great set of recruits and a strong reserve list which we will use.
This month we had 1 role an interesting admin role. Over a 1000 applications, so many good graduates, people with masters and even a few PhDs. People with professional qualifications, years of experience and fantastic experience. All kinds of background, academia, NHS, school, local government.

What is the job for?

Stuckintheswing · Yesterday 19:45

Universal credit forces people to apply for jobs, even if they are totally unsuitable, so they'll be clogging up your system.

I agree that reverting to a covering letter and CV would make your life much easier. You'd soon spot who has attention to detail, good communication skills etc.

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 19:50

Stuckintheswing · Yesterday 19:45

Universal credit forces people to apply for jobs, even if they are totally unsuitable, so they'll be clogging up your system.

I agree that reverting to a covering letter and CV would make your life much easier. You'd soon spot who has attention to detail, good communication skills etc.

There are very few of the lower level roles who bother to complete a covering letter. Any that do stand out instantly.

Also to PP who has finance qualifications and can't find work. This is my bread and butter. There are lots of remote bookkeeping roles at the mo.

glitterpaperchain · Yesterday 19:50

throughthe · Yesterday 17:01

A lot of people who don't really want a job apply for unsuitable jobs so that they can show that they are job-hunting but not actually have to suffer the indignity of working

A literal real life example of how terrible the job market is and you've still managed to twist it round to criticising unemployed people...that actually takes some skill

Toughwork · Yesterday 19:57

MFL · Yesterday 17:17

@NellietheNumpty You need better wording in the advertisement and job spec/description. You then need an application form where candidates highlight the key educational criteria and experience you need. If it’s not there, out it goes. Get this info on page 1. You need to try and cut out a vast number who clearly won’t be the right fit. Be precise about what you ask for and look evidence of fit on their application by making application forms work for you. If you don’t need a PhD, bin it. Likewise, no English GCSE, bin it. Make candidates list their attributes and match to the job clearly. Then apply your criteria and stick
to them.

Why bin the PHD person just because the job doesn't require a PHD, assuming they have everything the job does require? They want the job and they can do the job.

Bitzee · Yesterday 20:07

Joke all you want about the ex HGV driver @StockingsByTheFire but one of our brilliant board directors was an out of work lorry driver when he applied (many years ago). Fortunately the company was willing to take a chance on him.

Also, we’ve recruited for 3 ‘second job’ type roles and have had our pick of really amazing candidates in their early to mid twenties. Ended up recruiting one who’d done an apprenticeship and 2 graduates with a year or so of experience under their belts. It’s our more experienced roles that we’re struggling with because we want people in the office, not remote, and a lot of candidates apply clearly not having read the job spec properly and then withdraw when offered an interview.

Jobdiscussion · Yesterday 20:12

Toughwork · Yesterday 19:57

Why bin the PHD person just because the job doesn't require a PHD, assuming they have everything the job does require? They want the job and they can do the job.

Yes, I was thinking this! One of my DD's friends has had real problems trying to get a job (not at all precious about what she does). She has a masters degree in a science subject from a highly ranked university, and I suspect part of the problem may have been that employers saw her as overqualified. When she did finally land a basic admin role she did really well in it. I personally find it entirely unsurprising that someone whose degree required them to do lab work that required a very high level of attention to detail (and production of a lot of Excel spreadsheets) was able to do an excellent job in a basic admin role.

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 20:16

Toughwork · Yesterday 19:57

Why bin the PHD person just because the job doesn't require a PHD, assuming they have everything the job does require? They want the job and they can do the job.

In the example I gave above two were graduates. It's less about the academic accolades, it's literally an age thing.

A 40yr old graduate? Absolutely. A 40yr old without a long list of qualifications? Yep. Different mindset, different work ethic.

A 25 and under, graduate or otherwise? Haven't found a good one yet. The few I have hired have all failed to pass probation.

doormats5 · Yesterday 20:22

@StockingsByTheFirewhere are all these remote bookkeeping jobs? my friend is struggling to find them

thaegumathteth · Yesterday 20:36

I have been desperately applying for admin roles that can be done remotely (am disabled, can’t travel and feel utterly bloody useless). It has been 14 months of applications several every week and NOTHING. I’ve had about 6/7 interviews but not got past.

im trying to volunteer remotely now for my mental health and for my CV but honestly it’s a totally soul destroying process.

Jobdiscussion · Yesterday 20:40

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 19:24

A fellow member of the Board is quite high up in DWP. Another is an MP. Funny that you picked examples so close to home.

The former knows it's a broken system.

The latter says nothing about it.

I sit in on interviews from the most basic roles, to executive level, depending on who else is free. We like to have a panel at interview for anything over minimum wage.

We aren't bombarded at senior level, but we will still get 20-30 "Kirk's" from Zimbabwe in Antarctica auto sending in their benefit complying applications. You get quite quick at sifting. I had a CV with a smiley emoji on last month.

See also "full time mummy." If you can't grasp why it shouldn't be on your CV under the employment history section, then I appreciate you saving me the waste of time interviewing you.

I've been successful for every job I've applied for since my first job at 16, bar one. And the one was a volunteer role bizarrely enough. I know I won't have been the most competent or best qualified in all these cases. I interview well, I look very presentable, I work hard, people like working for me, I get results.

It's no good being the smartest guy in the room if you've pissed off everyone by lunchtime. If people are struggling, my recommendations would be to work on their interview technique and have a recruitment agency go through their CV to streamline it.

Your post tells me you have no idea what the jobs market is like for many young people at the moment. For many young people the proportion of applications that leads to an interview is tiny. As the OP has outlined in her post, she has received so many high quality applications that inevitably most high quality candidates will be rejected without ever getting an interview.

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 21:36

doormats5 · Yesterday 20:22

@StockingsByTheFirewhere are all these remote bookkeeping jobs? my friend is struggling to find them

Lots of them on Indeed

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 21:39

Jobdiscussion · Yesterday 20:40

Your post tells me you have no idea what the jobs market is like for many young people at the moment. For many young people the proportion of applications that leads to an interview is tiny. As the OP has outlined in her post, she has received so many high quality applications that inevitably most high quality candidates will be rejected without ever getting an interview.

No. Your post tells me you don't like to hear why young people are being overlooked. I know exactly what the job market is like. I'm posting 2 roles to recruit next week.

seahorsessky · Yesterday 21:39

Oh but it's easy to find a job. People who don't are just not trying...I hope all the people who actually think this read your post.
Most of us could easily pick up a job in the 00s. Not now. And th applications take up so much more time than just walking into a shop/cafe/office building like we did.

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 21:49

thaegumathteth · Yesterday 20:36

I have been desperately applying for admin roles that can be done remotely (am disabled, can’t travel and feel utterly bloody useless). It has been 14 months of applications several every week and NOTHING. I’ve had about 6/7 interviews but not got past.

im trying to volunteer remotely now for my mental health and for my CV but honestly it’s a totally soul destroying process.

Hi

Here's the first few things I'd be asking (forgive me if it's abrupt, it's from a good place)

What kind of jobs are you applying for?
What qualifications do you have that would put you above other candidates for that exact role?
What experience exactly do you have that would put you above other candidates for that exact role?
What interview practice have you done?
Why would I hire you?