Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

A question for anyone who is not a teacher

122 replies

EBWhite · Yesterday 09:56

I’m a teacher and have resigned after years at the chalk face. Many of my colleagues are desperate to get out and a lot of the new recruits don’t last beyond the first couple of years. It’s also harder than ever to secure your first post. Everywhere I look, teachers are unhappy but maybe that’s because I’m unhappy. I’ve joined the Facebook groups about leaving the profession and look at the data from teacher tapp that shows deep dissatisfaction.

So my question is this- if you have a teacher in your family or as a close friend, are they ok in their job? Are they happy? I think my opinion is skewed because the only opinions I see are from people who feel the way I do. Are there a quiet majority getting on happily and enjoying the role as I used to. What do the teachers in your lives have to say about school?

OP posts:
TreacherousPissFlap · Yesterday 12:01

DS is newly qualified and was fortunate to have a job "created" for him in the academy trust he did his training in (the role is a combination of the subject he trained in, the subject he did his degree in and a subject he had assisted with on an extra curricular basis)

Overall he's happy though a lot of his colleagues aren't. He's considering moving schools as he's had a lot of responsibility dumped onto him that is a lot in his first year (he's practically HoD in one subject with support from colleagues in unrelated subjects) His opinion seems to be that it's the particular trust he works for rather than teaching in general.

However after 4 years living off a student loan I can see the salary is an attractive retainer 😉

JuliaAgrippina · Yesterday 12:01

Actually also know someone who retained to be a teachcer few years ago - phycics in secondary had god awful placements and only managed a few years before heading back to previous career. His other half was a happy primary teacher till she moved schools.

ToadRage · Yesterday 12:01

My Mum was a teacher for years, she is retired now. For a long time she really loved it bar the odd difficult child or parent. In terms of nqts, they often don't realise how hard it is. I have heard of so many peope who wanted to teach cos they thought they would get short days, weekends and holidays off but didn't realise you still spend a lot of that time working behind the scenes. My Mum took a break when I was doing my a levels and loved being a SAHM temporarily. When I went to uni she returned to teaching and did the headteacher qualification. She says teaching is much harder than most people realise but it can be so rewarding. Knowing that she might have made a difference to someones life was what kept her going back every day.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

TopseyTree · Yesterday 12:02

I was a teacher and HoY for 33 years, loved being in a classroom, had great discipline and unshakable parental support. However I hated the politics, INSET and OFSTED, became cynical about SLT’s avoidance of management and eager clock watching. Whenever anyone suggests teaching as a career I put them off.
Well done for resigning. A happier future awaits; I know you’ll be healthier mentally and physically.

bumblingbovine49 · Yesterday 12:02

I can't answer this for nowadays but in the late 1980s during family Sunday lunchtimes and holiday get togethers, when I was a late teenager/ and young adult at university, we had 3 teachers at the family table (two of my uncles and my older sister ) and their conversations about the job made a very strong impact on me at a time I was seriously considering what I wanted to do as a career. The decision I came to was that you could not pay me enough to ever become a teacher

My sister regularly told me that the environment in which she taught (Inner London comprehensives generally) was appalling, buildings that were very poorly maintained, children who regularly swore at her, peeling walls and broken windows etc. This was after almost a decade of the Thatcher years though and she didn't leave as despite all this she like the kids and the teaching.

In later years - when Tony Blair's government came in, she said things had improved a lot. Even though she did not like Blair or his government, she grudgingly admitted schools were light years better in the late 90s and early 00's than they were under Thatcher. They started to get so much worse again in the late 00's, by then she had moved to the LA SEN teaching support teams but what happend to them in the last years of her career under the Tories was absolute devastation . I wonder why that could be 🤔

MissZara · Yesterday 12:05

One cousin works in a Primary School and she loves her job.

Another cousin works in a Secondary School and she hates it.

Another cousin works and has progressed to department head in a Secondary School but not in the UK and she loves it too.

Think it differs depending on school/country.

CanIRunYet · Yesterday 12:06

I'm surrounded by teachers in friends and family, but am not one myself!

DH - teacher. Generally happy in the job, but not intention to become SLT or take on more responsibility as the increase in pay vs workload increase is totally not worth it (and we're lucky not to need to extra income). Only annoyance for us is that during term time I have to pick up a lot of the flexibility slack (my role is thankfully quite flexible, albeit stressful!) but its made up for by DH being around during school holidays so childcare not an issue in holidays which is amazing! DH sees how much I work when I'm up against deadlines, and how cut-throat my industry is (private sector, tech - layoff's very common, no union, unethical HR depts, lots of egos to navigate) and appreciates the relative stability of his teaching role.

Sister in law - SLT teacher in primary. Part-time and job share. Obviously has its moments but seems generally happy and enjoys having holidays off with her kids. Did have a period of disliking the job, but a change in school seemed to help fix that as the new SLT appear a lot better.

Friend - Techer in secondary. Hates it currently and hoping to have a baby soon, and not return after mat leave.

EBWhite · Yesterday 12:08

TraitorOrFaithful · Yesterday 11:53

@EBWhite can you explain why it's harder now to find your first post but also that lots of teachers are leaving? I find that hard to understand?

I’m not sure to be honest. I would guess that teachers don’t move around as much as they used to because of pay portability. New posts are advertised as main scale so won’t attract UPS teachers. The UPS teachers stay where they are. There are teachers being trained through lots of different providers. Perhaps there are more trained than required considering we have fewer children and schools are closing. On top of that you have budgets being squeezed. Cost of pay rises haven’t been fully funded historically. Schools look to cover on the cheap- getting cover supervisors to take classes where there is staff absence.

