Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

I have spent the week sifting application for an admin role.

122 replies

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 16:52

It has been an eye opening week. I sift and interview regularly, the last time being in the early summer. In the summer we had 7 trainee roles with good prospects. I we had around 100 applications per role, interviews and had a great set of recruits and a strong reserve list which we will use.
This month we had 1 role an interesting admin role. Over a 1000 applications, so many good graduates, people with masters and even a few PhDs. People with professional qualifications, years of experience and fantastic experience. All kinds of background, academia, NHS, school, local government.

OP posts:
thaegumathteth · Yesterday 21:51

I’ve tried to prep answers to all of those. I wrote individualised cover letters and update my CV every time I apply tailoring it to the job / person spec.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 21:52

PoppetDog · Yesterday 17:33

Guyana in Africa 😖

Maybe the pp got it mixed up with Ghana.

Yourchildrenwillbegiants · Yesterday 21:52

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 21:39

No. Your post tells me you don't like to hear why young people are being overlooked. I know exactly what the job market is like. I'm posting 2 roles to recruit next week.

Someday Stockings you’re going to get your comeuppance.

Redsofacushionsandsnacks · Yesterday 21:52

You spent a WEEK sifting applications for an admin role? An entire week? Where on earth do you work?

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 21:54

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 21:52

Maybe the pp got it mixed up with Ghana.

See also Zimbabwe in Antarctica

Willowback · Yesterday 21:55

Are you Civil Service OP? We have the same for our AO level jobs lots of degree/phds folks and even more AI responses from abroad. Ours now go through extra HR checks before they go to the people on the sift.

Jobdiscussion · Yesterday 22:08

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 21:39

No. Your post tells me you don't like to hear why young people are being overlooked. I know exactly what the job market is like. I'm posting 2 roles to recruit next week.

You know what the job market is like as a recruiter in your particular field. You haven't shown any insight into what it is like from the applicant side. You've said yourself that you've got every paid job you've ever applied for, so you've acknowledged that either you've never had the experience of applying for jobs in a tough market, or if you have, you got lucky. If the young candidates who you invite to interview are largely turning out to be hopeless, that suggests a pretty fundamental flaw in your recruitment process in that you're failing to screen out no hopers early in the process and thereby missing out on better candidates as a result.

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 22:15

thaegumathteth · Yesterday 21:51

I’ve tried to prep answers to all of those. I wrote individualised cover letters and update my CV every time I apply tailoring it to the job / person spec.

Very gently, if you can tailor your CV to suit whichever role you are applying for, then it's not got specific qualifications.

Cover letters are great. Admin wise most people can't be arsed and we often joke about the number of candidates who claim to have "excellent attention to detail" and yet don't bother following the instructions of submitting a CV and covering letter. For an admin job.

Tailoring a covering letter, definitely. But your CV is really just that, you shouldn't be looking to notably change it.

I know there is massive discrimination towards all manners of groups, irrespective of how shoddy that may be. Employers won't ever admit it, but they all do it. If I've got an 8/10 single person, or a 9/10 parent of 3, then I'm taking the 8/10. Because there's 4 people who might get sick resulting in the parent needing the day off.

Do you declare your disability and does it require you to have any days off each month? Whilst it's not ok for someone to ask that and discriminate, employers will just look at candidate A who is likely to be reliable most days, or candidate B who has said that roughly 4 days a month they will be absent. The reasoning why is not important.

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 22:19

Jobdiscussion · Yesterday 22:08

You know what the job market is like as a recruiter in your particular field. You haven't shown any insight into what it is like from the applicant side. You've said yourself that you've got every paid job you've ever applied for, so you've acknowledged that either you've never had the experience of applying for jobs in a tough market, or if you have, you got lucky. If the young candidates who you invite to interview are largely turning out to be hopeless, that suggests a pretty fundamental flaw in your recruitment process in that you're failing to screen out no hopers early in the process and thereby missing out on better candidates as a result.

I don't think it's "luck" when people are successful candidates. Nor do I think it's just bad luck in 95% of cases that are unsuccessful.

