Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

I have spent the week sifting application for an admin role.

122 replies

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 16:52

It has been an eye opening week. I sift and interview regularly, the last time being in the early summer. In the summer we had 7 trainee roles with good prospects. I we had around 100 applications per role, interviews and had a great set of recruits and a strong reserve list which we will use.
This month we had 1 role an interesting admin role. Over a 1000 applications, so many good graduates, people with masters and even a few PhDs. People with professional qualifications, years of experience and fantastic experience. All kinds of background, academia, NHS, school, local government.

OP posts:
doormats5 · Yesterday 23:16

I just looked on Indeed there really aren’t loads of remote bookkeeping jobs!

Chikenpotpoe · Yesterday 23:17

We talk a lot about private vs state but IME a lot of people got jobs via nepotism ie their dad/mum's mate irrespective of what kind of school they went to.

For example I had to do a masters to get on a competitive graduate scheme at a PR company then I saw the director's niece who hadn't even finished her undergrad was doing work experience there. Fair enough it was unpaid but it was with the understanding she'd get a job once she graduated.

She didn't shine in terms of her work or effort, swanned in when she wanted to and seemed quite bored by it.

I know a lot of kids from my school and other local schools walked into jobs like that, some of them didn't even need to graduate first. Their parent/family member/family friend secured their career.

Now I get why parents would do what they can to help their kids but I'm just wondering about the impact of all of this on those who don't have that? And these parents are also the most likely to give their kids a leg up on the housing ladder. Add to that the well documented discrimination based on race, gender and disability and it's no wonder some kids/young adults feel hopeless.

CloveRinse · Yesterday 23:19

PamelaShipman80 · Yesterday 19:07

I hope you find something soon

Thank you. I really appreciate that. I hope so too.

thaegumathteth · Yesterday 23:19

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 23:13

My background is corporate finance, but I run a charity organisation now. I wouldn't want someone who could never attend the office, the charity sector is too rife with attracting people who exploit it, but of course, if the role they are advertising is fully remote then they obviously are happy with that.

The competition for totally remote admin in the charity sector will be extreme, because honestly, people think it's a doss and they'll get away with doing hardly anything in this soft sharing caring industry. So already, you need to be outstanding, because if you're not, you're just in a sea of "she's alrights".

If you then, irrespective of accuracy, give an employer reason to worry that you can go off sick for 6mths under a protected characteristic, then they will pick the person who doesn't have that potential risk. So that means you need to have an absolutely excellent CV that outweighs their perceived risk factor.

Out of interest, have you had a friend role play interview you. A good friend who would give honest feedback. Just thinking of a recent interview where the woman's CV could not have been more perfect. Her covering letter (and follow up email for extra brownie points) showed a level of interest that we rarely see. Pretty much nailed on, I thought. Throughout the interview, she finished everyone's sentences. It was beyond irritating. The manager she would have been working for said how it would have driven her crazy. Not saying you do, but you might be an excellent candidate with a shocker of interview technique. We even got this lady back for a 2nd interview in case it was initial nerves. It wasn't.

Another recent one had no idea what our charity did. I'm not asking to to recite our mission statement but at least know what we are about when you tell me you think you're an excellent fit for the role FFS.

Generally when unsuccessful candidates ask for feedback, we say that they did really well and it was a close call, etc, because they already feel dejected. They generally haven't done really well and we knew within 5 minutes we wouldn't be hiring. Most people haven't got the heart to say "you just come across really badly" in whatever form that may have materialised.

I mean I don’t know what to say to that. Unfortunately I can’t magic away my disability to make employers more likely to hire me. I wish I bloody could.

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 23:56

I am a professional with over 30 years experience. I was made redundant Sept 25, got a 12 month contract in Jan, which finishes next month. I have been job hunting for 6 months - targeted jobs that I really want (since I am being paid until the end of the year). Nothing. I've had 2 interviews and many rejections. The whole process is very time consuming and dehumanising.
If I don't find something I will be one of the people applying for ANYTHING just so I can pay my bills. When my small buffer runs out, I will claim UC which will not help with my mortgage. I am single parent with a teenager at home.
I don't see any signs of things improving any time soon, getting much worse in fact.

Chikenpotpoe · Today 00:32

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 23:56

I am a professional with over 30 years experience. I was made redundant Sept 25, got a 12 month contract in Jan, which finishes next month. I have been job hunting for 6 months - targeted jobs that I really want (since I am being paid until the end of the year). Nothing. I've had 2 interviews and many rejections. The whole process is very time consuming and dehumanising.
If I don't find something I will be one of the people applying for ANYTHING just so I can pay my bills. When my small buffer runs out, I will claim UC which will not help with my mortgage. I am single parent with a teenager at home.
I don't see any signs of things improving any time soon, getting much worse in fact.

That sounds tough. Good luck OP. Has AI affected your industry?

I think it's disgusting that the amount UC give to people who have a mortgage can be so low. In various european countries they will pay something like 2/3 of your former salary for at least 6 months if you lose your job.

