Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

A question for anyone who is not a teacher

122 replies

EBWhite · Yesterday 09:56

I’m a teacher and have resigned after years at the chalk face. Many of my colleagues are desperate to get out and a lot of the new recruits don’t last beyond the first couple of years. It’s also harder than ever to secure your first post. Everywhere I look, teachers are unhappy but maybe that’s because I’m unhappy. I’ve joined the Facebook groups about leaving the profession and look at the data from teacher tapp that shows deep dissatisfaction.

So my question is this- if you have a teacher in your family or as a close friend, are they ok in their job? Are they happy? I think my opinion is skewed because the only opinions I see are from people who feel the way I do. Are there a quiet majority getting on happily and enjoying the role as I used to. What do the teachers in your lives have to say about school?

OP posts:
bookdook · Yesterday 18:15

I have lots of family & friends who are teachers, they all enjoy it. a lot depends on the school culture

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · Yesterday 18:16

DBro is a teacher and loves it. He retired from the school he did his teaching practice in after 30+ years a few years ago and has gone back part time. He is a natural born scientist.

3 of my teacher friends ones from mainstream to SEN about 15 - 20 years in, and one to a school for blind children. 1 moved from state to private. 2 moved to educational psychology via a master’s degree, and one to educational welfare. 1 became a part time youth support worker. So essentially, all the teachers know socially have stayed in education in some form, but only 1 as a mainstream school teacher, which he trained for in the first place.

chasetheace99 · Yesterday 18:18

My child is a secondary school teacher and head of year, and whilst I don’t think they feel it’s their life vocation, they recognise they are fairly well paid for their age and role, and now only teaches about 20-25hrs due to HoY duties, and likes the holidays! But they are the type of person who doesn’t worry too much about anything… also have siblings child who is a primary school teacher and think they find it harder as more full on.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

ClawsandEffect · Yesterday 18:33

I was a teacher. It was my vocation. But there is only so long any individual can work 80 hour weeks.

I loved, loved, loved the students. Even bottom set, challenging classes.

But SLT & Ofsted and the ridiculous amount of work that had no benefit at all, ever, to the students did me in.

I tutor now. Earn the same amount I made teaching. But half the workload. And most of the year, it's 1/4 of the stress. It's not as satisfying, but it won't kill me.

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 18:36

moonraker0 · Yesterday 17:32

Do you think everyone who works in a supermarket lives in a cardboard box? Of course people can support themselves in this type of job, thousands already do.

I don't think someone on a single very low wage (PP mentioned delivery driver, not all supermarket workers) can support a home and family, no. They may get some benefits and it will still be very hard.

I presume the people who retired early from teaching are also not entirely relying on a single minimum wage. That was my original point.

AmnesiacDream · Yesterday 19:06

I have a lot of friends and family in teaching, but they're all heading towards retirement (as am I!).

They all have plenty of moans about work (as do most people) but are mainly pretty happy. Though one was bullied out of his job and had a really hard time mentally before finding another position. They all work in the midlands and the north so their pay seems good to them (I assume because experienced and all have leadership roles of one level or another). They've all bought houses paid off before retirement and have pensions they expect to be enough, enjoy the holiday time, travel and have time for hobbies.

As I recall, they found it a lot harder in the first 10 years or so, but experience seems to make the job easier. It used to be when we had weekends together in term time the teachers would all spend about 8 hours doing prep or marking, wherever we were. Not the case any more.

They do all seem to think things have been harder with parents and behaviour since the pandemic, the two who work in primary especially. And the primary teachers seem to think current SEND arrangements are hurting everyone (biggest thing they moan about). The primary teachers are probably the least happy of them all.

Joanne200019 · Yesterday 20:01

I teach reception and I love it. It has definitely got a lot more challenging and the need increases year on year. A caring and supportive SLT is everything, with it and the job is great, without it it’s impossible. The hours are long, it works for my stage of life. I totally understand why so many people don’t enjoy it though, I know I am very lucky.

EBSAteacher · Yesterday 20:39

I know you really wanted to hear from non-teachers but I thought I'd join in anyway.

I've been teaching for 20+ years, in inner London. For the past ten of those I've been in specialist settings e.g. primary PRU, SEMH outreach or similar and am now in an EBSA setting. Teaching is a brilliant job and I can't really see myself doing anything else but unlike a lot of my teacher friends, I haven't stayed in one school for years and years, preferring to follow my interest in different roles and/or settings. I've never had any interest in headship as it's the teaching I enjoy and care about.

There's far less autonomy than there used to be especially when it comes to what should be on display, what to teach, when to teach it, curriculum links that are dictated from above etc. Some of this is positive as it means children don't miss out but other aspects are stifling and there are definitely schools that feel more corporate than they used to, with little in the way of professional trust. Thankfully, that's not always the case.

As an ever increasing number of children can't access school because of their mental health, I live in hope that there may - eventually - be a shift away from the formulaic rigidity of data-driven schooling...

herewegoagainonwednesday · Yesterday 20:49

I have several teacher friends and family members. All secondary school though.
All happy with their jobs, appreciate how family friendly they are (yes, you need after school clubs and work after the kids are in bed - but that’s normal in many jobs, and you get most of the holidays automatically off without having to fight for it).
There are no perfect jobs, and none of them went in with rose tinted glasses- they all had a very realistic view, and changed schools until they found one that suited them.