Yes indeed it's our fault for even entertaining any further interviews with an age group who indeed have so far demonstrated themselves to be "hopeless". Must be the interview process...

Yourchildrenwillbegiants · Yesterday 22:24

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 22:19

I don't think it's "luck" when people are successful candidates. Nor do I think it's just bad luck in 95% of cases that are unsuccessful.

Yes indeed it's our fault for even entertaining any further interviews with an age group who indeed have so far demonstrated themselves to be "hopeless". Must be the interview process...

How can an entire age group be hopeless? That’s absurd and, looking at the young people I know, demonstrably untrue.

IAmNotMyJobTitle · Yesterday 22:29

A lot of places are using AI to sift through candidates, as a result everyone’s CV becomes more generic with keywords to get past the sifting. I think a lot of good candidates are being missed because of that. It’s brutal.
One of my relatives had a full telephone interview with a bot. She was told about it in advance but there was zero opportunity to build a relationship.

doormats5 · Yesterday 22:34

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 21:36

Lots of them on Indeed

Loads of ghost jobs on there…

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 22:34

Yourchildrenwillbegiants · Yesterday 22:24

How can an entire age group be hopeless? That’s absurd and, looking at the young people I know, demonstrably untrue.

I've kinda addressed this on an earlier post. The one someone quoted and said it was exactly this.

Jobdiscussion · Yesterday 22:35

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 22:19

I don't think it's "luck" when people are successful candidates. Nor do I think it's just bad luck in 95% of cases that are unsuccessful.

Yes indeed it's our fault for even entertaining any further interviews with an age group who indeed have so far demonstrated themselves to be "hopeless". Must be the interview process...

When there are way more good candidates than vacancies I think there's inevitably some element of luck involved as to who gets the job.

If you are really writing off an entire age group as "hopeless", I think that says more about you than the people who are in that age group.

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 22:35

doormats5 · Yesterday 22:34

Loads of ghost jobs on there…

Best not even look or try then eh. They must all be.

thaegumathteth · Yesterday 22:37

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 22:15

Very gently, if you can tailor your CV to suit whichever role you are applying for, then it's not got specific qualifications.

Cover letters are great. Admin wise most people can't be arsed and we often joke about the number of candidates who claim to have "excellent attention to detail" and yet don't bother following the instructions of submitting a CV and covering letter. For an admin job.

Tailoring a covering letter, definitely. But your CV is really just that, you shouldn't be looking to notably change it.

I know there is massive discrimination towards all manners of groups, irrespective of how shoddy that may be. Employers won't ever admit it, but they all do it. If I've got an 8/10 single person, or a 9/10 parent of 3, then I'm taking the 8/10. Because there's 4 people who might get sick resulting in the parent needing the day off.

Do you declare your disability and does it require you to have any days off each month? Whilst it's not ok for someone to ask that and discriminate, employers will just look at candidate A who is likely to be reliable most days, or candidate B who has said that roughly 4 days a month they will be absent. The reasoning why is not important.

I mainly tailor the cv because I’m applying to admin roles which I have experience of, charity admin roles again which I have experience of and fundraising roles which is what I really want to get back into. I’m not changing huge swathes but I have 3 versions of you like.

i declare my disability when they ask. I don’t need any days off more than anyone else. In my last job I did have a week off but I was in the high dependency unit and seriously ill. Other than that which was a one off (touch wood) then no. I cannot travel though but can work full time from home and I work bloody hard when I’m given the opportunity.

thaegumathteth · Yesterday 22:38

And actually I’m not adjusting the qualifications more just highlighting the different experience which is relevant

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 22:42

Jobdiscussion · Yesterday 22:35

When there are way more good candidates than vacancies I think there's inevitably some element of luck involved as to who gets the job.

If you are really writing off an entire age group as "hopeless", I think that says more about you than the people who are in that age group.

If that suits your narrative, go for it.

Candidates thinking they are good, or good on paper, are not always good candidates.

The younger candidates, particularly graduates, having very little desirable qualities beyond their paper qualifications, is pretty a well established theme across the board.