My friend was unemployed briefly a few years ago and if she hadn't been renting she'd only have been entitled to about £400 as a single person with no dependents. It feels illegal to give someone that little!The rent allowance bumped it up for my friend by £600 but if they'd had a mortgage they would've been screwed financially. I think for people that have worked for several years, if they lose their job there should be recognition that a. they paid into the system and b, they will likely have higher financial commitments than say someone who has never worked (eg mortgage or expensive car payment) and their benefits should reflect that.

placemats · Today 01:05

CloveRinse · Yesterday 17:03

@StockingsByTheFire Guyana is not in Africa. FYI.

Love this 😂😂

iamnotalemon · Today 04:09

thaegumathteth · Yesterday 20:36

I have been desperately applying for admin roles that can be done remotely (am disabled, can’t travel and feel utterly bloody useless). It has been 14 months of applications several every week and NOTHING. I’ve had about 6/7 interviews but not got past.

im trying to volunteer remotely now for my mental health and for my CV but honestly it’s a totally soul destroying process.

@thaegumathtethNot sure if it’s any help but there is a website (and Facebook group) called The Work From Home Hub who advertises mostly fully remote jobs.

HoraceCope · Today 04:15

in the nhs it is usual for a vacancy to stop taking applicants after a certain number
might be something to consider in future @NellietheNumpty

UnoriginalPoster · Today 05:06

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 18:15

God forbid my auto swipe keyboard opted for Guyana instead of Ghana.

Yes that's the point to note....

But presumably one of the purposes of your sift is to weed out applicants who don't bother to proofread what they have written?

SquashPenguin · Today 05:54

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 16:59

Where did you post the job?

I have previously used Indeed and got hundreds of spammed CVs for an admin role.

No, "Kirk" the now out of work ex lorry driver, you are not suitable for our admin/finance role that clearly says we want QuickBooks experience.

No, David from Guyana, you can not do our shop assistant role remotely from Africa.

Some people just click apply on anything, utter time wasters. You have to show you're "actively looking" for interviews to get your benefits. Out of interest, we invited "Kirk" for interview just to see what happened. Naturally he didn't even show up. It's just to keep his benefits coach happy.

I could’ve written this myself.

Advertised for two entry level positions, clearly stated it wasn’t WFH (lab based), people would apply from 150 miles away.

Also plenty of people would be invited to interview and never show up. It was clearly just being used as as application to keep their benefits coming in when they had no intention of actually getting a job. This would happen everytime we advertised.

NellietheNumpty · Today 06:11

Thanks for all the tips for the next recruitment campaign. I will think them through. I hadn’t thought about applications that were sent in to fulfil the requirements of universal credit.
There was a large amount of AI used. It is like any tool it is how it is used. There were some applications that closely reflected the advert but didn’t cover the qualifications, experience and impact of the candidate. AI was used well in many cases but made the applications a bit bland and similar. Where AI had been used to précis and sharpen statements it stood out.
As mentioned I am usually focused on the twice a year higher level recruitment. I helped out this week on another lower level because of the high volume of applications. I also carried on with my regular role.
In the summer interviews we did have a higher percentage of no show for interview on the day. It was disappointing as we could have called in another candidate if there had been more notice. It was a successful recruitment though and I am impressed with all the starters. They are more mixed in age than usual, so perhaps the office etiquette is being shared. They start as a cohort and initially spend a lot of time together and are encouraged to become collaborative.

OP posts:
DearBrendaa · Today 07:39

I'm in the South East. I re-trained as an OT a few years ago. I recently applied for three OT jobs and got invited for interviews for all.

It took two adverts to recruit a senior OT due to their being very few applicants.

Any graduates struggling to find work, could consider similar - 2 year fast track qualification with NHS bursary.

ThisWiseRobin · Today 08:15

doormats5 · Yesterday 20:22

@StockingsByTheFirewhere are all these remote bookkeeping jobs? my friend is struggling to find them

I found my last and final job on Indeed. Basic retail in a pharmacy but I was 67 years old.
49 years counted for something. I was told that on the same day, a 25 year old had started and left by lunch. Said the job was too busy for her.
I managed 2 years until cancer did a flyby , I am totally fine now, and I realised that my contributions to the company were going to suffer.
I chose to leave. They still as me to cone back at 70.
So much has to do with old fashioned work ethic.
This generation coming up is really going to struggle without work experience and a lot of luck.
If I had kids this age now I would be encouraging them to look abroad. (Australia is nice this time of year).

Badbadbunny · Today 08:29

Chikenpotpoe · Yesterday 23:09

That's shocking, I expect the situation will be even worse for those outside London.

I imagine it must be very demoralising, especially for those with large student debts, to end up in those positions after studying for 3+ years.

And then you get insensitive older people who don't have a clue making critical comments about how they moved out at 18 and bought a house by 21.

Edited

Nail on the head. And yes far worse outside London and other big cities. Very bad in run down forgotten regions.

HoraceCope · Today 09:07

DearBrendaa · Today 07:39

I'm in the South East. I re-trained as an OT a few years ago. I recently applied for three OT jobs and got invited for interviews for all.