OP posts:
EBWhite · Yesterday 12:10

I also think there are a number of teachers who feel stuck and want to leave but can’t because they know the pay and holidays are better than in many jobs.

OP posts:
louderthan · Yesterday 12:12

My ex (we are still on very good terms and speak
regularly) was a teacher. He had since retrained as a social worker and claims it is less stressful…!

TopseyTree · Yesterday 12:16

I wouldn’t say the pay is commensurate with the hours required plus teachers work on preparation and marking during school holidays.

user293948849167 · Yesterday 12:27

Yes my DH is a fairly new teacher having had a career change.
He enjoys it and although it’s hard it is actually less work than his previous job and he enjoys the interaction with the kids. I’d say he works fewer hours overall than his previous job because although he does do some work at home he is always home before 5pm.

I have other family members who have been teachers for a few years too and they are still teaching and enjoying it as far as I know.

BigBrownBoogyingBear · Yesterday 12:33

I know five teachers. One primary, the rest secondary (all state schools in Northern England). They have all progressed well and really enjoy their jobs.

YourJoyousDenimExpert · Yesterday 12:34

Think it is the same in some health roles - -particularly SALT and OT - people love the work with the children but it is the bureaucracy and pressure from SOME parents that make people give up.
In health, they seem to go into private practice. Very sad - we are losing some great teachers and therapists.

SquigglePigs · Yesterday 12:35

I know one teacher who is happy and works part time in Primary.

Two others who work in the private sector. One full time and relatively happy. One part time and pretty miserable.

Another friend is a head of department in a secondary school. She is super stressed and overworked but she's also super passionate about what she does and the good she can do in the school she's in. It's hard though. She has two primary age kids and barely has a life in term time.

I also know two who have left the profession.

From experience with these friends it does seem to be very school and Head dependent. The job will always be full on in term time but it's the Head and culture that seems to determine whether people are happy overall or miserable overall.

Similar to a lot of work places I guess.

SmokeyRidge · Yesterday 12:35

They seem happy with their job, such that it is, and their complaints are no different to complaints from others in other trades/sectors re: favouritism, bureaucracy, hours/pay etc.

TheLastSilverSaint · Yesterday 12:36

All the teachers I know mostly enjoy teaching. Obviously they have things that annoy them at work, like everyone does, but none of the teachers I know are burnt out or considering leaving the profession etc. One teaches primary school and the others teach secondary.

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 12:40

Two of my sisters are teachers, one a head.
Many of my friends are teachers and TAs.
They all work bloody hard and have many, many stories to tell, especially the ones who have been in the profession many years.
But all the teachers (less so the TAs) went into it because they love teaching and seem happy.
Yes, they work during some of the holidays, but also acknowledge that they do get long breaks and haven't needed to worry about childcare.

FirmSnake · Yesterday 12:45

I (not a teacher) work at a very well regarded girls grammar. The teachers here seem very happy, and we have very low teacher turn over. But I imagine it is because we don't struggle with the same behavioural or SEND challenges a comp might and our parents tend to be very engaged.
I do find though, that a school full of teachers who have never done anything other than teaching, leads to culture of self pity because they wrongly think they work so much harder and so many more hours than any other industry.

moonraker0 · Yesterday 12:48

I know three and they all seem happy in their jobs. My best friend is one of them and she absolutely loves teaching, she left retail management to teach and appreciates the hours and annual leave being a lot better plus she’s not getting yelled at by customers. On the whole she’s a lot less stressed these days.

BigSmoking · Yesterday 12:50

I am not sure why you are asking the question OP? If your straw poll shows enough happy teacher experience, might you look for another job? And it really is a very subjective straw poll!

FWIW my SIL is a teacher after a job in business; she loves it - she is a bit of a comedian and is popular with the kids. She especially loves the pastoral side and has taken on more in this area. My dad was a teacher and had a love-hate relationship with it for years (loved kids, hated paperwork), but his experience is a bit out of date. My friend's daughter also retrained as a primary teacher after a city job - works in a deprived area, loves it, feels that she is doing something worthwhile. I know two people who didn't survive their NQT years, but I would say their motivations for retraining as teachers were probably not right.

I don't think there is much special about how teachers view their jobs compared to people I know working in private or public sector. Some live to work, some work to live. Teachers don't stick out in any way as far as I can see.

devonsevon11 · Yesterday 12:50

I do know one teacher (friend of a friend / acquaintance) who seems very happy.

I do hear, though, that she is not good at her job and puts in the bare minimum effort.

So maybe that’s the secret.

She teaches in infant school though, which is such a horrible thought.

blythet · Yesterday 12:53

why is it so hard to get a job as a new teacher with so many leaving?

CheesesForUsMeeses · Yesterday 12:57

I have two close friends who are teachers. One is generally very happy, she has a few whinges (as we all do about our jobs!) but she enjoys it.
The other one is miserable and complains a lot. She says she won’t leave/retrain though because of the holidays.

WouldLikeToKnow92 · Yesterday 12:58

My Mum is a fairly recently retired teacher. She enjoyed her teaching career, she didn't enjoy the administrative aspects and certainly did a lot of extra work, but she absolutely loved teaching (secondary age) children throughout her career. She loved being part of a school and was proud of her profession.

She went increasingly part time in the last few years but didn't properly retire until 70 and has continued to work at the school as a TA where she still is now working with small groups of SEN children.

I have a number of younger friends who are teachers, bit of a mixed bag. Some really enjoy it but also find it increasingly pressured. A couple really don't.

I do wonder a bit whether my Mum enjoyed it because more of her career was spent in a less pressured, less bureaucratic era.

I do remember her being very stressed with work for large parts of my childhood !