Boudy · Yesterday 22:47

Pieceofpurplesky · Yesterday 17:07

Mine too

My 27 year old dosen't even have that at the moment. Awful isn't it?
There also appear to be non existent jobs advertised regularly.

Chikenpotpoe · Yesterday 22:55

Yup. This why my 25 year graduate daughter is still on a zero hours contract in a minimum wage retail job

Sad to hear so many people echoing this. I graduated in 2008 around what they called back then the 'credit crunch' I also had issues with getting graduate work for a year or so until I eventually moved down to London and of course my wage was swallowed up by London rent, but it was better than doing seasonal or zero hours MW work in my hometown. I know now even those in London are struggling to find work too.

Qualitypinnacle · Yesterday 23:04

Chikenpotpoe · Yesterday 22:55

Yup. This why my 25 year graduate daughter is still on a zero hours contract in a minimum wage retail job

Sad to hear so many people echoing this. I graduated in 2008 around what they called back then the 'credit crunch' I also had issues with getting graduate work for a year or so until I eventually moved down to London and of course my wage was swallowed up by London rent, but it was better than doing seasonal or zero hours MW work in my hometown. I know now even those in London are struggling to find work too.

Yes we are in London

Meand2Ls · Yesterday 23:08

My work had our grad scheme applicants. We have about 10c more than every before and we’ve had to get over 400 volunteers through the organisation to review them all and that’s just the ones that passed the automatic tests

Chikenpotpoe · Yesterday 23:09

Qualitypinnacle · Yesterday 23:04

Yes we are in London

That's shocking, I expect the situation will be even worse for those outside London.

I imagine it must be very demoralising, especially for those with large student debts, to end up in those positions after studying for 3+ years.

And then you get insensitive older people who don't have a clue making critical comments about how they moved out at 18 and bought a house by 21.

doormats5 · Yesterday 23:12

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 22:35

Best not even look or try then eh. They must all be.

I don’t need a job but as I said friend is struggling. I was hoping for something more insightful than Indeed!

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 23:13

thaegumathteth · Yesterday 22:37

I mainly tailor the cv because I’m applying to admin roles which I have experience of, charity admin roles again which I have experience of and fundraising roles which is what I really want to get back into. I’m not changing huge swathes but I have 3 versions of you like.

i declare my disability when they ask. I don’t need any days off more than anyone else. In my last job I did have a week off but I was in the high dependency unit and seriously ill. Other than that which was a one off (touch wood) then no. I cannot travel though but can work full time from home and I work bloody hard when I’m given the opportunity.

My background is corporate finance, but I run a charity organisation now. I wouldn't want someone who could never attend the office, the charity sector is too rife with attracting people who exploit it, but of course, if the role they are advertising is fully remote then they obviously are happy with that.

The competition for totally remote admin in the charity sector will be extreme, because honestly, people think it's a doss and they'll get away with doing hardly anything in this soft sharing caring industry. So already, you need to be outstanding, because if you're not, you're just in a sea of "she's alrights".

If you then, irrespective of accuracy, give an employer reason to worry that you can go off sick for 6mths under a protected characteristic, then they will pick the person who doesn't have that potential risk. So that means you need to have an absolutely excellent CV that outweighs their perceived risk factor.

Out of interest, have you had a friend role play interview you. A good friend who would give honest feedback. Just thinking of a recent interview where the woman's CV could not have been more perfect. Her covering letter (and follow up email for extra brownie points) showed a level of interest that we rarely see. Pretty much nailed on, I thought. Throughout the interview, she finished everyone's sentences. It was beyond irritating. The manager she would have been working for said how it would have driven her crazy. Not saying you do, but you might be an excellent candidate with a shocker of interview technique. We even got this lady back for a 2nd interview in case it was initial nerves. It wasn't.

Another recent one had no idea what our charity did. I'm not asking to to recite our mission statement but at least know what we are about when you tell me you think you're an excellent fit for the role FFS.

Generally when unsuccessful candidates ask for feedback, we say that they did really well and it was a close call, etc, because they already feel dejected. They generally haven't done really well and we knew within 5 minutes we wouldn't be hiring. Most people haven't got the heart to say "you just come across really badly" in whatever form that may have materialised.