It took two adverts to recruit a senior OT due to their being very few applicants.

Any graduates struggling to find work, could consider similar - 2 year fast track qualification with NHS bursary.

Edited

thank you
i have been suggesting this to my dd for many years,
falls on deaf ears sadly

LlynTegid · Today 09:14

I hope OP that you find a good person for the job.

The comments and observations that this thread has prompted says a lot about the current job market and also how vacancies are filled.

LlynTegid · Today 09:16

ThisWiseRobin · Today 08:15

I found my last and final job on Indeed. Basic retail in a pharmacy but I was 67 years old.
49 years counted for something. I was told that on the same day, a 25 year old had started and left by lunch. Said the job was too busy for her.
I managed 2 years until cancer did a flyby , I am totally fine now, and I realised that my contributions to the company were going to suffer.
I chose to leave. They still as me to cone back at 70.
So much has to do with old fashioned work ethic.
This generation coming up is really going to struggle without work experience and a lot of luck.
If I had kids this age now I would be encouraging them to look abroad. (Australia is nice this time of year).

Fewer people should be going to university, far more going into apprenticeships or other jobs where you start as a school leaver. Much more chance of knowing about the real world and its expectations than leaving it until you are 21 or 22 years old.

203percent · Today 10:04

I've been sifting for 3 roles this week and agree how eye opening it is. I work in the public sector so recruitment is tedious.

Maybe my thoughts are useful to someone.

There were 6 essential criteria, 80ish applications , maybe 8 fulfilled all 6 properly and for 4 of these I had to search for the info.
Make the essential criteria that you can fulfill very clear.

I totally support going for it if you have 5/6 and decent experience but please, as a minimum, allude to being open to training, or do a bit of home study on the topic mentioned or something, anything so I can justify giving you an interview.

People don't appear to consider the organisation they're coming to work for either. Yes it may be a HR/Admin/h&s role but is it in a small warehouse, a housing association or a retail store with 200 branches nationally? How do your skills/previous experience link to that? At least show you've googled my organisation and thought about what it might do.

Personally Im drawn to applicants who feel human, and include a line about personal interests in the personal statement. Nothing massive just 'In my free time like hiking and I'm a scout volunteer' whatever. I accept this may be personal preference.

I find screeds of overly-wordy achievements a big turn off. If the advert doesn't ask for budget management dont open with the fact that you saved £xx through a budget review. Shove it at the end if you feel it's important but to me, it indicates you haven't a clue what I need.

Just stay focussed on what skills & experience you can bring to this specific role and include a couple of highlights please.

ifonlytheydlisten · Today 10:51

AI makes it very easy to invent CVs and take 5 mins to bang in applications. A large percentage are probably fabricated

ifonlytheydlisten · Today 10:53

We get less no shows as interview as it’s civil service and hard to get to that point. But at initial sift we easily get 800 apps for admin grade roles - mostly rubbish

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Today 11:10

StockingsByTheFire · Yesterday 21:54

See also Zimbabwe in Antarctica

Give yourself a pat on the back for being so clever.

Jobdiscussion · Today 11:55

ifonlytheydlisten · Today 10:53

We get less no shows as interview as it’s civil service and hard to get to that point. But at initial sift we easily get 800 apps for admin grade roles - mostly rubbish

@ifonlytheydlisten Do you have any tips for how a genuine applicant can maximise their chances of making it through the initial sift in the application process? With 800 applicants you're obviously not going to have time to read each in detail, so how do you do your initial sift? Do you use AI? Search for key words/expressions? Look at them in batches in order of receipt and stop looking at them at all once you've got a certain number that have made it through the first sift?

Cars4Gov · Today 12:46

I can see the recruitment issues on both sides as have DC applying but I also recruit.

The job market is really, really tough, objectively so because most employers are expecting low growth, they anticipate AI will reduce roles and the recent legislation means you can't take a chance on a person, unless you have a robust HR process which could be costly given the day1 rights.

However I also think the younger applicants do need a mindset change. Perhaps it's due to social media focus but there does seem to be weaker communication skills and less inclination to work hard. This shows up in interviews but I've also seen students who were fortunate enough to get an internship demonstrate low effort whilst working, such as not showing up on time or spending time on their phone. A recent grad for accountancy turned up in the first week dressed in clothes more suitable for the gym, oblivious to the formal work culture. These grads were let go.

It also seems that the universities are not doing enough to help with careers, they are keen to accept students to get the funding when realistically the courses they offer will not make their grads competitive candidates in the job market.

ifonlytheydlisten · Today 15:12

@Jobdiscussion we have to follow CS code so each one is reviewed and scored and ranked in merit order. Blind sift. We can’t deviate. CS job ads are very specific what they want to see in personal statement. base pass is normally 4/7
if loads score 4 or 5 etc interview score bar can be raised.

if it’s obvious AI generated - score a 1
if hasn’t followed advert - same
if it no clear examples - will get a 2
if don’t use full word count - unlikely to reach a 4

recently we had one with a 750 word count and a significant number write maybe one paragraph claiming they were perfect for the job