PurplGirl · Yesterday 21:06

My husband and sister are teachers/school leaders. They don’t love it, but they don’t hate it any more than most people dislike their jobs/going to work in general. I get that it’s a tough job at times. But honestly, I think a lot of teachers have jumped on a bandwagon of thinking they have it really tough. 13 weeks off per year and the potential to leave at 4pm (yes I know about meetings, parents eves, planning etc), guaranteed 2 weeks off at Xmas is not to be sniffed at. Most of us are stressed out all year round without a meaningful lump of time off to recouperate, 4-5 weeks off per year, working around/over Xmas, struggling to get leave in school holidays to look after our kids etc. I’d be interested to know if teachers leaving find that the grass isn’t greener.

whyexactlythough · Yesterday 21:08

I’m an ASN teacher and I absolutely love it. So I think specialism and the right school helps.

I have a lot of freedom in what and how I teach and spend a lot of time out of the classroom doing things like swimming, art, cross country, trips out, gardening etc.

So it’s miles apart from the usual primary or secondary teacher stuck in the classroom all day.

Is ASN something you would consider?

WaryCyanStork · Yesterday 21:09

DP used to be a teacher. She left because she missed being able to use the more technical aspects of her degree, but wasn't unhappy with teaching as a whole. We're still friends with some of her ex-colleagues, and they mostly seem happy in their roles.

As a non-teacher, my job isn't exactly niche but there's only 2 of us in a large company, so I hear more complaints from colleague in other roles, which helps me realise the grass isn't always greener. I do sometimes wonder if professions with a lot of people (e.g. teachers, doctors) can create a bit of an echo chamber, as it's easy to find other people unhappy with the same job.

OneNewEagle · Yesterday 21:23

All the teachers I used to know, in the family or as friends, are no longer teachers.

Meand2Ls · Yesterday 21:29

My two best friends are teachers. One primary and one secondary. They are both made to be teachers type personalities. Both mid 30s so in the game for 10+ years each. I’ll be honest I don’t know how they are doing it. The primary teacher has a permanent post in a very deprived school but feels she can never move because permanent posts are like gold dust but cannot believe the change in the children over the past decade. She had primary 4 and says most of their attention spans are so bad they can’t follow a 2 part instruction. I think her years are limited, she’s really struggling. My other friend who is a biology teacher has been back about 9 months since having her first child and she’s still got the same love for the job but the resentment for how much it doesn’t support mothers is really getting to her but I don’t think she’ll ever leave and could even see her going for a head teacher position when the kids are older

Jiski · Yesterday 21:41

Two of my cousins are teachers. They enjoy it and really make use of the holidays travelling, camping and going on days out with their kids. They also don’t tend to do much work outside of school. I think they are very experienced, efficient and good at time management. They probably work at good schools though with less issues than you get in areas with high poverty.

SapphireSteel28 · Yesterday 22:18

I am in my 34th year of teaching in a secondary school. I moved schools two years ago and I love my job. So much depends on the school and the Headteacher and SLT. My previous school was in a deprived area. Behaviour was out of control and management was weak and blamed staff. After 25 years I’d had enough. My new school is in an affluent area. It’s a totally different job. The parents are supportive and the pupils want to achieve.

seahorsessky · Yesterday 22:20

I know a few. They say the job is really hard, because of parents and the government, but some say there's enough good stuff so they stay, and that these days it's hard to find jobs in other fields.
It surprises me you talk on FB though.

EBWhite · Yesterday 23:10

It’s an anonymous group on FB for teachers who want to leave. Some of the stories are quite sad which is why I was looking for a balance. It’s heartening to hear of good schools being out there.

OP posts:
Menonut · Yesterday 23:49

My husband retrained as a teacher after 15 years in industry.
He always says that his worst day in teaching doesn’t even touch his worst day in his previous job and he wouldn’t go back at all.

Aydel · Yesterday 23:53

Several of my cousins are teachers. They all fled to the private sector some years ago and seem to be happy. The DDs American school was full of British teachers fleeing the state sector and the national curriculum.

jumpingjohnny · Today 00:04

Out of all the teachers I know who have left (most of my original pgce cohort, plus a good 20%+ of colleagues at various schools over the last 15 years), not a single one regrets leaving. The ones I keep in touch with properly, have expressed regret at not leaving sooner.

That being said, most miss the children, just not the job.

CosmicBlunder · Today 00:06

I actually am a teacher, and I think most of my friends and extended family would assume I am contented in my role. This is far from the truth, but I just don't bother telling anyone anymore because everyone hates a whiny teacher. I focus on the delight which is most of my pupils, and just cry in the bath about the 20+ hours per week I'm required to work from home while missing out on spending time with my own DC, and quietly carry on closing my laptop at 2am, whether I've completed my work or not. Workload became overwhelming overnight when we were taken over by a multi academy trust.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page